New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Question about jointer plane

Posts

Re: Question about jointer plane

#26

Re: Unnecessary fretting

Dan Rode

I can't recall an edge joint I've made failing. Not one. I'm just a hobbyist, so the number of edge joints I've made is maybe a a couple (few) hundred over the last 20 years. By the same token, I'm in close contact with most of 'em. Most of what I make in in my home or that of family and friends, so I'd know if something split.

Maybe 100 years from now, I'll be the guy who made kindling, but not so far.

I make them flat or slightly sprung, never concave. Square (or matching) edges, enough glue and even pressure (not too tight). I think that's the whole recipe.

I clamp most joints but for smaller and thin stuff, I'll use stretched tape to pull it together. I prefer my Bessy K clamps, but pipe clamps have worked just as well.

It's so simple a task that I rarely think about it.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#27

Re: No Clamps - Green Tape

TomD

Though I wouldn't recommend it to others, it is the method I first tried, and I remain fascinated by it. I prepare the edges as you say, then clamp one to a board, and simply rub the other against the first, and let them grow together. There is nothing holding them together. It is just a rubbed joint but it works so well it never fails to delight.

The best way is probably that 3 wedges and rope caul method developed by Charlie Fox. It never goes wrong, or comes back. There is very little gear and the advantage is that even with the incredible wood we have to build guitars out of, it still sometimes has a wobble at the edge that needs a little control.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#28

Re: Stuff still breaks at the glue joint

TomD

"A well done glued joint is stronger than the wood. So why would a well made joint preferentially fracture over some other location if the end of a panel dried out too quickly?"

I agree with most everything you said. The only but is this idea that the glue joint is stronger than the surrounding wood.

1) "stronger" means a variety of things, even in the simple world of furniture. Is the joint more resistant to elastic creep, probably not, and there is ample scientific testing to show that including testing you can do in your own shop. Often joints will telegraph over time as the glue slips. Titebond one, as an example, has an excellent reputation for low creep. That is why it is the only stuff of that kind I use. Other glues that cost the same and come from manufacturers with labs too, fail.

2) Assumes all grain is side grain. In many cases with figured wood there is some non-parallel grain. This will not be stronger in split than surrounding grain.

3) Over time stuff falls apart at the glue joints. What the statement you made refers to is normally, as in the example, someone glues stuff together, snaps it apart, and it doesn't break in the joint. That certainly tells you stuff you need to know at the time, but it is a cartoonish model of a failure mode. But stick around, over time that is exactly where it breaks. If you take in repairs, continuous wood often stays together, and glue joints come apart.

4) If you have something like a canoe paddle, even with the best industrial glues, the solid ones hold together and the laminated ones come apart (the super laminated and glassed ones usually don't come apart). The reasons isn't the water and all that, it is just the dissimilar pieces of wood that work against each other. Most paddles live indoors except for a few hours. Normal expansion and contraction cycles shear the joints apart. It is just one example I can think of where you have nearly identical structures one of which is all solid wood and another that is not.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#29

point made, and a new point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hear by change the title to "unnecessary detailed techniques that are painstaking and meticulous".

Why is such a discussion useful to have.....Beginners. Make something sound more difficult that it needs to be and beginners may not try it or waste time learning something that they may eventually find unnecessary for them.

My calling something needless fretting means that at least I, and this usually means more than I, find that what ever is being fretted is being made unnecessarily painstaking and/or meticulous. I recognize that others thrive on just this kind of activity. The beginner needs to know that there is a choice. Learning how to spring a joint , for example, does not need to be learned to get on with making a panel. That said, it is a technique challenge that some may find a worthy challenge to learn, and it certainly doesn't hurt.

The reader benefits from both perspectives.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#30

The myth of too tight

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

By my testing and confirmation from the tech staff of Franklin glue company "yellow glue" is immune to clamp pressure beyond what is required to squeeze excess glue from the joint. So as long as the assembly does not distort there is no adverse consequence to cranking down the clamps. There is no evidence to support the "starved joint" from excessive clamp pressure claim. As the clamps are tightened water leaves the glue and it viscosity climbs dramatically. It is impossible to squeeze too much of it out of the joint. On the other hand it is possible to not squeeze out enough, or not bring the wood surfaces together sufficiently by insufficient clamp pressure.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#31

Removing squeeze out- unnecessary fretting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Case 1, gluing hit and miss thickness planed lumber I don't worry about it. The next step is running the panel through the thickness planer to achieve a target thickness and the planer does not care if the glue drops are a rock. (I know this is the Hand tool forum, a place I maybe don't belong)

Case 2a, gluing lumber that is already at target thickness. When I remember to do so I remove the clamps when the squeeze out is rubbery (1-3 hours) and scrap it off with a Red Devil paint scraper. Unless I know the joint is stressed I leave the clamps off at this point.

Case 2b, (much of the time) Hours or days later the glue is a rock. I knock it off with a Red Devil scraper or flea market block plane relegated for the purpose. Care must be taken to not lift divots of wood under the glue drops. A wide shallow sweep works good too.

Case 3 wash it off at once.....seems like a bad idea that I never employ. I stain most everything I build and I don't know how one keeps the glue from penetrating and interfering with stain.

Note: I put news paper between clamps and wood to prevent iron stain.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#32

good tip, question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what kind of glue have you fond this technique to work with?

Re: Question about jointer plane

#33

Re: Question about jointer plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Those joints sound fine to me.

Drawer bottoms tend to be fairly thin, unless of course this is a big ole drawer.

So on the chance you're jointing 'thins', I wanted to ask: Do you ever shoot edges, with the plane on its side? If not, it's a good technique to pick up, dead easy, and need not be fussy. For shooting long grain, two lengths of plywood and a plane that is pretty square are all you need. Photo if interested. I recognize you may be well-acquainted with the method.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#34

i certainly benefit

Joe shelton

And thank you

Re: Question about jointer plane

#35

Re: Question about jointer plane

Joe shelton

Hey, Wiley,

I tried that, or pretty much that, but had a problem with keeping the two boards together. A picture would be very nice, thanks.

Good luck to Davidson in the tourney, too.

Joe

Re: Question about jointer plane

#36

Re: Question about jointer plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe and all,

I've tried it both ways--shooting one at a time or ganging two or more--and find that one at a time is simplest and fastest for me (others' mileage does vary).

Normally, I don't bother to clamp things down--just hold the work in place with one hand and move the plane in the other. Here's a picture, using a 22" try plane, but plane length or type doesn't t matter, as long as the plane is pretty square:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8261509377/in/album-72157632172323442/lightbox/

Plane from the 'inside out', starting with the middle first, then working outward til you go end to end in the final pass. If you don't have to clamp, then it's easy to check fit as you go.

There are much fancier ways to do this, but for flat stock, you can go simple.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#37

Re: good tip, question

Hank Knight

Bill,

I've used both hide glue (hot and bottled) and Titebond. It works fine with both. I don't finish drawer bottoms, so I usually use Titebond for those. If I'm going to finish the panel, I use hide glue. I've gotten it down so I have almost no squeeze out, but I still worry about getting a glue smudge on a panel I plan to finish. Hide glue solves that problem.

Hank

Re: Question about jointer plane

#38

Re: The myth of too tight

Dan Rode

That's interesting to know. I tend to be a little strong armed with the clamp pressure, so perhaps I can just relax about tightening too much.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#39

Re: The myth of too tight

Hank Knight

I used to worry about "starved joints" until I read Franklin's write-up Bill refers to. According to Franklin, the glue line in a properly clamped joint is invisible. If you can see a glue line, you haven't used enough clamp pressure and the joint will be weak. As Bill says, you can hardly use too much clamp pressure. Now I crank down on the clamps hard when I'm using tightbond. The pressure is to eliminate the glue line, not to make up for poorly cut joinery. If you have to exert a lot of force to pull a joint together, you need to go back to the bench and refine the joint. If it doesn't fit properly without glue, glue and clamps won't fix it in the long run. Some joints, like thin panels we are discussing here, aren't generally stressed, so I don't worry about using a lot of clamp pressure. Sometmes a lot of clamp pressure is counterproductive. It can warp or deform a joint or force a structure out of square.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#40

Re: Alternatives to Newspaper

William Duffield

There are some other strategies I employ to prevent iron staining on glue joints.

Instead of newspaper, I have used squares of Visqueen (plastic sheeting). SWax paper also works. Either of these are also useful to catch epoxy and aliphatic resin dripout from under small items being glued up About a foot square is convenient. I don't need to fret about bleed-through. Admittedly, bleed-through is only a problem if you are really heavy handed with your glue bottle.

I cut lengths of PVC pipe and slide a stack of them over my pipe clamps. About 2-1/2" long seems to be convenient. A disadvantage shows up when you run out of short clamps and need to use a long one to complete a glue-up, since you have to slide the end off the pipe clamp, remove some sections of PVC, put the clamp back together, and put the extra PVC sections somewhere until you are done with the glue-up.

The bars on Bessey K-body clamps are chrome plated, so they don't rust. Also, it's a bit easier to remove the hardened glue from them than from pipe clamps.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#41

why news paper is better, I hate pipe clamps

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Newspaper absorbs glue and water which enables it to harden where the paper is located. Having all the glue line dry after the clamps come off is an advantage for clean-up. I keep a stack of news paper in the shop and use it for many tasks.

2. Expect for the potential handiness of making very long clamps, pipe clamps have no advantage over other styles, and their lack of stiffness is a fatal disadvantage..

Personally, the aluminum bar clamps now sold by Lee Valley would be my recommended clamp to buy. Their light weight , strength and stiffness make them a top choice. The popular Bessy clamps are to heavy and too expensive by comparison. I don't know why they are popular. I bought 2 thinking I was missing something but never found any advantageous use for them.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#42

Bessey clamps are popular because of.....

roger lance

Norm......and they work really well which is why most owners stick with them (which is why companies like Jet have introduced their version to get a piece of Bessey's action).

The LV clamps are less expensive but are only offered in a small size range of 24" -36" - 48"......which is fine if you only build things that that size of clamp can handle.....but bigger builds call for bigger clamps.

As far as Besseys being too heavy, I've never noticed that as my muscle mass is still intact!! :D :D

Re: Question about jointer plane

#43

Removing squeeze out

Steve Elliott

The following comments refer to yellow glue, although some may also apply to other adhesives.

When possible I leave the glued up panel horizontal so that the drips of squeeze out on the underside don't run down the surface of the panel. If I haven't used too much glue I can set the panel up vertically after the glue has skinned over a little.

At some point the glue in the middle of the largest blobs reaches a consistency where it is soft but won't stick again to a new surface it might touch--in particular the surface of the wood panel. At this point I use an old 6-inch stainless rule to scrape the soft glue off the panel. Even if I'm going to put the panel through the planer or a widebelt sander I like to have the glue mostly removed. A hardened blob of glue on the underside of a workpiece going through the planer will affect the thickness of the piece. On a widebelt sander the blob of glue will probably be pressed into the rubber feed belt so that it doesn't affect the dimension, but removing yellow glue with an abrasive belt can heat the glue and make it clog the abrasive.

Sometimes washing off the squeeze out is necessary, but it can cause problems with staining and finishing if the glue isn't thoroughly removed. On a hard, non-porous wood like maple there's not too much of a problem but on porous species like oak and mahogany it's best to remove as much glue as possible by scraping and then to wet the surface and dilute the glue until it can be washed out of the pores. After all the glue appears to be gone there will still be a little glue in the water being removed. Using a damp cloth to feather out the edges of the area that was washed will make it unlikely that the remaining glue will cause a visible line during finishing.

For a while I worked at a furniture shop that used obeche, a light-colored African wood that is as soft as balsa. The veneer was wide and had a beautiful ribbon grain figure but it was like using a layer of cellulose sponge that was 20 thousandths of an inch thick. Even the veneer tape with stickum like a postage stamp would leave a pattern that showed up in finishing. I learned to wet the entire veneered surface and leave it wet for about five minutes while the stickum dissolved, then to wipe it off and rinse a couple of times. We used urea formaldehyde glue in the hot press so softening the glue wasn't a concern.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#44

Re: Bessey clamps are popular because of.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger and all,

I keep looking at those LV 700-lb. quick clamps that Bill spoke of.

However, I really like Bessey K-body clamps because they make such a sturdy and level bed, and clamp square so I don't have to alternate having them clamp from above and from below. Maybe this is typical of most modern clamps, and I just like what I have :) .

The square plastic moldings make them good for all kinds of miscellaneous stuff--the clamp by itself can be used as a stop blocks for shooting against.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#45

Re: good tip, question

wilbur

Hi Hank,

Is there an advantage of using Titebond over bottled hide glue (assuming you mean liquid hide glue) for your drawer bottoms that you’re not going to finish? I’ve pretty much given up using PVA glues for most things unless it’s a project that I know is going to contact water, such as a cutting board.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#46

Re: Bessey clamps are popular because of.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Clearly you have not had enough of them on a project you needed to move!

The LV clamps are available from the manufacturer up to at least 6', maybe 8.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#47

Re: Bessey clamps are popular because of.....

roger lance

I've overcome problems with having to move heavy projects/glue ups with whatever the number/weight of clamps by having my assembly table on wheels.

Stalemate. :D

Re: Question about jointer plane

#48

Re: good tip, question

Hank Knight

Hi, Wilbur,

I don't think there is any advantage. I use PVA for most everything, so I use it as a matter of habit. The only time I have any concern about it is when it might interfere with the finish. Then I use hide glue. I've used hot hide glue and liquid (bottled) hide glue and have had no issues with it. Hot hide glue is a little more trouble, but I've enjoyed the results every time I've used it. Unless something triggers a warning i my mind, I use PVA, because I'm (A) lazy, and (B) a creature of habit.

Hank

Re: Question about jointer plane

#49

Re: good tip, question

wilbur

Inertia is hard to overcome, isn’t it? ;)

I’ve taken to saying that there are two reasons to use PVA glue over hide glue. (1) when you need water resistance, and (2) when you want to make finishing more difficult. :D

Re: Question about jointer plane

#50

I never liked them much...

John in NM

Years ago a shop I worked for had a couple in addition to all the pipe clamps and iron bar clamps. I tried them and found them overly fussy compared to pipe clamps. Its been so long now that I can't remember what was fussy, but really I've never seen much to agree with in the pipe clamp complaining.

Pipe clamps have their faults, but I find those faults to be out weighed by their extreme economy and versatility. One day when I have tons of money to spend on this stuff, I may try other options, but I suspect I'll still prefer lots of pipes around.

Now if you want to talk about the best clamp ever made - Wetzler F clamps were it.