New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Posts

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

David Weaver's wooden and infill planes are delightful to behold and read about. I recommend that people head on over there to have a look...

Thanks for posting your work, David.

Ellis


David's gallery

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#2

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David

david weaver

Thanks for the kind words, Ellis.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#3

Yes!  And..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I'm really impressed with the beautiful beech blocks he managed to obtain. That Try Plane #2 and the large Jack both have wonderful blocks. Maybe they all do--I was only able to make out the end grain on those two.

I have a question of David. I wonder if David prefers the 2-1/2" width for all uses? I love the long woodies, and prefer a narrower plane, like 2" or so for edge joining.

Any thoughts on plane width for various uses--scrub, jack, fore, try, jointer...?

Wiley

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#4

They look great!

John in NM

Of course I'm a sucker for cocobolo too!

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#5

Re: Yes!  And..

david weaver

Good eye on the wood. The jointer and the first try plane came from billets from a generous person on another forum (prashun patel) who mentioned that he'd gotten beech from horizon to use as bench legs, but he'd be willing to sell it to me given my enthusiasm at the time. i wasn't sure how these planes were going to come out, I just know I was going to build planes until i got some I liked. they are not quite as ideal as the later billets, but they are plenty close to make beautiful planes - and I don't need to make another jointer or try plane for myself. I think the closed handle jack may have come from prashun's stock that he gave me, too.

Two more try planes (including the second one in that spread), I made for other people and they are from wood that I got myself from horizon. I had the chance to be very specific with them on the phone, and almost everything I got is like that. I got 60 bd feet of it, and it was a bit pricey (about $16 a bd foot when shipped), but it is easily worth the price to me. I asked them for wood away from the pith but sawn with the pith as on center in the cut as possible, and that's what they gave me.

As far as the iron sizes, I don't use much softwood, but I use a lot of cherry when I do build something, (which admittedly can be intermittent). Sometimes oak, walnut, and maple, and of course I used the planes to spawn more (it's surprising how fast it is to size the beech billets with a try plane, vs. a metal plane). So hardness wise, I guess that's mostly cherry through beech, and 2 1/2 inches is a size I can comfortably handle, as well as being large enough to match plane stuff that's a little over 4/4 rough to make panels.

I hadn't used a wide jack plane (where it's of little consequence other than allowing you to build a heavier jack plane because of the width allowing for a wider and taller billet) until I got a hold of a matiesen closed handle jack that's a lot like the closed handle jack there. I really don't know where the line is for jack and fore, but I know that there is about 1 1/2 to 2 pounds more jack in the closed handle jack than there is in a 2" jack, but it doesn't feel onerous using a 5 1/2 pound jack plane.

The jointer is 9 1/2 pounds or something, maybe 10? Despite being wood, it will wear you out when edge jointing. It's a plane I probably won't use much, but it's hard to find good 28" jointers that aren't a later cheaply made plane, so it was the first thing I wanted to make. I'm kind of glad I made it first, because it's aesthetically the worst because of it, and it has an iron in it that was already fairly well used. Using it tells us why there are a lot of 24" try planes (that can really do anything a skilled user needs to do edge or face jointing) and not nearly as many 28" jointers. The try plane is about 2-2 1/2 pounds less, but what a difference it makes in fatigue.

Anyway, that doesn't very precisely say anything about the width, but I guess, yes for right now I like 2 1/2" for everything except smoothing, for the big planes because it allows a lot of real estate to be covered (though a cherry shaving that is flat and approaching a hundredth thick does take a lot of thrust), and for the jack it allows the weight to be increased and it's up to the discretion of the user as to how much blade width will be used. I like the closed handle on the jack, too, because I can't feel it springing in a heavy cut. I guess I'm a bit harsh on the planes, in terms of trying to take as heavy of a cut as I can without it being a struggling cut. I suppose it's all a preference that's come out of use because I've turned through about two dozen wooden planes, four infills, a bunch of japanese planes, and this is what I've settled on - this style, size, weight, handle shape, type of steel, type of sharpening stones.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#6

Re: They look great!

david weaver

Thanks, John. I didn't notice that the cocobolo smoother was covered with as much dust as it is. it's a bit dry looking. It was -10 here last week, and the coco smoother is already checking even though it was made earlier this year with a billet that has been drying for 5 years.

I like its weight for a smoother, it's nice, but it's hard to find big quartersawn cocobolo, especially if you don't have time to wait for it to dry, and it's subject to cracking with swings in humidity, even if it's properly dry. So....it's a pain!!

I'll clean the dust off and retake the pictures this weekend if I can remember. All of the planes are just a little bit dirty from use.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#7

Re: They look great!

John in NM

I feel for you on the checking. Surprising that it still checks after that long drying. Of course, if it's not going to affect the use, it's really no big deal, just annoying.

I bought a chunk of mesquite recently and cut it up into stock blanks, only to see it checking within a week. Metered it and was absolutely appalled to see it +25%. Vendor and I had some words over it, and he offered a refund, but in the end it's either something I can work around or some really expensive firewood. If I took the refund it would just be really expensive firewood in another spot. I think he thought I was nuts, but someone who loves wood and hates waste would get it.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#8

Horizon?

John in NM

Never heard of them... looks like a decent outfit by first glance at their website.

Is the beech domestic or steamed Euro? I use Euro fairly often but have never seen anything over 8/4 for sale. I pay something like $5 a foot for that.....

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#9

Re: They look great!

david weaver

I've gotten wood like you describe, where people say it was dried and then it's wet enough that you can *feel* it. It's as if they dried it in pensacola or something.

Cocobolo is just really badly behaved. I used to wonder why a lot of the old rosewood planes are cracked, but I don't have to wonder any longer, just changing acclimation can lead to deep checking. This coco plane will probably probably end up in a bath of raw linseed oil to get soaked, but not sure.

Beech does the same thing. Horizon kiln dried my beech, and I can tell by the weight that it's dry dry, but if it's subzero over night two nights in a row, the air in my garage gets dry enough that it still checks some. Thankfully, steve voigt warned me of that early on, and told me to check my pile, and sure enough it had some light checking on the ends before it was even that cold. There aren't too many old planes that don't have a check or two in them, unless they're made of something other than beech, or are encased in lacquer.

It's cosmetic on cocobolo, though, it still is a nice smoother compared to a beech coffin smoother, at about a pound heavier than it would've otherwise been (still only 3 and something pounds - it's my opinion that beech isn't ideal for a smoother, there's just not enough wood there to make the wanted mass).

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#10

Re: Horizon?

david weaver

It's american, kiln dried. 16/4, sawn straight and with no cracks. It's almost unseen anywhere, and as the contact there described to me, they are making it almost out of guilt (paraphrasing what he said), because they know a few people want it, but nobody else markets it.

They are an old school dealer, they deal by phone, show you pictures of what you're getting and then ship only after a lot of back and forth - lots of person to person contact in what is otherwise a shopping cart and paypal transaction completion world.

4/4 and 8/4 are pretty common (not common like cherry, but you can find them) quartersawn, but what you want to make bench planes is very specific and not found many places. I will probably buy another pallet from them when they come into more, but it'll be more than $16 a foot shipped on the next batch according to them.

IIRC, the kiln schedule is several multiples longer than 8/4 or 4/4, so I guess it ties up the kiln for a long time.

I couldn't count on one hand how many people have told me they could've gotten it for $5 a board foot (the "you're a stupid fool and easily parted with your money implication), but nobody yet has come up with a source that has wood similar to that you see on my planes. It usually ends with "well, I found flatsawn and you could just laminate it". that's obviously something I can't live with, and nobody should if they're trying to make a plane that will outlive them. Nothing wrong with glued together planes, but it's just not the kind of thing we're going for here.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#11

Is this the same bunch? *LINK*

John in NM

The old school, deal by phone comment has me wondering if I found the right place.

All the $5 beech I've seen is flat sawn Euro stuff. Must be incredibly cheap over there if they can ship it here and sell it for that. The red oak of Europe perhaps?

I know what you mean about not laminating. Some stuff you prefer solid wood even if the difference is nothing but aesthetics.


http://www.horizonevolutions.com/unique-item-month.html

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#12

Re: They look great!

John in NM

One thing to consider, at least as a trial, is stabilizing. They put the wood in a resin bath and pull a vacuum for a while, then bake it to cure the resin. I have to do that to burl parts when I go and make them against my better judgement.

You end up with a crusty skin of resin, so that would have to be removed from critical areas of the plane, like the bed, wedge mortises, and sole, but it does scrap off easy enough. Doesn't do tools any good, but it comes off. That prevents much of the shrink and swell with moisture changes, and makes the wood heavier - could be just what you need for a beech smoother.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#13

Re: Is this the same bunch?

david weaver

That's them. They're somewhat local to me.

A guy here named Mike Digity used to cut and sell a lot of 4/4, 5/4 and 8/4 quartersawn beech for cheap (kiln dried) and I have a bunch of it. That's what's in my plane handles so that I don't have to cut up a 16/4 billet to get plane handles out of it.

Mike said he's sold stuff to horizon (I would interpret that to mean he's sold logs or cut wet lumber to them to finish).

Unfortunately, Mike retired (for the most part), and he lives and worked right in the middle of a LOT of beech trees in southern ohio.

I don't think he had a lot of luck drying 16/4 as a lot of his billets had checks in them, or maybe he sold all of his good stuff to larry and don, and (can't remember the name of the other maker in new england).

Anyway, beech in europe is a utility wood. They've dumped it by the ship full on the US market at least once and screwed up our markets. I don't know about 16/4 stuff, though. I've worked a little of both and the steamed euro beech I worked wasn't quite as nice to me as american beech. It was very even, but less buttery feeling.

Beech trees aren't uncommon in part of the states here, but there's no great market for high grade clear large billets.

I asked that question of Rick Hearne, and he wrinkled his nose and said "utility wood".

I've harassed a lot of different people looking for something affordable for tools, and I don't have a great answer. Horizon is hard to order from if you just want a piece or two, it takes a little while to get a hold of them, but as good as their stock is, I don't care what they ask (within reason) if nobody else pops up. I will probably drive there next time I order, though. It cost $140 to get 60 board feet of wood delivered 120 miles away, because that's just what freight costs.

I've given up on trying to find good tropical wood for smoothers, it just isn't out there available and dry without given up an arm or leg. I don't really need more of anything, anyway. Eventually, I'll have to figure out what to do with the planes I'm making, I just don't have the interest in trying to run a business doing it, and the planes themselves are already more in materials than a decent used wooden plane costs. I can find good planes cheaper than I can build them for myself.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#14

Utility...

John in NM

I would suspect that it's largely a matter of institutional prejudice, beech seems to be considered junk wood here due to drying difficulty and tendency to be unstable. I've heard that steaming works on Euro beech due to it being a different species.... maaaaybe.... I'm pretty skeptical of that, but it could be possible. More lignin to relax or something....

I think it is pretty wood, if plain. I like it better than red oak.

I remember some of my grandmother's 1950's factory furniture has beech drawer sides. I doubt very much it was imported from Europe, so some of the NC factories must have had domestic sources of stable beech.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#15

Plane wood comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

there is indeed a cheap and seemingly easy source for plane wood. I works for the chair makers. Buy logs and rive out the blanks. The resulting blanks will be quick to dry. If I wasn't in retirement mode and persons were willing to pay $16/bd/ft for it I would be harvesting it with enthusiasm. Much better $$$/hour than cutting beech firewood.

Everyone in the East lives near a saw mill, and therefore loggers. Ask your local forester for names of local loggers. Ask them to harvest you a beech log or two an buck it into plane sized lengths at the loading site. Personally I would saw the blanks out with a chain saw using a modern chisel tooth pattern chain. I could cut out a blank in about a minute. Or split them out.

There is no market for beech lumber. I have never seen it sawed in this area (except). Occasionally there will be demand for rail ties and beech is an accepted species for this purpose. It is currently in demand for ties and logs are selling for $450/1000 bdft. I burn two large trees worth of it each year, enough to supply one with a lifetime of plane blanks. It is not uncommon to encounter large beech in previously harvested forests. It is usually just left behind if the tie market is not available. I'm trying to be rid of it in my woodlands.

European beech is steamed to make it easier to dry straight. These are plantation trees with a high yield of high grade lumber. There is no reason that the same could not be practiced here if there was a market. But we have too many other more easy to deal with and attractive woods. If your country only grows beech you learn to live with it.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#16

Beech question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is beech used for planes because that is all that was available in Europe and the habit crossed the Atlantic. Or does it have some property that makes it really better? What is used in Asia?

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#17

Re: Plane wood comments

david weaver

I think the value in the beech isn't in the wet lumber itself, I'd expect to get that cheaply, too, because it would have to dry for four years and I'd have to follow it around.

I think the price for the wood when I got it was $13.50 a foot, and there is literally no part of any billet that I got that isn't similar to what's in the pictures I showed here.

The skill is in drying it and getting it to me crack and check free, and to some extent sawing it as cleanly as they sawed it (of course, I don't know if they just instead selected the nicely sawn stuff for me, but that's only probably partly true because I got some of the last of what was there of this batch).

As far as getting wet lumber, I think I know a couple of folks around here who might be able to get it for me, but if they wanted more than a couple of bucks a board foot, I'd rather just buy it dried.

Mike digity had sold me a fair bit of 8/4 for about $6 a foot, and the last pile of about 75 feet of 5/4 and 4/4 for $3.25 (that was a sale deal though because it was literally the last he had and I asked for soft maple for drawer sides, and he said he only had QS beech left in terms of light colored woods). Of course, I don't have the heart to turn that into drawer sides for my kitchen cabinets, so it lays in my shop waiting to be used for something more valuable, like moulding planes and the handles in these bench planes.

Anyway, I think you wouldn't sell much unless you could get it dried and defect free, and IIRC,the kiln schedule for it is something like a month. And it has to be partially air dried first. Even at that, I'll bet a lot is thrown out.

As far as I know, larry dries his own. I just can't recall the name of the moulding plane maker in CT, but I have no clue what he does. I do know he started with cherry moulding planes, and while it makes an OK but very light and soft feeling moulding plane, I wouldn't use it, let alone buy something made of it. It wasn't a surprise when he went to offering beech. (I say that having made my first pair of moulding planes out of QS cherry because I hadn't yet found beech).

I don't know if horizon sells smaller wood, but if they do, I'd imagine it would be at a fraction of 13.50 a foot plus freight, because it's a lot quicker and easier to do it.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#18

Re: Beech question

david weaver

I can only give you my opinion, and i know larry is going to be offended when I say this, but larry likes to use big words and make big explanations of everything and it's really not necessary when talking about why beech is ideal for a planemaker. And here's why.

It's the right density for jacks, try and jointer planes. Look across the range of any well established planes and you'll find jacks in the 4-5 1/2 pound range, short jointers in the 7 pound range and the largest jointers offered in the 9-10 pound range. That is what beech makes in a bench plane.

It works well by hand and when carving, it allows itself to be removed predictably. It's got a dead non-musical feel to it (as opposed to something like a rosewood plane that is very loud and tinky), the right amount of grab of the iron both on the bed and with the wedge, reasonable hardness for a wood of its density, it doesn't splinter easily, both the sap and the heart are suitable for a plane (including when both are on the same plane).

I really can't find any shortcoming of it for planes, and the only wood I have ever worked that is nicer for them is air dried apple, and we've talked about that before - any quantity of that that is quartered and straight is a rare bird.

I've seen videos of people in southern ohio bucking beech trees that were deemed firewood fodder that were 42 - 48 inches in diameter at the trunk.

The other possible woods that are in the same density range:

* white oak - splinters more easily, not as nice to work, more musical (not a desirable trait)

* red oak, same, garishly porous

* hard maple - the right density, but more dry and hard feeling when working, doesn't carve as nice around the abutments and eyes and splinters more, both at the mouth, on the handle and for all of the carved elements

I hear birch and pear woods of various types are nice, but the density to me is important. The user of a try plane like I've made is going to be dissatisfied with the plane if it weighs 6 pounds, and dissatisfied if it weighs 10 (which it would with tropical woods).

As far as the chinese go, they've got a whole range of woods that don't mean anything to us. Shungee rosewood is a popular one, it looks a little like bubinga or padauk, and must be inexpensive because they use a lot of it. There are also light white oak colored woods, and they have a range of ebonies. I've only had shungee and some of their ebonies (which look a bit like macassar and are very smooth). All are very musical, dense and hard. Their planes are different, so it's hard to compare. they have a very simple wedge and a very short wear, and the mortise isn't tall, so working with a wood like that isn't such a big deal. They also make smaller planes, and any density they can get is probably seen as a bonus.

Obviously, I don't have a problem with cocobolo, as you can see in the gallery, but it is not nearly as convenient to make a plane from, it's extremely musical, the eyes have to be cut across the grain instead of with it, and the maker had do most of the fitting work with a scraping tool instead of a chisel. I wouldn't want a large plane made of cocobolo or some other type of rosewood or ebony, the density isn't right and it would be a loud plane to use, possibly over 85db loud.

A lot of this stuff is all just opinion of mine, and beech does have a well deserved reputation for being very poorly behaved when it dries or changes humidity and temperature. I think, based on what I've seen with old planes, when billet of beech comes from a straight tree and is sawn with the pith on center like mine is, there is nothing going on but shrinkage. If it is sawn with the pith off center it will move even after it's dried ,and it's a pain. There are cheap old planes made of so-so stock that have a lot of twist in them, i'm convinced because they lowered their standards on the wood. I have some 8/4 that is sawn off center, and without fail, it twists and untwists itself with changes in humidity.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#19

Re: Beech question

Steve Voigt

I haven't noticed that Larry uses a lot of big words; he seems pretty plain-spoke to me. Not that there's anything wrong with big words; I never met one I didn't like.

Anyway, I personally think his article, aptly titled "why make planes from beech," is an excellent resource:

http://planemaker.com/articles_beech.html

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#20

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

TomD

I think the claim in Larry's article that it dries differently than some other woods is proven in my shop. I had a 5x18 inch thick 7 foot piece standing like a person in my shop for about half a year after I cut it, and I went to move it one day, and it was dry. By which I mean A) I could tell by the weight it was all but dry; and B) for a bench top it could have been used. Probably not dead nuts dry, but I have dried a lot of wood and this stuff was well on the way. 5 inches! My drying conditions are unheated shop on the edge of lake Ontario.

I found the stuff a little harder to not end up ruined at first, possibly because it dries so fast. Another time I would know what to do, and I lost virtually none of it, so I don't think that is a cost factor.

I have had my load of wood drying since I think 09, it is more than ready. For myself I would use it without a qualm after 2 years, I wouldn't probably sell a plane from that periods, but I have wood sitting around now for 30 years, and it isn't all that noticeably different than when it first dried.

David has said a number of things about beech that I agree with about it's weight or it's working or musical character. I think another way of putting it is that it is possibly the lightest wood you can find that serves the purpose. I am contrarian to the extent that I think and have said here for years, that mostly only bad planes rely on weight for their performance. There may be some very heavy, very good planes out there, tons of them, but the weight should not be, or at least, need not be, the key. We have probably moved a little more in my direction on this point with the whole breaker thing. Many see this with new eyes and find this one addition makes planes work very much better for them. It isn't the weight. As far as heavier woods like rosewood are concerned, you can make the plane using that wood very thin, so that the weight is much lighter, I think that is the way Larry's Jack is in the H&R tape. Technically it is possible to use beech that thin also, the real limit is how much material you need to make a plane and it gets pretty dicey when you go thinner than maybe 1.25 inches.

So stability is important, and structure is important, you can split a plane that uses a wedge. The wedge is set much harder in Japanese planes, and beech holds up well enough in that use. Strong stable, the rest is gravy.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#21

Re: Beech question - weight a minute

Kees

A large part why so many tools in Europe were made from beech is of course the plentyfull availibility. Oak is even more available, but oak is a treasured wood for nice stuff.

Beech dries fast, but still planemakers would wait 3 to 4 years before using it. I think they want to get a couple of dry-wet cycles to the wood to get a bit of hysteresis effect.

Other popular woodspecies where hornbeam, especiallin Germany and Austria. Until they couln't find enough thick billets anymore. After that they used hornbeam for the planesole.

In France they have been using "servicetree". A very good wood for planes, but also suspectible for worm damage.

Both hornbeam and servicetree are heavier and harder then beech.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#22

drying not as slow as you are assuming

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The drying rate out the end of wood is about 10X the radial rate. I can dry 24 to 28" beech firewood logs to something under 20% in 5 months. I have no doubt that 3 x 3 x 3' (to take an example) blanks would dry to useable moisture content in a year or less.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#23

Re: Beech question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Beech is good for the maker and the user.

The most important thing is what David called the deadness of the wood. I have used the term at least thirty years; it refers to how the wood absorbs shock. Because of this quality the wedging action of a beech plane is superb. A beech plane with a well adjusted wedge that is used day after day, year after year, is just really easy to work with. A tap here the iron retracts, a tap there the iron advances. A wood that is not so dead needs to be hit harder to secure the wedge and then does not adjust so easily.

Also because of the deadness, the plane absorbs shock while you are planing so the whole thing is easier on your hands, arms, body. It is like the difference between walking on packed dirt or concrete. Walk a quarter mile and there is not much difference, but walk 15 miles or walk every day and your body will notice the difference. If you use a dogwood mallet to hit a boxwood handled chisel on some very hard wood resting on a hard maple bench standing on concrete, the only thing to absorb shock is your body. Some beech in the chain is helpful.

Beech is also a joy for the maker to work with, as others have noted. I would use beech even if I could not get quartered material, even if it had defects or small cracks, even if I was unsure of the seasoning.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#24

makes sense

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

thanks for the discussion. Yellow birch must have some non-apparent drawback. Perhaps the most obvious is its limited range for trees with good growth habit.

I know what you mean about the "brittle" nature of maple. This feature seems to vary with where it grows (probably climate). We used to get maple for some mill in VA and it was pleasant to plane for customers. Other sources could behave less well. My notion of these differences were confirmed by a furniture factory manager.

Re: Awesome work in Gallery, David *LINK*

#25

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the turners are learning some things about drying large chunks without defects. A locally popular approach is to submerge the wood in ethanol. The ethanol exchanges with the water rapidly, and then leaves the wood rapidly. Why this rapidity doesn't lead to splits becomes an interesting question. A local cellulose expert had some speculation for the reason. I don't recall the speculation, but it made sense at the time.

If I was faced with sourcing beech for planes I would evaluate boiling/steaming the blanks for a while before drying.

And then there is vacuum drying, entirely practical for something like a plane blank, and quick.

The bottom line is that the relatively tiny pieces of wood used for planes can be quick to dry where as 16/4 planks are definitely not.