I recall 40 degrees for the "bed" angle as well.
more from Kato and Kawai
Posts
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#27Re: Angles ain't angles
Steve Voigt
It's interesting that lately the discussion of cap iron angles has centered on 50° vs. 80°. What I recall from previous discussions, and what has certainly been confirmed by my own (entirely informal) experimenting, is that 50° and 80° are best thought of as outer limits.
Get much below 50°, and the cap iron effect begins to fade. Recall that the whole notion of secondary bevels on a cap iron arose because people with LN or LV cap irons beveled at 30°-ish couldn't get them to work; the angle was too low.
Get much above 80°, and you'll feel like you are running into a brick wall, and you'll have escapement problems as well.
So it seems to me that if anyone wants to do further research, the most fruitful ground would be to explore the field between these two extremes.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#28Re: It is called a review article
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I think I spent more time experimenting and evaluating the double iron than Lee Valley spent with the PM VII.
It seems as if there is a movement to dumb down hand tools woodworking, to fit everything into a one day workshop. The specifications you laid out at the beginning of this thread (50 degrees, 150 microns) is a good example. It will work passably in some situations, poorly in others. It is like setting up a car with one gear, just to avoid teaching people to really learn to drive. Its chief virtue is that it does not require thought or skill.
I could teach you how to play Mary had a little lamb on the piano with one hand. You would not even have to read music, just 3-2-1-2-3-3-3 etc. Then you could teach your club to do the same and remark how easy it is to learn.
I once made some nice rolls for a friend's birthday. I was getting some compliments and then a lady I didn't know took one bite and said "I want the recipe! I want the recipe! Does it involve yeast? I don't want the recipe. She did not want to do something which involved risk of failure or development of skill.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#29Identify your personality type
markhennebury
As it will determine the route your take;
If you are the "Get er done" type, just pick an angle get your plane functioning good enough to be of use to you and forget about it, if you get occasional minor tearout use the random orbit sander.
If you are the obsessive " relentless pursuit of perfection" type:
Use all that you have read and heard as motivation to search for the absolute, then promptly forget all that you have heard and read, empty your mind of all preconceived "knowledge" and prejudice and embark on a journey of learning; experiment, observe, analyze, modify, trust nothing and no one, verify everything. when you are sure that you have found limits, push past in both directions just to confirm. Question everything, even things that you firmly believe are beyond question, your mind is your biggest ally and your biggest enemy.
The truth is always in front of your eyes, but rarely reaches your brain.
Mark Hennebury
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#30Nice post, Mark
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#31Citation please?
Steve Voigt
Warren, I don't think I know Martin (1813). Do you have the title, please?
Is Smith (1816) the same as Smith's key?
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#32Salute to the path 2 teachers and mentors
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Accept that if you need a place to put your socks and path two is employed for very many steps of the journey your socks will accumulate on the floor....or visit IKEA.
Thankfully some pursuing path two share what they learn with those pursuing path one, which enables the path one pursuers to make more and better stuff. A salute to the path two teachers and mentors.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#33a result not a specification
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What I quoted was the result of an experiment. These values yielded the best result within the bounds of the experimental space explored. I have said numerous times that as far as we have translated Kato and Kawai never recommended any setting, which is not to be confused with reporting results or experimental conditions that led to results.
Anybody wishing to explore the benefit of the cap would find these values a place to start, and stop, if it met their need.
This work is an example of why research results are published, and reviewed, and books published. It gives others a place to start. Each generation stands on the shoulders of those that came before them.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#34Re: Citation please?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Here are the references, Steve. They are not so earth shaking, but part of the picture.
Thomas Martin The Circle of the Mechanical Arts 1813 page 481
James Smith The Panorama of Science and Art Volume 1 1815 page 108
Sorry for the ambiguity; I forgot about Joseph Smith.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#35Bill, sometimes you need to look a little harder
markhennebury
I was sharing quite a lot of what i have learned.
Mark Hennebury
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#36Re: more from Kato and Kawai
marhk
I don't write much any more but - I still read.
I just have to wonder why folks want to ignore the only actual data on this issue? It seems clear in the video - 80 degrees works better. The author even reported that.
Now as to resistance to plane travel - my opinion would be that a cap iron ground at mainly a polished 30 degrees with the edge sharpened and honed to 80 degrees would not add much to forward resistance to travel. (No data, just my opinion) However, here is where we split hairs about how wide the leading 80 degree bevel should be for a hand operated plane.
Mark
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#37the only data?!
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If indeed you read my communication skills have failed. There are lots of data as I have stated numerous times.

I have several papers the authors wrote where they describe the cap iron angle used. Soon I hope you will have available to read the translation of the tutorial they wrote for setting up the hand plane where they used an angle of 50 degrees. Figure 9 of the video they report at 50 degrees "Neither chipped nor torn grain occur" (Kato's English translation of the Japanese text) Ditto for Figure 11 with the cap iron angle at 80 degrees. Figure 9 and 11 show that angle and distance interact (and likely several other variables not studied in this experiment as well).
Kato believes that the friction generated by the shaving sliding up and over the cap iron generates the downward force through the shaving stiffness necessary to prevent grain fracture ahead of the blade tip. From this hypothesis one can further hypothesize the variables that would interplay to generate this friction induced force- stiffness of the wood fibers, perhaps planing speed, cap iron angle and distance, others?
Indeed finding the optimum for a situation may involve either a lot of experience or trial and error. On the other hand something even far from optimum may be good enough in many cases and sand the rest.
We are trying to reestablish communication with Kato. A question to be asked is why is the great majority of their work done with a cap iron angle of 50 degrees and not some other angle. I expect the answer is that there is some other price to pay for the high angle and Steve may have revealed it.
BTW, if an experiment explores a variable with a gap between them of 30 degrees (50 vs 80) one would be at great risk to conclude from the data that either is optimum for the situation. The optimum could lie outside this range or somewhere between. To find an optimum one changes the variable in small steps and looks for a response to get better, peak and then get worse. No doubt it is for this reason that Kato never recommended at cap iron angle in any paper.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#38Re: more from Kato and Kawai
david weaver
80 isn't something you want to use as a rule by hand, anyway. Curved and closer to stock stanley profile is what you want.
The machine is a fixed set of variables, and hand planing is not. The reason you don't want 80 is the working projection range is fairly narrow. Closer to 50 and it widens, perhaps the curvature makes the final angle slightly steeper, but it's not 80 on any of my planes. On a try plane, just over 50 might straighten a chip from 5 to 9 thousandths and prevent tearout across all settings. If a blunt 80 degree wall is applied to a chipbreaker, then the working range is narrow and the difference in settings is abrupt and very annoying.
When this started, it was pretty easy to separate the wheat from the chaff, because the chaff was just parroting what was said in the video and not afraid to post recommendations about things they didn't even try.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#39Re: more from Kato and Kawai
marhk
So, we are back to opinion vs. the only real data on the subject. I guess saying it makes it true?
Mark
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#40Excellent, thanks Warren
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#41Re: more from Kato and Kawai
david weaver
The only real data? Did you ignore Bill's post about the professors recommending 50 degrees for use with hand planes (and that's not something I knew until the last three days or so - it was easy enough to figure out on my own).
You stated in your post you haven't actually tried any of this.
Try it. It's not that hard to figure it out just based on how it works in practice.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#42Re: more from Kato and Kawai
marhk
Sorry, but you are mixing up an editorial comment from the author with results supported by actual documentation in the video. Now, if he has experimental evidence (which is what led me to this video in the first place) to support some other conclusion then I'm in. For now, 80 degrees is his official published position.
As far as using this - I've been trying all sorts of cap iron settings for years including 80 degrees which seems to work if the bevel is not too wide. (And, no, I didn't say that I haven't tried this - I have, since the early 1960's.)
Regards
Mark
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#43Re: more from Kato and Kawai
Steve Voigt
Aha. I see the problem now, loud and clear.
When David writes:
The reason you don't want 80 is the working projection range is fairly narrow. Closer to 50 and it widens, perhaps the curvature makes the final angle slightly steeper, but it's not 80 on any of my planes. On a try plane, just over 50 might straighten a chip from 5 to 9 thousandths and prevent tearout across all settings. If a blunt 80 degree wall is applied to a chipbreaker, then the working range is narrow and the difference in settings is abrupt and very annoying.
It's "opinion" and not "real data." It's pretty obvious that his highly specific observations are taken from direct observation at the workbench. In my mind, that makes them far more useful, but I guess they're "opinion" because, I dunno, because they're not couched in the language of a scientific study? Because they don't have the impartiality of a planing machine like the one used in K/K, something that is utterly unlike a real planing situation?
A couple weeks ago, there was a request here for feedback on cap iron angles. I wrote:
as CB angle increases, small changes in distance have more drastic effects. With a very high angle, it's a bit like riding in a sportscar. You have the CB set back a bit and you don't even notice it, then you move it just a little and wham!--it's like you're pushing a 60° single iron plane. Whereas with a CB angle in the 50°-60° range, things are a bit smoother.
Notice how similar my observations are to David's, though less detailed. We both establish a relationship between the severity of the angle and the effective range of the chipbreaker effect. It's not because we compared notes, it's because mine were also based on direct observation at the bench. But obviously my observations aren't "real data" either, because two weeks later in this thread it is asked:
Is anyone experimenting under US wood and plane conditions to see what angle or range of angle is optimum?
So, I'm glad I understand now that actual, practical experience and observation don't count as either "experimenting" or "real data."
Gee, I can't possibly imagine why Warren was reluctant to post detailed information, or a tutorial, about his experiences with the double iron.
I think I'm done here.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#44Re: more from Kato and Kawai
david weaver
Official position for what, how to set a super surfacer?
Are you an engineer?
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#45Re: Going off half cocked
TomD
An open mind and going off half cocked are two different things. It is perfectly easy to see many situation where the cap iron is useless and surplus. These have been enumerated here ad naseum with very little evidence of open minds as far as the proponents of cap irons are concerned. To take cap irons seriously one needs to establish their usefulness which was apparently done hundreds of years ago. Then one has to engage in the work for which they provide any useful increment of performance. That was also established years ago when we look at a universe of planes almost all cap iron less.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#46Re: more from Kato and Kawai
TomD
It worries me a little that these are results for a machine. The research elements of this seem to continue as though the Japanese do not actually make hand planes, blade sets, or prep them to some kind of observable dimensions. I have quite a few sets but mostly I ground away the secondary bevels and they still seemed to work. The primary bevel (which might not actually be the one doing the work in some cases) is normally about 25 degrees.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#47Re: more from Kato and Kawai
TomD
I'm not so exercised about the idea of science vs observation, but one always has to keep in mind results are only as meaningful as the questions that one is trying to answer. So if for instance the question was how long can one plane between sharpenings, a scientific test might give interesting data, and the SS with it's elaborate sharpner might be a good testbed. But as to what angle gives the best feedback to the user and produces the best results when planing x wood, the very fact that scientific test are trying to avoid subjectivity is a disadvantage in that case.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#48Don't give up
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It is abundantly clear to me, at least, that you and David have planed some orders of magnitude more than I. If you all use 50 degree then you have convinced me to at least start there (which coincidentally (well, probably not coincidentally) happen to be the angle Kato and Kawai used in nearly all the results they published). Hence, I have benefited from some of this discussion.
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#49Spot on!
Re: more from Kato and Kawai
#50Old Stanleys
Kees
Lately I have been restoring 3 old Stanleys. They are from all from the 1890's. Out of curiosity I measured the angle of the capirons first. I used a sliding bevel, holding it up to a light until I couldn't see any light shing through in the corner anymore. I measured them slightly under 45 degrees.
I don't now how representative this small sample was. They didn't look like they had been tampered with. Increasing the angle is easy, reducing means a lot of grinding which I am sure hasn't been done to these.



