CJ can speak for himself, but
Bruce, a MN Galoot
He is a patent attorney
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
CJ can speak for himself, but
Bruce, a MN Galoot
He is a patent attorney
Re: Oh, there's that word
John in NM
My point is that a law that is unenforced might as well not exist. It is up to the IP holder to pursue enforcement of their rights. That is what I mean about case law, it gives an idea of the actual practical limits that the courts have set. I suspect those limits are a lot less brutal than a grad seminar would conclude from reading the text of a law.
However, if you are sticking to a strictly legal use of the word "theft" I will agree with you that by definition, copying is theft. For 70 years.
Re: CJ can speak for himself, but
Tom
"Copyright protection may cover purely aesthetic aspects of furniture, though this is difficult. Copyrights also extend to the printed/recorded plans and/or instructions that might be used to inform the building process. Copyrights also cover the photographs of furniture that we share. Copyrights do not protect anything that is functional. Copyrights last forever for all practical purposes."
So if you look at his definition of Copyright, the first sentence would seem to be the main one of concern, and in his characterisation, it is "difficult". Which means economically pointless as regards anything Derek might be concerned with. Of course some people routinely send out letters, etc... Even when the economic infringement is very low, if they prefer to defend their rights vigorously.
The middle stuff is the conventional stuff, and either doesn't exist in this case, has various disparate holders, ie the photos are the property of the photographer. Or would not be the commercially valuable part of the deal, which one assumes is the chair. Drawing your own drawing of the chair, for instance, would be something you would have rights to, probably, up to the point where you try to sell it as Wegner plans.
The fact that Copyright is "forever" comes to an ethical point, where the original purpose now diverges from the current purpose, which has largely been established by unethical means, such as lobbying, in the real sense of passing large wads of cash to elected representatives.
Re: This really requires clarification . . .
Sgian Dubh
As a footnote to your post, here in the UK one of our students some years ago made a piece 'inspired' by Mark Newson's Lockheed Lounge. The piece looked remarkably like the original except it was in painted GRP (fibre glass) and had human feet and hands for the feet. The student got in touch with Mark Newson's design practice about the piece, basically seeking I suppose a pat on the back and murmurings of approval from them along the lines of "Nice to see you were inspired by my original, and I can see the 'genetic' linkage with my 'iconic' work."
What he got were letters from high powered solicitors threatening all sorts of retribution and damning in Hell. The college management received similarly threatening missives indicating the piece could only be used for the purpose of assessing the student's work in the relevant module of study and then must be destroyed, and it could not under any circumstances be displayed at the end of year graduation show, or at any other exhibition in the future. The piece didn't leave the college for several years, after which it was deemed safe enough to be quietly shipped out to the then ex-students home.
What does this prove? Well, not much really, except that if a rich and successful design practice decides to take umbrage at something you do because you've hurt their oh, so delicate feelings and sensitivities they can make life miserable if they feel like it.
Personally, I don't think the Lockheed Lounge piece is especially iconic. It looks cold and uninviting, perhaps it's meant to be, and I can't see much point in it myself, but my opinion is of little import. I guess the vacuous chatterati that shape public perception decided it was a classic piece of design and that's what matters, ha, ha. Slainte.
Re: This really requires clarification . . .
CJ in MPLS
I am a patent attorney. I wrote the above as as simplification of the various laws that might apply to the reproduction of The Chair. As you might guess, a lot was omitted. But then since I'm long out of law school and only dream about exams, I didn't feel it necessary to go down all the rabbit holes. So long as it is understood that 1) I'm not providing actionable legal advice and 2) I have my own opinions on IP that may differ from those of others, I'm perfectly willing to answer any questions or address any concerns you might have with what I wrote earlier.
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Roger and all
It has been (and hopefully will remain) an interesting discussion.
The ethics of building The Chair on line is still not clear in my mind. Rob Lee suggested a simple, useful distinction that I find appealing:
I would boil it down to this... If your article slant is "Here's what I did....", then i believe you're OK. If your article slant is "Here's how you can do it....and avoid buying one", then you have crossed a line (incitement to infringe)...
I am not looking for an excuse to build on line - indeed at this time I am leaning towards a very minimalist blog - but I am curious that there seem to be so many furniture builders that flout the ethic issue. Consider ..
There are "replicas" of Wegner chairs on eBay. Just search for them. Why are they permitted to be sold (not just on eBay, but from a number of on-line and departmental stores)?
For interest, there are also originals available: http://www.ebay.com/itm/Danish-Modern-Teak-Presidential-Debate-CHAIRs-by-Hans-Wegner-/320765020493?pt=Antiques_Furniture&hash=item4aaf15c94d
One can purchase plans to build Maloof chairs and rockers. These are sold on the Popular Woodworking website. There are how-to DVDs from a few makers, such as Charles Brock. Not to mention 100s of amateurs who have built these and referred to them as Maloof Rockers or Maloof Style.
http://www.popularwoodworking.com/article/the-best-plan-to-build-a-maloof-rocker
Similarly, Caleb James makes and sells Wegner chairs. He just states, " Call it an homage to the Wegner style". However his chairs (he has not attempted The Chair) are as exact a copy of the Wegner design as he can build.
http://www.custommade.com/search/?q=wegner
Perhaps the manufacturers just do not care to defend a copyrite? And if they do not do so, then that is tacit approval to be copied?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
CJ in MPLS
Derek:
My guess is that you are (or perhaps have long since) regretting bringing this project up in the first place.
Since most of us, including yourself, reside in locales with adversarial legal systems and we cannot control or sometimes predict the actions of third parties to a high degree of certainty, there is always a risk that any action you take make give rise to liability. In this case it would appear that the objective likelihood of risk is very low. The risk that someone at Wegner would be both upset and motivated enough to send hate mail to you in Australia over a single reproduction of a chair is also very low (but admittedly unpredictable).
It is NOT unethical to copy the design of a chair. You have conscientiously considered and weighed the ramifications of your actions and have, perhaps shortsightedly, consulted the all knowing internet as well. You have good reason to believe that there are no issues other than pique that might arise. Ethical requirements have, I believe, been satisfied. But then I'm an attorney so what do I know?
I look forward to your always entertaining and informative write up on building the chair and to reading the massive intellectual property disclaimer that you are probably going to start including in all of your content. 
Good luck,
Chris
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
Jesper, Denmark
Derek,
There are two clues in the eBay offer to sell "The Chair" as originals:
"May not be shipped to Denmark"
and
"Original Teak Frames"
Customs in Denmark would most likely impound them on entry and the originals (as you know) were built in Oak, not teak.
PP, the current manufacturer is a rather small company, and trying to defend whatever rights exist in a US court is likely to be prohibitively expensive.
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
Tom
"Perhaps the manufacturers just do not care to defend a copyrite? And if they do not do so, then that is tacit approval to be copied?"
Unless it is explicit it probably can't be assumed to be approval of anything. It could just as easily be their way of not spending all their time chasing stuff they can't stop. What are they supposed to do, tell people they aren't chasing them?
Rob's break out doesn't deal at the level of ethics it deals with the issues around promoting copyright infringement. The reality is that anyone who might have wanted to build the chair, but was too stupid or lazy to reverse engineer it themselves, now has instructions, and kinda your stamp of approval. This affects the rights owner, though the marginal effect is minimal, as it pretty much always is.
Just for fun, a few other points:
1) We all learn by copying. Consider what other things you have made that are blatant copies of the work of others, but you just didn't give it much thought because you weren't in the presence of a master designer. It's prudent when violating the rights of important entities to consider their reaction, but at the level of ethics it doesn't make much difference.
2 To me it isn't just the chair. You are essentially manufacturing content, that you "sell", that is your blogging, using someone's trademarked name. If you wish to see that as an ethical issue you can. It would be like my making a holster and marketing it on ebay, as a John Wayne model. I'm not selling John Wayne DVDs, but I am pulling on his name to sell my product, a kind of triangle. That gets done all the time, though they are called "Duke" holsters.
3) There is what the kids like to call your "brand". Assuming you could figure out the legal and ethical issues, put those aside. Is it good for your brand to copy stuff. Seems like it wouldn't be. Seems like an obvious wedge issue, where people will either think it is fine or not, and further disagree on the reason that they come to those conclusions. I have a hard time seeing that as a brand win, you are giving up control.
Would it be a brand win for LV to bring out one of their tie clip sized planes in a Hotley version, even if there weren't any legal issues. It was cool to do it in the shape of one of their own planes, as an exercise for the staff. It made me think their full size planes were a better value, oddly. But it would seem like some kind of derivative stunt, possibly mean if they did a Hotley.
I don't actually like The Chair all that much, and the joinery doesn't look all that interesting. There isn't anything all that novel about a fishtail splice, if that is what I am seeing. Not sure it really will reflect all that well. If you want to get into the area of making machine joints by hand, it would help to come up with some exclusively machine joints, and then maybe just do them without reflecting on someone else's work.
4) When I started out in my teens, I was in a professional family, and I had this conceit that I would always design my own stuff. I felt that merely making it was a little beneath me. Hey, I was young. These days I do make "copies"n of stuff I might be able to buy, though usually I want something I see, ++. Anyway, as I think I have mentioned here before, when one copies something one is in a kind of loose, loose situation. If it works out, all credit is due to the original designer/maker. But if it is a bust (flaws possibly present in the original), it's my fault, because I presumably messed up the copy. I do it nonetheless, but I sure don't blog about it.
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
Tom
"... other than pique that might arise. Ethical requirements have, I believe, been satisfied. But then I'm an attorney so what do I know?"
Well, let's see...
https://www.google.ca/search?q=lawyer%27s+ethics+jokes&client=firefox-a&hs=o4s&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=ZRGqUqDqH4HdqgHZkYCwBA&ved=0CAcQ_AUoAQ&biw=939&bih=456
How is "pique" not an ethical issue. Isn't that saying that causing others pain is not an ethical issue, because you are legally entitled to do so? While I believe some people won't care and take it onboard ethically, it certainly could and should be regarded as an ethical issue in my mind. One can't know how another person will react. If they have some kind of heightened sensitivity, I would feel justified, if I didn't know, to use a normal standard in assessing whether I would cause pain. Of course they may not be at the average, if their rights are constantly being violated by others.
I would also say it pretty much automatically goes beyond pique, to the fairly universal test which is do unto others as you would have them do unto you. I am guessing that lawyers feel pretty strongly about that since they operated under a legal monopoly.
I cannot discern . . . *LINK*
CJ in MPLS
whether I'm being helpful or simply pedantic, but here (below) is a good case on whether furniture is copyrightable.
Functional items are not copyrightable. Aesthetic features may be copyrightable if they are "conceptually separable" from the underlying functional aspects of the object. This idea is described elsewhere as follows:
“conceptual separability exists where there is any substantial likelihood that even if the article had no utilitarian use it would still be marketable to some significant segment of the community simply because of its aesthetic qualities.”
Where as here we are talking about the epitome of spare, form-follows-function style, copyrights are going to be hard to support. For example, while the curve of the arms of the chair are very aesthetic, there simply doesn't appear to be an aesthetic feature that can or does exist independent of the functional aspects of the arms of the chair.
On further review, what I've written is really just a more complicated way of reiterating what you said. It's just nice to have everyone using the same terminology I guess.
Cheers,
CJ
http://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Published/072180.P.pdf
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
CJ in MPLS
Tom:
I suppose pique could be an ethical issue in some circumstances. It is not in this case. Pique relates more to one's perceptions than to an objective standard of harm. Being solicitous of the feelings of others is a goal we should all strive for. But foregoing otherwise legal acts merely because moving ahead might engender "a feeling of irritation or resentment resulting from a slight, esp. to one's pride" isn't a particularly useful standard. Pique, by itself is not legally actionable.
As in all things there is a balance that we should seek. Making a one-off reproduction of a chair that is arguably not covered by IP rights doesn't seem to me to upset the ethical apple cart.
CJ
Re: Derek, ethics, and The Chair.....
Bruce, a MN Galoot
CJ, the email listed in your profile doesn't work. Will you shoot me an email? I have a personal question for you.
Sounds like a Windsor ....
Bruce McCrory
This looks more like a Windsor copy similarity the more you discuss, debate it. Is there any record of "Windsor" chasing copies with his adze?
The chair had a certain appeal early in the discussion. Now, I think I would prefer to move on with my own seating spin.
Re: Sounds like a Windsor ....
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
Actually to see the design influences for the 'chair' you need to look further back. There are some clear similarities to some of Wegners other designs, in particular his wishbone chair which is his version of a Ming dynasty chair.
Robin