New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Posts

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#101

Terminology;  reference faces;  more pictures

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

As Bill T. points out elsewhere, 'vertical' and 'horizontal' require a reference. For the plane stock, I'm using the sole (with the plane sitting on a bench) as a reference. In that attitude, the sole is horizontal to the world, and grain lines parallel to the sole are also horizontal. For the wedge, I'm using the wide faces as reference. Annual rings parallel to the wide faces are 'horizontal'. Just my terminology; not trying to impose on anyone else :) .

Some specifics, with pictures:

1. Your photos. I make both of your photos to be showing grain (annual ring) lines parallel to the flat faces of the wedge. I'm calling that 'horizontal grain'. Can't tell if the grain continues parallel to the flat face of the wedge along its full length. Nevertheless, that grain orientation appears to be what I see in every C&W and old plane. I'm having to blow these photos up a lot, so maybe I'm seeing them wrong. Can you concur or disagree with my assessment?

2. The Mathieson jack:

a. The stock. I'm calling this horizontal grain, just about parallel with the sole; almost dead quartered, very slight rift:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/16374426272/in/album-72157650078973847/

b. The stock, side view. Slight upward sweep of the grain lines, viewed from side, similar pattern to all the C&W bench planes:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/15752850174/in/album-72157650078973847/

c. The wedge. This is a little harder to make out. Look at the inside of the horns--these annual rings appear to be running about parallel to the wide faces along the sides. Now look at the end grain between the horns--I see rift, about 30 degrees to the wide face.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/16477786298/in/photostream/lightbox/

Are we seeing the same thing? Not saying I'm right in every case; just trying to clarify what I'm seeing and saying :) .

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#102

Seeking clarification

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

For some reason, I really want to get this sorted out. Try Plane #2 from your Gallery, seems to me to have the same grain orientation as the C&W plane I just showed elsewhere in this thread:

http://gallery.woodcentral.com/all-gallery/?gaId=83

Questions:

1. Do you agree with my observation above?

2. Are you calling that grain pattern quarter sawn? Or something else?

3. Are you saying you're going to change the Try Plane #2 grain orientation, or keep it the same?

Thanks! Not trying to argue--just trying to sort out what these words mean :| . I'm probably dense today; something in the coffee.

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#103

Re: Seeking clarification

david weaver

1) I agree, my #2 is a lot like the CW planes

2) I call that flatsawn, because of the way it's sawn off of the blank

3) Try plane 2 is getting shipped to Chris Griggs in the near future, so I'm leaving the wedge alone, but I'll give him stock to remake it if he'd like.

My three planes that are my personal users as shown, I won't do anything with. They are all rift-ish orientation because the wood I used wasn't quite as well oriented as the blank that #2 is made from, and as those blanks tops were nearer the pith, the slab sawn off of them is more rift than flatsawn.

I'm also leaving them as is because they're mine, and I don't care as much about their aesthetics. I'd originally built them figuring that after I knew I had a set of planes that I liked, I could build planes with better aesthetics later. I did correct the eyes on them to some extent, but that's about it. That's also why the fat handles on the top were left the way they were instead of thinning them. I don't want to be able to break them that easily, but if I were selling them, I would consider giving the buyer the choice to have them thinned at the very top of the horn and in front of it to something a bit more sleek.

I've already dropped each one of them at least once, so despite the fat look at the top of the handles, I feel like I made a good decision there!!

The three planes (the ones other than try #2) don't look so bad as the wedge on try #2 because they are rift sawn, a quick glance at their top leaves them looking like they're not as slab-ish looking.

That doesn't mean I think CW planes have ugly wedges, they obviously chose the stock very carefully like that. I just want my planes after this discussion to have wedges that move laterally with the iron, which is not at all, so that the fingers have a better chance of staying tight against the sides.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#104

Correction--sorry

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Steve,

Sorry. I see now your photos show vertical grain clearly.

I think I'll follow the rule of holes: If you find yourself in a hole, stop digging :) .

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#105

Re: Correction--sorry

Steve Voigt

Wait, whut? I'm just getting started on digging holes! :D

No seriously, I'm glad we are both seeing the same thing on my pics. I did want to follow up on part "c" of your previous post:

c. The wedge. This is a little harder to make out. Look at the inside of the horns--these annual rings appear to be running about parallel to the wide faces along the sides. Now look at the end grain between the horns--I see rift, about 30 degrees to the wide face.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/16477786298/in/photostream/lightbox/

Are we seeing the same thing?

I think the lines that are running at about 30° on the ramped surface are the rays. on the flat part of the face, the lighter-colored specks are also the rays. The quarter-sawn surface of beach often looks like that. For example, here is the side of one of my planes:


I'm sure you can see that the side of my plane looks like the wide face of your mathieson wedge. On the other hand, the side of my wedge looks like the wide face of your wedge.

OK, now let's take a poll. After this thread is over, we're all going to:

(A) drink heavily.

(B) gouge our eyes out with chisels.

(C) all of the above.

(Just kidding; I've really enjoyed this)

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#106

Re: That single iron.

Bob Rozaieski

Yeah, the small smoother was a bit of a surprise when I got it. I took a chance on it on eBay a few years ago. Think I paid about $10 for it. I was surprised to find it had a parallel iron when I got it. But it is bedded at 55 degres, which is a bit odd for a late model plane. I haven't been able to find any info on the maker, but I haven't searched that hard. Like you said, probably a very late 1800s, early 1900s tool.

Thanks for the compliments on the jack! It looks OK in pictures. Closer examination inside the mouth & throat aren't as pretty. It is made from some beech that was sawn by a friend a few years ago. He sawed it at about 5" square, and it sat air drying in my shop for the last couple of years. Some pieces checked really badly. The piece for this jack has some checks in it still, but I used it anyway. I just sawed and planed up a few more blanks for a pair of smoothers and found some hidden checking inside when I ripped into the 5" square block. I tried to saw as much of the checking away as I could, but there's still some. The wood is of marginal quality. But I had it sitting around so I decided to give it a go anyway. Worst thing that will happen is that the blanks will turn out to be unusable when I start chopping into them and I'll end up tossing them in the fireplace. We'll see.

The jack has a few issues I need to address in terms of use. The wedge seems to be slipping lately. It didn't do that when I first built it, but after sitting for a few weeks now it has moved a bit and the wedge isn't holding quite right. I need to re-check the bedding of the iron and re-fit the wedge I think.

I'm also not crazy about the handle. I didn't cut a big enough shoulder at the back of the tote so I didn't have enough wood left to shape the bottom of the handle very nicely. So it's a bit square for my liking at the bottom rear of the tote. This was my first attempt at a vertical grain orientation in the handle though. I like the style, and I like the offset, I just need to tweak the pattern a bit on the next one.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#107

Re: Older planes

Steve Voigt

I don't know how I managed to convince you while simultaneously starting to doubt my own conclusions! Talk about over-thinking!

I feel like what I need to do is look at 50 or so old bench planes, to really get a representative sample. Maybe I'll try to hit the antique malls after next week, when I have some free time.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#108

You can't loose copying what the ....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

competition uses regardless of what is historically correct. One will have enough scraps left from plane making to use any grain orientation one chooses for wedges. Offer the customer the option. Customers like customization.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#109

Re: Older planes

david weaver

I think with my supply and as intentionally as most are quartered or very close to it, what convinced me is two things:

1) I had just made the assumption (without doing enough thinking) that getting the wedge to move with the plane was a good thing. That's only true if the iron never gets tight, because as soon as the iron gets tight, the wedge fit is no longer laterally tight (that said, my original try plane is not quite as tight of a fit as I'd like, but it doesn't clog - there is a point where it becomes a problem, I just don't know where yet).

With your prodding to think, I realize that in a tight fit plane like mine, I want the wedge to move with the iron (not move laterally at all) instead of the plane, then as the plane is let out for the iron a smidge, the wedge will still be tight or very close to it laterally.

2) aesthetically, it's undeniable that quartered looks better. Some flatsawn wedges look good, but all quartered wedges do

Especially if you use a generous amount of oil on the surface of the planes. I'm assuming that larry used some kind of drying finish on his planes, I remember him saying it in the moulding plane video - that limits how different the wood can look. If you put a liberal amount of linseed oil or tung oil on instead, differences really stand out.

If I was selling planes, I'd have to consider a finish that doesn't require maintenance and doesn't allow dirty sharpening stone fingers to make a plane dirty beyond what can get wiped off, but I like oil and wax and don't care about dirt.