Re: Still incorrect
Christopher Fitch Memphis
That's a great story Hank, thanks for sharing.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Still incorrect
Christopher Fitch Memphis
That's a great story Hank, thanks for sharing.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
Clint Searl
This discussion is one helluva cracker barrel morality play.
Not the same thing at all
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) Is this tefth? Is it unetical?
Let me give an example. In the outdoor sport world, lightweight is everythink. So let us asume that Black Diamond brings a new doodad to the market and claims it is twice as light as the competition, but they keep the real weight as a secret. I buy the doodad, put it on my kitchen scale and find it is actually almost the same as the competition. I publish this on an outdoor forum.
Kees, I'm afraid that is not a good analogy.
To take that one specifically, Black Diamond advertised that their doodad was lightest, and your weighing the product simply demonstrates that it is not the case. That is called a "review" 
On the other hand, if BD's doodad was lighter, and this was their advantage in sales - for which they had put in time and money to discover a way of doing so - then revealing publicly what they used and its formulation would be taking something from them without their permission. That is what is considered "theft". Whether this goes on in the business world or not, and whether this is easy to do or not - none of that detracts from the act of taking something of value from someone without their permission.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Different perspectives
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Christopher
I am not a lawyer and I am not attempting to act like one. My work day involves does not involve looking at what is "right" or "wrong", but trying to understand what makes people tick. I question motives, and do so by (hopefully) looking at the Big Picture.
I know Bill as a person with an enquiring mind, and with an interest in tool steel. So the issue of "why" he wants to know the structure/composition of Two Cherries chisel steel does not surprise me. Lee Valley's PMV-11 steel has a similar fascination for others here. I very much doubt that anyone here has thoughts of commercial espionage, certainly none of the forum member with whom I am familiar. It is just curiosity.
However, as soon as Bill begins to offer his service to explore steels for others, and this is with the implication that the information will be divulged publicly, then we move into a different sphere since this is no longer indulging a personal curiosity but placing another in a disadvantaged situation.
I have no knowledge of the patent situation of TC or LV with regard their tool steels. That could take disclosures into the legal area. There are others here - Hank? - who might comment. For me Bill's offer is reckless.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Don't agree
Kees
The weight and the size and the color are all properties of the product. It's there for everyone to see. So it is not a secret. Disclosing the prperties is not theft it is indeed a review. The same goes for the contents of the steel nowadays. A secret that isn't a secret can't be stolen.
Re: Don't agree
TomD
That is the weakness of your original example. Weight is something you can tell a lot about, in virtually any BD product one might care about, simply by lifting the biner or whatever. The composition of PM is a secret or this thread strand wouldn't exist. I know of nothing relating to patent or trademark, copyright, etc... that would make it illegal to disclose the composition, and I AM curious. But if LV doesn't want it known for whatever reason, what purpose is served by making it so. The curiosity is idle, the only people who would really gain will be people with commercial interest.
There is always more subtlety in things than there appears. For instance, torture is sometimes regarded as ineffective because "people will say anything under torture" But the specific stories they make up, even the time they hold out, can tell you something. So in the case of the steel, even if it was proprietary, it doesn't mater. There can still be ways in which the playing field is tilted.
But the main point is why hurt LV, they are a sponsor here, and a friend (not personal). I am not even sure that testing PM is actually under discussion, but I do seem to recall some people around here even got free samples. As David says, just a mater of courtesy.
And I don't know how Ellis feels about this, but it would also seem to put him in difficult situation.
Re: Not the same thing at all
TomD
"On the other hand, if BD's doodad was lighter, and this was their advantage in sales - for which they had put in time and money to discover a way of doing so - then revealing publicly what they used and its formulation would be taking something from them without their permission. That is what is considered "theft". Whether this goes on in the business world or not, and whether this is easy to do or not - none of that detracts from the act of taking something of value from someone without their permission.
Regards from Perth"
That isn't theft. That is why we have patent laws, and copyright, and trademark. Precisely to describe those situations in which intellectual property and other commercial rights are protected. I gather none of those applies. Open season. You can probably make an ethical argument that most Americans would laugh at given it is a very "law abiding" place, that these categories are very blunt instruments and do not protect many real innovations etc... There are many things that are clearly innovations of the first order, but some prior art that is completely dissimilar, and where the originator had no interest in the new version none the less stands in the way of the development being protected. Likewise clearly derivative products gain patent protection every day, probably in the hundreds. (might not stand if challenged though).
There is also the ethics around what might be regarded as a need to show some loyalty, or a sense of obligation.
Re: This post reads like.....
TomD
And part of that is the quandary an entity will find itself in choosing one of the other vehicle for protection since both has risks and limitations. Neither approach fully supports the public interest in protecting property in the short run.
If you are a competitor, red in tooth and claw, you will go for it. If you are a friend you will realize what may be legal, may not be right, and even if OK, may none the less hurt someone who does not deserve it.
Nonsense...
John in NM
I've been too busy to get embroiled in this one, but I think you are stretching the notion of ethics to the breaking point, past even.
Any material marketed for use may be analyzed by anyone willing to spend the bucks to do so. Composition is readily observable by anyone wishing to make the effort, to claim that interest in it is unethical is akin to expecting people to look the other way when they happen upon someone practicing their trade in public. Nothing unethical about curiosity at all, it is the very thing that drove the development of steels like this one.
Now if the suggestion were to break in to a facility where there were genuine trade secrets - such as how to best harden and temper this steel - that would be unethical 
Re: I disagree
John in NM
Readily observable properties, such as composition are never considered trade secrets because they simply cannot be kept as secrets without silly draconian legal measures that most sensible societies do not embrace. The only way to keep a secret is to not market it.
Now steel compositions are patentable, so if one were to analyze, replicate, and market a steel like this that had been patented, then you would have a point. But there is no intellectual property here.
Absurd
John in NM
You need to do some research into manufacturing and ethics before weighing in on this stuff. I have the utmost respect for your contributions to this and other boards, so it pains me somewhat to see you speaking with such ignorance of a subject.
I'm sorry if you find that offensive, it would not be unreasonable to do so. Truth often hurts feelings, just as truth can hurt marketing, but sparing feelings or profits is absolutely no justification for ignoring or avoiding the truth when it is right there to be seen.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
Chuck Kettler
I have the resources to analyze the composition and structure of any tool steel. I could easily analyze a sample of PM11V. What good is the information that I possess and what value does it have? Am I really going to go to a steel mill and ask them to make a one off crucible of steel to my specification? And then purify the content through remelt and cast the crucible contents. And then who will roll out those billets and get them into a usable dimension. Then there is the heat treatment that is needed and the process to optimize the temperature profile and residence time in the furnace. Who is going to go to all that effort? If an amateur metallurgist has the where with all to make a ten pound sample of the target steel then this person also has or has access to all of the analysis instruments required to properly analyze the sample to make and the sample he has made. For what? As Bill Tindall and others have pointed out the process of reverse engineering the work of others is an ongoing pursuit done by many and most companies that are seeking an advantage in a competitive arena. If I have a sample of PM11V I would analyze it just for the scientific interest. Would I share the numbers on this board? Why would I? My time would be better invested in acquiring better plane iron sharpening skills.
Motivation extends well past curiosity
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I suggested that you drop this discussion of thievery, but since you didn't......
The name of the steel used in this application and its manufacturer is the "property" of LV. The steel itself is a product of some steel company that invented it and offered it for sale, most probably not exclusively, to LV. The suggestion to evaluate this steel most likely came from the tech service department of this steel company. The properties of this steel, discovered by the steel company, were no doubt made available to LV, and any other perspective customer. From these properties one can predict to a first approximation how the steel would perform in this or that application.
Given the trivial effort to determine composition the only people that don't know composition are most of the customers. Any slightly curious competitor only had to send a plane blade to the tech service department of their preferred steel company and in short order know its composition and probably who made it. Surely LV knows this fact. So why are they coy about divulging more data to customers? (I don't intend to buy the steel so I have no interest in who made it.)
If LV "owned" anything about this steel they would patent it. I suspect the patent department of LV offered the opinion that there was nothing novel about the application of this steel to making a chisel. Hence, using this steel for chisels could not be patented and in the world of business ethics and law they don't "own" the composition or application.
I bought a good knife a few weeks ago at the Smoky Mountain Knife Company. After evaluating its physical attributes-color, shape, construction- I asked what the steel was. Without hesitation the clerk replied 440C. This information told me at once what I could expect, to a first approximation, for performance. Premium knives often have the steel name engraved in the blade so that knowledgeable customers know, to a first approximation, what to expect for performance. Even woodworkers are beginning to learn what to expect from O-1, A2, or M2 blades. Hence, it is not an idle curiosity to want to know about the steel in one's tools.
However, I have a more important motivation to investigate steel for woodworking tools and in particular this steel that is reported to have the apparent conflicting properties of slow blade wear when planing but relatively easy blade wear when sharpening. "How's that", one might ask. The answer could be of great value to the woodworking community.
As an aside, I have a question, the answer to which I expect experts in the field like My. Knight will confirm. Why did governments invent patents?
To spur innovation? Well, yes but not in the way I expect you to believe. Patents were invented by progressive governments to spur competition to benefit the government's constituents. An exclusive right to some revealed composition or process spurs competitors to work on other approaches. Anyone that works in a field where patents are common knows this fact. This quest to come up with different solutions to avoid patent infringment leads to better solutions for the world. It may work with plane blades too, and we all benefit.
As you say...
david weaver
..there's more to the steel than just the composition, and as I've said and maybe others implied, it's not like LV is asking the moon for any of the stuff of playing predatory.
My first question as a user of steels would be, who else is going to make it as well and for the same price? Probably nobody.
it has occurred to me as a hobbyist that what I thought was edge longevity problems years ago was my use problems, and not even sharpening. but the realization that if any decent steel (including plain stuff made 150 years ago) isn't lasting me long enough, I'm taking too many thin shavings. The bulk of the work should be done without those, and those thin shavings saved for last, even on fitting joints.
If a beginner is hell bent on getting PM V11 because they're convinced it's going to change their lives (and allow them to work faster and longer), then I'm likely to have a conversation with them asking why they think it will, and point them toward a discussion about how useful it will be for them to gear themselves up to make a million thin shavings. The answer for a serious hand tooler is "not very".
I've used stuff up to and including HAP40 (powdered M4), and none of it changed my life like I expected it would. Eventually I went to removing more material with each pass of the plane and it's all trivial.
For chisels, chisels are so easy to sharpen that it really doesn't matter what we use.
If I had the urge to buy everything in V11 though, I'd be inclined to give LV my dollars and let them be the experts at it. all things considered, they've spread their dollars of hoped recovery over a pretty large swath and as an individual I'd be glad to give them a few extra bucks to cover, knowing that saving those few bucks for someone else who dead copied their formula may not yield the same thing.
I don't know, like I said, it's courtesy. LV has never failed to provide service when I've had a concern, they've never failed to deliver what I've ordered, and at least I assume they have taken comments that we've all made to heart and provided a lot of stuff to various folks gratis for feedback. If they didn't care what we thought about it and just wanted our $$, I think the marketing would be a lot slicker and the interaction a lot less.
Re: Absurd
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
You need to do some research into manufacturing and ethics before weighing in on this stuff. I have the utmost respect for your contributions to this and other boards, so it pains me somewhat to see you speaking with such ignorance of a subject.
Hi John
You are correct - I am not a manufacturer, and and I am pretty ignorant of the technical or legal factors involved. I do not pretend otherwise. However the issue here has less to do with legalise and more to do with the line that separates curiosity and a value system, which ever way you wish to define this. About this we all have an opinion.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Not consistent
CJ in MPLS
Derek:
You switched up the definitions right in the middle there.
Theft is depriving someone of a tangible thing. The remedy is jail time.
Infringement is violating an intellectual property right, which is an intangible thing. The remedy is to pay to the IP owner a reasonable royalty or a lost profit.
Also, I hope you filed your patent applications before you put your newest marking gauge on line. 
CJ
Two Sides of the Coin
Hank Knight
I think protection of an owner's proprietary interest and the consequent effect of spurring competition are two sides of the same coin. The courts and the drafters of IP laws probably had (and have) both sides in mind. Both are beneficial to commerce.
Re: Absurd
John in NM
The reason for the title of my original reply is that the vast majority of people will not agree with you that your argument is actually about a value system.
Physical properties are readily observable, in this case by x-ray fluorescence, not exactly a new, novel, or even expensive technique.
In arguing that it is unethical to analyze and discuss the readily observable physical properties of a product on the open market, is about as sensible as claiming that it is unethical to discuss what color a garment is if that color gives it a sales edge, or whether the exact coefficient of squish to a sneaker sole gives it an edge.
There are absolutely no secrets in science - unless one keeps them. Marketing a product is about as far from keeping a secret as you can get, which is why we have patents.
You have not, as far as I've seen (and I've not read every post) made a compelling argument as to how a readily observable property of a marketed product could be considered IP.... If you are serious about making a convincing ethical argument, this aspect of it strikes me as your first task - you must prove that what can be easily seen is actually IP.
Re: Not consistent
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) You switched up the definitions right in the middle there. Theft is depriving someone of a tangible thing. The remedy is jail time. Infringement is violating an intellectual property right, which is an intangible thing. The remedy is to pay to the IP owner a reasonable royalty or a lost profit. Also, I hope you filed your patent applications before you put your newest marking gauge on line. CJ
Derek:
Hi CJ
You're right, of course. My terminology is all over the place. I'm not a lawyer and I really was not thinking along those lines, but used the vocabulary (incorrectly).
This thread went off/away from Bill's original post. Bill and I chat every now-and-then (and about this thread) and I know that there was absolutely no intent on his part to deprive or infringe TC or LV of technical information. He was not likely to post any of that here. The context in my head was really subtly but importantly different from the message I think I actually conveyed. I work with emotions and my mind set was the (emotional effects of a possible) deprivation of ownership for TC and LV if the information was made public, and there seemed to be an indifference to this element by some posters. Mixing legalese and ethics and emotions is not a workable model.
With regards protecting my ideas and designs, hell I don't care - I am not in this hobby for money, just the fun. Like Bill, I am curious about everything. Unlike my day job, forums de-constrain me - and sometimes the rebound is not appropriate! 
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Motivation extends well past curiosity
TomD
The first few paragraphs are full of guesses. Basically you are saying you know their strategy and positioning better than LV does. And that whatever passing curiosity you might have if your interest was in the PM direction is somehow proportional to the loss the whole community might face by damaging one of the players. There is a difference between competition and the efficiencies that result, and undermining serious players, which is sorta like hacking under some noble cover like pointing out gaps in the system.
If it was me and I had some serious investigative purpose, and needed to do something relative to PM, unless my intention was to be an LV competitor, I would just put it to them. Otherwise it sounds like some kind of fairy tale.
I stress that I don't actually know in what direction your interest lies, and all this may just be an interesting hypothetical.
Re: Half story
TomD
"I bought a good knife a few weeks ago at the Smoky Mountain Knife Company. After evaluating its physical attributes-color, shape, construction- I asked what the steel was. Without hesitation the clerk replied 440C. This information told me at once what I could expect, to a first approximation, for performance. Premium knives often have the steel name engraved in the blade so that knowledgeable customers know, to a first approximation, what to expect for performance. Even woodworkers are beginning to learn what to expect from O-1, A2, or M2 blades. Hence, it is not an idle curiosity to want to know about the steel in one's tools."
And the other side of the story, that Bill either knows, or doesn't know, both of which are interesting... Is that there are plenty of knives that are sold with unknown compositions and processes behind them. Sometimes the people selling are up front, sometimes not. There are different ways of marketing stuff. If you are selling some 440C knife, normally to an entry level kind of buyer, or a pragmatist, it is basically a check list kind of item. Customer wants stainless, doesn't want to pay for one of the higher performing steels because 440c is decent stuff, but they want at least that Ford level of quality. So they tell you it is 440c because that is not the selling point other than that customers don't want something lessor than that. But if you want a Ferrari in a car or knife, you may not get the full picture, and you wouldn't understand it if you did. 440c wasn't exciting when I bought my first knives 35 ish years ago. 154CM was all the rage. It's like pants that are marked 100% Cotton.
Re: Weighing the wrong things
david weaver
You assume that it's bill's temporary curiosity against all of LV. Bill is not the only person who would find out if LV was injured by disclosure of what the steel is. If it really was just only bill, that would suggest that he had kept it to himself and it would make no difference to LV at all.
If he shares the information, everyone knows it. It's weighing the curiosity of anyone who would care what it is against LV's interest in keeping it secret.
Personally, I don't know what's in it. I'd suspect that it's more highly alloyed than A2 with something a bit rubbery (like chromium), but it's not a high speed steel. That would lead me to believe it's in the range of powdered D2 or a very well done 440C PM or variant.
Would it make a difference to me what it is? No, even if it was very close to something pedestrian like PM440C, well, where else am I going to get that and get it as well done with the back lapped dead flat on a rotary grinder? Nowhere. That's my side of it, it makes no difference to me knowing or not knowing what it is.
BUT, every quangsheng tool in the world would suggest they had come out with something similar, and given Woodcraft's propensity to sell knock-off tools of every makers, I'd assume they'd have IBC (who also seems to have a gripe with LV) make the same thing. The catch is, Woodcraft sells nothing cheaper than LV, so they'd get some convenience share but would it make much of a difference to LV sales? I don't know, that's LV's business to worry about that stuff.
So, it's everyones' curiosity that would be satsified and not just bill's, but at the same time those most wanting to get an advantage (even if it was just in marketing) would be all of the knock off artists who have no problem selling knock offs (woodcraft, JWW - who did that separately, but are now the same, and especially all of the UK, etc retailers who love to sell imported junk - same as they love to do with counterfeit guitars over there).
Re: Not consistent
CJ in MPLS
Derek:
From time to time I will jump into the middle of some IP argument on the internet and will find myself arguing about work stuff and wonder why I'm doing it. I will say that the ethics and morality of IP law is a tricky thing and probably not something we're likely to suss here. Pints of beer are needed for this type of discussion.
On a more interesting note, I dug out my auger bits yesterday to put them in a newly purchased canvas roll. I also removed a bit of rust and sharpened a couple of them. Its always nice to put something to rights. If you have need of a truly vintage Jennings bit roll, let me know. 
Cheers,
CJ
Thanks CJ. I shall email you offline.
Re: Steel for tools analysis
bridger
I say do the analysis of pmv11 and publish. I for one an curious to learn.
If pmv11 is what LV says- a sophisticated powder metal- knowing the composition won't somehow make it trivial for anyone to duplicate it. If knowing the composition made it easy to duplicate, there would have been a thousand clone steels on the market 6 months after LV released it.
If it turns out that pmv11 is actually something simple, say plain carbon steel with a novel heat treatment, that information would be very interesting too.
What publishing this data- especially as part of a larger database of tool steel analyses- will do is advance the general state of knowledge at the user level about the tools we use. If we can look at a chart and see that for instance having a level of chrome higher that a certain amount without also having a certain amount of tungsten or something makes it impossible to harden beyond a certain point without brittleness.... or some such.... this kind of knowledge allows us ordinary users to be a certain kind of tool geek. Tool geeks buy a lot more tools than joe shmoe garage homeowner users do.
LV will not be harmed.