New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

The Chair is finished

Posts

The Chair is finished

#1

The Chair is finished

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The seat has been woven and now the chair is complete.

For those interested in the weaving process, details are included in the final chapter: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/WeavingSeatCompletingTheChair.html

For now, I present the final pictures ..




A comparison with the original chair … I think the weaving creates a lighter feeling. What do you think?


Thank you all for your support and encouragement along this journey.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair is finished

#2

Re: The Chair is finished

roger lance

Derek.....I can only express praise....great work....inspirational....masterful....you have more than met the challenge....you are certainly operating at a very high level....congratulations!!

Re: The Chair is finished

#3

Fabulous!

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

In contrast, the original with the black seat looks "ordinary" and like a piece of office furniture. The woven seat not only makes the chair seem "lighter" but more exotic and interesting. It becomes a "that-would-look-NICE-in-my-house" chair. You must feel great and very proud of this accomplishment. You should! And you should win some kind of award when you take it to the show. Can't wait to hear about that experience. Thank you so much for taking us all on this journey.

Re: The Chair is finished

#4

Re: Fabulous!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joanne

A comment on competitions.

Competitions are a different world, so I have discovered. The judges do not seem to score points on the basis of the level of difficulty, whether one used handtools instead of power tools, or the aesthetic merits. They seem to judge on the level of perfection. Last year I submitted a kist which involved matching curly figured board, masses of perfectly executed through dovetails, and drawer hidden in the base skirting. They barely commented and instead pointed out that a part of one breadboard was higher than the surrounding top when you ran your finger along it!

I'd love to do well in the competition, but it is not possible when there are entrants who spend all year building a single piece just for this time of the year.

Thanks for the very kind words. They make it worth all the effort. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair is finished

#5

Re: Fabulous!

Steve Voigt

Derek, congratulations. The finished chair is beautiful. It was a worthy and ambitious project, and the wealth of documentation is a valuable resource.

Re: The Chair is finished

#6

Re: The Chair is finished

BrianMonumentCO

Based solely on the pix, I like your version better.

Well Done !

Re: The Chair is finished

#7

Re: The Chair is finished

Sgian Dubh

Excellent work Derek. Hard won, but you got there in the end, and I've long had a fondness for the form of Wegner's chair. Slainte.

Re: The Chair is finished

#9

Re: The Chair is finished

chuck

Derek-

Top notch work. Thank you for the detailed writing about the build. I noticed that the first post about the chair was on the first day of this year and you finished it up 200 plus days later. I especially enjoyed the arm to back joinery. Your indepth description was enlightening about the complexity and difficulties you overcame. The results are outstanding. Your work and the wood make me prefer your copy to the original that you showed in your first post. But I like the weaving on the chair that you showed in that first post better than what you did on your chair. On yours the front and the back of the seat seem incomplete to my eye.

chuck

Re: The Chair is finished

#10

Reflections

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I noticed that the first post about the chair was on the first day of this year and you finished it up 200 plus days later.

About the time expended - I began working on the chair January 1st this year. Obviously I began thinking about it, planning my plan, obsessing and scheming long before this. How does one factor planning into build time?

I had leave from work in January. I specialise in the paediatric area and kids are on school holidays then, and no one wants to see me :( ... so I take off the time for vacation :) We do quite a bit of travelling and it was a pleasure to stay home, enjoy the beach and sun, and have a few hours every day in the shop. I was able to put in 3-4 hours every day for 4 weeks. That is why there was so much progress at the start.

Came the last week of January, and I was back in my practice, and once again left time on weekends for the build. Most weekends I can get about 4-5 hours each day (unless family arrangements are made first, which they were not in February).

Then came a long break until July, where I once again managed weekends.

I estimate that the build required about 175 working hours. I am not sure if that is long or short by the standards of others. What this does not take into account was the thinking (planning, scheming, obsessing ... ) that went on during the week, and so that on the weekend I was pretty focussed with what needed to be done. The time in the shop was not wasted.

This has been my most complex build to date. Woodwork is really about sawing or chiseling to a line. That is the easy part once the basics are mastered. The hard part has been figuring where the lines go. Even with a model in front of me the compound curves looked daunting to measure and reproduce. Learning to break down components, recognise where a line begins and ends, and how much waste to leave ... all that was a constant headache. I cannot say that this was a relaxing project as there were very few times where I was working within myself. Everything seemed a risk, especially the fact that I did not have any backup wood. Is that not what David Pye was referring to?

The end of the build was a race to finish to get it to the woodshow. It is really unimportant to me how it places in a competition. The judges cannot place the kind of value on this chair that you have done here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair is finished

#11

Re: The Chair is finished

TomD

The weaving, at least as pictured, is a huge improvement, and certainly a very popular seating for the time. Superb result, you must be pleased. Just 3 more to go?

Re: The Chair is finished

#12

Re: Reflections

TomD

"I estimate that the build required about 175 working hours. I am not sure if that is long or short by the standards of others."

That is long, but has anyone else even done this? You did it by hand, and while you copied a design, I do a fair bit of that kind of thing for technical stuff, like making a boat I want to build and not buy. It is hard in it's own way to do a reverse engineering job, and in this case you had to make you own technical path. I always say if it works, it is someone else's success (the design not the workmanship), but if it fails it is my fault. While doubtless you can achieve a more sensible state, it sometimes feels hard to be all that happy either way. Your technical challenge was often in areas that machines would have made trivial, most notably the fishtail splice was configured for it's simplicity of manufacture, and yet was a huge technical challenge by hand.

"This has been my most complex build to date. Woodwork is really about sawing or chiseling to a line. That is the easy part once the basics are mastered. The hard part has been figuring where the lines go. Even with a model in front of me the compound curves looked daunting to measure and reproduce. Learning to break down components, recognise where a line begins and ends, and how much waste to leave ... all that was a constant headache."

It is a skill like anything else, and gets a lot easier with practice. There is a lot more of it in other stuff than furniture, chairs being one exceptional area. A lot of our furniture in rectilinear, and therefore presents few interesting problems as in boats, or planes, or even timber work. I would say it is my favourite part of working, the thinking through the plan in 3d.

" I cannot say that this was a relaxing project as there were very few times where I was working within myself. Everything seemed a risk, especially the fact that I did not have any backup wood. Is that not what David Pye was referring to?"

I don't think so. I think for the most part he was dividing work into stuff that was creatively risky like a doodle on paper, vs something creatively simple, like drawing a grid. While a great doodle must be demanding, in that there is some magic there, so don't the line have to be in the right place? Yet if a line were slightly off, it might add to character. But the grid needs to be perfect, and every line the same width, and weight. It is difficult to do a great job, but creatively must be pretty close to the zero. If you spill ink on the grid and ruin it, does that mean it was workmanship of risk. I don't think so.

In essence, your job was a copy, so it would seem that there was little risk. But in fact, doing that kind of thing, particularly on a one off, there normally is a lot of risk because you have to judge shapes, as they develop. I often find the first pieces are too heavy. You might remove one too many spokeshave cuts, and ruin an effect. Even though it is a copy, it is not always clear what it is you are looking at. We all think we know where stuff is. But it isn't so easy when you actually have to produce it. All of sudden what you thought you knew intimately turns out to be only the roughest sense, and that continues even if you have a piece in front of you. If one has ever drawn a human form, at the outset, despite having lived with bodies all one's life, it is often difficult to know what one is to draw. One may lack the control, but even looking directly at a model, still not know where the parts go.

Re: The Chair is finished

#13

Re: The Chair is finished

Philip F Duffy

-- - -so Beautiful! Thanks for sharing and Congratulations, Derek! Philip

Re: The Chair is finished

#15

Re: The Chair is finished

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

I love the woven seat it provides good contrast to the wood!!

Work safe!

George

Re: The Chair is finished

#16

Is it comfortable?

Patrick Gibbons

It certainly looks like it is. The woven seat looks lighter but which chair sits better?

Re: The Chair is finished

#17

Re: Is it comfortable?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

The chair feels taut. The woven seat is firm and the cord is tight. I was amazed that it was so comfortable. My wife said that she could not tell the difference from the original. My bottom says the padded seat is a little softer. I suspect that the woven seat will bed in over time. My head thinks it is prettier but is the biased end of my anatomy! :)

I made a brief comparison of weight difference between the original chair (made in Tasmanian Blackwood and Teak - it was manufactured under licence in Melbourne in the 1960s by Danish Designs) and this Fiddleback Jarrah reproduction. I estimate that the repro weighs 50% more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair is finished

#18

Ellis Walentine

Re: Reflections

Ellis Walentine

Derek, the chair looks grand, and it is probably even more impressive to us, your fellow woodworkers, because we know what you went through to make it. A significant portion of that 175 hours seemed to be taken up with figuring out how to join things in three-dimensional space, and you came up with a lot of excellent solutions.

...which brings me to a comment about risk vs certainty: My take is that Pye's dichotomy had mostly to do with how much you depend on jigs, fixtures, machines, and mechanically controlled processes, versus working by eye and feel. Making an exact replica of the Wegner chair had aspects of both, as you were quite methodical and mechanical in the layout of the curves and joinery ("where to put the lines"), and you devised jigs for guiding your drilling operations and aligning your parts; but, you also relied on eye-hand coordination to fair the curves and duplicate the final shape. There was risk in that, and even more in the way you created the tapered finger joints and the slots for the woven seat, compared with the certainty of more sophisticated machine processes.

It's also risky to improve on any iconic design, as you did with the fancy wood and the woven seat. People are conditioned to the look of the original, which can underscore the differences visually. In one sense, it makes the piece less of a reproduction than an interpretation of the original, so there is great risk involved. In this case, I think you've succeeded wonderfully.

It is quite an accomplishment to look back upon. I'm grateful that you documented the build so eloquently. Following along vicariously has been entertaining and enlightening.

Ellis

Re: The Chair is finished

#19

Re: Reflections

Patrick Gibbons

While your chair is a reproduction in the strict sense, I have to agree with Ellis that your build method was so different that I am hard pressed to say you reproduced anything. You reverse-engineered it. There was not much certainty from one step to the next. I have enjoyed eaves dropping in on your thought processes and the end product is beautiful. Not to be curmudgeonly, but we'll have to wait to see how your chair holds up over time. Personally, I think it's a safe bet to go the distance.

Re: The Chair is finished

#21

Re: The Chair is finished

Scott Burr

Turned out great Derek!

Re: The Chair is finished

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The Chair is finished

Jesper, Denmark

That was a very interesting and informative project, Derek.

Just in case you are looking for another challenge, the Catalan architect, Gaudí designed some chairs, which would be a real challenge to duplicate.


It is quite another style from Wegener, but seen in context in Barcelona is quite interesting.

Re: The Chair is finished

#23

Re: The Chair is finished

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Jesper

I can't say that that chair does anything for me. It is both square and too ornate for my tastes. It lacks the organic qualities of either a Maloof or Wegner chair.

I am interested to read your thoughts on its design, however. What made you think of it in the context of Wegner?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair is finished

#24

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The Chair is finished

Jesper, Denmark

I visited Barcelona and the Park Guell, which was designed by the Catalan architect Gaudí, earlier this year. The chair style has no relation to Wegner or any of the other Danish designers - and actually is quite opposite their main artistic direction.

It only came up, as it is all curves, and probably even more of a challenge to copy that the round chair. As an individual example, it does not do anything for me, but in the context of his other works, and located at the Park Guell, it made sense.

More details here - but the pictures do not do justce to the spacial genius of Gaudí.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Park_G%C3%BCell

Re: The Chair is finished

#25

Re: Reflections

TomD

"...which brings me to a comment about risk vs certainty: My take is that Pye's dichotomy had mostly to do with how much you depend on jigs, fixtures, machines, and mechanically controlled processes, versus working by eye and feel."

It is interesting that one of his main tools to illustrate the point was a fixtured chisel with lever assist. It was risk in the sense of creativity, you could put the cut however you wanted, but the tool itself had many characteristics of a machine, I believe it technically qualifies as such due to the linkage and leverage. While it might be nice in this forum to consider dichotomies of the type described above but I think they are mostly meaningless. There are many non-challenging, and indeed boring things that happen entirely by eye and feel. Squaring up a split for a leg with a drawknife would be very hands on, but I don't remember it being difficult when I first tried it, and if I were a bodger, I think the risk element would have vanished long ago. Most amateurs (not a word that can be spoken of our host of course), are more interested in the idea of risk relative to skill (which they don't have), and the manipulation of tools. But a real craftsman, knows his tools and is working in a design mode (when they are working in a risk mode at all). I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned.

I just got the latest blog by CLC which covers 17 years with their CNC. And some earlier years pattern routing. None of the methods proved foolproof, even at that level of technical intervention. But more interesting is the degree to which they had to massage designs to get the results they wanted within the capabilities of their machines. It is hard to get this into the frame Pye described, but if you know the 3D parts interfaces that are required, and the minimal degree to which these could be predicted or controlled, it really is a workmanship of risk, getting what you know is in the plywood sheet out on the water. And consider, the CNC does nothing to deal with the parts that are bent, that is all a design issue for the designer, the CNC is there to cut flat panels, even if it cuts bevels and tabs , and other useful things, the skill of the designer to define how all this works first when deformed into 3 dimensions, and then when placed in the water, is still considerable.

http://www.clcboats.com/life-of-boats-blog/seventeen-years-of-cnc-machines-a-survey.html