New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Steel for tools analysis

Posts

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#76

Some random thoughts

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I'm late to the party on this one because I had many conflicting notions. Bridger's post helped me to get sorted out.

First off, Robin Lee, who I don't even know personally, has taken time to help me solve problems that he got nothing from (he directed me to another vendor). Therefore, I wouldn't for a second entertain the notion of doing something gratuitous that would cause him or his company any pain. (I hasten to add that Bill Tindall didn't propose to do so, either.)

I also wouldn't presume to tell Rob Lee how to manage his affairs. He is as successful a CEO as I have ever heard of.

The other side of the coin. It's too early for this suggestion, but in days or years to come....maybe. I suspect there is a great story to tell about PM V11 (TM), whose telling would add lustre to the name of Lee Valley. If told by a professional writer--I'm thinking those writers who can make a biography read like a novel. I've grown to love biographies and true accounts of things--much more interesting than novels (except maybe Moby Dick, and it had a lot of factual content also).

To develop a new steel is an audacious act. To develop one that abrades more easily than A2, but holds an edge longer, is a great achievement. I imagine there is a wonderful detective story/yarn buried in this adventure, that would make for great reading, and great knowledge. But only Lee Valley could tell it--the story would not be told by the mere reverse engineering of steel content. The original motivation, the false starts, disappointments, course changes, key decisions made along the way, the moment of discovery...I sense a great story.

Wiley

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#77

Re: I agree..

david weaver

..i'm not a very voracious reader of things, but on the help side of things, there is a non-public undercurrent of nice things that Rob and LV do for people behind the scenes. Things that they have no financial interest in, but just share the same excitement for tools that we do.

I heard about one the other day (that I won't repeat), that just reiterates why I had said in another thread that they are the good citizen of good citizens in our hobby so while I have no problem grasping that there's no legal issue with the disclosure of the composition, it's just extending the same courtesy to LV that they may some day extend to any one of us.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#78

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Tony Z

I say absolutely no to publishing the composition! Here is my reasoning and first let me begin by saying I own a powder metal parts fabrication business and also have a provisional patent(full patent pending) on a magnetic material.

I equate LV's material as proprietary (and protected) to LV. There are only a handful of powder metal part makers in this country and given the composition, we could make several assumptions that would quickly lead us to how the PMV-11 material is made. Once that occurs, it is a hop, skip and a jump to others entering the marketplace with this material, perhaps not in competition for the chisel and plane blade market, but definitely into other markets, where the disclosure will do harm (if Rob would ever want an opinion from someone within the industry, I would gladly provide one). LV may very well make far more money from the material outside the woodworking industry and I certainly hope they exploit their material and do so. To disclose what LV has developed will be harmful to the company and possibly harmful to us as woodworkers, inasmuch that such disclosure may be enough to stifle LV from being an innovator.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#79

An XRF test costs $200 *LINK*

Lars Parrington

Are you suggesting that a potential competitor who is interested in ripping off PMV-11 wouldn't be able to afford that $200? So instead, they would blindly trust material composition data they found on the internet?

How much does it cost to make a batch of custom PM steel?

Here's where that $200 number comes from:


http://oxford-labs.com/certification/the-cost/

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#80

Comments to your comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"To develop a new steel is an audacious act." I presume that Lee Valley came upon this steel the same way we came upon CPM 3V for chisels. Present the steel company tech staff with property requirements and evaluate their suggested candidates. It was the steel company that developed the steel. Lee Valley developed the manufacturing to turn it into products, the marketing to convince customers to buy them, and the distribution to get them to customers. In my opinion the competitive advantage lies in these parts of the business, not in the futile hope of keeping the composition of some steel a secret. Given the trivial task of determining its composition, the composition remains a secret only to customers and competitors that don't care.

"To develop one that abrades more easily than A2, but holds an edge longer, is a great achievement." I see this claim as a puzzle to be solved. We have always thought of plane blade dulling to be a result of abrasive wear. And plane bade sharpening is abrasive wear. A curious mind would seek an answer to this apparent conflict.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#81

You should know, as a patent holder...

John in NM

Just what that patent protects.

It categorically does not protect trade secrets. It protects the holder from unlicensed imitation, and then only if the holder protects their patent by legally pursuing infringement.

I'm no lawyer, but this is pretty basic concept stuff.

So if LV is marketing products made of a novel steel of their own design, which they have patented, that patent does not prevent others from analyzing and discussing their steel. It does prevent others from copying the steel and marketing their own products made of it without a licensing agreement.

Another disclaimer - I think the world of LV and Rob himself. They are a fantastic company and I wish them nothing but prosperity. I don't think there is a single regular poster on this board who would disagree with this sentiment.

That does not mean, however, that anyone should self-censor information that advances the art and science of metallurgy applied to hand tool work. As others have pointed out, discussions of this type are more likely to help marketing of novel steel products along than damage it. These discussions should generate interest in trying those products out.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#82

3V

david weaver

What ever happened too the squirt of people who were making 3V irons?

IIRC, you mentioned that it was easy to work if it was worked slowly, but problematic if it wasn't.

It would seem to be a very good choice for irons and chisels, but it just sort of disappeared. Cost issue maybe?

I couldn't ever understand why everyone making irons wanted to make them really thick, but that's their choice. IT would be interesting to see if folks responded better to a round of thin irons. Thick ones are a pain in the ane to grind for anyone using "regular" grinding wheels.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#83

Actually, free is common

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is a 30 second analysis that one can get for free if you can find a steel user that has the equipment, which is common now days. The companies selling this equipment are delighted to demonstrate its capability, again for free. Tech service departments of steel suppliers are delighted to identify a competitive material in the hope of selling their similar or better product, again for free. .....to name a few free sources.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#84

Re: Some random thoughts *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I had the same thoughts as Bill, Wiley. I had already copied your text "To develop a new steel is an audacious act. To develop one that abrades more easily than A2, but holds an edge longer, is a great achievement." They have never claimed to have developed a new steel. For all we know it is the same steel as in my "Swing-A-Way" can opener.

If you read Lee Valley's own version of events they assembled plane irons of 15 available alloys (they call them "metals") for testing. They have revealed four of the alloys, O1 A2 M2 M4, and there were 11 mystery alloys with code names.

For their impact testing to "emulate" chopping with a chisel, they fastened the plane iron in a fixture and dropped a 102 ounce weight to chop "red oak". The edges were evaluated after only three impacts. The irons were sharpened and the test repeated twice more. For alloy there were three sets of three impacts for four different microbevels, or 36 impacts per sample. I would be more interested in how an individual chisel performs after 400 hits by a professional woodworker. Using a chisel is an art.

For the "wear testing" they used a machine set up to pare mdf .020 inches thick with a 2 degree clearance. 40 to 100 feet per sample. It might have been more interesting to test a real plane with a real woodworker and real wood. LV does not recommend planing mdf with pmv11. I think both these tests were abusive, not the way we treat a fine tool.


Alloy Testing

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#85

MDF..

david weaver

..I've planed it before as my seldom used router table is made with an MDF top. I planed it flat (sure was easier than trying to build the understructure perfectly), but I don't know of any plane iron that likes it!!

In my estimation, real world results tend to be a little bit closer together than prescribed ultra tests (which is what I'd call planing MDF).

I don't have many thoughts on the chisels, and I've never used a V11 chisel.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#86

Re: 3V

Steve Elliott

As one of the people who made some 3V plane blades I can say I stopped because I had enough to last several lifetimes. The steel as purchased was easy to work and the blades are still my favorites to use. There's a learning curve to sharpening 3V, though.

In the past two days I've ground and honed a 3V blade that was quite dull and also sharpened a 2-1/4" wide Japanese chisel that had seen hard use. The 3V is much easier to deal with because it can be ground without fear of burning and doesn't chip easily. The Japanese steel must be handled more carefully but also gives a great edge with good longevity.

Since the retirement of Paul Bos I don't know of a heat treater who will do a blade or two for a reasonable price. Paul was also very experienced with just which treatment schedule for 3V would produce the best qualities for woodworking tools.

As for your comment on thick blades, David, I agree that a blade thicker than necessary is just more steel to grind away each time. My blades are 3/16 thick only because they were made to fit infill planes.

I'm glad there are more good options for blades these days, including PM-V11.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#87

Re: 3V

david weaver

3/16ths is a common size for parallel planes if I'm not mistaken, I don't see too much of a problem there. Or am I wrong about that? I only have one "real" infill with a vintage iron, I'll have to check it. Doesn't much matter,though.

I see a lot of people wanting for the thickest thing they can find for an iron, and I guess that's an easy thing to want. I made an infill with a 1/4th iron and even though it's only O1, it's a pain in the butt to grind.

Anything harder to hone than A2, I've always just broken out the diamonds. Even M4 is like silly putty when it's introduced to them. Same medicine for really cheap cruddy steel that's rubbery.

I kind of hope that someone else comes along and makes 3v irons, but I believe there's a group doing it on the australian board and it's taking something like 5 years to get irons delivered.

Not much is going to sway me from carbon steel, but if I used a diamond regimen, I'd be more open to other things. CBN wheel mitigates issues with grinding, too.

I made the comment a while ago on another forum that I can get just as much work done and ultimately faster if the work is heavy when using western chisels and grinding them, because damage to a japanese chisel results in what is essentially restoration quality work by hand!! That comment was panned. I don't think it was interpreted the way I meant it, because I definitely have high regard for the older ouchi stuff and the other chisels that are full hardness, you'd (as in me) just have to be careful when using them to not do something abusive, or there may be a 10 minute penalty to grind out the nick by hand and then work an attractive finish back onto the chisel.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#88

Re: You should know, as a patent holder...

Tony Z

Actually I do know and I also know that you rush to market to capitalize on it as quickly as you can as others will analyze and otherwise look to do enough different to do what you have done in order to enter the market.

The fact is, the late comers are just that-late comers. It is one thing for them if they are already in the same market, but something entirely different for them to study your intellectual property to copy and compete with you.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#89

You have innovation all backwards...

John in NM

What drives innovation is precisely what you appear to disapprove of - people looking at your product and perhaps competing with it if they think they can provide the same for less money. That should spur you to improve it and come up with other novel products to give you an edge over the imitators.

Once you put your product out there in the market place, there is no legal footing to claim that it cannot be studied by your customers and competitors - at least no footing that I'm aware of. Patents do not prevent analysis. Patents attempt to prevent imitation for profit, not observation - and observation is what we are talking about here, it always has been.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#90

Re: You have innovation all backwards...

Tony Z

Well, this is my last reply, and if you are in business, or decide to go into business for yourself, I wish you well with your idea of innovation. Thoughts change with your own money on the table.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#91

right again

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The purpose of the patent system is to require others to innovate a better product of process to be able to compete. Otherwise, society would have just embraced licensing. This fact is taught in every patenting class I have been forced to take.

You can't make a widget by banging it out with a left handed hammer if there is a valid patent covering this device and process. If you want to compete in this market you will need to make something that does the function of the widget that isn't pounded out with a left handed hammer. The motivation to compete in the market becomes strong motivation to come up with something different and hence, potentially better.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#92

Re: 3V

TomD

"I made the comment a while ago on another forum that I can get just as much work done and ultimately faster if the work is heavy when using western chisels and grinding them, because damage to a japanese chisel results in what is essentially restoration quality work by hand!! That comment was panned. I don't think it was interpreted the way I meant it, because I definitely have high regard for the older ouchi stuff and the other chisels that are full hardness, you'd (as in me) just have to be careful when using them to not do something abusive, or there may be a 10 minute penalty to grind out the nick by hand and then work an attractive finish back onto the chisel."

That would be true, though I have only rarely injured one. I know I did have to grind a chip out of a plane blade once, and it took more like 2 hours on the 600 King. But it is such an infrequent occurrence I wouldn't worry about it. Japanese chisels can be ground on belt machines reasonably quickly without ruining them in a number of cases, but I didn't get one of those until the tooling die was largely set.

A lot of this is pretty meaningless like arguing the burden of commuting vs a larger mortgage. Who really chooses along those lines. I live where I do because it had a large workshop and was 100 yards from where I could moor my boat. Over the years those "advantages" have proven relatively immune to rational argument.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#93

Re: You should know, as a patent holder...

TomD

Business is business, but one thing that is new is the opportunity for a bunch of clucking hens to derail the best laid plans of those with skin in the game. But it is a reality as much as anything else.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#94

Re: 3V

david weaver

There were no hypotheticals in my statement. It was especially tempered by my experience using a medium quality (imai) timber framer to chop a few plane bodies. I had to be too gentle to it for it to be useful, and a western framer fared better under heavy work and sharpened three times as fast.

A vintage western chisel takes a minute to sharpen. I can't remove any substantial amount of wear in a japanese chisel in a minute and have a good finished edge. Grinding a western chisel takes an additional minute for maintenance. It's just no time savings for most harder chisels as is always touted on the forums...unless someone doesn't know how to sharpen quickly, and that's an issue of the individual and not the chisel.

You're reading it backwards from what I intended, though, and that is the argument that all harder chisels mean less time sharpening. it's not the case. That's usually given as the excuse for $15 chisels not being good enough to do woodwork - that they don't hold their edge long enough. Avoiding chipping is the goal for all tools, but heavy work sometimes causes it, anyway.

Never had a significant chip on a japanese plane, but even the small ones smaller than a grain of sand are a nuisance.

All of this is, I guess, only interesting to me because I bought into the whole finewoodworking tool test garbage when I first started a decade ago.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#95

My money is on the table...

John in NM

My side biz is making some rather unique wood products, one of which I am the only maker of in the country. My method of discouraging competition is to keep them as cheap as possible and every time I improve the process to save time I cut the price some. That literally discourages others from entering the market, which is very small.

The trade secret is in how I streamline my production and save time, decreasing price while increasing volume for a net gain in revenue. Types of wood used and overall pattern of what I make are not trade secrets, anyone who buys one can figure that much out with their own eyes, analogous to the subject under discussion here.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#96

Re: 3V

TomD

"You're reading it backwards from what I intended, though, and that is the argument that all harder chisels mean less time sharpening. it's not the case. That's usually given as the excuse for $15 chisels not being good enough to do woodwork - that they don't hold their edge long enough. Avoiding chipping is the goal for all tools, but heavy work sometimes causes it, anyway."

Not me at all, been at this every way longer than 10 years.

The other backwards thing is assuming people are starting with nothing and moving to a tool choice based on rational principles, and enough knowledge. What more often happens is people find themselves in a certain time or place, or are cheap or like fancy stuff, whatever: They get some tools, and if they are around long enough, learn how to use them. If I grew up in a rich tool culture like Japan, I doubt I would really care about what woodcentral users thought this week, and just keep on trying to make the best of it. A kind of those who can do don't teach thing.

"Never had a significant chip on a japanese plane, but even the small ones smaller than a grain of sand are a nuisance."

I never had one chip out, but I may have dropped it on concrete. Hit an inclusion, I honestly don't remember. I do remember the time I stuck my foot under one while wearing a sandal to stop it hitting the floor. I also had that deal where the guys came to take out the oil tank, and used one of my Ouchii blue steel chisel as a cold chisel going after some bolt. Stuff does happen over 35 years, and I do use Japanese tools for the most part as they are intended to be used, so when something bad happens it might take longer to fix than to make a blade and a plane out of O1 and beech.

"All of this is, I guess, only interesting to me because I bought into the whole finewoodworking tool test garbage when I first started a decade ago."

They did a few of those. Their tests were normally so far off on methodology I just laughed.

I have wondered what kind of tools I would prefer if I worked other woods often enough. With guitars I worked a fair amount of harder woods, but normally easy work, installing bindings planing small parts, or cutting fret slots, not heavy cabinet type work.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#97

Re: My money is on the table...

TomD

John, I wasn't aiming anything at you, if you got that impression.

It is hard to draw analogies because we don't know what LV is protecting, not really. As in your case, your obvious product is not really your edge. Maybe they just want to control their story.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#98

Re: An XRF test costs $200

TomD

First off it isn't even that easy to imagine who is a competitor to LV. To some extent it is woodcentral community WCC). If you look at the other company that puts ot desirable stuff in the "same" price range it would be LN. But they have very different approaches. LV started out as sorta a no name provider of quality but at a lower cost (it was really like their 3rd restart). More recently they are selling their expertise and innovation (I am talking about core tools, they always had innovative products like the Tucker, or the sharpening jig, etc... .) So places like WCC that are also trying to play in the we know more than you thought you ever wanted to know field, are natural competitors.

At the next level down it is quite possible that the people involved don't even know that they can get the chemistry analysed for a reasonable price.

But any way, the analysis is only going to be the first step. That will be followed by a lot of pontificating, and then it may either go for or against the steel in question. Since WCC doesn't buy advertising to promote it's findings, how much sway it really has is open to question, but the product cycle does seem to be narrowing down. If you make an investment in a product, and need a certain amount of time to recoup it, loosing control of the marketing at some point is an issue. And it seems to be a common occurrence these days.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#99

Re: My money is on the table...

John in NM

Not at all, I was responding solely to Tony's comments.

As with anything, there is likely more to all this than we are discussing here.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#100

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Greg DaCosta

Prepare to be underwhelmed. It's a decent steel, about on par with Hock cryo A2. It's no breakthrough - still needs honing at a relatively high angle to offer any of the claimed benefits as to edge longevity.

You can put a lot of ingredients in a cake but it doesn't always make a better cake.