New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Posts

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#26

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

david weaver

In this case, the weight is important. It's important because you want the plane to allow you to take the maximum shaving that you can take with the minimum amount of abuse on your hands and elbows (and I guess shoulders, I've never had shoulder pain from planing).

Some people may have a different preference, especially if they're not working many hardwoods harder than cherry or if they're working a lot of soft woods, but a plane with an iron as wide as mine and that is minus weight from mine trades weight for pain.

I think Larry's jack is probably a little lower (not as high of a cross section), I can't remember (as in smaller cross section) and is probably a bit heavier than something like an open handled 2" beech jack plane. But I don't think it's heavier than my closed handle jack, which is 5 1/2 pounds (and at that is noticeably nicer to use in a very heavy cut than a lighter jack).

For japanese planes, the weight doesn't make much difference because no joint really takes impact when it makes a cut. I wouldn't like a heavy dai, and I don't like anything that's more musical than white oak (I don't even like the red oak dais that much). The property of the shiragashi is a lot like beech, that it's a deadish wood.

I don't know, a lot of this is preference I guess. I made a bunch of planes, infills and whatever, before I came across a couple of good double iron planes and really preferred them. Even if I couldn't qualify this stuff verbally, the planes at specific sizes and weights and orientations of every part just "feel right", especially in heavy use.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#27

Re: Beech question

david weaver

I think I've read that in the past. the trouble with reading an article like larry's is it never even means remotely anything to me until I experience something for myself.

This topic isn't specifically where the big words thing comes up, more other things, like tearout, bevel up or down, grinding with diamonds, etc. I recall discussions in the past where it went so far that larry played academic critic and called Derek's ph D in question. Somehow, I remember those kinds of things.

I have a technical job, but it's client focused. One of the things that irks me is when people don't make an effort to communicate using common vocabulary when it's appropriate, and the discussions we've had where "beam strength" and all of this stuff comes up is pointless when the conclusion of it is "you can't set a cap iron close enough to be practical, anyway".

I prefer plain and proven, and less posturing. I guess that's why I appreciate picking up the phone and talking to George so much.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#28

Re: pretty

david weaver

I think it's exceptionally nice looking wood, too, and when it's sawn properly, it makes fantastic looking drawer sides. The folks who smoosh together poplar or pine dovetails for a squash fit might not like beech so much, but it sure would be a lot more durable in some drawer types than poplar.

Crossing from the comments below, I haven't yet tried infused wood for planes, but I am cheap. I tried some on a chisel handle blank, but I think it needs to be infused after the blank is roughed, as I think I turned most of the heavily infused part off.

I have added as much as a pound of raw linseed oil to beech, but not something as small as a smoother. At some point, I will make more coffin smoothers just because I'll have short wood from some of my blanks, and I'll try that then. I know I won't be buying more cocobolo because it's just too hard to find cheaply in blanks that are 10x10x4 or so.

The bois de rose blank that I made the infill from (I thought it was cocobolo until someone pointed out to me that it was bois de rose - smells a little different and works a lot more nicely than cocobolo, too) was about 16x7x4. Vintage and not to be found again, but that plane was all I got out of it because it had a lot of cracking and bug damage. If I'd have known what it was, I wouldn't have wasted it on a plane before knowing anything about design.

Long way around, maybe I'll try the oil next time....or maybe all of those shorts will end up being continental smoothers.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#29

Re: I don't mind...

david weaver

..if people have less than unflattering opinions of me or my conclusions, though, either - or how I talk or drone on and get engrossed in a topic and just keep bringing it up over and over.

There are lots of people who practically worship larry's opinions, and love his planes, and that's fine with me as long as we're not all forced to have the same opinion about anything.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#30

Re: PS

david weaver

I wish it would become available if it was that easy.

I agree that it does transfer moisture quickly, but if it's allowed to do so unmonitored, even air drying, it can crack up.

I just haven't seen anyone else offering clear blanks (in the last 10 years, too) like horizon has, and I suspect it's because it's difficult to dry them to the standard that they need to be dried (and not cracked) for planes.

I'd be more than happy to be proven wrong about that, though. It'd be lovely to make a bench out of it, even if it was 8/4 material, which is listed by a lot of lumber sites, but not retailed for a reasonable price anywhere near me.

I'm going to end up building a decent bench out of oak because that's what's available to me in big wood for a decent price.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#31

Re: They look great!

Brian Holcombe

I've found this to be a trait of lignum vitae as well. I've had some since the mid 90's and it still develops new cracks...

I've been lucky with rosewoods, I think most of the initial cracking has been due to them arriving in America with a lot of drying to do. For instance I bought some Morado a while back ( Bolivian rosewood) and used it for a table top with breadboard ends. Luckily I had the foresight to shellac the end grain inside the breadboard ends as that table top then shrank about 1/2" over 24". I had a similar experience with Indian rosewood.

Anymore I buy exotics and just toss them in the rack, they've usually been seasoned by the time they actually get put to use and that is quite helpful.

I can't imagine there are too many advanced drying procedures going on in the parts of the world that export exotic timbers and those parts are generally very damp, so I think some of the crankiness of exotics is due in part to them arriving here, wax sealed, then adjusting to much drier weather.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#32

bench wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would consider ash for your bench. When maple got high priced (at one time it was higher than walnut) we moved our industrial utilitarian customers to ash and they found it a good substitute. Some years later I found out the reason maple spiked. "Every" town in Japan decided to build a bowling alley or two. There is nearly no market for ash now and it is the cheapest dense wood.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#33

Re: bench wood

david weaver

I could get enough ash delivered to build a bench for about $600, and have some left over.

Unfortunately, being as close to the city as I am, the retail dealers around here pretty much stink. There's a chance that one of the lumber guys who comes into the city from time to time might have something for me cheaper than that, I just have to get in contact with them.

I wish mike digity was still in business, as I don't have a truck and mike drove a door to door route when he was in the city (as in the wood could fall out of his delivery van and be on my shop floor).

Oak may be it for me at this point, because a friend is getting a couple of trees sawn through and through, and one of them is 12/4 oak (hopefully it is white oak).

I'd rather have beech, but I haven't seen it dry and 8/4 for $4 or less. For two reasons:

1) no pores

2) it's not a loud wood to work on, even though it's hard

Anyway, this friend of mine doesn't move very fast, has hasn't picked up his trees yet and he's the kind of guy who might pay for it and spend a year to actually go get it. If he goes any slower, I'll be building a bench out of ash.

one of the WPINCA books (or some other book I've read) cautioned that ash becomes brittle with age, but it would probably be at an age that I didn't care.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#34

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

Kees

Old street tools make narrower planes. 2 1/4 for the try plane and jointer. 2" for the fore plane and 1 3/4" for the jack.

I think it also depends on your own body. you are a big guy, so it easier for you to push a 2 1/2" iron through a thick cut. I am very lightly build and probably not half as strong, so I think I would prefer narrower blades.

I looked it up. Hornbeam is only marginally heavier then beech. I can't find the specs for service tree wood because it is such a rare species. But I remember from an article in a magazine that it is quite a bit heavier then beech.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#35

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

david weaver

I'm probably not as big as I might look on video, just a little bit fat (under 200 pounds, though). Though I can't claim to make others' preferences, and certainly you've got to work with whatever is comfortable.

I haven't found pre 1800 bench planes (and it's unlikely I'd ever buy such a thing), so not sure why larry chose the sizes that he chose. I do know that after 1800, most big planes were 2 1/2 inches wide, with some jointers and try planes being 2 3/4. Not sure why the change if there was one.

Smoothers with a double iron became wider planes - most coffins being 2" to 2 1/4", and with the ability to plane quartered wood without angling the plane all over the place.

I'd have to guess the average workman using those planes was probably 150 pounds, which is in reality what I should weigh.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#36

Re: pretty

John in NM

Stabilizing should definitely be done on roughed out stuff. If for no other reason, the company I use charges by finished weight :D

Usually I sand parts to be done to 80 grit and then send them out. If you can turn off the stabilized part, it wasn't done by a pro. Everything I've had done the resin went all the way through. But then this was maple burl, so it's pretty easy to get resin all the way through. A dense, oily wood like cocobolo might not stabilize at all.

Last time I did it I sent out 6 buttstocks and the tab was around $120 with return shipping. A little pricey, but not too bad since for me it's commercial work.

On the other hand, based on what you and others have said about beech's properties for planes, all that resin would probably not be a good idea. Going to change a lot of them that you guys probably prefer unchanged. If you wanted to try it anyway, you could send me a roughed out plane body and I'd stick it in my next batch going out. I should have one more before I call it quits on burl work.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#37

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

Kees

The long plane and the jointer from the Dominy workshop are 3 1/8" wide. They don't tell the width of the iron, but at this size I'd guess the iron should be somewhere between 2 1/4" and 2 1/2" ? And these are single iron planes.

I would have to look up what the seaton chest has. I guess you could find some sizes in Roubo too.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#38

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

david weaver

That's probably a good size guess. I end up around 3" or just a hair more with a 2 1/4 iron, and 3 1/4 or a little more with 2 1/2. If the planes with 2 1/2" iron are left at 3 3/8th or so, they start to look a bit fat in the cheeks.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#39

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

Kees

It's a cuty isn't it?

33 1/2" long 3 1/8" wide, single iron 50 degree pitch.


img

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#40

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

david weaver

Any clue what year those planes were made?

I see no eyes, which isn't a surprise, and a concerted effort to make the wedge a bit ornate, as well as the front part of the handle (which looks more ornate than functional).

33+ inches long would've been a heavy plane - nose heavy in use (they are all a bit nose heavy, but it gets more noticeable as the planes get longer, even if it stays in proportion, the amount of weight goes up), but no clue how they were using it.

Any more pictures of their planes?

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#41

Re: bench wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

ash becomes brittle with age, ...I have not experienced this problem with ash handles, some of which are decades old.

I can get 8/4 FAS1F for about $2 bdft if you are in the neighborhood. And while here you can spend half a day and rive out a lifetime of beech blanks which will be dry before you have a bench built.

If you are planning on going from trees to dry 12/4 oak you aren't needing a bench any time soon!

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#42

Re: Is this the same bunch?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

"can't remember the name of the other maker in new england"

That would be Matt Bickford:

http://www.msbickford.com/

http://musingsfrombigpink.blogspot.com/

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#44

Re: bench wood

david weaver

I guess I wasn't that clear about that, the slabbed trees were slabbed a little over a decade ago and stuffed into a dry barn.

This friend of mine doesn't build much, I'm not sure what he wants with them, but if he got a good price, I'll use it.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#45

Re: Is this the same bunch?

david weaver

Yeah, very nice guy. I know I've talked with him a time or two a few years ago, but couldn't remember his name. He sent me some persimmon strips to make boxing in a beading plane.

I think he's a very productive maker, too (as in works at a good rate).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#46

Felix Dominy on What He Likes to See

david weaver

>> Lawyers scarce & out of employ <<

Haha! :)

I like the comment about liking to see a man who tends to his own property well and does not interfere with others' property.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#47

Asian/non-Japanese planes (木刨) Re: Beech quest

Chris

Traditionally planes in Asia were craftsman made. When you finished your 5-7 year apprenticeship you had a set of planes (木刨) in your toolchest.

Types of wood, well, whatever was available, i.e. cutoffs from projects. Depending where you lived, what we consider exotics, grow locally, but they also imported their exotics, like the highly esteem zitan (紅木) from places like Vietnam or India. Was walking through the botanical garden in a small town in South-Western China last week and run into a Hubei Rosewood tree, as I see it most of these trees are some form of bean trees.

Other types of wood that I am told are popular are generically called 紅木 "red wood", that I take it this is roughly equivalent to our generic term rosewood.

These wood species are becoming rare these days and and you start seeing serious efforts to protect them. For example, there's a major thoroughfare where literally in the middle of the road you have a big old bean tree. Few years ago they would have chopped that tree down, now they are protected with a fence and a historic marker.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#48

Red wood...

david weaver

I'd bet that's shungee rosewood or something similar. It seems to show up both in videos of craftsmen as well as in a ton of muji planes.

Muji was offering a lot of ebony for a while, and I was lucky enough to get a little bit of it in smoothing planes, but they said that ebony was getting harder to get a hold of and most of the ebony planes went to shungee.

It's kind of a boring looking wood, but property wise it makes a very nice dense little plane and seems to be very stable.

Muji was making planes with high speed steel irons - out of ebony - that were cheaper at retail than I could get a dried blank without any iron or anything else.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#49

Re: drying not as slow as you are assuming

Steve Voigt

So speaking of Larry Williams again...

Some time ago, I found an ancient forum post where he discussed drying beech. I contacted him with some followup questions and got a typically thorough response.

In a nutshell: They begin air-drying the wood (outside, covered and stickered, well off the ground and with lots of ventilation) in December or January. Larry stressed that starting the drying in the cold winter months is important because of the risk of fungi. I got the impression that the air drying was 1-2 years for 16/4. When the wood is in the 12-14% range, it's moved inside. In the old forum post (this was more than 10 years ago), he was using a lightbulb kiln, similar to what chairmakers use. Later, they moved to a ceramic space heater as the heat source, and he specifically mentioned keeping the temp about 15-20 degrees above the ambient temp.

The bottom line is that this is something doable without a lot of specialized equipment. However, I believe that they are now getting at least some of their lumber from Horizon. I don't know why, but my impression is that they are Horizon's main customer for beech.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#50

Seaton chest, iron widths

Kees

I looked it up in the Seaton chest book. The tryplane and the jointer have a 2 1/2" iron. The jacks and the smoother a 2" iron. These planes are from 1796.

So I have really no idea where old street tools got the idea that the 18th century British planes are narrower. Maybe it is just their preference, I don't know.