New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Posts

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#76

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Steve Voigt

Reading Wiley's description again, and looking at online pics of Old Street/ C&W planes, it appears that their wedges are exactly as Dave says, and the exact opposite of what I said. So, I owe Dave an apology for implying that it has to be one way.

I looked at my 19th c. planes again this morning and I do have one that's flatsawn (actually more rift than flat), but all the others are quartersawn as I said before. So, this is an interesting conundrum. Either (A) Larry and Don are going against historical practice (which seems unlikely), or (B) it's "maker's choice" as Dave said, or (C) the norm is flatsawn and by some freaky coincidence all my old users are anomalies. Maybe we should have a poll. :D

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#77

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

david weaver

I'm going to switch to making them quartered. I'm initially resistant to any changes once I've thought something through, but I looked again closer at my wedges this morning (they are all dark, and some have such a coating of old oil or tallow on them that it's difficult to see the grain orientation). Here's what I see scraping things away a little bit.

* Mathiesens (both ) dead quartered

* Baldwin try plane - dead quartered

* griffiths try plane - rift, but closer to quartered than flat

* jt brown jointer (single iron - the rest are double) flat sawn, not perfectly flat sawn, but on the flat sawn side of rift

All of the wedges in all of those planes are a good fit, at least the four I've looked at very closely.

I am obsessed with having the wedge move with the plane, and contrary to my initial very dumb thought, if anything, the quartered would end up tight in the plane if the body shrinks, which isn't really a problem because the iron will force the plane sides to be let out a little bit if the body shrinks to much.

It appeals to me to have the wedge and the iron say the same more than the wedge move exactly with the body.

So I am going to switch to quartered. Of the five long planes I've built, three had wood that was not close enough to dead quartered such that the wedges are bordering on rift, the last two the blanks have been very good and a dead flat sawn wedge results. I'm not going to remake the wedges on them, but I'll send griggs a piece of quartered stock to go with try #2 in case he'd like to make a quartered wedge to go with it. His wedge, as it's perfectly flatsawn, has a cosmetic problem because there is a strip of heart running through the top. You can see it in the picture. It absorbs oil different than sap surrounding it and has a big line running through the top. That'll even out some over time, but I didn't like it when I oiled it!!

It is undeniable that quartered looks better.

Thanks for bringing it up! I'd say I hope you get a few customers from my videos, but I don't know what luck you might have, as the youtube stats suggest that most viewers don't make it very far into each video!! Hopefully, it won't lead a stream of people who want a plane for $75.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#78

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

david weaver

Well, you've convinced me - you know I'm always bullheaded to change anything initially, I have spiked shoes and dig in.

But on the balance of things, I'm going quartered, without a doubt.

The only plane of these types that's ever going to have any fitting problems, is one that doesn't get used. I'm sure either wedge type will work fine.

This is going to sound ridiculous, but I even oriented my wedges so that if they cupped, the cup would not high center on the iron.

Two of my planes were made tightly enough at the bottom of the mouth that they've required a little bit of relief as the blanks have dried. I prefer them tight down there, though, but relief does create a conundrum with the wedge - and that is what was carefully made as a tight fit, as a bit of material is removed from the sides of the planes, the wedge has shrunk the same as the plane and now the wedge is a tiny bit loose. Not really a problem of any practical type, but given the choice, I'd rather the wedge move with the iron laterally (which is to say not at all), because the iron will dictate the tuning of the plane over the years, and if the iron is snug, so, too should the wedge be, including the fit of the fingers into the sides of the plane.

When I chose flat, I also had some concern (though this is an academic concern, just supposition), that one side of the wedge fingers may shrink faster than the others. I think that's not a practical consideration at this point, it would be a matter of a thosuandth or something, and that would get burnished off of the wedges in use - like anything else, if the plane is used I think it stays in tune and improves. If it's not, well, who cares how well a plane would work for someone who doesn't use planes?

It's been instructive - exactly the type of discussion that is nice to have with like minded people.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#79

Re: Wedges are not flatsawn

Steve Voigt

I agree-it's been instructive, and it is nice to have discussions about the nuts and bolts.

I'm still hoping some others will chime in with observations about their 19thc or earlier planes. Between us, it sounds like we have about a dozen old bench planes, which is still not a very big sample size.

FWIW, I'm not going to remake any flatsawn wedges either. Warren's observation about his 20-yr old wedge that still works puts it in perspective, as do his comments about the scale of the work. It seems like on something like a no.4 hollow, you'd really have a danger of twisting if the widest side weren't QS, but on a bench plane it probably doesn't matter.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#80

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

david weaver

Still, the weight is a performance issue.

I do have a physical problem, mild arthritis in my fingers. My elbows, shoulders and wrists don't really hurt from plane work unless something is drastically wrong. A light plane doesn't make them hurt for arthritic reasons, either.

The only place my arthritic fingers cause a problem is in refurbishing (via filing) an old saw that needs tooth correction, or doing a lot of work with the coping saw. The rest of my tools seem to make my hands feel a little better, as long as I don't have a closed clenched grip on something for a long period of time.

A 7 1/2 pound wooden try plane is an entirely different animal on wood than a 7 pound metal jointer, the weight is not felt unless you're holding the plane up by the handle for an extended period of time. On a jointer, the weight and friction surface is apparent if you don't religiously wax the bottom.

The jack preference is just a preference of mine, most jacks are narrower and lighter. I was lucky, based on what I've chosen as a matter of use, to get a 17 inch mathiesen plane with a 2 1/2 inch iron, or I'd have never made the type - most likely. Hanging the closed handle right on the back might be something I wouldn't chance. I wouldn't regard my preference there as much of anything useful, as most jacks are 2-2 1/4" iron planes that are shorter, lighter and have an open handle.

The try plane, though, I think is significant because just about every single try plane is that size and approximate weight. It is the plane where you'll push the hardest when dimensioning the wood (because a jack will often not have a full geometric cut in the shape of a curve with a flat top, but partial cuts as it works over other curves cut it - it's a lazier plane to use), and as much weight and length as you can have without adding any fatigue smooths the process and lets you do more work without the annoying stops at rough spots that beat up elbows and shoulders, etc, and break your rhythm.

I think that it is a general preference, not just of mine, or it would've been easy to make razee type planes to make that type of plane long and light at the same time.

The thing is, so few people are using planes to do dimensioning work that it may be a preference that not many will notice. For me, it's a big one, though. I wouldn't want the try plane lighter, and I wouldn't want to use a jointer all day in its place (like the 28" one I showed).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#81

Re: Widths..

david weaver

That and my early 1800s expertly made jt brown jointer (single iron) is also 2 1/2 inches wide.

I don't agree with any of larry's conclusions about the double iron, but I bought them all hook line and sinker when I first started. I had poorly made planes or poorly fitted that clogged at the corners, it all sounded good.

It took buying a large sample size of planes to extract the ones in good tune and that were well made to find out that those did and do not clog, are not hard to set and are not sloppily made as it is sometimes insisted that most double iron planes are.

That said, I've never heard anyone say they were unhappy with larry's planes, so different strokes for different folks. The argument against the double iron is just wrong, but that doesn't make his single iron planes bad, so I hope nobody is inferring that. There is a bit of a learning curve with the double iron planes, but it's sort of like learning to hit a hook with your driver on a coarse that is hook biased. The yield in scoring FAR outweighs the short amount of time that it takes to learn the skill.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#82

get your semantics straight

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As Wiley pointed out "flat" and "quartered" have no clear meaning for small pieces of wood. A board with growth rings perpendicular to the surface is clearly "quartered" grain. But the terms loose meaning on a 3 x 3 plane body and wedge. A 3 x 3 plane could be authentically made from the edge of a wide flat sawed 3" plank, so the wood source is no clear guide either.

Describing the rings relative to a reference surface is a clear way of communicating. So, in the case of wedges, are the rings parallel or perpendicular to the wedge surface? In the case of my 8 family planes about half are perpendicular and half vertical to the surface of the wedge, and one is at an angle but more parallel then vertical.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#83

Re: Richard Neve

Bob Rozaieski

Yeah, it was just a shot at a source. I've never seen Neve, so was just providing the source as a possible place to check. Oh well.

I have seen narrower planes similar to what OST make in the wild though. Not 18th century by any means, but they do exist. I just made a new jack plane with 1-3/4" wide Sandusky double iron. The old jack plane was junk but the iron was gorgeous. I'm not that happy with the way my jack turned out, so I'll likely remake it using the same iron. I do like the size though.




I also have a small single iron smoother, probably late 19th century (parallel iron, not tapered) that is only about 6-1/2" long and the iron is just under 1-3/4" wide. It's bedded at 55 degrees. It is stamped "Whitmore British Made' on the toe.




Pictured here with a larger (8") double iron English smoother with a 2-1/4" iron at 47½ degrees for size comparison.


Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#84

Re: That single iron.

david weaver

...plane is sort of a strange bird. To have a parallel iron and single at the same time suggests it was a low cost modern plane (circa 1900 or so). The eyes match the machine made style that's on later marples planes.

The jacks I've seen are all over the board. I've got three - one's 2", another 2 1/4 and the third is the 2 1/2" (that some might refer to as a short fore) that I prefer, but is less common than the prior two.

I've had smoothers all over, too, and only concluded that I don't much like the later american coffin smoother offerings. Seasoning had not been kind to them, but the good english planes are unaffected by it. Specifically, the ohio and auburn types of coffin smoothers have been very loosely made, and both of those tapered irons are the only two brands I've ever had disappointing irons. Two from ohio (one branded revonoc) and one auburn thistle iron. Three ohios if you count a metal ohio plane that I had that was junk all the way around.

That said, I've had irons from both (auburn and ohio) that were fine. I've not yet had a bad english iron, older or newer (newer is somewhere between the world wars, no truly new stuff).

Bob, if you can get people motivated to build their own planes, I think it will improve peoples' adventurousness with furniture (because you're then bound only by what you can't build for tools vs. what you can't find in the open market).

I've beat the drum between SMC and youtube now for half a year, and I literally haven't heard from a single person who decided to build a plane. Steve and I already had the bug.

Challenge #1, though, will be getting someone to stock beech billets so that the average person can spend a moderate amount and get a couple. Horizon has the stock, but they are not set up deliver it easily in a shopping cart style. Maybe I can convince them (I doubt it, though, but I'll try).

I can't much see a problem with the jack from the looks of it, looks pretty good to me! But seeing and using are two different things. What is it made from? (sorry if you already specified that and I missed it).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#85

Re: Richard Neve

Kees

Yes sure they exist! You can still buy NOS irons with even narrower dimensions. In the end it is personal preference and weaving theories around such things is probably a dead end street.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#86

Re: That single iron.

Kees

Graham Haydon is making one at the moment. And I am on the fence. Contemplating will I first finish the cabinet or....

After my skiing holliday I'll make a final desision.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#87

Re: get your semantics straight

Steve Voigt

I think QS and FS are appropriate for talking about bench plane wedges, not so much for the planes themselves.

As you indicate, we say a board is QS if the rings are perpendicular to the widest face. So for a wedge that is 2" wide and 11/16" thick (at its thickest point), if the rigs are perpendicular to the 2" face, the wedge is QS.

In retrospect, Wiley's explanation is not unclear; I think I was just in shock that the Old Street/C&W wedges were the complete opposite of what I expected.

That's interesting about your family planes. Another good data point, need more…

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#88

Building planes

Larry Barrett

David - I didn't hear your drumbeat, but did get inspired by Matt Bickford and built these two rabbet planes 3/16 and 5/8. QS beech with QS sycamore for wedges. I have a small amount of QS beech, including one 4x4 chunk long enough for a jack, so watched your video with interest. Thanks for your efforts to lead the way.


Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#89

Re: my drum is small and quiet!!...

david weaver

.. i figured that maybe there would be five people who would want to build a plane of their own, and maybe a couple of more who would think about building double iron planes commercially.

I think the fact that the beech is so hard to find is enough to scare a lot of people away.

Certainly, the bobs and matts of the world have a lot of blog following and can produce a much greater flow of desire!! (and cleaner and more concise instructionals).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#90

Wedge grain orientaion

Paul in NJ

Hi David,

I have been enjoying this discussion, thank you.

I have made a half dozen or so planes. If I have enough stock, I prefer to orientate the wedge exactly the same as the plane body. My thinking is that it will move the same as the plane. I will check my vintage planes planes when I get home to see how they were done.

Sometimes on an old plane or when you make a new wedge the fingers don’t sit tight against the sides. A trick that worked for me several times is to steam bend the fingers of the wedge outward. You wrap the fingers with a little bit of wet rag and aluminum foil. Play the flame from a propane torch on the foil until you generate some steam for a little bit. Unwrap the finger quickly with a gloved hand and gently bend outwards until it cools. Do the same for the other finger. Works like a champ. Worse thing that can happen is that you make a new wedge.

Keep up the good work.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#91

Re: Rabbet planes look good, BTW!!


Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#92

Re: Wedge grain orientaion

david weaver

That's a good idea, paul. Thanks for bringing it up, it's something I hadn't thought of.

I had a wedge on an old plane that was in from the sides, but not drastically, and supposed I might fix it by gluing veneer on the outsides, but that's an ugly fix.

Ultimately, most of the planes that I bought that were decent users with cosmetic issues or wedge fit, I just cut up and took the iron and cap iron set out of them. Something unappealing about spending $20 to ship a plane that's worth about $20.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#93

Photos

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve and all,

Gee, all those words and I neglected to tell you what direction I was looking from!!??

Well, to eliminate further uncertainty, here are some photos I just took of my 2" iron, 26" long, 50-degree try plane. This is a real favorite for edge joining (I like to do one board at a time, not match planing).

This plane is 2006 vintage--marked 2006. Viewed from the rear end, all the grain is horizontal and dead quartered--the stock, the tote, and the wedge. See photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/sets/72157650657669980/

Clark & Williams/Old Street are very particular. I think Warren's words on the subject have a lot of wisdom coupled with long experience.

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#94

Re: Photos

Kees

No doubt about it. They make some very sexy planes!

I looked at my motly collection of wooden planes and the wedges are mostly between rift and qs. Only one is flatsawn, it's a gerf plane, probably early 20th century.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#95

Re: Photos

Steve Voigt

Wiley--your explanation was clear; I just had a theory and was temporarily blinded to any contrary evidence! ;)

Thanks for the pics. I could look at those planes all day, they're just gorgeous.

I notice that they do the same thing Dave mentioned--the rings on the wedge curve away from the bed, so that if they straighten, the high spots will be at the edges, where you want them, and not in the middle, which would presumably render the wedge useless.

Wiley, do you have any pre-20th c. wooden planes? If so, would you mind checking the grain orientation on those?

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#96

Re: Photos

Steve Voigt

Thanks for checking your planes, Kees. My collection is pretty motley too!

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#97

Older planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

One thing that occurs to me, that you might check: If your grain looks vertical, in stock and/or wedge, be sure you're looking at the annual rings, and not the rays. Sometimes the rays are more prominent. Just a thought...

As for older planes, here goes.....

1. Mathieson jack, 17". Looks like horizontal grain, in stock and wedge

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/sets/72157650078973847/

I no longer have this plane, but the photo evidence is good.

2. A. Copeland, Columbus, OH. Boxwood plough from 1840's, very fine-grained. Horizontal grain in stock and wedge.

3. Numerous molding planes, English and American, from early 1800's to late 18 00's. I spot-checked them--the first dozen I looked at all had horizontal grain in stock and wedge.

4. Several plough planes, English and American, generally pre-1900. Take a look at the relevant albums in this Flickr account. They look horizontal grain in stock and wedge, with possible exception that Greenfield may have a rift wedge, but I don't have it in my hands to check:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/sets/72157650078973847/

Hope this helps!

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#98

Re: Older planes

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Thanks very much for checking!

To alleviate any confusion, here is what I mean by QS, or what you are calling (I think!) vertical grain:




Those planes are from 1840s-50s, though I can't be sure about the wedges. The wedge in the top photo has been stripped above the stock.

The wedge on your Mathieson Jack sure looks QS, or vertical grain, to me. The rays on the wide face (in img 1044) are very prominent, and the side view in the first photo looks like plane-sawn beech to me. Can't say for sure though…

I think ploughs/rabbets/moulding planes are a different ball game. On bench planes, the widest dimension is the top/bottom of the wedge, but on side escapements its the sides of the wedge, except for maybe some very wide rabbets or moulding planes.

Anyway, thanks for the photos and discussion!

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#99

Re: Older planes

Steve Voigt

"One thing that occurs to me, that you might check: If your grain looks vertical, in stock and/or wedge, be sure you're looking at the annual rings, and not the rays. Sometimes the rays are more prominent. Just a thought..."

Good point--and I just realized, the one wedge that I thought was flat-sawn, which is also a Mathieson, is actually QS. I was looking at the rays, which are extremely prominent, like the ones in your photo. So, now I am back to saying that all the bench plane wedges I have are QS.

My head hurts from thinking about this. :D

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#100

Re: Older planes

david weaver

That leaves us on 19th century planes, save one single iron plane that's early 19th century, all being quartered.

Larry's planes, or perhaps bill's at the time, notwithstanding (I'm not intending to build any planes like they're building them, though).

Quartered for me from now on. Thanks Steve.