Re: Stuff still breaks at the glue joint
TomD
"A well done glued joint is stronger than the wood. So why would a well made joint preferentially fracture over some other location if the end of a panel dried out too quickly?"
I agree with most everything you said. The only but is this idea that the glue joint is stronger than the surrounding wood.
1) "stronger" means a variety of things, even in the simple world of furniture. Is the joint more resistant to elastic creep, probably not, and there is ample scientific testing to show that including testing you can do in your own shop. Often joints will telegraph over time as the glue slips. Titebond one, as an example, has an excellent reputation for low creep. That is why it is the only stuff of that kind I use. Other glues that cost the same and come from manufacturers with labs too, fail.
2) Assumes all grain is side grain. In many cases with figured wood there is some non-parallel grain. This will not be stronger in split than surrounding grain.
3) Over time stuff falls apart at the glue joints. What the statement you made refers to is normally, as in the example, someone glues stuff together, snaps it apart, and it doesn't break in the joint. That certainly tells you stuff you need to know at the time, but it is a cartoonish model of a failure mode. But stick around, over time that is exactly where it breaks. If you take in repairs, continuous wood often stays together, and glue joints come apart.
4) If you have something like a canoe paddle, even with the best industrial glues, the solid ones hold together and the laminated ones come apart (the super laminated and glassed ones usually don't come apart). The reasons isn't the water and all that, it is just the dissimilar pieces of wood that work against each other. Most paddles live indoors except for a few hours. Normal expansion and contraction cycles shear the joints apart. It is just one example I can think of where you have nearly identical structures one of which is all solid wood and another that is not.