Re: Beech question
david weaver
I can only give you my opinion, and i know larry is going to be offended when I say this, but larry likes to use big words and make big explanations of everything and it's really not necessary when talking about why beech is ideal for a planemaker. And here's why.
It's the right density for jacks, try and jointer planes. Look across the range of any well established planes and you'll find jacks in the 4-5 1/2 pound range, short jointers in the 7 pound range and the largest jointers offered in the 9-10 pound range. That is what beech makes in a bench plane.
It works well by hand and when carving, it allows itself to be removed predictably. It's got a dead non-musical feel to it (as opposed to something like a rosewood plane that is very loud and tinky), the right amount of grab of the iron both on the bed and with the wedge, reasonable hardness for a wood of its density, it doesn't splinter easily, both the sap and the heart are suitable for a plane (including when both are on the same plane).
I really can't find any shortcoming of it for planes, and the only wood I have ever worked that is nicer for them is air dried apple, and we've talked about that before - any quantity of that that is quartered and straight is a rare bird.
I've seen videos of people in southern ohio bucking beech trees that were deemed firewood fodder that were 42 - 48 inches in diameter at the trunk.
The other possible woods that are in the same density range:
* white oak - splinters more easily, not as nice to work, more musical (not a desirable trait)
* red oak, same, garishly porous
* hard maple - the right density, but more dry and hard feeling when working, doesn't carve as nice around the abutments and eyes and splinters more, both at the mouth, on the handle and for all of the carved elements
I hear birch and pear woods of various types are nice, but the density to me is important. The user of a try plane like I've made is going to be dissatisfied with the plane if it weighs 6 pounds, and dissatisfied if it weighs 10 (which it would with tropical woods).
As far as the chinese go, they've got a whole range of woods that don't mean anything to us. Shungee rosewood is a popular one, it looks a little like bubinga or padauk, and must be inexpensive because they use a lot of it. There are also light white oak colored woods, and they have a range of ebonies. I've only had shungee and some of their ebonies (which look a bit like macassar and are very smooth). All are very musical, dense and hard. Their planes are different, so it's hard to compare. they have a very simple wedge and a very short wear, and the mortise isn't tall, so working with a wood like that isn't such a big deal. They also make smaller planes, and any density they can get is probably seen as a bonus.
Obviously, I don't have a problem with cocobolo, as you can see in the gallery, but it is not nearly as convenient to make a plane from, it's extremely musical, the eyes have to be cut across the grain instead of with it, and the maker had do most of the fitting work with a scraping tool instead of a chisel. I wouldn't want a large plane made of cocobolo or some other type of rosewood or ebony, the density isn't right and it would be a loud plane to use, possibly over 85db loud.
A lot of this stuff is all just opinion of mine, and beech does have a well deserved reputation for being very poorly behaved when it dries or changes humidity and temperature. I think, based on what I've seen with old planes, when billet of beech comes from a straight tree and is sawn with the pith on center like mine is, there is nothing going on but shrinkage. If it is sawn with the pith off center it will move even after it's dried ,and it's a pain. There are cheap old planes made of so-so stock that have a lot of twist in them, i'm convinced because they lowered their standards on the wood. I have some 8/4 that is sawn off center, and without fail, it twists and untwists itself with changes in humidity.