Re: Beech question - weight a minute
david weaver
In this case, the weight is important. It's important because you want the plane to allow you to take the maximum shaving that you can take with the minimum amount of abuse on your hands and elbows (and I guess shoulders, I've never had shoulder pain from planing).
Some people may have a different preference, especially if they're not working many hardwoods harder than cherry or if they're working a lot of soft woods, but a plane with an iron as wide as mine and that is minus weight from mine trades weight for pain.
I think Larry's jack is probably a little lower (not as high of a cross section), I can't remember (as in smaller cross section) and is probably a bit heavier than something like an open handled 2" beech jack plane. But I don't think it's heavier than my closed handle jack, which is 5 1/2 pounds (and at that is noticeably nicer to use in a very heavy cut than a lighter jack).
For japanese planes, the weight doesn't make much difference because no joint really takes impact when it makes a cut. I wouldn't like a heavy dai, and I don't like anything that's more musical than white oak (I don't even like the red oak dais that much). The property of the shiragashi is a lot like beech, that it's a deadish wood.
I don't know, a lot of this is preference I guess. I made a bunch of planes, infills and whatever, before I came across a couple of good double iron planes and really preferred them. Even if I couldn't qualify this stuff verbally, the planes at specific sizes and weights and orientations of every part just "feel right", especially in heavy use.






