This really requires clarification . . .
CJ in MPLS
The types of legal protection that apply to a furniture design are as follows:
Copyright - Copyright protection may cover purely aesthetic aspects of furniture, though this is difficult. Copyrights also extend to the printed/recorded plans and/or instructions that might be used to inform the building process. Copyrights also cover the photographs of furniture that we share. Copyrights do not protect anything that is functional. Copyrights last forever for all practical purposes.
Patents - Patent protection in the form of design patents cover the aesthetic aspects of furniture. These rights last for 14 years in the US. Patents may also be obtained to cover functional aspects of furniture, e.g. new joints or methods of making. These rights last 20 years from the date on which the case was filed in the US. No patent may be obtained on any inventive concept that is publicly known, though the US does grant a 1 year grace period.
Trademarks - In addition to the more prosaic logo or product name, features of furniture that are unique enough to point to a specific maker can be trademarked. For example, the fellow that controversially used a nail as a pull on an otherwise straight up cabinet could use this as a trademark if he continued to use it. Since a trademark is all about making a connection between a product and its maker, so long as the maker continues to use the trademark appropriately, the trademark may last indefinitely.
Contracts - While contracts are not intellectual property, there are some promises that we make, which are enforceable contracts, that might have an effect on your woodworking. For example, plans purchased from vendors like Woodcraft often have a license attached to them that prohibits commercial use of the plans. If you were to violate that license, you could be liable for contractual violations and likely copyright infringement as well. In addition to written contracts that you are hopefully aware of, verbal agreements regarding purchase, sale or confidentiality are ones that we enter into all the time without really realizing it.
Fair Use - The concept of fair use comes up all of the time and its application on the internet is, as you might expect, wrong. To start, fair use applies only to copyright law. Fair use is not a get out of jail free card, but rather a defense to another otherwise proven copyright infringement. Fair use recognizes that there are valid reasons for one to "quote" a protected work and that society as a whole is better off when this is permitted. The concept to keep in mind here is "quote". The less one quotes from a copyrighted work, the better. Further, if your reasons are non-commercial, you'll have more luck. Examples include commentary, critique, and education.
Artists Rights - In some instances laws such as the Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA) may apply to prevent one from modifying a work of art in such a way as to damage the work. Think about the cabinet with the nail for a pull. If that cabinet qualified as a work of art under VARA then the expediency of replacing a period pull with a nail might be something the artist could sue to prevent or reverse. VARA is mostly to protect the integrity of the art.
So, for some quick, dirty and frankly dodgy legal advice you should not rely upon, I'd assess "the chair" as follows:
- The chair has been publicly available and known for decades. Unless there are new features to the chair, which I doubt, patents of any type that might have existed are likely expired.
- Because copyright protection doesn't extend to functional items, there is likely little, if any, copyright protection on the chair itself.
- The chair is iconic. Accordingly, there is likely trade dress or trademark protection (either statutory or common law) on the chair. This is why passing off copies as originals can come up from time to time.
- If you are working from plans in written form (or perhaps a video or photos), it may constitute a copyright violation to make a copy of the plans in 3D. This could be considered a derivative work.
- If you are working from plans, videos or photos, these items may have come with a license agreement that limits how you may use the plans. If you violate this contract, you may be liable for copyright infringement as a consequence of the violation.
So long as one does not try to pass of their work as someone else's, the risks relating to IP are fairly low; however, this all depends on how litigious the IP owner. To the extent that an original creator of a work self-identifies with their work, you could be in more danger. Anecdotally, I have found that individuals who have more self worth tied up in a work can be much more prickly about these matters than a ruthless corporation (btw, I'm the guy whose "ruth" we are measuring here). In the former case the issue is one of a personal affront and in the latter a consideration of the bottom line.
What really protects most of us from IP violations is two things: anonymity and the amounts of money involved. It is really hard to figure out who you guys are in real life which makes it hard for an attorney to start sending hate mail. And frankly, a one off copy of a piece of furniture is unlikely to be worth the hassle of a lawsuit.
As always, consult an attorney if you have any concerns along these lines.
CJ