New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Question about jointer plane

Posts

Question about jointer plane

#1

Question about jointer plane

Joe shelton

When using a jointer, how coarse a cut do you take? Under what circumstance do you vary the thickness of the shaving you take? How often do you take shavings that are around .003 or .004 inches?

Thanks for feedback.

Joe

Re: Question about jointer plane

#2

Re: Question about jointer plane

Brian Holcombe

I pulled some shavings from yesterday's pile, I was dimensioning walnut;

Heavy cuts (almost all of them are heavy shy the last few strokes) .0045"

Light cuts (to finish) .0020"

Sometimes I take a heavier cut yet, that is not problem but was unnecessary in this instance.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#3

Re: Question about jointer plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've never measured shavings off my jointer, but I can say that the thickness of the cut depends on what I'm doing. If, for instance, I'm fitting a door, then the cut can be much thicker, maybe .005 or so. But if flattening a panel, approaching the final surface, then those shavings will get to around .002. Now not having measure those shavings I can't tell you precisely but those are good guesses.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#4

bridger

Re: Question about jointer plane

bridger

I guess I'm more likely to adjust the jointer plane for a mediumish shaving and leave it there. If I need to move stock faster than that will get me there I'll get out a jack.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#5

Re: Question about jointer plane

TomD

The depth of cut varies as to how curved you want the surface to be. It is a little more complex than the following, but conceptually if you have 1 thou projection you will get a surface that is curved over the length of a plane to 1 thou. If you have two plane lengths it is going to be a lot more than 2 though out, it will be like two 1 thou arcs connected together. Of course one doesn't functionally think of it in those terms, but it helps to know the relationship. In practice you use it to create the curve you can use relative to the aspect ratio of the material in question. Stuff like bookmatched cabinet door panels, or guitar tops are extremely stiff and require very fine shavings over the length of a plane. Some other stuff springs easily and can be quite curved allowing rapid stock reduction. Jointer plane length is mainly about these ratios as other planes can do the surface smoothing and ripple removing, only jointers plane spring into joints automatically as a function of their geometry and without operator skill. 1 thou over 22 inches as a no brainer is a pretty cool function and it can be better than that if needed.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#6

Re: Question about jointer plane

david weaver

Heavy as I can get away with. Probably something more like 5 thousandths with a long jointer, and whatever about 80% of the max I can possibly push would be on the try plane. If I test fit boards and they are proud just at a spot, instead of working that spot with a jointer, use a smoother instead to get a no tension fit.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#7

Re: Question about jointer plane

Mark P

I keep my #7 at a medium (.003) cut. If I need to pull off a lot of material I use the #5. I use a smoother after the jointer to finish. I almost never have large surfaces to do. The largest panel I usually have would be 30" x 60" or so.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#8

Re: Question about jointer plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

For me, the jointer, usually 26", is used to do the final shaping of the edge. 1 to 2 thou shavings, I would guess. The shaving thickness is based on setting the spring of the board (see below). The board will already be in good shape for square and spring (or no spring) and if I'm hitting a width line (which is rare) it will be right at the line by the time I get to the jointer. Maybe 3-4 passes with the jointer to get the ends and center in right relation.

Prior to the jointer, I will use an 18" or 20" fore plane with approx. 1/32 or 3/64 camber, and maybe a 22" try plane. If rough sawn, the fore plane; if already s4s or straight from being power sawn, then to the try plane and then jointer.

Will pay particular attention to two things:

1. Make sure there's not a little hump approx. 1/2" in from either end.

2. Get the spring right. This depends on length and thickness of the stick being jointed. This is gauged by shaving thickness on the final pass--usually slightly thinner at the middle of the board than at the ends. For example, if the plane is taking 1 thou shavings, and it's 4/4 stock 40" long, I would want the blade to just kiss the middle of the board.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#9

Re: Question about jointer plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

When removing a shaving for a spring joint, do you do so from one adjoining edge or both boards?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question about jointer plane

#10

Re: Question about jointer plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

I do all boards the same, so if there is to be spring, it will be the same on both boards. As I said, for the wood I use at 4/4, about one thousandth for each board over 3 or 4 feet seems about right. The boards should come together with a hollow 'clack' and the join should disappear to the eye with very light hand pressure.

'Sprung' is almost too strong a word for what I am after. I want the ends slightly in compression. It will not be necessary to squeeze the two edges together to make the join disappear--very light hand pressure only.

On shorter or 8/4 wood, no spring is often the rule.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#11

Re: Question about jointer plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I do all boards the same, so if there is to be spring, it will be the same on both boards.

Hi Wiley

I do the same as you do, but there is an interesting issue here.

I wonder if a spring/sprung joint actually requires both edges to be planed since the aim is to create a slight concavity between the boards with the intent to add slight extra tension at the ends? Does planing both edges equalise tension in the centre? Would planing one side force the boards out of alignment?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question about jointer plane

#12

Re: Question about jointer plane

Sgian Dubh

"Does planing both edges equalise tension in the centre?"

Derek, I can't see that it makes a great deal of difference if both edges are concave, or if one edge is straight and the other edge is hollow. Whichever is the case pressure at the mid-point of the two assembled boards will bring the edges together along the whole length, although frequently not tight enough when the glue is applied and the joint needs a series of clamps from one end to the other. The pressure required to pull the (ideally) tiny gap in sprung joints of any sort together should be minimal, no more than the pressure needed to hold a downward facing fairly thick telephone directory between finger and thumb - I imagine you remember how thick telephone directory's used to be, but maybe nowadays the analogy should be updated to a fairly thick book of any sort, ha, ha.

You're more likely to have to bend one board more than another, if that's what you were alluding to, to close the gap if you are dealing with boards of markedly different width where the narrower board would naturally bend more easily than the wider board, whatever concavity is worked (or not worked) on either or both edges. In my work, it's seldom the case that I use equal width boards to make up a panel and I've not come across a problem, although I do like to make sure that each join does have a 'spring'.

Actually, if you think about it, there's no real reason for not making joined edges that are wavy, even markedly wavy, or S shaped, just so long as the edges line up very well without a gap at either end that needs extra pressure to pull it up. I can't recall including this feature in any of my own work but I've done it for employers and helped quite a few people do just this where perhaps they wanted to join two different coloured woods together with a sinuous line, e.g., sycamore and cherry, or maple and walnut.

As to the discussion about try planes and the thickness or thinness of the shavings you can, could, or should get out of them, I don't think I've anything useful to add. I've never measured a shaving of any sort for thickness, it being something that has never occurred to me to do. If I need to plane more off quickly I set the iron deeper, and if I just need a light skim I retract the blade a bit, and that's about all there is to it, although it's quite easy to get a slightly heavier shaving for a pass or two without adjusting the iron, if desired, simply by bending the sole of the plane slightly convex in the hands as you use it. Slainte.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#13

Re: Question about jointer plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

I agree with Richard in all respects, including his remarks about using multiple clamps (sometimes you hear about one clamp in the middle being sufficient).

His remark about the boards in a glue up being generally of different widths is also pertinent. Whatever concavity there is will--when clamped shut--create a reaction shared between the boards with equal pressure going each way along their join line, causing some tiny deflection in the boards inversely proportionate to their widths cubed.

If the boards are over sprung, they will go into torsion and begin a twist, if they have that degree of freedom. Hence, for our dry wood (Oz and So. Cal.), I think the least concavity that will cause the ends to come together just ahead of the center is the one we want. [here endeth Prof. Corey style lecture :) ].

In other words, Richard nailed it.

Wiley

Re: Question about jointer plane

#14

Re: Question about jointer plane

TomD

I agree with that. It is questionable if the gap adds anything. Despite various clever theories. But it is a result of stop cutting with a jointer and it doesn't cause any harm, unless the aspect ratio of the board is too stiff. For very wide to length pieces, because stiffness is a third order property they need to be considered as incompressible.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#15

Re: Question about jointer plane

Sgian Dubh

"(sometimes you hear about one clamp in the middle being sufficient)"

I have to admit Wiley I've managed to get away with that trick a few times. It's not something I'd recommend as normal practice. I recall once an "unmissable" deadline fast approaching and a need to get two or three panels manufactured in a bit of a hurry. The wood was slammed over the surface planer, faces and edges, rammed through the thicknesser and left fat, edges skimmed for a spring with a No 7 try plane, PVA slathered on the edges, and single clamp in the middle of each panel. The panels were prepped and clamped one after the other, and half an hour or so later the first in clamp was whipped out, and on to the surface planer again, followed by the other panels, and then they all went through the thicknesser prior to the rest of the follow up work.

From beginning to end there may have been two and half to three hours putting those panels together starting with rough sawn wood, and why those panels have survived for the last 35 years or so I've never really worked out. But survive they did because I saw them again recently when visiting the old client's premises, and the joints are still tight. It's remarkable sometimes what you can get away with ... and at others where meticulous forethought, preparation and work practices lead only to failure! Slainte.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#16

Re: Question about jointer plane

Joe shelton

Rich, that's interesting, but only about half reassuring. I'm gluing up panels for solid wood drawer bottoms now, and trying to spring joints in a condition of ignorance. Last night I trimmed ends on a number of these panels, and tested joints by breaking them. Many of these joints (in off cut ends) had markedly different adjoining members, sometimes differing in long grain length by 3/8".

Every one of them broke with wood failure on one side of the joint.

Does this auger well for the future, or will wood movement still separate the ends of some of them? And with the parting, will I lose my card in the guild?

Re: Question about jointer plane

#17

Re: Question about jointer plane

TomD

I can't say I have ever had a panel separate at the ends whether sprung or not. It might happen in an extreme if you moved somewhere very different, but it still shouldn't happen in the ends. If the end glued up, weren't dry, and the middle disappeared when planed or sanded, it should be fine.

Bottoms are like book matched panels, they are short and fat. That is a bad place to use spring, though if it goes together without too much force it is probably fine. I am looking at a table that is about 6 feet long and 3 feet wide, and there are 5 equal boards. I glued up the two outside pairs, and them assembled them around the middle board. It would require 8 times the force to close the same joint around the middle pair. And one is still looking at an aspect ration of only about 1-5 vs 1-10. A two piece guitar top is about 4-10, so you can see how extreme that is if you are trying to close spring. That would be 8 times stiffer again. Or 64 times stiffer than pairing the 1-10 planks. In jointing the guitar or a two piece drawer I would try to use a method that created perfect, straight, edges.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#18

Re: Question about jointer plane

Sgian Dubh

"Every one of them broke with wood failure on one side of the joint."

Joe, the fact that the wood broke rather than breaking on the glue line suggests the glue bond is good. But as Tom mentioned, drawer bottoms tend be made of relatively short parts and any spring should be minimal.

I'm assuming the drawer bottoms are thin, something like 1/4" or 3/8" thick. This can be difficult to glue up satisfactorily with over and under clamps because the panel tends to buckle and cup across the width. It might be worth considering a clamping board, a piece of MDF, ply or particle board a bit wider than the panels. Fix a straight piece of wood firmly on the face along one edge. Lay the boards that make up the panel on the clamping board and suck them up tight to the fixed down straight edge with clamps or other means. This way you can align the top and bottom face of the drawer bottom pretty well by tapping (thumping?) every join line down level with a hammer and block of wood, and even get some downward pressure over each glue line, e.g., clamps, weights, etc.

This is just one variation of a clamping board, and how one is made depends a bit on how you plan to apply pressure to the outer edges of the glued up panel. For instance, you can fix two straight edges on either side to an over-wide clamping board and you can use spacers and folding wedges to apply pressure. And don't forget to put some polish (or some other barrier means) onto the surface of the clamping board to prevent the glued up panel sticking to it. Slainte.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#19

Unnecessary fretting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. My opinion of sprung joints- they are insurance that there are no gaps at the ends of the panel joints. (Millions of panel joints are successfully made each year without this feature.) Beyond that they offer insignificant benefit to keeping a joint together during an episode of drying the panel (seasonal changes). A well done glued joint is stronger than the wood. So why would a well made joint preferentially fracture over some other location if the end of a panel dried out too quickly?

2. If you are concerned about the ends of panels splitting in a drying episode finish the ends. Some testing I did on this topic demonstrated that finished end grain looses and gains moisture very slowly, thereby minimizing stress on the end of panels.

3. "Every one of them broke with wood failure on one side of the joint." Does this auger well for the future .....YES, ....." Testing the glued joints on end cut offs is to be recommended. It gives you feedback on the success of your panel preparation. "or will wood movement still separate the ends of some of them?" I have never had a drawer bottom joint fail, or any other panel joint failure. If the joint is tight before the clamps are applied and glue has wet both mating surfaces and all the excess glue is squeezed out the joint will be as good as it can get.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#20

Woodworking made unnecesssarily complicated

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Panel gluing can be simple. It is one of the most easily taught procedures. There are only a few things to worry about.

1. The joint needs to come together with minimal clamping pressure, especially the panel ends.

2. Glue must wet both surfaces.

3. Excess glue must be squeezed out, for the glues we normally use have no strength in a gap.

4. Arrange clamps to achieve approximate uniform clamping pressure. (The oft stated 45 degree clamp force distributed from the clamp head is a convenient but inaccurate and useless description of the situation. ) .

5.. Strive for good joint alignment to save level work later.breakfast is ready....more later

Re: Question about jointer plane

#21

clamping crutches- unnecessary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Clamp cauls and the like- No harm in using them, but, they are unnecessary and one can learn to do without them. (If forced into using a twisted or bowed piece of lumber some clamping aid will be necessary.)

Cauls can aid in aligning a joint and keeping it aligned as the clamp pressure is added, but I, and most others, don't use them. If I am striving to keep panel joints aligned as much as possible I glue them one joint at a time. I can usually keep the joint aligned to within a few shavings thickness. Yellow glue sets quick and a second joint in the panel can be made in 30 min or so. I start at one end of the panel joint and while coaxing the joint into alignment gently, and partially!, tighten clamps just enough to initiate squeeze out as I work my way down the joint. (Others start at the middle and work to each end. )

The joint will skid out of alignment if clamps are tightened too quickly. Yellow glue has fast tack so gently tightening clamps a little at a time along the length of the joints will avoid skidding joints. I will tighten clamps many times during the course of making the joint.

Too much glue makes aligning difficult. One should get just a bit of squeeze-out along the joint. Tons of glue slows the initial tack and promotes skidding as the clamps are tightened.

To prevent the panel from cupping there must be enough clamps on the top of the panel to balance the clamp force on the bottom. Using only the clamps under the panel, I get the joint aligned and snugged with most of the glue squeezed out to get initial tack . I then add the top clamps for balance and tighten all the clamps. I can successfully glue thin drawer bottoms by balancing the clamps top and bottom with out addition aids.

Banging on joints_ The rheological properties of partially set yellow glue make it highly resistant to impact, and weakly resistant to shear. As a result, pounding a joint into alignment may not be successful. Pulling/squeezing a joint into alignment with a clamp will work many minutes after the joint is made. If a panel joint slips out of alignment at an end, a C clamp hastily applied will slip it back into place.

How many clamps to use- the 45 degree description is without merit. How many clamps depends on how stiff the assembly is and the size of joint gaps to be pulled together. Two infinitely stiff boards could be clamped with one clamp. Limber strips needs a stiff backing piece to get uniform force applied along the joint. On the average I typically have a clamp every foot, but closer for a limber assembly.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#22

Fretting is vital

Joe shelton

It's my way of caring about what I'm doing and what the result is. You and others have detailed techniques that are painstaking and meticulous. Those are just longer words for fretting...

Re: Question about jointer plane

#23

procedural question.....

roger lance

When I'm making a panel, I do, as you suggest, spread out a thin layer of glue on both mating surfaces to insure good bonding and also minimize squeeze out.

Also agree about placing clamps on both sides of panel and applying pressure gradually.....I've also been using an LV straight edge placed on the panel to check for flat.....their straight edge is aluminum and I don't have to worry about rusting from contact with the glue or wet rag to clean off said glue from the straight edge.

Here is the step I'm curious about, after about 15 - 20 minutes with the panel in the clamps, the squeeze out is beginning to set and has a rubbery consistency.....I remove the clamps and use an old chisel to remove the squeeze out which generally comes off nice and neat......and then reapply the clamps with the straight edge check and leave the panel alone.

How do you handle removing your squeeze out ? Norm's method of a wet rag is not the method of choice due to finishing problems.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#24

No Clamps - Green Tape

Hank Knight

I don't use clamps for thin panel glue-ups, I use a method I learned from our luthier friends that relys on green tape instead of clamps. First, I try to plane a perfect edge match - as perfect as I can get - between the pieces. Then I apply a thin coat of glue to both edges, lay the panel on a flat surface, align the ends, push the pieces together with hand pressure, quickly scrape off any squeeze-out and apply a piece of green painters tape along the seam lengthwise. I flip the panel over and apply strips of green tape at 90 degrees to the joint, 3"- 4" apart, stretching the tape as I apply it so it pulls the joint together.Then I flip the panel back over and apply strips to the other side in the same manner, pushing the edges together to align them along the seam. Then I place weights on top of the joint to keep the seam from moving while the glue sets up. A quick scrape with a card scraper when the glue sets and the tape is removed takes care of any squeeze out that remains. Green painter's tape was designed by 3M for painting automobiles. It is stretchy so it will conform to the curves of auto bodies. The stretch affords enouge pressure to pull panel edges together without threatening to buckle the panel like clamps do, and it's a lot easier to deal with than clamps. I've been using this method for several years and I've yet to have a joint failure.

Procedure modification:

I forgot that the last time I glued up drawer bottoms, I used a slightly different procedure that works better. Instead of applying the glue first, lay the panel on a flat surface, apply the tape strips to the panel to pull the edges together and apply one strip the full length of the joint. Flip the panel over and fold it together like a book to expose the edges. Apply a thin coat of glue to both edges. Open the panel to close the joint and lay it on a flat surface. Apply tape strips and weights as described above. This method reduces the glue squeeze-out on the under side of the panel.

Re: Question about jointer plane

#25

Perhaps...

John in NM

Many find various forms of insurance to be unnecessary, and being a bit of a cheapskate, I often agree.

But I find sprung joints to be a trivially easy form of insurance, so I do it. A few minutes of additional joint prep time is not difficult, whereas fixing a failed joint can be - a round table top for example, is difficult to rip and re-glue.

Part of this habit comes from repairing old houses, and constantly cursing the short sighted and lazy craftsmen who built it - at least that is how they look when you see how something failed 100 years or more later. Perhaps it's not rational, but I spring the joints to, maybe, spare some future craftsman the aggravation of fixing my work.