Interesting... see new thread above
Steel for tools analysis
Posts
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#102I disagree...for chisels and data to support
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I don't plane enough to have an informed opinion on its dulling resistance in a hand plane. I do chisel to baselines a lot. I have done some chisel testing and have examined with some sophisticated microscopy the dulling behavior of chisel edges prepared from various US tool steels .
Some years ago a friend and it went on a quest to find the best chisel steel and with the guidance of the tech staff of Crucible Products arrived at CPM 3V as the best at the time steel for chisels, with edge durability as the main criteria.
The reported LV test of this steel for chisels tested edge durability with a demanding test. The edge failure reported in their microscopy data was in agreement with what we observed in our testing. Bottom line- I found no reason to question their data and conclusions that predicted this steel would excel in a chisel used to chop to baselines.
More bottom line. In my hands the LV chisel made from PMV11 is at least as durable as CPM 3V for a chisel to be used for chopping hardwood to a baseline. This steel after heat treatment is extremely tough, a highly desirable attribute for a chopping chisel. If potential edge abuse lies ahead it is the go-to chisel for me. Disclaimer- I am not a fan of the relatively thick blade so I am more likely to pick up a home made 3V chisel for routine work.
I don't know anything about Japanese chisels so I have no idea how this steel compares to the best Japanese product.
The LV handle ergonomics are excellent but that is another issue.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#103Note to Greg...
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"It's a decent steel, about on par with Hock cryo A2."
While I am not questioning you conclusions they need to be put into perspective. Without knowing how you are using this steel and what you consider important for performance we can not judge the relevance of your conclusions to how we might use this steel.
Exactly how are you using the steel? What are your criteria for judging performance.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#104My experience with PM-V11
Steve Elliott
I've had a 3/8" Lee Valley PM-V11 chisel for a year or more and while I haven't done any controlled tests I've been happy with its performance. I have a co-worker who turns to me when he needs "a really sharp chisel" and he usually takes the PM-V11 one.
My chisels are a mix of older vintage ones: Buck Brothers, Berg and some English ones, plus some non-vintage Japanese ones. The steel in them varies but all are plenty good enough. Each one gets sharpened a little differently depending on the steel and the tool's intended use. The PM-V11 chisel is well balanced and comfortable in the hand and the steel hasn't required any change to my sharpening technique.
Over the years I've owned a number of chisels that I just didn't like, often because they were clunky to handle (too heavy or poorly balanced) or because the steel was too soft to hold an edge for anything more than light paring. The chisels I've kept have both good steel and good ergonomics.
While I haven't used A2 chisels and can't compare them to either the good carbon steel ones or PM-V11, I can say that I'm glad the Lee Valley chisels are available. Compared to looking for vintage chisels with the width I want and then doing the work to get them into shape for use, the ready-for-use LV ones are a good option for me in spite of their price.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#105Re: Note to Greg...
Greg DaCosta
We've used the steel in a commercial yacht fitting and boat restoration operation, both plane irons and a couple chisels.
It's not a game changer. It's not horrible it's just on par with other good steel that's been out for quite a while at this point.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#106Re: PMV-11!
Dan Rode
I'm hesitant to jump in so late but I really take exception to to the idea that
... it is an unethical act to make public what is the private property of another.
In certain circumstances, I might agree with this statement. Perhaps if one were an employee or had some other specific ethical responsibility to not disclose something.
Otherwise, I believe information should be freely available wherever possible. That would include reverse engineering or copying existing works as well as incorporating, modifying or improving them.
Copyright and patent protection, at least in the US, exist to provide a limited protection in order to encourage development. This right to exclusively profit from new works is not intended to enrich individuals and companies. It is instead intended to enrich society by stimulating new work and allowing existing work to eventually fall into the public domain where others can build upon it.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
#107Re: PMV-11!
TomD
"Copyright and patent protection, at least in the US, exist to provide a limited protection in order to encourage development. This right to exclusively profit from new works is not intended to enrich individuals and companies. It is instead intended to enrich society by stimulating new work and allowing existing work to eventually fall into the public domain where others can build upon it. "
I think the right to exclusively profit is at least indirectly intended to enrich individuals, that is called the profit motive. At the same time others are stimulated by their turn at the profit motive trough to produce better products. Eventually products loose protection and anyone can use them. These are stages, there has to be a profit stage if the product can generate profit, or the whole thing falls down.
However, neither copyright, nor patents protect you from the details of you product being discussed. But there could be benefits to not discussing them as a consumer. If you have no horse in the race, and you take the profit stage as being necessary, just randomly supporting actions that would minimize the profit phase also harms innovation. The system as it exist is not some perfect construct, it can be disrupted as happens broadly with software and media piracy. The specific tool to protect those products is copyright, those tools were created when copying a work was laborious, not just the push of a button, Industries are reshaped today by piracy that may be harmless, or harmful, and policy formation is pretty much a random product spun off from innovation.
There is also an issue of loyalty if you get bro deals on product it would be nice to not use knowledge thereby gained to ruin the profit of the company that helped you. If my neighbour was Steve Jobs and he discussed his inventions with me, I would not then violate those confidences by getting my own product to market, even if it was legal to do that. I probably would experiment in my own basement if I felt inclined, based on the info I gleaned. Those are matters of personal integrity that are for individuals to decide.



