Re: Reflections
TomD
"I estimate that the build required about 175 working hours. I am not sure if that is long or short by the standards of others."
That is long, but has anyone else even done this? You did it by hand, and while you copied a design, I do a fair bit of that kind of thing for technical stuff, like making a boat I want to build and not buy. It is hard in it's own way to do a reverse engineering job, and in this case you had to make you own technical path. I always say if it works, it is someone else's success (the design not the workmanship), but if it fails it is my fault. While doubtless you can achieve a more sensible state, it sometimes feels hard to be all that happy either way. Your technical challenge was often in areas that machines would have made trivial, most notably the fishtail splice was configured for it's simplicity of manufacture, and yet was a huge technical challenge by hand.
"This has been my most complex build to date. Woodwork is really about sawing or chiseling to a line. That is the easy part once the basics are mastered. The hard part has been figuring where the lines go. Even with a model in front of me the compound curves looked daunting to measure and reproduce. Learning to break down components, recognise where a line begins and ends, and how much waste to leave ... all that was a constant headache."
It is a skill like anything else, and gets a lot easier with practice. There is a lot more of it in other stuff than furniture, chairs being one exceptional area. A lot of our furniture in rectilinear, and therefore presents few interesting problems as in boats, or planes, or even timber work. I would say it is my favourite part of working, the thinking through the plan in 3d.
" I cannot say that this was a relaxing project as there were very few times where I was working within myself. Everything seemed a risk, especially the fact that I did not have any backup wood. Is that not what David Pye was referring to?"
I don't think so. I think for the most part he was dividing work into stuff that was creatively risky like a doodle on paper, vs something creatively simple, like drawing a grid. While a great doodle must be demanding, in that there is some magic there, so don't the line have to be in the right place? Yet if a line were slightly off, it might add to character. But the grid needs to be perfect, and every line the same width, and weight. It is difficult to do a great job, but creatively must be pretty close to the zero. If you spill ink on the grid and ruin it, does that mean it was workmanship of risk. I don't think so.
In essence, your job was a copy, so it would seem that there was little risk. But in fact, doing that kind of thing, particularly on a one off, there normally is a lot of risk because you have to judge shapes, as they develop. I often find the first pieces are too heavy. You might remove one too many spokeshave cuts, and ruin an effect. Even though it is a copy, it is not always clear what it is you are looking at. We all think we know where stuff is. But it isn't so easy when you actually have to produce it. All of sudden what you thought you knew intimately turns out to be only the roughest sense, and that continues even if you have a piece in front of you. If one has ever drawn a human form, at the outset, despite having lived with bodies all one's life, it is often difficult to know what one is to draw. One may lack the control, but even looking directly at a model, still not know where the parts go.