New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Steel for tools analysis

Posts

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#26

Re: PMV-11!

Paul M

I would be inclined let LV keep PMV-11 as their own proprietary material. As much as you might be intrigued as to what it is, they have been such an open and generous company with the user base, that they have the right to ask us not to pry too much into things that concern them. And they offer this up in blades and chisels at a reasonable price.

Now if someone would do molecular analysis on "tung oil" finishes and let us know exactly what is in those crappy cans, that's fair game. The labeling in the finishing industry is so awful that it warrants "homeland security" levels of scrying. :)

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#27

Re: PMV-11!

david weaver

I would imagine that you couldn't get a mill run of their material to begin with, as it's probably something that the mill running it (presumably one of those may be latrobe near here) has signed an agreement to keep nondisclosed.

It's definitely not powdered O1, and it's probably not stainless (though I haven't check for rust). Maybe it's close in composition. If someone handed it to me and said it was refined and finer grained A2, I'd be inclined to believe that.

I'm satisfied to not know what it is, as Rob said, there are gobs of other steels out there that make good tool steels. It just takes familiarity to become partial (so long as it's not something that's complete junk).

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#28

Ellis Walentine

You and Bob Flexner...

Ellis Walentine

... would get along. :)

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#29

bridger

Re: The miracle of miniaturation

bridger

Next it'll just be an app for your cel phone...

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#30

prying "secrets" from finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The can label is useless but if one knows a bit about the chemistry used in finishes the MSDS sheet typically tells the finisher all they need to know to use the product. There are of course details not revealed by the MSDS that need to be teased out by analysis if one wants to copy the finish.

Going back to the glass example, in the early 70's someone came out with an optical glass that darkened in sun light and faded nearly clear indoors. Corning wanted to copy this glass for eye wear. It took minutes to reveal that the glass had silver in it, and how much. Just like in photography the sun reduced silver ions to silver metal which darkened the glass. Indoors oxygen oxidized the silver back to colorless silver salts. A motivated competitor can figure anything out.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#31

Re: PMV-11!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Whether it is PMV-11 or Two Cherries, or any other steel ...

... it is an unethical act to make public what is the private property of another.

As a student I worked in a restaurant over a number of years. I was trusted to act in the position of temporary manager when the owner went on vacation, and privy to their recipes. Whether the recipes were commonplace or not, they were not for others to know.

In the recent build of the Wegner "The Chair", we discussed here how much information I would report. In the end I decided that I would not make public dimensions or any other information that would enable another to copy the chair in case they decided to do so commercially. The only information that was published was that which was available from the manufacturing company.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#32

Re: PMV-11!

Kees

Maybe? Worth a discussion. I understand your position being a close friend of Rob Lee.

Usually a trade secret means nothing positive for the consumer. If only that he pays more for a cheap product. And for a competitor the secret also means nothing because the secret can so easilly be broken as Bill expains with this example.

I am used more to the scientific world. I am not a scientist myself but work in a university hospital. Research means publishing and your published results are a starting point for others to improve on that. If every researcher would keep his results secret that wouldn't be very helpfull.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#33

Re: PMV-11!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Maybe? Worth a discussion. I understand your position being a close friend of Rob Lee.

Actually Kees, that is a little insulting to my integrity. I am sure you did not intend this, but your comment implies that my remark was biased.

Usually a trade secret means nothing positive for the consumer. If only that he pays more for a cheap product. And for a competitor the secret also means nothing because the secret can so easilly be broken as Bill expains with this example.

That is simply encouraging others to commit theft.

I am used more to the scientific world. I am not a scientist myself but work in a university hospital. Research means publishing and your published results are a starting point for others to improve on that. If every researcher would keep his results secret that wouldn't be very helpfull.

There is a world of difference in sharing research or information for public (clinical) consumption, and offering up information that would jeopardise a financial investment. I doubt that a pharmaceutical company would release the chemical composition of one of their "wonder drugs" to benefit their competition after spending millions on research.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#34

Re: PMV-11!

Kees

No insult ment! I appologise for that.

When you want to protect your research investment, get a patent. that's what the paharmaceuticals are doing.

In the mean time, at least overhere in Europe the idea is that consumers are always running behind regarding information compared to the producers. In the food industry the producers nowadays must publish the contents of their products on the label of the product. That's a law.

And I don't think theft is the right word when you analyse the product. It would be tefth if you hack their computers. Analysing samples is something comsumers organisations do all the time.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#35

poor example

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I doubt that a pharmaceutical company would release the chemical composition of one of their "wonder drugs""

The composition would be part of the drug application and patent(s). Only the marketing department would be so naïve as to presume a competitor would not soon know the composition of any product . Here in the US we have many commercial labs devoted to competitive analysis, as well as ubiquitous internal departments. When I wanted to know what Zinsser stable shellac was all about I just read the patent. A trivial procedure revealed the details of the solvent composition. It satisfied my curiosity, something I have a lot of. I wasn't intending to make any.

While you seem to have a different opinion, here is the business and legal accepted situation- if I bribe an employee to tell me what is in a product, or how it is made, that is theft and the parties involved can be prosecuted. If I buy some in a store, submit it to my company's competitive analysis department and find out what is in it, that is normal business practice. What I learn is my information to use as I please. If I haven't been annoyed I will use it wisely, if you get my drift.

If you want to sell something and don't want the customer to know what is in it then you sell it with an "non-analysis agreement" if you are able to do so.

I'll willing to shut up for now unless I get called a thief for being curious and practicing accepted research practices, for then I will be motivated to justify my curiosity.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#36

Re: poor example

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Bill is right from my standpoint (and from my knowledge of I.P. laws as well). Some of the responses infuriate me as well but I won't go in to that.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#37

I disagree

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

While you seem to have a different opinion, here is the business and legal accepted situation- if I bribe an employee to tell me what is in a product, or how it is made, that is theft and the parties involved can be prosecuted. If I buy some in a store, submit it to my company's competitive analysis department and find out what is in it, that is normal business practice. What I learn is my information to use as I please. If I haven't been annoyed I will use it wisely, if you get my drift.

"In common usage, theft is the taking of another person's property without that person's permission or consent with the intent to deprive the rightful owner of it".

(defined by Wikipedia)

You are considering the publication of intellectual property without permission, and this will deprive the owner of the full value of that information.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#38

Re: I disagree

Christopher Fitch Memphis

The notion that understanding what's in a physical tangible item that you purchased free of any contractual obligations is theft is wrong.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#39

Re: I disagree

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The notion that understanding what's in a physical tangible item that you purchased free of any contractual obligations is theft is wrong.

Christopher, you have misread my words. I referred to the publication of this information, not simply the understanding of it via examination.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#40

Re: I disagree

david weaver

I don't think that's theft, either, but there is a bit of courtesy that is extended to good players like LV. If they were predatory, I'd be all for publishing - well, I guess I wouldn't care. I wouldn't go out of my way to do it.

That said, I don't think it really moves the needle too much no matter what steel we use, and the belief that it really does is a beginners tale. I'm not advocating LV's prescription be known, or whatever the machine Bill's talking about would yield - LV doesn't want it known ...like I said, they've always been courteous to us as a bunch of hobbyists. But there's more to it than just what the chemical composition of the steel is.

The "secret" and the "wondersteel" stuff is more of a perception advantage than it is practical, though. It's good for catalogs and beginners, and since it's quality stuff and it hardly costs any more than run of the mill (poor choice of words?) stuff like softer O1 and pedestrian non-cryo A2.

I'm happy to verbally or in text grill the unfavorable players, like those who make farcical claims or who sell counterfeit tools, and happy not to grill anyone who is a good player with a good reciprocal relationship with customers.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#41

Re: theft vs. theft

david weaver

IANAL (I am not a lawyer), but I see two different definitions of theft, and maybe that's the problem. The dictionary says this:

In common usage, theft is the taking of another person's property without that person's permission or consent with the intent to deprive the rightful owner of it.

In a legal sense, it involves a crime so far as I can tell, but the above encompasses a larger circle of possibilities than just criminal acts.

I'll defer to the attorneys about what's a criminal act. The former does seem to fit, and from my simple upbringing, I'd say "publishing it when they don't want it published is very rude".

And I am an expert on rude, but I am not the kind of rude who antisocial rude on purpose - just rude in genuine disagreement but honest disagreement.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#42

Trade Secrets and Patents

Hank Knight

Trade secrets and patents are two different animals. Both are designed to accomplish the same purpose: to protect the owner's investment of time and resources to develop a competitive advantage. Both give the owner/developer a property interest in the development that he can protect. With a trade secret, the protected interest is the secret. The developer can protect it, indeed is obliged to protect it, by reasonable means like contracts (non-disclosure agreements, licenses, etc.) or physical means (preventing outsiders from viewing a secret manufacturing process for example). What he can't do is prohibit someone from learning the secret on his own through research, reverse engineering or accidental discovery, as long as these efforts are legitimate. As long as the secret remains a secret, the owner can protect it in the courts (by suing for trespass or to enforce non-disclosure and license agreements) and continue to enjoy the economic benefit of the trade secret.

A patent works differently. It does not depend on secrecy. As someone noted above, patent applications reveal everything about the subject of the patent and they are readily available to anyone. Once the government grants a patent, however, the public is prohibited by law from copying the patented item, process, technology or whatever is the subject of the patent. The reason patent applications are so detailed and explicit is to avoid being over broad or ambiguous; I.E., to make clear the line around what is protected and what is not, so others are not unduly restricted in what they can do with respect to developing similar products, processes, technology, etc.

Kees' comment that trade secrets offer nothing to the consumer is off the mark. If developers, entrepreneurs, scientists, inventors and the like had no way to protect the products of their labor and investment, few would be interested in committing the time and money necessary to achieve the kinds of advancements that have lifted us out of the stone age. Altruism is a strong motivator for many, but money is stronger and it propels research and development in areas that altruism never would.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#43

Still incorrect

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Derek, I didn't misunderstand anything.

All 'good will' aside, even publishing this information in lieu of a contract or written agreement is not illegal and it is certainly not theft. Bill or anyone else for that matter can publish their findings *even if it is patented or a trade secret*. So long as the *customer* did not agree to this, it's fine and protected in IP law (DMCA notwithstanding). Hank covers this below (though I disagree with his assertion that money is the larger driver of innovation). Further, if someone attempted to sell me something physical with some agreement that I gave up rights that I normally have, I would reject it and tell everyone else to as well. Please note that I am not against patents or copyright, etc just against the idea that, as a customer, a manufacturer can control what I do with my own possessions. Might as well reopen company towns and start paying everyone in company scrip.

I will try to restrain myself by merely pointing out this attitude of secrecy is morally and ethically repugnant to me and the entire discussion smacks of blatant hypocrisy or willful blindness.

I respect you and I respect Rob Lee and appreciate and understand his position as a manufacturer with regards to trace secrets but I have to disagree with the idea that Bill can't do what he proposes legally or that it's even unethical. We would not be having this discussion if we were not able to build on the shoulders of others (poor paraphrase of Newton) and sharing knowledge is core to our progress as people.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#44

Re: PMV-11!

Mark Nowicki

>

IMO, PMV-11 consists of the following:

P, for Price

M, for Multiplier

V-11 is a joke, the root of which it the movie "This is Spinal Tap" where the band thinks it is special because they crank up the volume to "11"

PMV-11 a is secret formula to sell $5.00 chisels for $90. (Ooops , can I legally say that?, If not, I hope Mark works pro-bono)

Mark

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOO5S4vxi0o

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#45

Re: Still incorrect

Kees

Let me give an example. In the outdoor sport world, lightweight is everythink. So let us asume that Black Diamond brings a new doodad to the market and claims it is twice as light as the competition, but they keep the real weight as a secret. I buy the doodad, put it on my kitchen scale and find it is actually almost the same as the competition. I publish this on an outdoor forum.

Is this tefth? Is it unetical?

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#46

Re: Still incorrect

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Not to me Kees...I would compare it to someone wanting to know the ingredients of the food we eat and then telling someone else there's arsenic in it.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#47

Re: PMV-11!

david weaver

I think it's to sell chisels for an additional $10 isn't it?

I can't see the cost of it as being a real problem for folks not knowing what it is. O1 is still available for the oil stoners, I think (though I can sharpen V11 on oilstones, it does take a lot of edge-teasing to get the wire edge to separate).

I can't get that cranked up about it, but I do wish LV would figure out a super pure carbon steel that is about 60 and 64 hardness (probably require two alloys)!!

(that's unlikely to happen because such things are very poorly behaved in heat treat)

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#48

Re: PMV-11!

Old Baleine

I read this forum frequently, even though my participation in it is so scant that I had to reactivate my profile to make this comment.

I suspect that learning the composition of PMV-11 steel will explain as much about the performance of the cutting edges made from it as would, for instance, learning that James Krenov used ash and Swedish oak explain one of his cabinets.

I am sure that LV's proprietary information is safe from prying eyes, x-ray fluorescent analysis notwithstanding. But some of the comments regarding PMV-11 as a tool steel strike me as unworthy of this forum, even if meant to be humorous.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#49

This post reads like.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

......the text from various classes I have taken on these topics. Mr. Knight must know what he writes about, or at least he is in agreement with other authorities.

Re: Steel for tools analysis

#50

Re: Still incorrect

Hank Knight

Christopher,

I agree with you that Bill can do what he wants with his PMV-11 sample, including publishing the results of any tests he conducts on it. The purpose if my original post was not to suggest otherwise but to alert the Wood Central community that there may be consequences to Lee Valley from such a disclosure. While I have my own views about the ethics and morality of such an action, i take no stand n those issues here. I'll let the community and it's individual members decide for themselves.

With respect to whether money or altruism is the more powerful motivator of development, it probably doesn't matter on a global scale. They are both powerful incentives and people devote their entire lives to both. I personally witnessed one of the great and virtually unknown examples of altruistic motivation in this area that I'll share.

I represented duPunt at its Savannah River nuclear weapons facility near Aiken SC during the mid 1980s. DuPunt was the original contractor/operator of the facility under Truman's enabling letter in about 1952 and operated the facility continuously since its inception. During that time the Savannah River Plant (SRP) was one of two or three premier nuclear research facilities in the world. DuPont scientists at SRP advanced the world's knowledge and understanding of nuclear physics and developed an incredible amount of technology in the area. These developments were worthy of IP protection at the highest level and could have made millions of dollars for duPont. DuPont, however entered in to the agreement with the government to run SRP with one purpose in mind: to use its expertise and resources to give back to the country in appreciation for maintaining a culture that allowed it to flourish since E.I. duPont first made gunpowder on the Brandywine. They were paid a total of $2.00 a year for running SRP. By their own design, they never took any proprietary interest in any of the developments they made there.

In about 1985 or '86, duPont turned the reins of SRP over to Westinghouse. I had the privilige of being a fly on the wall during some very high level discussions leading up to the turnover about whether, in its last days as the contractor, it should perfect iinterests in some of the technology it had developed over the years. The decision was a quick and resounding "no". Executive management reaffirmed duPont's commitment to operating SRP as its gift to the country and declined the opportunity to profit from it, even after all the years since it first started there in the very early 1950s. I was impressed.