New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Derek, The Chair *LINK*

Posts

Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#1

Derek, The Chair *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I stumbled across this video on another forum and thought you'd find it interesting. I don't know if the link will work since it's intended for a mobile thingie, like my ipad.


The Hans Wegner Chair

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#2

Worked fine on my immobile computer


Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#3

Re: Derek, The Chair

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Bruce

I am familiar with that one - must have watched it 20 times ... make that 21 now! :)

There is another one of interest, by Jeremy Broun: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lP5p1aZEDaM

He notes that he made by this chair by hand at 17 years of age (or something like that), which is pretty amazing.

I am still waiting for the chair I purchased to arrive. The more I studied the photos, the more complex the curves became. It will be a huge challenge even with a copy in front of me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Derek, The Chair

Jesper, Denmark

Well, if anyone is up to the challenge, you are. It will be interesting to follow, as I am sure it will be well documented.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#5

Re: Derek, The Chair

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm working night shift this week, so replies come at strange times.

Regarding the curves, I recall an interview with Sam Maloof in FWW a bunch of years ago, in which he discussed his designs and in particular the curves on his chairs. He said, and I'm paraphrasing because I can't lay my hands on that article, that it is one thing to conceive of the line and the curve and even to draw it, but it's an entirely different thing to make it mean something. Good luck.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#6

Re: Derek, The Chair

David Katz

Thanks for posting this Bruce

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#7

Re: Derek, The Chair

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You're very welcome. There's a lot of nifty stuff out there, and I'd like to say it was diligent research that led me to this one, but truth is I just stumbled on it.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#9

A question of ethics

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I plan to start work on Wegner's The Chair in earnest after Christmas, when I am on leave from my practice. The day time job is too consuming at present, and with social arrangements there is just not enough time on weekends.

I shall be writing up the build on my website and blogging it on the forums. The idea of sharing dimensions taken from an original chair here has given me several headaches - keeping in mind that this is a chair in production (I am not sure if it is still under copyrite).

I do not see a problem making a copy for oneself. I assume that someone who wishes to sell the chairs commercially will require CNC machines (There are several replicas in the market place, and these are "photocopies" - similar in looks but missing relevant details). My dimensions will not help this group. And anyone who wants to go commercially by hand from the plans, well all I can say is good luck! Consequently, I will assume that the only ones interested in the dimensions (not published plans, per se), will only be building a chair for their own use (in a similar manner to the replica Maloof chair plans that are available).

Let me know your thoughts on this please.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#10

Clint Searl

Re: A question of ethics

Clint Searl

I'm certain that there are no ethical considerations under the conditions you describe.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#11

Adam of Oakland

Re: A question of ethics

Adam of Oakland

it seems ok to me.

I'm actually not so interested in the exact dimensions. It's more your techniques and well written exploration from previous work that matters to me. Please Derek, climb that mountain and let us folks cheer you on with our spotting glasses!

I feel like you're much more a scientist exploring Wegener's masterpiece. Put it this way: Poof, here he shows up, extracted from the afterlife and fully concsious, in the middle of your shop, while you are at work on The Chair. Let's play it safe and say you are not engaged in a glue-up, but resting by your bench and contemplating how your pieces will fit together once the glue-up begins.

How would that conversation go? I think Wegener would be flattered that someone studies his work so intimately that they wish to make one themselves. just for the joy of the process. you're not hurting anybody by doing this, man!

-Adam of Oakland

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#12

The reason why.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Adam

I think that you have been inside my head :) (Perhaps that is not something many would wish!).

I was asked early on why I decided to build a copy of this chair rather than simply build one to my own design. I much prefer building my own designs. Indeed, this is the first time I have consciously copied the design of someone else. I see it as a challenge. Frankly, it is easier to build something that does not resemble anything else - then no one will know how accurate you are! Building a replica of The Chair without a plan to follow is the most difficult challenge I have set myself so far.

The Chair was designed to be built with CNC power tools and finished with a few handtools. Well I do plan to use some power tools, such as a bandsaw, for roughing out. For me the issue is partly whether it can be built with handtools, and also whether Wegner created constructional shortcuts for machine use.

I have been mentally constructing this chair for some months now. There are parts that are better understood, such as the reason for the mortice-and-tenon shape that is used (I shall show pictures when the time comes). And I've come up with ideas for handwork - for example, how to do the stepped mortice-and-tenon joints with handtools rather than a power router.

There are other joints that are scary still, such as the finger joints at the join of the arms and chair back. There is an organisational system that underlies the whole build that Wegner developed, and this is beginning to become clearer. I agree with you that all this is the interesting part, and I assume that others will find the exploration as exciting as I. Hence blogging it on the forum. I trust this will create much discussion, and we shall learn something for ourselves. How much fun is that! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#13

CNC in 1949?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Wikipedia says The Chair was designed in 1949. I didn't realize the Danes had CNC already.

...though I was surprised to learn, digging around in the Interweb, that Numerical Control, using punched tape, was available as early as the early 50s.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#14

Re: CNC in 1949?

Bruce McCrory

I think CNC construction was developed for the Chair by one or more of the licensees, after 1949. Derek will likely reverse engineer to build by hand. And, stock up on good, handmade rasps.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#15

Re: CNC in 1949?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Here is a video of The Chair being manufactured. I used the term CNC, but that is not correct. I just do not know the correct one - I used CNC in a generic manner .. lathe duplicating sanding machine? In any event, as one may see, computers are not needed to duplicate by machine.

http://www.pp.dk/index.php?page=gallery&cat=14&id=173

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#16

Re: CNC in 1949?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was teasing you a bit, Derek. CNC = computer numerically controlled, and is distinguished from numerically controlled mainly, I think, by the sophistication of the programming. According to the Interweb, numerical control for production started out with punched tape, a little bit like marrying a player piano to a production machine of some kind (whether lathe or other machine).

My first college had an automatic typewriter in the fundraising office that used punched tape for repetitive letters, allowing them to personalize letters to potential donors: you would "program" it by typing the body of the letter on a special setting that punched the tape, with buttons that signaled the tape to stop, while you typed in the inside address, salutation, etc. You then switched it over to production mode and fed the tape in, letting it run through. If I recall correctly, the tape ran as a loop, although it's been over 50 years now, and the memories are a bit fuzzy. I learned how to use it when I sweet-talked the secretary there into letting me use it to send out application letters to potential employers when I decided to leave (the reasons for my leaving would require getting into politics, so shall remain unspoken).

In operation, it typed more slowly than I could (and I was, not then and not ever, a high-speed typist), but never made a misteak, and so was, on balance, faster than manual typing.

I suspect the early numerically controlled machines were similar in operation.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#17

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A question of ethics

Jesper, Denmark

It is absolutely certain that the chair is still in production. As far as I can tell, it is only in manufacture as orders, not made for general distribution.

Typically the design rights of the many danish chairs, designed by well known architects have been vigorously defended. I have no clue as to the legal situation either locally or internationally.

Most copies have had minor changes to the design, typically making them easier to build and not quite the same design, and not as comfortable, elegant, pretty etc. as the original.

Here in Denmark, there have been a number of cases, where internet auction sites have been nailed for passing copies as originals as originals. Confiscation and hefty fines are usually the result. This has applied not only to Hans Wegner designs, but Arne Jacobsen, Børge Mogensen and many others.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: CNC in 1949?

Jesper, Denmark

The video shows current production methods - seemingly started as early as 1989.

Production methods before that probably also used the purely mechanical copy lathe/router to form the near circular arm/back combination - but the rather simple leg/stretcher design would have lent itself to many simple fixing methods. CNC not required.

The prototype was definitely made by hand - not machine.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#19

Re: A question of ethics

BrianMonumentCO

Under what legal concept is the design of the chair protected.

In the USA, I think the choices are Copyrights or Patents.

Did I miss a concept?

Then the next question is where is the "alleged infringement" being made.

And whether the country of infringement recognizes the original claim.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A question of ethics

Jesper, Denmark

As previously mentioned, I have no idea of the legal protection, and do not and did not intend to comment on the ethics of making one copy by hand and for your own use and edification.

I have not contacted the present manufacturer, and do not intend to - it might only open an unnecessary can of worms.

I did comment on the probable construction process now and previously, but have not researched it in any detail.

I am really looking forward to the reporting of the construction by hand. I am also anticipating that the report that the legs and stretchers were sorta easy, but the back and arms challenging.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#21

Re: A question of ethics

Brian Greene

As previously stated here and in other places, there is no infringement issue in copying for personal use, whether replicating a trademarked or patented item of commercial manufacture, or photocopying an article in a magazine. I'm not a lawyer but I expect that the matter would turn not on the rights of the trademark, patent or copyright owner, but the practicality of enforcement.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#22

Re: A question of ethics

Tom

I have heard these arguments over and over, and don't know for certain. However, the idea that personal use exemptions exist is frequently refuted. Patent reserves rights against someone else making the thing whether they have a commercial intention or not.

I don't know about US laws on chairs, but as of about 10 yeas ago it became possible to copyright boat hulls, which was previously unheard of. Of course, even if such protection applied to other design items, it would not be retroactive. And it presumes that the thing is being copied exactly.

Once on is relying on the supposition that an owner may not defend his rights for reasons of economic efficiency, one has pretty much lost the ethical argument. I say that though I have a lot of disdain for the over-reach in current patent and copyright schemes.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#23

Inducement to infringe

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I don't know if the chair is protected by a patent or a copyright (and since IANAL I'm not sure of the legal ramifications).

But if there is some kind of protection at play, "publishing" your building of the chair could be construed as inducing others to build their own, which is punishable in some jurisdictions (Canada and US for instance). The fact that you are not making money from publishing the work does NOT matter.

The question standing out here is whether a blog qualifies as "publishing", and I am not qualified to answer that.

In all likehood you will not get in trouble for publishing your construction of the chair. Just keep in mind that you might legally expose yourself by doing so. If I were you I would check with an attorney, just to make sure...

Good luck!

DC

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#24

Re: A question of ethics

Brian Greene

This is a very interesting discussion.

I think the ethical issue comes down to intent. If the intention is to profit from someone else's inspiration and hard work, then we could argue it's unethical. Borrowing an idea or a design or part of a design because you enjoy the form, want to practice a technique or because your confidence as a furniture designer is lacking is not unethical in my mind if you are making one for your own use. Passing off the work of someone else as your own for commercial gain is clearly wrong. That is not the case here.

Some would argue there are no new ideas. Possibly. There are plenty of new combinations of ideas that form a complete design. We read about them all the time in the woodworking literature. Not once have I read a disclaimer saying "thou shalt not..." To the contrary, I strongly suspect every major designer/maker who publishes his/her work expects and probably encourages copying. This is how we advance the craft.

I am currently designing/building a table. The original germ of the idea came from a bench built by Henry Varnum Poor in the 1920's. That same germ of an idea was later used by Hank Gilpin. I created my design before I saw Gilpin's. They are similar in form but different in most every detail. My design is original in my mind and was arrived at honestly. I'll have no hesitation in citing it's parentage. The table, or ones similar to it, will likely be offered for sale. I am not troubled with any ethical dilemmas over this but I also want to make sure that the perception of fair dealing is also present.

Re: Derek, The Chair *LINK*

#25

Much of the problem with these discussions...

John in NM

Is that they inevitably begin with practical considerations - should I or shouldn't I - and end in theoretical discussions of law vs ethics.

I have seen probably a dozen discussions like this over the years, and they are interesting - but not as interesting or fruitful as they would be if anyone could actually cite case law to back up their predictions of the strengths and limitations of patent and copyright law. I suspect that doing so would be a lot of boring legal research, which is why no one does it.

While balancing risks is something we all do, I tend to see a lot of legal hypochondria whenever this subject comes up. When there is no research work to back it up, I tend to dismiss such worries as what they are - worries about hypothetical possibilities.

In terms of practical application - do I build and sell such and such a design - I think the question really comes down to whether you'd be willing to fight over that design. Although intent is not the be all and end all of legal questions, it is important. If a copyright holder contacts you and tells you that you are violating their copyright, and you stop doing so and attempt to make amends within the means you have available - then your odds are very good of not getting sued. If you basically tell them to pound sand, well your odds of getting sued tend to go up :D

Which one a person does depends on a lot of variables. In the question of this chair, I frankly wouldn't worry about it myself. If a copyright holder (design is too old for a patent as I understand it) contacted me and said that this blog post detailing construction violated that copyright, then the simplest thing to do is remove the blog post. That is usually how these things get resolved - and it never goes further because the effort needed to win some kind of damage settlement is large and the odds of winning are not good enough. Neither party is usually looking for a fight and they are usually easy to avoid if one party is and the other isn't.