Re: Beech question - weight a minute
david weaver
Still, the weight is a performance issue.
I do have a physical problem, mild arthritis in my fingers. My elbows, shoulders and wrists don't really hurt from plane work unless something is drastically wrong. A light plane doesn't make them hurt for arthritic reasons, either.
The only place my arthritic fingers cause a problem is in refurbishing (via filing) an old saw that needs tooth correction, or doing a lot of work with the coping saw. The rest of my tools seem to make my hands feel a little better, as long as I don't have a closed clenched grip on something for a long period of time.
A 7 1/2 pound wooden try plane is an entirely different animal on wood than a 7 pound metal jointer, the weight is not felt unless you're holding the plane up by the handle for an extended period of time. On a jointer, the weight and friction surface is apparent if you don't religiously wax the bottom.
The jack preference is just a preference of mine, most jacks are narrower and lighter. I was lucky, based on what I've chosen as a matter of use, to get a 17 inch mathiesen plane with a 2 1/2 inch iron, or I'd have never made the type - most likely. Hanging the closed handle right on the back might be something I wouldn't chance. I wouldn't regard my preference there as much of anything useful, as most jacks are 2-2 1/4" iron planes that are shorter, lighter and have an open handle.
The try plane, though, I think is significant because just about every single try plane is that size and approximate weight. It is the plane where you'll push the hardest when dimensioning the wood (because a jack will often not have a full geometric cut in the shape of a curve with a flat top, but partial cuts as it works over other curves cut it - it's a lazier plane to use), and as much weight and length as you can have without adding any fatigue smooths the process and lets you do more work without the annoying stops at rough spots that beat up elbows and shoulders, etc, and break your rhythm.
I think that it is a general preference, not just of mine, or it would've been easy to make razee type planes to make that type of plane long and light at the same time.
The thing is, so few people are using planes to do dimensioning work that it may be a preference that not many will notice. For me, it's a big one, though. I wouldn't want the try plane lighter, and I wouldn't want to use a jointer all day in its place (like the 28" one I showed).