New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Steel for tools analysis

Posts

Steel for tools analysis

#1

Steel for tools analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I will likely be able to analyze steel next week. If anyone has a curiosity about the composition of this or that steel, and I happen to have a piece or tool on hand, I will likely be able to get it analyzed. I am going to get an analysis on the Two Cherries steel, taking along a chisel for analysis.

I can't get a value for carbon as it involves destroying the sample. But for other stuff I can do it on a chisel or plane blade, non destructively.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#2

Re: Steel for tools analysis

CJ in MPLS

Are you going to be looking at the crystalline structure or actually analyzing the content of the steel itself?

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#3

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

composition by X-ray fluorescence analysis. Composition will identify the steel and identity will reveal expected properties such as toughness, abrasion resistance, etc. I can get structure data but I don't know what I would use it for.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#4

Re: Steel for tools analysis

CJ in MPLS

Crystal size, stacking, and dislocations caused by inclusions (intentional from carbon and other alloying agents or unintentional from random junk), all have a bearing on the steel's quality.

I'm not familiar with the specifics of X-ray fluorescence, but it will be interesting to see what shows up in the tests. When I've dealt with fluorescence imaging it is usually in the context of UV wavelengths being used to identify organic contaminants. While these may be present in your situation, I presume that the XRF systems will cause the constituent parts of the metal (alloying materials) to fluoresce?

I would imagine that x-ray diffraction (XRD) would be useful (if mathematically more intensive) for determining crystalline structures. Though again, the XRD systems I'm familiar with are for inspecting semiconductor wafers which are supposed to have a single, mono-crystalline structure. Multiple crystalline grains might be kind of difficult for XRD given the small size of the grains and the relatively large focal point.

Have fun and wear some lead clothing.

CJ

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#5

Re: Steel for tools analysis

david weaver

Bill, I'm curious to find out what you're looking for.

I had a hirsch branded set of two cherries chisels and would call them very good chrome vanadium type steel (I have no idea what alloy they actually are, other than to state that they are certainly not plain carbon steel or even as plain as O1 by a mile).

They seem about as good as vintage chisels, but don't take an edge as fine on vintage stones in the same amount of time (it makes no difference what's being used if the finish stone is micron or submicron, or some kind of oxide paste or small diamonds).

I eventually sold them just because I've tried about everything interesting that I could find, eventually settling on older chisels and japanese chisels and that's pretty much it. I'm not sure what an analysis could tell me, but I know what use has told me.

At one point, I thought it was normal to buy and try various things, but I realize now that I am an exceptional pig and for a while I had a tolerance for the money that is lost buying, trying, and then reselling things.

Two cherries pretends to be secretive about their steel, but in my opinion (and this is only my opinion), it's not because they're protecting the coca cola formula, more that they'd not like anyone to know just how common and inexpensive the steel is that they're using. Speculation on my part, but the difference between their chisels and a set of vintage stanley/buck/pexto, etc, is for the benefit of the maker and not the benefit of the user.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#6

PMV-11!

Kees

We're all dying to know what it is actually. 8)

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#7

yes but..... and XRF explained

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Crystal size, stacking, and dislocations caused by inclusions (intentional from carbon and other alloying agents or unintentional from random junk), all have a bearing on the steel's quality. " Agreed, but all these properties are going to largely be the same if the same steel composition is heat treated the same way. There may be small differences in M2 steel at Rc60 from supplier A vs. supplier B, but composition is going to be the main variable affecting performance.

X-ray fluorescence- The steel is illuminated with high energy X-rays which knock core electrons from the atoms in the sample. The atoms rearrange their electronic structure and in doing so emit an X-ray. The wavelength of this X-ray is unique for each element. The intensity of the X-rays for each element is proportional to the amount of the element in the sample. So, by measuring wavelength and intensity one can determine composition. The x=ray for carbon is too weak to escape the steel so carbon can not be measured by this technique. The analysis can be done in a few seconds and the sample is unaffected.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#8

Clint Searl

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Clint Searl

Interesting comment, and begs the question of what practical value is knowing the elemental composition of the steel(s)?

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#9

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Bob Hackett

If you know what the steel`s elemental makeup is and in what proportions then you can more accurately identify what alloy it is. When you have identified the alloy you have in hand you can go to a site such as Crucible Steel and access the properties and characteristics of that steel as well as the heat treatment procedures to bring out the the aspects you desire. All this is very useful information (some would say required information) for people who intend to make things like edged tools out of the different steel alloys available.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#11

Re: Steel for tools analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Two cherries pretends to be secretive about their steel, but in my opinion (and this is only my opinion), it's not because they're protecting the coca cola formula, more that they'd not like anyone to know just how common and inexpensive the steel is that they're using."

That exactly is my motivation for analysis. Anybody familiar with analysis knows how trivial it is for a competitor to determine what steel is used so there is no competitive reason to claim trade secret. It's all marketing. I like peeking under the curtain.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#12

Re: Steel for tools analysis

david weaver

That makes sense, in terms of just curiosity. It'd be interesting to find out how different the composition is from a cheap chisel like a narex.

Years ago (I know I sound like a broken record), a friend and I had a whole bunch of tools hardness tested. Some of the tools that I couldn't get on with (a couple of defective vintage chisels), the test just confirmed that they were too soft.

It also confirmed that an iyoroi mortise chisel a friend got was several clicks short of what it said it was in terms of hardness. At the time, we were disappointed with the results of some tools because we hadn't really tested them in a long cycle of use and sharpening. The iyoroi mortise chisel averaged strikes of 61 hardness (rc scale of course) and I'd bet that it would be a very good working chisel for an experienced user. He still has it, this many years later, he's still not an experienced user. A person like me might even appreciate it more than a chisel that's 64/65 because the balance of time sharpening may be in favor of a chisel that's 61 over one that's harder.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#13

Re: Steel for tools analysis

William Duffield

At the January Williamsburg woodworking conference, we got a very interesting tour of their Bruton Heights conservation facility. One of their scientists showed us one of these machines, explained how it was used (on paint and finishes, mostly, instead of steel), and showed us how they interpreted the graphs produced by the computers it was connected to. It was hand held and wasn't any larger than a biscuit jointer. I asked about lead shielding, and she explained that it emitted a very small amount of X-rays, and you could use it day in and day out for a year and not receive the dose of one dental X-ray.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#14

Re: no clue..

david weaver

...how old the handheld technology is, but I took a materials science elective in college and the professor obviously had access to spectral analysis type stuff. He analyized a piece of *red* corning glass and found that it had cobalt in it, and he thought that was novel enough to mention when he was at corning when they took a group of people around the factory for a tour and said they had a trade secret for making red glass. He said "it's cobalt!", and they'd assumed someone had leaked it to him and he almost got kicked out of the tour - until he explained how he found that out.

Anyway, re: the steel, I wonder how different the pre and post heat treatment analysis would be, or if the analysis of the surface will be any different than any other part would be (like the core).

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#15

The miracle of miniaturation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These machines used to occupy a small room and cost 6 figures$. The X=ray source looked like a 90 mm artillery shell delivering watts at 50,000V to an X-ray target, which had to be water cooled. Now, as you saw, they can be portable and cheap enough to be used to sort steel by composition in a steel store or scrap yard. The X-ray source has been made tiny as well as the devices to resolve X-ray wavelength(energy) and measure intensity, which means the XRF part of the instrument can be placed almost next to the target. This close contact with the sample enables a greatly lower power for the X-ray source and less wasted X-rays going hither and yon. Most of what you saw was computing and printout and a handle to hold it. Nearly as small bench top machines are also common and they provide some more capability. They are a dandy device for revealing composition.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#16

Re: The miracle of miniaturation

William Duffield

Maybe even more important is the huge database of known samples shared by research institutions, and the computing power to support analyzing and matching the unknown sample data to this library.

The machine I saw would have been comfortable on the bridge of the Starship Enterprise. :D

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#17

providing the clue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The higher the atomic number of the element the deeper into the sample it can be measured. (the emitted X-ray has to get out of the steel to be detected. The bigger the atomic nucleus the more energetic will be the emitted X-ray,ie. the more steel it can penetrate)

Heat treating indeed affects the surface composition which is why tool steel is sold a bit thicker than nominal so that after heat treatment it can be ground to 1/8" or whatever. We must hope that the manufacture of a blade ground away all the damaged surface steel. I was told that the damaged depth was only a few thousandths of an inch.

The Corning tour must have been led by marketing or public relations. Only these departments would be foolish enough to think adding such an easy to detect element as cobalt could be kept secret. (red glass is more commonly uranium doped) The capability to determine anything in glass has been widely available since well before 1970 . But the machines were very expensive back then and only a large company would have one. There are many labs across the land that earn their keep deciphering the "secrets" of competitive products....successfully.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#18

Re: providing the clue

david weaver

This would've been a tour in the early to mid 1990s, and the machine was described as something uncommon at that time (it was a university setting). Probably was a marketing tour or some kind of arranged tour for professors.

I can't imagine the engineers would've cared if someone knew what was in the glass. As a customer, I can't imagine why I would care if they used cobalt to make red glass red. Someone selling stuff or doing the books might think it's a trade secret, but unless it was ultra cheap to make something that was otherwise seen as expensive by other manufacturers, I have no clue why anyone would care.

I'd rather have cobalt than uranium, though!!

The fact that cobalt makes it red has probably been printed 100 times on the internet, though, not much is secret these days. It's hard to confirm that, though, because people refer to blue glass as "cobalt" blue.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#19

not how it works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This machine doesn't get data on an unknown steel and then search these data against a library of known steels. (you would have seen other machines in this lab that do work this way to identify organic compounds) Instead, this machine measures emitted X-ray intensity at the energy (wavelength) for vanadium for example. This intensity is then converted to an amount with a simple equation of amount = intensity x constant. The constant is determined by measuring the intensity of known composition standards. (there is another complicated detail involved that is solved by the computing power in this small machine)

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#20

Re: not how it works

William Duffield

Oops. They showed us a lot of equipment and analysis results, and I wasn't taking notes or photos. The graphs were probably from a gas chromatograph or something similar.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#21

Re: PMV-11!

Rob Lee

Hi -

While I can certainly understand the curiosity - there are literally 1000's of good steels out there that would make good choices for tools.

We invested heavily in making our choice - why not let someone else do the same ???

If manufacturers in general do not want to disclose something like this - it's generally to protect the investment thay've made. Consumers have all of the benefit of our choices and philosophy, and are free to buy into them - or not.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#22

Thanks

CJ in MPLS

The XRF stuff should be fun. If you can get some time on an XRD system you'd be able to figure out what percentage of the material is austensite or martensite and whether their heat treating processes are taking full advantage of the cool alloys they are using.

Have fun.

CJ

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#23

Re: PMV-11!

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We invested heavily in making our choice - why not let someone else do the same ???

If manufacturers in general do not want to disclose something like this - it's generally to protect the investment thay've made.

As Bill noted, any competitor who wanted to know the composition of so-called "pmv 11" could do so at the cost of one block plane iron and one lab test. There is no need to invest heavily. Your argument does not hold water.

For myself I lost interest in stainless steel around 1966.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#24

Re: PMV-11!

TomD

That makes me wonder who is right. Rob certainly knows enough to know whether this would affect him. One would think. On the other hand it may be as simple as Bill says, in which case I don't really see the problem. Of course there could be a middle ground such as minor competitors not having the access to expert help Bill seems to easily find. So if the PMV-11 is made public it could help a minor player compete, or make marketing claims. For that mater the other people out there may not even know they could do this research. But I guess that is what the internet is all about, commoditizing intellectual property.

What if PMV-11 is just O1 with super duper heat treatment cycle. :)

My thanks to Rob for the research Lee Valley does, and how fairly they treat their customers, with stuff like voluntary refunds or parts upgrades, particularly considering the size of our segment.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#25

Re: PMV-11!

Hank Knight

I'm not an intellectual Property lawyer, but i think Lee Valley probably has an intellectual property interest in the formula and composition for PMV-11. They invested resources to develop it - or at least to inform their choice of PMV-11 for their products. The formula/composition of their choice is a secret and not generally known. This almost certainly gives them a protectable interest in keeping it secret. Otherwise, anyone else could enjoy the benefit of their investment in research for free and compete with them in the same market. At this point the composition of PMV-11 probably qualifies as a "trade secret" and Lee Valley is entitled to protect it in order to enjoy the benefits of its investment. Trade secrets are like toothpaste: once it's out of the tube, you can't get it back in again. Once the composition of PMV-11 is disclosed and becomes known in the community, it is no longer a secret and Lee Valley loses its protectable interest in it - and the benefit of its investment. They might, however, be able to recover damages from anyone who learned the secret from them and discloses it without their authorization. They cannot prevent a third party from "reverse engineering" the formula and subsequently disclosing it, but they have an obligation to discourage such practices when they learn of them. Bill can have a PMV-11 blade analyzed and publish the results of his analysis on this forum or in the New York Times if he chooses. In doing so, he might satisfy the curiosity of some on this board, but he would seriously damage Lee Valley.