New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Posts

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#51

Re: drying not as slow as you are assuming

david weaver

Larry was mike digity's biggest customer, I gather. I never asked mike specifics, because his business is none of my business, but I know he sold beech to Matt and Larry at some point.

When I asked him if he had 16/4, he said no (i knew if he did, it would be cheap from him). I told him my only other choice was horizon, which cost a fair amount (and I didn't have the stock yet, so I had some fear that some might be rift and not sawn with the pith on center). He said he'd sold a lot of wood to them and they do a good job.

Some of the beech that I've gotten from Mike (the thin stuff) had a little bit of surface fungus on it, and I doubt mike held it that long, so probably between the mill and the kiln that showed up. If I had it wet straight off of the log, I'd probably bleach it and then check it from time to time.

I'm sure that it's a very doable process, as George mentioned that all they did at CW was put it in the attic of a toolmaker shop or one of the shops or storage sheds. It sounds like it did fine there. I don't know if it was summer or winter.

The trick, it seems to me, is to:

* get it and not let it dry too fast

* keep it from getting fungus

* find a sawyer who can saw it so that it is oriented like my #2 try plane

The wood that prashun graciously sold to me was not quite as straight as the wood that I requested, but I'm sure he told them that he was using it for bench legs, and they probably chose based on that. They are (horizon) very knowledgeable, and at the low volume of hobby making that i do, I've got no qualms about paying them. I'll just know not to pay freight next time because they're only 2 hours away. They don't have a retail storefront though, so anyone who reads this and figures they'll follow the directions on the website and go there, don't do it. You have to pre-arrange pick up.

I have another option that some others may not, and that is that some of the people who work there come to the city here once in a while, and they did mention that if they'd have been coming, they would've just dropped it off.

I guess this discussion probably only interests a couple of us.

This summer, I'll probably check a couple of the local custom sawyers and see if they get beech logs from time to time that are straight and have no twist in them. I don't envy the guys who are trying to make a living getting this stuff when there really is no organized market to provide them with wood that is as exactly sawn as it should be to make planes.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#52

And that is why you can't find quartered beech

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I guess this discussion probably only interests a couple of us. " That's the problem. There isn't a market big enough to interest those that could supply it. However, if someone wanted to culture a local Woodmizer owner many would supply what is needed. But I suspect the problem is what is needed is too small for the plane maker to expend the effort.

Everything said about drying is reasonable. Mold does attack if it doesn't dry quickly. I see mold in the firewood pieces that stayed wet for a time and any log the lays in the woods for a few months is shot.

I don't know much about planes but none I have seen would require 16/4 lumber. I have 8 family planes on the shelf and they would require 6/4 to 12/4 to make. In total there is 8 bdft of lumber in them, a rather piddly amount. On the other hand riving blanks from firewood sections for a half day would yield more blanks than anyone would likely use in a lifetime. Hence, the firewood route seems to be the way to go, not log sawing. Chair makers do it all the time.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#53

Re: And that is why you can't find quartered beech

david weaver

Most of the good quality try and jointer planes will require 16/4. The finished height and width of my jointer and try planes are all bigger than 3 inches (the try planes are about 3 1/4 inches wide, and 3 1/8th tall.

It's not something you want to compromise on in terms of height, and it's an absolute no go on compromising on width if the iron is 2 1/2 inches wide.

In addition, it is ideal if you can get the wedge stock off of the same blank, but on top, as it needs to be flat sawn, and you'd like the plane body to shrink a little faster than the wedge when it dries (inevitably, even with dry wood, the plane will shrink a little bit more at some point).

Small open handled jacks could get away with 12/4.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#54

shungee rosewood

Chris

Shungee is Kantonese, makes sense, Woodwell Tools, the company behind Mujingfang, is located in Gaungdong (aka. Kanton).

Poking around the web ab bit, it's called suan zhi, 酸枝, literally "sour branch". Google translates that into...rosewood, so shungee rosewood is rosewood rosewood. No, that doesn't help.

Scientific classification is a very recent (relatively speaking) phenomenon. In the old times the wood was classified according to what it looked like. I think Ecke describes the phenomenon that from the same tree you could harvest wood with totally different names.

In the entry for rosewood in Wikipedia, under "other rosewoods", they mention that many other (i.e. non-dalbergia) "rosewoods" come from the legume genera. As a non-biologist I call that "bean trees". Sure enough you see a lot of "bean trees" in Southern China.

Thinking about it, we have a fair amount of gnarly old prickly "bean trees" here in Texas, I think they just use them as firewood. Maybe we should look into this a bit.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#55

Re: shungee rosewood

david weaver

I wish someone sold some of woodwell's dry stock over here. I like it as a material. It's got a little bit of porousness, but it takes a nice polish.

Of course, I like their ebony better, but that doesn't come in large pieces very cheaply.

I have never seen anyone marketing chinese wood here, and if they did, it would be like beech where Bill tells us it's 50 cents a foot in volume, and once it's dried and at retail, it costs $4 for plain sawn and 8 to $10 for quartered.

Even jarrah is priced expensive here, and I gather it's fairly common in aus.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#56

Re: shungee rosewood

david weaver

thanks for the translation, by the way.

I'm a big fan of woodwell. One needs to know what they make to make sure you don't get a tiny plane or a plane that has odd proportions, but their good planes are a steal, and their (what appear to be) T series HSS chisels are interesting to say the least.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#57

Re: Seaton chest, iron widths

Bob Rozaieski

OST planes are based upon the ones from Neve I believe.

"We offer the complete line described by Richard Neve in his 1736 The City and Country Purchaser's BUILDERS DICTIONARY".

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#58

Re: Seaton chest, iron widths *LINK*

Kees

I found Neve's description in an older post on woodcentral. But it mentions the length of the planes, not their width.

It's not important, I'm just curious. The only source I could find with long planes with narrow irons is Roubo. He mentions a 2" wide iron in a 27" long plane. The smoothers also have 2" irons. And then there are smaller planes for specific purposes with narrower irons.

The smoothing plane found in the rubish pit in London had a 2 1/4" double iron and dates from somewhere in the second half of the 18th century. The latest possible date of that pit is 1896 but the plane was completely worn out and thrown away, so probably quite a bit older then that.

Link to Richard Neve below:


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3108/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/15465h6DcSWc5ueuIXZI1424982184/spage/1/sanc/130635/sbid/3108/md/read/id/130635/sbj/richard-neve-had-it-right-in-1736/

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#59

Re: Seaton chest, iron widths

David weaver

I also had an old continental jointer that was 28" long and had a 2" wide iron.

The seller neglected to mention the handle was broken, and I threw it away. I'll say more of the choices of width when I get home and am not typing on a phone .

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#60

Richard Neve

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Richard Neve edited a Builder's Dictionary over a period of decades with lots of editions. The 1736 edition is the first one to list planes. His descriptions appear to have been largely a condensation of Moxon. I don't think Neve himself ever planed a board. And as Kees mentioned there are no widths printed.

I made a double iron jack plane in 1978 which is still in use. I have never owned another jack or a planing machine. The irons are 2 1/8 so it is considerably lighter than David's plane. So far my frame is holding up.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#61

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Steve Voigt

"In addition, it is ideal if you can get the wedge stock off of the same blank, but on top, as it needs to be flat sawn, and you'd like the plane body to shrink a little faster than the wedge when it dries (inevitably, even with dry wood, the plane will shrink a little bit more at some point)."

You would think this would be true, so that the shrinkage rates of the plane and wedge match exactly. I assumed it was true for a long time, and made a bunch of wedges that way. But it is not true. Every old plane I have has a dead-quartersawn wedge. If you find one that's not, it is probably a user-made replacement.

The reason is that a flat sawn wedge can warp as the annular rings try to straighten out, while the QS wedge will stay flat.

I have had no problem with my flat sawn wedges, so I wouldn't sweat it. But something to keep in mind if you make more planes.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#62

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

david weaver

I should've said that's where I prefer to cut the wedges.

In all of the old planes I've seen, I've never had one where the wedge was a problem for twist, but I have had several planes where the wedge fingers had shrunk in from the sides enough to cause a problem.

Of the four that I have, the two matheisen planes have quartered wedges, the griffiths has rift, and my old jt brown single iron plane has a wedge that's closer to flat sawn than anything else. Another baldwin plane is sawn rift. The two that are rift sawn may have been intended to be quartered.

I haven't obviously read a book about it, but because of what I've seen with a couple of wedges that had fingers causing problems, I'm going with the flatsawn wedge, despite the majority of my planes having quartered.

The other consideration is that my flatsawn stock is coming from stock that's sawn center on pith, so it may cup but it will not twist.

Strangely enough, my jt plane that is flatsawn has wedge fingers that fit very well, and it's my oldest plane, somewhere between 1820-1840 most likely. It did have one problem, though, and that was that the iron was almost impossible to get out of it.

I think JT brown made double iron planes, I just had bad luck when I got mine (and I got it a while ago, so I wouldn't have known the difference, anyway).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#63

thinking it through..

david weaver

it doesn't make sense that my wedges had their fingers in, if they're quartered, the wedge should stay wide if the plane narrows.

They may have been swapped.

I don't know if the fingers would be stronger one way or another, though.

I had kind of figured with the array that I have that it was maker's choice, but now that I know yours are all quartered, I guess I'm going to have to gnash my teeth if I don't make the next ones quartered!!!

I haven't departed from historical practice with much.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#64

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

david weaver

I updated my video to suggest that quartered is historically correct.

By the way, do you have any way for people to contact you on your web page? I suggested your site in the beginning and last video that I put online, but when I went to your blog, it doesn't look like there's an easy way for people to contact you if they want a double iron plane.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#65

Widths..

david weaver

I can't say too much of the width talk without speculation, I guess.

I would speculate that the average beginner would take one of my planes and consider it to be harder to use than larry's (and everyone else making single iron planes that are narrower), there's a little more to work with and if you don't get the depth set right, there's more width to push. It's like swinging a sledge or anything else, it takes a little bit of time to get the mechanics down, so a 2 1/2" wide double iron plane doing what it does best isn't much of a wood show type plane for beginners to use.

I think for truing and having the ability to match plane edges, one will want as wide of an edge as they can practically use. Somewhere above 2 1/2 inches, it gets really hard to push a plane.

I don't know what the average width of a jointer was in the past, and as we talked about earlier, the jack is limited by the camber more than the width of the iron, so it's left out of the discussion. The jointer and try plane can cut full width, so there is more to their widths commonly being 2 1/2, and sometimes 2 3/4s (two out of a dozen jointer and try planes I've gotten were 2 3/4" wide, both american made).

I don't know if maybe there is a greater chance of chatter with wider single irons, too? My JT brown plane will chatter in a heavy cut, so will any single iron plane with a 1/8th iron. George told me some of the curators at williamsburg were convinced that chatter was just accepted as being there.

There is none of it with a double iron plane 2 1/2" wide.

There may also be a customer issue with Larry's planes, that they need to be suitable for both experienced and gentlemen users. Don't know, though.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#66

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Steve Voigt

Dave, my sample size of old planes is not large. So, although I'm pretty confident about what said before (about the wedges being quartered), it would be nice to hear from some others (Warren, Wiley, anybody) about what they see in the 18th/19th c. planes they own.

It's very nice of you to mention my name in your vids. And thanks for reminding me about the contact info--I will update my blog. I've sort of been waiting until I get the website going (which will be soon, I hope), but that's just silly. Anyway, it's voigt(dot)planes@gmail(dot)com.

Like I said before, I don't think it is a big deal with the wedges--none of mine have twisted, and I'm glad to hear none of yours have either! But, just one other thought: the quartered wedges definitely look nicer. Not sure if that was part of the original reasoning, but it might have been.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#67

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Steve, Dave, and all,

I'm not sure exactly what 'quarter sawn' vs. 'flat sawn' means in this discussion, so will describe the grain direction as best I can.

I have many, many Clark & Williams and Old Street planes--smooth, jack, fore, try, jointer, match planes, filletster, plough... Without exception, the grain on the wedges is oriented just like the grain of the plane stocks--dead-quartered horizontally (parallel grain lines running east to west, left to right). All the planes are beech, except for a cocobolo smoother that Bill Clark made, and it has grain oriented same as the other beech ones.

If you then look along the side--the length--of the wedge, the grain lines are again parallel, so there is minimum runout. Effort has been made to have the grain lines exactly parallel with the back--the flat, downward edge--of the wedge. The grain lines run from finial to tip, parallel, with de minimus runout. This parallelism in the wedge is a little different than the grain in the length of the plane stocks, which though parallel runs slightly upward from rear to front. Larry describes the reason for this slight angle in an article on his website. Has to do with avoiding short grain in the mouth, as I recall.

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#68

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Steve Voigt

Wiley, apologies for being dense, but I'm not sure I get your description. Does the widest dimension of the wedge--the one you look down on when viewing the plane from above--look like the sides of the plane, or the top/bottom of the plane?

To put it another way, are the Rays on the wife faces of the wedge, or on the sides?

It sounds to me like your description agrees with what David said, but I want to be sure.

Thanks!

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#69

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

TomD

"In this case, the weight is important. It's important because you want the plane to allow you to take the maximum shaving that you can take with the minimum amount of abuse on your hands and elbows (and I guess shoulders, I've never had shoulder pain from planing)."

That is a different issue from performance in quality terms, and an important one. Do I remember correctly that you have certain issues in that area? If so I sympathize as I have some ankle and back issues, but I wouldn't make a general prescription unless everyone is planing on a plane crash and climbing accidents at some point. We are a geriatric lot. I am told from inside sources that the whole woodworking biz is drying up. Anyway, in my case I formed my views on plane weight in the 70s and 80s when I was in my early 20s, and trying to turn out volume work. I remember getting beat up by the 7 pound jointer that was recommended as a general purpose plane by Ian Kirby. I was a lot more energetic back then, but not to the extent that I ever got used to the specific work that beat me up. I decided that the 5.5 pound saving in weight, or whatever, was more important to me than any shock absorber effect. There are other ways to deal with that like sorbothane, but weight is always weight.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#70

Re: I don't mind... thoug in fairness

TomD

"I think I've read that in the past. the trouble with reading an article like larry's is it never even means remotely anything to me until I experience something for myself."

"I prefer plain and proven, and less posturing. I guess that's why I appreciate picking up the phone and talking to George so much."

In fairness, he and his partners have probably done more for the revival of their type of plane than anyone else as long as I can remember. Larry & co. proved it could be a business, and people are very much more attracted to that which can be bought than any amount of anything else; They did the videos, when essentially they were teaching their competition, which has emerged; and they may have upped the game at Williamsburg. The doers are the ones who mater, the followers are not remembered except as the ornament to the doers. For their efforts they deserves our thanks, and part of that is moving on and taking it to wherever it needs to go, which may not be exactly where they left it. That can be noisy at times.

I picked Larry's brain through an email once, and I rented his videos. So his generosity is not necessarily well repaid in due measure.

You name drop George a lot which really doesn't mean much to me, not entirely sure who he is. It is presumably nice for the both of you that you have each other. And so?

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#71

Re: Widths..

Kees

Yes I think chatter certainly playes a role. With wider irons the forces increase especially when higher cutting angles are used. Most single iron planes have at least a 50 degree bedding.

I have been digging a bit more. Problem is, no pre 1750 bench planes in the British planemakers tradition are known. We have planes from earlier times but they weren't made by professional British planemakers. For example the Mary Rose planes. I have no measurements from these. The Dutch plane from the Nova Zambla expedition in 1596 is a small plane, 6" long with a 1 3/4" blade. Among the other tools is also a planeiron 2 1/4"wide, maybe from a jointer? Other 18th century Dutch planes are quite narrow too. Looking further back into the middle ages you see planes in pictures with very wide bodies but narrow irons. The Melancholica plane from Duerrer for example.

I remember an argument from Larry Willliams many years ago that wider blades were neccessary for double iron planes because they always clog in the corners. The single iron planes allowed the use of narrower irons thus reducing the weight of the plane and making it more agile. Now you have demonstrated how a well made double iron needs to be made and how it behaves without clogging we can turn that argument around. The single iron planes needed to be narrow and the double iron allowed the planemaker to make wider planes.

But then again we have this single iron jointer from the Dominies with the 2.5" iron from 1766.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#72

Flatsawn wedge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I made a new beech wedge for my trying plane more than twenty years ago. The original was quartered, but my new wedge was flatsawn; it was probably made from old firewood or an old pallet. It continues to work well and I don't recall adjusting it in the meantime. The scale of the work is important here. We are not dealing with a 12 inch wide board or a board that is 10 or 15 times as wide as it is thick. Both David's and Steve's rationale would be worth considering on a larger scale.

A quartered wedge probably looks nicer. When I make beech chisel handles, I like to put the quartered surface up.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#73

Dominy planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Dominy handles have much more of that 18th century style. A few years ago one of my friends was looking down his nose at my 19th century trying plane. Then he looked under the bench and said "Now there is an 18th century plane!" It was the jack plane I had made in 1978, with a Dominy style handle. I guess it is getting some age on it.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#74

Re: I don't mind... thoug in fairness

david weaver

The reason you don't know who george is is because he can't follow the format on here.

He was the musical instrument shop master at williamsburg, then the toolmaker when he had a chance to get away from the public (which made him the doer basically for anything there that was difficult and related to tools for the trades, special orders, etc - though I think he was that, too, when he was the musical instrument maker).

The reason I mention george is because he (and no offense to larry) is a craftsman in a completely different league at every level, but he is genuinely interested in giving people good advice and for free. He is a fan of the tools, and before larry and don were around he made most of the planes for williamsburg (and saws, and anything else the trades needed, and guns, and cannons).

He's got such a huge range of fine work, but is not married to doing work any specific way - so he can advise about almost anything if you're in a rut. The only thing that he doesn't really get cranked up about is furniture.

I can't link to much of his work because he's posted it on SMC and their images are not viewable unless you register. I'm hoping i can convince him to post pictures of his work here in the gallery.

The difference between him and other craftsmen is that he will advise someone who is a rank beginner, without compensation, but anyone who reads the woodworking or machinist forums he posts on will know that he doesn't tolerate it well when an amateur comes along and criticizes him about something they don't know enough about to criticize.

There is a page with his a little bit of his guitaring stuff (because it's a guitar related site), but it does little justice because it's just a narrow slice of his work.

http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson.html

http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson1.html#wilson6

There are some parallels to warren, because you may have noticed that warren's encyclopedic knowledge of a topic's history. George is much the same, the encyclopedic thoughtfulness and care is there in all of his work.

(as far as larry goes, I've bought everything he sells in terms of videos, and I don't talk about moulding planes that much because I learned to build them entirely from larry's videos, and thus don't like to offer up much in detail about making them as I'd probably just be relaying information that should be purchased through larry's videos).

I talk freely about bench planes because the double iron stuff primarily comes from steve and I examining planes and talking the bits and pieces of their fitting out. If I were to make another single iron plane, I would just pull the JT brown out and examine it. I don't have any (old) moulding planes of the quality that larry's videos describe how to build, but the long planes are easier to come by in good proportion. I hope larry has made a few bucks off of his videos, as you say, he pretty much put together a care package for anyone else wanting to build moulding planes, and it's easy to see that those that are sold (not just matt bickford, who got larry's permission IIRC) are made as larry's videos describe.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#75

Re: Dominy planes

david weaver

From a design perspective, I don't know what kind of bent eye would consider the handles on the 18th century planes to be more attractive than those well made at the beginning of the 19th century, but to each their own.

The eyes on those 18th century planes were pretty doggish and low risk, too.