We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
" Now, if he has experimental evidence (which is what led me to this video in the first place) to support some other conclusion then I'm in"
note it says NO Torn Grain at 50 degrees. "the surface finish is good"
When I requested a copy of the video from Professor Kato he supplied his English translation of the various experiments described in the video. The picture is a scan of the text of Professor Kato's translation of Experiment 8 and 9 that accompanied the video.
To repeat for the zillionth time......*****This video was made as a demonstration.***** The steps in the experimental variables are huge. He is exploring experimental space, demonstrating the gross effect of the variables, not searching for an optimum. If he intended the work to discover an optimum there would have been vastly greater work described and it would have been published somewhere.
The fact that Kato never recommended 80 degree, and never used 80 degrees in any of the peer reviewed publications shown in my previous picture of this stack on my desk, and now Weaver and Voigt reveal that 80 degrees has practical problems, should lead someone looking for a place to start to start at 50 not 80.
I don't mean to be a bore but I have to keep going back to the Kato video (and my own experience). This is from the next to last frame translation (emphasis mine):
15:37
16:11
Summary:
1. If the blade is sharp, and if the cutting depth is smaller than 0.05mm, then ripping[grain tear] will not occur even with a single blade.
2. Cap-iron recess should be adjusted to suitable amount according to the cutting depth.
3. Cap-iron edge angle at 80 degrees, compared to 50 degrees, has a greater effect of against grain rip[grain tear] prevention, and also a greater cap-iron recess can be applied.
Thanks to all for putting up with this discussion.
This information is interesting, but one can't help but wonder why the scraper continued to be recommended for difficult grain all throughout the periods in question, at least in the woodworking manuals of which I am aware. Is there a source that ever said, flatly, they had become completely superfluous (even on flat work) because of the double iron? Why sharkskin? Why scouring with sand? Why scrape? All this even after the double iron was well entrenched, right? Or is my timeline somehow screwed up again.
I was in the midst of a long response to your question when once again I hit something and it deleted. I don't have the patience to recreate it.
Summary- you don't have an accurate translation of the Kato video and you are over interpreting his statements. It is true that he states a greater cap iron effect at 80 than 50. Greater cap iron effect does not mean better for planing at all conditions. Kato got good results at 50 degree and bad results at 80 degrees depending on other variables in the experiment. The fact that 80 was never used in any other work suggests there is some price to pay for 80.
Weaver and Voigt, both highly experienced practical planers (they plane to get a job done not just diddle making thin shavings) claim there is a price to pay and that price is more fiddly set back adjustment and harder to push if set less than optimum. These are significant factors to the practical planer.
It would be useful for this discussion for you to describe your results at 80 degrees and the conditions under which you got them. It may well be that under some conditions 80 is better. I would like to know. And if 80 is better than 50 has anyone tried 60? Example- This is my planing experience, this is what I did, this is what I found. (in a new thread so it doesn't get lost)
One only has to know about business to answer the question and nothing about the technology. Given the skills in the hands of the maker, and the tools available, a scraper (or drum sander) was the most cost effective means to an end. If the plane or experience using it didn't do the job and the client was waiting for a place to put their socks a scraper got the job done instead. The scraper was easier to learn and/or more capable.
But for those that are not relying on making sock drawers for a living and plane for the satisfaction it brings, knowing the limit of what can be done with a cap iron plane would be desirable. It would also be inspirational to those climbing the learning curve.
I rounded the bevel on my chip breaker then put a bevel of about 50 degrees on the leading edge, it works very well in the woods I use.
I will echo the sentiment with regard to making setting changes based on results. If you always have it set to the most extreme setting it will make most planing operations very difficult, so I generally bump it up for the finished surface.
I think when we work the front of them, we probably get them to about 50.
three plus years ago, i wrote in an article (if I remember, it's not like it can't be read to check, but I'm not going to check it), that I like the stock stanley profile.
I still do. It's the best thing I've used as far as a final authority on tearout reduction and easy setting. Nothing introduced since is an improvement on it, and I've bought and used an awful lot of things.
I like the old woody chipbreakers, too, but when you buy old ones that are not finished quite as consistently, they can have some unusual adjustment habits.
There's another angle to this 80 degree business, and that is that when your range narrows, so does the chance that the cap iron set close will leave a less bright surface.
I've seen a lot of toothed scraping planes intended to scuff veneer but I haven't seen many that were intended to prepare a final smoothed surface. Maybe I haven't been looking for them (that much is true).
I'm still (since this whole debate started), looking to find a piece of wood that can't be smooth planed fairly quickly for final finish. Some wood is still contrary on interim steps if you want to plane it fast (curly cherry, etc). I have scraped and sanded some mouldings, though. Or rather sanded, scraped and then burnished so they'd take finish at the same rate as a planed surface (it takes about half as much shellac to get a good uniform base on a planed surface vs. sanded).
Instead of asking questions, maybe you could pose a scenario where the plane isn't practical. We'll let warren speak to it. He does, after all, make a living doing this stuff and the rest of us make a living elsewhere and is probably a lot closer to what someone would've done 200 years ago.
I have no clue, by the way, why there would be so much talk of the double iron working difficult woods if that were to be left to a scraper....speaking of flat surfaces.
I used to plane, scrape and sand. Then in 1976 I noticed that the scraper was actually degrading the surface. I used it one last time in 1977. In 1978 I realized that the sanding was also degrading the surface and abandoned that also. I also noticed that a cap iron too close yields a cloudy surface. I have finished straight from the plane since that time.
The double iron plane is 100% reliable in a professional setting. The young people working in my shop have had no trouble using it. It is fast and yields a finer surface than high angle planes, scrapers, or sanding. The surface is easier to finish than a sanded surface.
Many historical books have been written by industrial arts teachers, journalists and amateurs, not highly skilled professionals. Peter Nicholson, who apprenticed as a cabinetmaker in Scotland and worked in London in the late 18th century wrote: The double iron planes now in use are a most complete remedy against cross-grained and curling stuff Nothing about scrapers.
Right, but what about veneered work? Dare we put plane to exceedingly thin burl walnut and the like?
This appears to be very, very high end woodworking. I'm thinking a plane was not the last tool to touch the surface of some of these fine veneers, though I could be wrong:
Charley, the 20th century furniture you show was designed for machine tool and abrasive techniques. It is awkward to make such furniture by hand. The flat surfaces could easily be planed by hand, but the curved surfaces would not be possible to do with a plane. Earlier veneer made during the hand tool era was thicker and could be planed on the bench before gluing. I would not recommend a beginner trying to plane thin figured veneer.
Generally reproductions from the hand tool era are more efficiently made by hand and those from the machine era are more efficiently made the way they were designed. That said, we sometimes use hand methods to restore machine work because of the cost of reproducing the original tooling.
The point being with these links (feel free to browse for there is a whole lot more) is that there is a whole raft of even 18th century furniture simply not susceptible to being all hand planed due to curved surfaces with highly figured veneers, yet the surfaces seem to be breathtaking in every respect. I think it's worth noting for perspective if nothing else. The Ruhlmann stuff is not wholly different other than for the fact that the veneers are thinner. They're still highly figured and applied to a curved substrate. I think scrapers were crucial to the success of the 18th century work at the very high end just as they are with the Ruhlmann pieces and current reproductions of Ruhlmann pieces.
This notion of never having to use a scraper or an abrasive, in reality, applies to a fairly limited range of flat and square work in the grand scheme of fine furnituremaking. Anybody aspiring to something beyond rectilinear work had better be thinking about an approach that goes beyond what a Stanley No. 4 can handle.
I've worked as a professional cabinetmaker since the late 1970s and for a few years built pieces that were sold through David Sutherland Galleries. The Pollaro pieces you linked to remind me of the pieces I built, although the ones I made were contemporary styles by living designers rather than Ruhlmann or Art Deco.
The shop I worked at had a computer-controlled widebelt sander that cost something like $200,000 used. It had a narrow cross-sanding belt plus two main sanding belts and had so many modes and possible adjustments that it was hard to know if everything was set right before I sent a workpiece through. I suspect the Pollaro pieces are made using similar technology.
There were cases where the sander didn't work quite right and I would use a smoothing plane to correct the problem areas. I remember one time a co-worker saw me planing a veneered surface and remarked, "Wow, Steve has balls." The other workers used sanding blocks instead, in my opinion a slower and less effective method.
It's my belief that the current technology has become dominant because of its speed--the ability to produce large surfaces that are almost ready for finishing very quickly compared to older methods. It has never seemed to me that the work I was doing had been de-skilled because I've always had to keep developing new skills or refining the ones I already had.
For antique reproduction or small design/build operations I'm sure the situation is different. Woodworking as a hobby is probably much more like these. When I retire I don't expect to set up a shop with power tools, at least with very few, so I'm interested in the sort of work I can do primarily with hand tools.
Planing either with or without a cap iron is an enormously useful skill. It takes practice and the willingness to try different things to get a feel for what works in different situations. For me planing is much more pleasant than arguing about planing on a woodworking forum so I tend to stay out of many of these discussions.
Just now I read Warren's reply and agree with him. The furniture I was building seemed to have been designed using CAD software by a designer who had never done much hands-on woodworking. The shapes and material choices sometimes required custom metal pieces and fasteners to give strength to a joint that the visible materials couldn't provide. I was amazed by the prices the gallery charged, or maybe by the willingness of customers to pay the prices.
I think as soon as someone delves into a piece with curves, and maybe a sharp set of curves, perhaps with veneer, then some sort of other reality sets in. I don't work wood at that rarefied level but it doesn't take a genius to see there are places a No. 4 simply won't fit. And on some pieces there are A LOT of places one wouldn't fit. And the hell of it is is that some of the pieces make one's jaw drop.
Not offered as an insult or an accusation but simply for comparison, contrast, and perspective. And there are plenty of 18th century pieces which would present similar difficulties for the hand plane. For me, this is what really high end woodworking looks like: it's not all flat and square and made with thick lumber that one can plane until the cows decide to come home and the tearout's gone.
And of course there is plenty of French furniture from the 18th century just as curvy and crazy as an Osgood piece. It's not a '20th century' thing I don't think.
The question at hand isn’t whether a plane with a chipbreaker can be used for all purposes. The question is whether a plane with a chipbreaker is a good enough technique for the purposes that one would use a plane for.
Let’s take it as a given that for a curved front dresser was prepped for finish with scraping and sanding, and that this process yielded great results. That still doesn’t mean that in a situation which one would actually use a Stanley No. 4, scraping and sanding is a better method than a sharp blade and a chipbreaker.
As far as whether one should risk planing a veneered surface: a well set up plane can take a shaving in the 0.001” range, which is a goal that I know that Charley has scoffed at in the past. Assuming that the veneer is thick enough, planing the veneer should not be much of a problem. Commercial veneers today are about 0.023” thick, which means that you should be able to take a dozen passes without problems.
Here’s a real world example. I’m not a professional, but I planed the walnut burl veneer that was applied to the front of this Bible box with a Japanese plane without a chipbreaker to prep it prior to finishing, and it survived. I figure if I can do it, so can a whole lot of other people.
Beautiful, but apply that veneer to something not flat.
The overall point I'm trying to make it that beautiful and essentially flawless surfaces can result from something other than planing and this has been true for hundreds of years up to this day.
This isn't a fact to be scorned and derided but one that should be celebrated. Why take arrows out of one's quiver? To what end would it serve or does it serve to those who appear to have done just that? It's not even terribly historically accurate unless one excludes furnituremaking at the highest end, or just curved furniture in a lot of instances.
This reply is a general comment, and not directed specifically to David - the reply button after his message merely being convenient. The research undertaken by contributors to this thread, and comments, added to the work undertaken by Kato and Kawai is fascinating and informative. It's interesting that such seemingly small changes to tool set-up and methods of work yield remarkably different results in performance, albeit at some cost in time and effort.
On the other hand, I can't really see how prepping a surface polish ready with just hand planes is likely to be a regular practical option when set against the work needed to set up the tools, followed by the care needed with them in use. I have in the past gone through an exercise or two to prep a surface with just planes, and achieved it, but they were slow and painstaking exercises, especially on some 0.6 mm thick American cherry veneer.
Perhaps it's just me, but for handwork, I get a surface acceptably polish ready through using planes that perform 'well enough', scrapers for bits of tearout, and abrasives to finish. I can't think of any fellow working furniture makers that don't regularly incorporate scrapers and abrasives in hand prep work, whatever the surface - veneered, flat, curved, carved, etc. I guess that's the compromise we make to marry, as best we can, speed with acceptable end results. Slainte.
I have a reasonably broad collection of old woodworking manuals and I can't remember a single one that doesn't list scrapers as essentials. I'm frankly not aware of any that do. One has to selectively ignore a broad swath of classic manuals on the craft to contort themselves into a 'no scraper' get-it-done with nothing-but planes camp. This, plus confine one's work or one's project aspirations, to nothing but the flat and square.
With appreciably thick veneers, it's not that difficult to plane to finish. With modern thin ones, sure, it's a nuisance unless they're on a dead flat substrate.
I understand you're making mostly modern furniture at this point, because that's what the market wants. Most of us really don't want furniture of that type, let alone have a desire to make it. We're working from solid, and perhaps applying veneer to mostly flat areas, and maybe cutting mouldings and doing some carving.
For that type of thing, it's not very hard to finish with a plane. It's maybe (to me) easier, actually. And faster.
The local teacher here teaches all of his students to plane with tearout and then scrape it out. That's fine. it does take more time to do that, though, in cases where the tearout is not necessary.
For three years now, I've finished surfaces with planes - I do use scrapers a lot when making tools, so that I don't have to sand on the handles and risk removing crispness. The last two (this is in regard to tool care), just using a washita stone to sharpen (no follow on). There's really no care needed other than to keep the iron in the same squareness as the cap and to include a little bit of camber. Maybe the care thing is trouble at first, but within a short period of time, it's trivial.