New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Derek, The Chair *LINK*

Posts

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#26

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A question of ethics

Jesper, Denmark

This is getting to be a rather lengthy discussion - with dubious utility.

I looked at the Danish "Patent Office" or whatever it would be translated to into English.

"Design protection" is only possible for 25 years.

"Trade Mark" can last forever.

"Copyright" lasts for 70 years.

I am not in any way qualified to speak on this, but as I understand it:

1. There does not seem to be any reason why you cannot build the chair.

2. You cannot sell it as a Wegner Chair.

3. It seems that you are free to publish any description of your own work - and it could be copyrighted for 70 years.

I suspect that consulting with a lawyer in ether OZ or United Bluff will only have the usual result: Cost you money.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#27

This really requires clarification . . .

CJ in MPLS

The types of legal protection that apply to a furniture design are as follows:

Copyright - Copyright protection may cover purely aesthetic aspects of furniture, though this is difficult. Copyrights also extend to the printed/recorded plans and/or instructions that might be used to inform the building process. Copyrights also cover the photographs of furniture that we share. Copyrights do not protect anything that is functional. Copyrights last forever for all practical purposes.

Patents - Patent protection in the form of design patents cover the aesthetic aspects of furniture. These rights last for 14 years in the US. Patents may also be obtained to cover functional aspects of furniture, e.g. new joints or methods of making. These rights last 20 years from the date on which the case was filed in the US. No patent may be obtained on any inventive concept that is publicly known, though the US does grant a 1 year grace period.

Trademarks - In addition to the more prosaic logo or product name, features of furniture that are unique enough to point to a specific maker can be trademarked. For example, the fellow that controversially used a nail as a pull on an otherwise straight up cabinet could use this as a trademark if he continued to use it. Since a trademark is all about making a connection between a product and its maker, so long as the maker continues to use the trademark appropriately, the trademark may last indefinitely.

Contracts - While contracts are not intellectual property, there are some promises that we make, which are enforceable contracts, that might have an effect on your woodworking. For example, plans purchased from vendors like Woodcraft often have a license attached to them that prohibits commercial use of the plans. If you were to violate that license, you could be liable for contractual violations and likely copyright infringement as well. In addition to written contracts that you are hopefully aware of, verbal agreements regarding purchase, sale or confidentiality are ones that we enter into all the time without really realizing it.

Fair Use - The concept of fair use comes up all of the time and its application on the internet is, as you might expect, wrong. To start, fair use applies only to copyright law. Fair use is not a get out of jail free card, but rather a defense to another otherwise proven copyright infringement. Fair use recognizes that there are valid reasons for one to "quote" a protected work and that society as a whole is better off when this is permitted. The concept to keep in mind here is "quote". The less one quotes from a copyrighted work, the better. Further, if your reasons are non-commercial, you'll have more luck. Examples include commentary, critique, and education.

Artists Rights - In some instances laws such as the Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA) may apply to prevent one from modifying a work of art in such a way as to damage the work. Think about the cabinet with the nail for a pull. If that cabinet qualified as a work of art under VARA then the expediency of replacing a period pull with a nail might be something the artist could sue to prevent or reverse. VARA is mostly to protect the integrity of the art.

So, for some quick, dirty and frankly dodgy legal advice you should not rely upon, I'd assess "the chair" as follows:

- The chair has been publicly available and known for decades. Unless there are new features to the chair, which I doubt, patents of any type that might have existed are likely expired.

- Because copyright protection doesn't extend to functional items, there is likely little, if any, copyright protection on the chair itself.

- The chair is iconic. Accordingly, there is likely trade dress or trademark protection (either statutory or common law) on the chair. This is why passing off copies as originals can come up from time to time.

- If you are working from plans in written form (or perhaps a video or photos), it may constitute a copyright violation to make a copy of the plans in 3D. This could be considered a derivative work.

- If you are working from plans, videos or photos, these items may have come with a license agreement that limits how you may use the plans. If you violate this contract, you may be liable for copyright infringement as a consequence of the violation.

So long as one does not try to pass of their work as someone else's, the risks relating to IP are fairly low; however, this all depends on how litigious the IP owner. To the extent that an original creator of a work self-identifies with their work, you could be in more danger. Anecdotally, I have found that individuals who have more self worth tied up in a work can be much more prickly about these matters than a ruthless corporation (btw, I'm the guy whose "ruth" we are measuring here). In the former case the issue is one of a personal affront and in the latter a consideration of the bottom line.

What really protects most of us from IP violations is two things: anonymity and the amounts of money involved. It is really hard to figure out who you guys are in real life which makes it hard for an attorney to start sending hate mail. And frankly, a one off copy of a piece of furniture is unlikely to be worth the hassle of a lawsuit.

As always, consult an attorney if you have any concerns along these lines.

CJ

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#28

Re: A question of ethics

john sayles

Hi Jesper,

I followed your post up until about the last sentence:

"... OZ or United Bluff ... "

Can you enlighten me on the meaning of this fragment?

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#29

Great summary, and point about ruthless...

John in NM

Thanks CJ, that fit my usually ironic (not in this case) bill of brief, concise, and specific :D

I think you are right on the mark with the rule of thumb for where trouble will come from. The one experience I have had with civil suits backs this up too - we sued over a very clear and documented contract violation, and after 5 years of back and forth and attempts to muddy the waters, they relented and offered a settlement. Our odds in court were good, theirs were not, and the money was available for a full judgement in our favor. Common sense prevailed and they kept a fair chunk of assets rather than lose all. We took the settlement offer because though our case was strong, nothing is ever certain when you push it to court. Bird in the hand and all that.

Now if either or both parties decision making had been wrapped up in pride and saving face, things could have gone very differently!

For all the supposed ruthlessness of corporate behavior, it does tend to average out to rational and kind of boring.

I wonder to what degree that image springs from our tendencies to dislike the boss? :D After all, he tends to be more interested in the bottom line than giving us well deserved raises :D

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#30

Re: A question of ethics

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

There is absolutely no provosion in design patent, utility patent, copyright, or trademark law that provides for an unauthorized personal copy of any protected material. This includes the chair in our discussion.

You can try and justify it anyway you like but you should call it what it is, theft.

Robin

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#31

Jesper, Denmark

Common Nicknames for Australia and USA


Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#32

Oh, there's that word

John in NM

Got to be very careful using that word. If you mean theft in a legal sense alone, that is one thing. I believe you are wrong, and that you can't back it up with case law, but it remains a valid argument you are making.

If you mean theft in a moral sense you are venturing onto some thin ice, with some very deep water below :D

Sure does keep the discussion interesting though :D

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#33

Re: A question of ethics

BrianMonumentCO

The one thing that is most important and most relevant to this discussion especially in the legal sense is what exactly is protected and by what mechanism.

Simple and limited view here;

Patents were intended to protect processes, such as how to make steel.

Copyrights were intended to protect printed/written/drawn material, such as songs, novels, maps etc.

Sounds like Jesper's observation about Denmark and the chairs is about fraud, ie someone passing of ones non-name brand work off as an original name brand work.

So is the subject chair protected by a current patent?

Or is it protected by some implied and derived copyright notion based upon shape, form etc of an object.

The follow up question of the day is how much similarity between object A and object B must exist before they are deemed to be the same object and not two distinctly different objects.

In my opinion;

Best known abuse of a copyright is probably the happy birthday song.

Most infamous patents were the Wright Brothers patent on aircraft, and A Bell on the telephone.

My 2 cents worth. I am not lawyer not did I stay at holiday inn.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#34

Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....

roger lance

Derek.....you have started another prolonged discussion and I'm guessing that you already have resolved this issue in your mind and know how you will proceed. I know that if you consult a lawyer, you will spend some money in exchange for an "opinion" (which may or may not be accurate).....even if you land in court, the judge will render a decision which is legally an "opinion".....which allows for appeals and more "opinions".....lawyers have a way of limiting their liability by rendering their opinion.....

In my opinion, I see no advantage for you in placing yourself in a potential "trick bag"......so I'd recommend that you build your chair and that you keep to yourself any information that would possibly be a basis for litigation. If there is someone out there who wants to build this chair for profit, let them go thru the same research process you've undergone.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#35

Re: Common Nicknames for Australia and USA

Bruce McCrory

I keep learning new and charming words and phrases on this forum. :)

hbm, from Uuber Bluff! Under Buxx? No, Bu--!

Yaw-shoe-rrrr!

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#36

The one for USA may be common in Europe,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

not so much here in the breakaway colony.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#37

Re: The one for USA may be common in Europe,

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I'd never seen that particular epithet either, but then, maybe, they don't say it to our face. We are, after all, very dangerous and quick to anger. I think I like what Pogo used to call us, "The U. S. and A" but I never figured that one out either.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#38

Re: Common Nicknames for Australia and USA

john sayles

The Australian nickname is self-explanatory; the other one is dopey, uninspired, and offensive.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#39

Re: Let's call their bluff.

Bruce McCrory

Ya' know, ... ... ... we used to adopt insulting ditties. Like "Yankee doodles." What went wrong? :\

hbm, from "UB"

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#40

Re: Let's call their bluff.

john sayles

Bruce,

You're on your own -- you can go around telling people that you're from the "United Bluff."

The Yankee Doodle analogy is hardly apt -- once we proved our military prowess, it was an ironic, in-your-face move to co-opt a tune intended to ridicule us.

Don't see how it applies here.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#41

Re: A question of ethics

Tom

Derek, I can't imagine publishing the dimensions is a violation of anything. The only copyright infringement would be if I then copied and published your text.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#42

Jesper, Denmark

Nicknames are terms of endearment...

Jesper, Denmark

However cheeky they might seem.

People we do not like do not get nicknames.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#43

Re: Nicknames are terms of endearment...

Patrick Gibbons

I had a girlfriend once who never got that. I had a nickname for her she couldn't stand. At the time, I adored her.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#44

This begs the question...

John in NM

Having never had a nickname stick, I guess no one finds me endearing! :D :D :D

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#45

Re: Let's call their bluff.

John in NM

I don't remember dad ever telling me that I was entitled to go through life without ever being offended by a careless word here and there. I seem to recall that his advice trended in the opposite direction :D

For what its worth, I found the reference irritating too. But I would gently remind you that no good comes from doing anything but laughing it off.

After all, next time around it may be you who inadvertently offends some one - I certainly have done so myself, quite recently even - best to be forgiving when you can because you may need others to treat you in the same way later.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#46

Re: Nicknames are terms of endearment...

john sayles

Jesper,

You are a man of few words -- but I thank you for those.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#47

Re: This really requires clarification . . .

BrianMonumentCO

CJ are you an attorney?

Where did you get those definitions?

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#48

Re: A question of ethics

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

copyright covers much more than just printed materials. Where it applies to Wegner's chair is the design of the chair is copyrighted and that includes all parts that are separate from the function of the charie the idea of Four legs a seat and a backrest are not copyrightable. But the things that make Wegner's chair unique are what is protected.

And like other copyrights a design copyright can be renewed, just ask Mikey Mouse.

Robin

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#49

Re: Oh, there's that word

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

as an artist I have a pretty good understanding if copyright law. In one of my graduate seminars we read title 17 and I can tell you there is nothing in it that allows for an unauthorized copy of a protected work for personal use.

Perhaps you can site case law to support your position.

Robin

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#50

Basic things

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Jesper and all,

There's no distance, except mileage, between Jesper and us. He's been our friend, and has been contributing solidly to our assemblage, going back at least to Badger Pond. He clearly feels relaxed around us, as well he should, and we around him. More generally, Europeans and the Danes in particular are in our band of brothers--Afghanistan, NATO for instance.

That's all.

Wiley