Re: Steel for tools analysis
david weaver
Bill, I'm curious to find out what you're looking for.
I had a hirsch branded set of two cherries chisels and would call them very good chrome vanadium type steel (I have no idea what alloy they actually are, other than to state that they are certainly not plain carbon steel or even as plain as O1 by a mile).
They seem about as good as vintage chisels, but don't take an edge as fine on vintage stones in the same amount of time (it makes no difference what's being used if the finish stone is micron or submicron, or some kind of oxide paste or small diamonds).
I eventually sold them just because I've tried about everything interesting that I could find, eventually settling on older chisels and japanese chisels and that's pretty much it. I'm not sure what an analysis could tell me, but I know what use has told me.
At one point, I thought it was normal to buy and try various things, but I realize now that I am an exceptional pig and for a while I had a tolerance for the money that is lost buying, trying, and then reselling things.
Two cherries pretends to be secretive about their steel, but in my opinion (and this is only my opinion), it's not because they're protecting the coca cola formula, more that they'd not like anyone to know just how common and inexpensive the steel is that they're using. Speculation on my part, but the difference between their chisels and a set of vintage stanley/buck/pexto, etc, is for the benefit of the maker and not the benefit of the user.