What is risk?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I've been wanting to reply to Ellis for a while, and Tom's post is timely.
Ellis wrote:
...which brings me to a comment about risk vs certainty: My take is that Pye's dichotomy had mostly to do with how much you depend on jigs, fixtures, machines, and mechanically controlled processes, versus working by eye and feel. Making an exact replica of the Wegner chair had aspects of both, as you were quite methodical and mechanical in the layout of the curves and joinery ("where to put the lines"), and you devised jigs for guiding your drilling operations and aligning your parts; but, you also relied on eye-hand coordination to fair the curves and duplicate the final shape. There was risk in that, and even more in the way you created the tapered finger joints and the slots for the woven seat, compared with the certainty of more sophisticated machine processes.
And later Tom commented:
While it might be nice in this forum to consider dichotomies of the type described above but I think they are mostly meaningless. There are many non-challenging, and indeed boring things that happen entirely by eye and feel. ...... .... Most amateurs (not a word that can be spoken of our host of course), are more interested in the idea of risk relative to skill (which they don't have), and the manipulation of tools. But a real craftsman, knows his tools and is working in a design mode (when they are working in a risk mode at all). I just don't see the risk for any experienced person, doing anything in the shop, as far as simple manipulations are concerned.
I am hoping that the forum members will offer their views on what constitutes "risk" in woodworking. Can risk include the use of power, or is it about handtool use? Can risk include jigs? Do established, professional woodworkers not qualify, as Tom suggests? Or does risk simply means working with the new and outside ones comfort zone?
Regards from Perth
Derek



