New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Question about jointer plane

Posts

Re: Question about jointer plane

#51

neither reason is valid

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Titebond II is resistant to water and III is water proof. The most widely used common Titebond and its brothers are not, and in fact it is as reversible as hide glue with heat and/or steam.

I don' t understand the fear with finishing, nor have I ever heard this concern before. If there were finishing issues it would not be by a huge factor (likely 10000:1 or more) the most widely used wood glue.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#52

Re: Woodworking made unnecesssarily complicated

Sgian Dubh

Bill, are you suggesting using a clamping board is an over-complication for gluing up thin panels? I've never found that to be the case, being a technique that simplifies the process in my experience because of the ease of preventing buckling across the width as pressure is applied. Slainte.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#53

Re: Bessey clamps are popular because of.....

Dan Rode

I like my Bessy K clamps. I only have a few and no intentions to buy more. I bought a set of 4 24" and 2 40" clamps for $79 years ago. Due to the weight and cost, I don't want more than that. They are terrific for applying pressure evenly without pushing things out of square or the sliding from the rotation on F clamps.

I don't own any, but I like the aluminium bar clamps. Good design and they are fairly light.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#54

Finishing for newbies..

david weaver

..I think the titebond thing is a problem for beginners who get surprised by a surface looking clean and then showing that it is not once there is finish on it. For anyone else here who is at the sealing step, this isn't the end of the world - especially sealing with shellac. Scrape it off and reapply.

I don't find a great difference between titebond and liquid hide for finish interference, because any significant amount of either left on a surface is unwanted. I usually use liquid hide because I don't have something up and going consistently enough for hide glue.

Kitchen cabinets have been all TBIII, though. It's cheaper, its waterproof (important), repairable doesn't matter much (the first woman who moves into our house after me will have the cabinets ripped out so that they can change the color), and I can use it in my shop in the winter, which is about 50 degrees. When I get forced to make something else, like the recent bookshelf, I'll use hide because I intend to keep it, but the temperature (60 degrees in the adjoining basement, and as low as 40 in the shop some days this year when it barely got above 0 makes liquid hide a no go unless a cold weld joint is good enough.

Anyway, I have no important spots on any cabinets where I've had a TBIII issue with finish, but the very first piece I ever made 10 years ago has a big blotch on it. It'd have had a problem with hide glue, too, though, as much glue as I missed near one of the mouldings. This reminds me of a topic for discussion.

(aside from the fact that we all get better at everything we do if we repeat it a few times - including avoiding getting glue where we don't want it, and then accidentally leaving it behind before finishing).

Re: Question about jointer plane

#55

Re: I also like the old K bodies..

david weaver

..They have a very simple mechanism in them and they work the way they're supposed to. The're borderline overly heavy, but the next generation of loppy overweight stuff that came after them...china made junk....in my opinion, it sucks.

Someone pushing a pencil and appealing to beginners decided if you made every part 50% bigger and heavier, made it in the third world and then appealed to beginners making them thing you need a thumb trigger for cabinet clamp, that it would be better. It's probably lined the pockets of a few people, but now we have garbage instead of the reasonably priced and nice to use K bodies.

One of the worst jokes in clamping (and I say this because I have some of these) is the Jet door clamp set. $270 for awkward loppy made in china clamps. When they came out, they sold them for $99 to try to squeeze german made bessey clamp sets that were about $150.

I guess there's always a supply of beginners, but that, in my opinion, is a terrible joke. they got me on price early on, I have half jet and half bessey. I wish I had no jet clamps. I just shake my head at chinese clamps that are almost $70 each (and none of the four in a pack are particularly long).

Re: Question about jointer plane

#56

Re: neither reason is valid

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It doesn't sound like you have done a lot of restoration work. Hide glue is very much easier to deal with when you need to take something apart.

I visited some friends over the weekend and came home with a cabinet door to repair. It has crappy joinery and crappy glue. A through tenon and hide glue would be a very routine job to disassemble. Good joinery would not have failed as easily as this has. I am going to glue it without taking it apart and hope for the best. It is tempting to just make a whole new door. If it had not been a dear friend, I would have never have touched the job. Life is too short to fool with throwaway furniture.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#57

Re: neither reason is valid

Hank Knight

"Life is too short to fool with throwaway furniture."

Warren, that's a great tag line! :)