New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Subtleties of shaving deflection

Posts

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#76

Re: clarification

William Duffield

When I explain the strengths and weaknesses in wood, especially oak and other ring porous woods, to people just trying to grasp the concepts, I often use the expression, "Tear along dotted line." They seem to get that image immediately. (It might not be so useful in Europe, where people are not so familiar with American idioms.)

Another concept that seems to help is to suggest that they imagine a bundle of paper (or plastic, in the case of purpleheart :) ) soda straws soaked in sticky Coca Cola.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#77

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Winton Applegate

How long can we string this thread?

Ha, ha, ha

I know a guy, Hi Mel, who started a thread, "jointer planes", and kept it going for like six or seven thousand entries.

I got a bag of coffee beans here and a battery charger and spare batteries for my wireless keyboard so I'm game.

Rat holes are in bounds as long as you use the trem "plane" or "wood" in the post. Varieties and variations on the spelling of those terms are fair game, (thats to cover me when my water cooled, industrial, extra heavy duty cycle, spell checker is down for rebuild).

Readysetgo

PS: hey I am able to edit on my iPad again ! Yeh! Thanks for the tip on how to fix that, I was a little slow figuring out where I screwed it up to start with.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#78

Hey Joe

Winton Applegate

Old chip breaker.

I can see how the new all flat ones support the blade better. Not really as good as a thicker blade though.

#40 ?

Yes LN single iron. They describe it as :

Based on the Stanley 40 1/2,

I am quite pleased with it.

Scrubs are fun and tricky to sharpen. The way I sharpen the main bevel is leave the blade in the plane and stick it way out if that makes any sense.

Back bevel with the LV mark II jig. There is a back bevel setting on that. Not too critical though. Plane cross grain or diagonal; which ever seems to tear out less. If diagonal I go both ways, right to left and left to right. Gives you a chance to build up your non dominate hand planing muscles without really messing anything up. That is if you are right handed then you have your left hand on the tote.

When you back bevel, how much and at what angle?

about five degrees but really that is based on the wood you are working. Experiment to determine what works best.

How much ?

I am not sure I understand the question but I will say the smallest amount at the edge is all that matters. The bevel gets wider from more sharpening though.

Have you continued to use the back bevel, or did you return to a flat back?

On the LN bronze finish plane shown in the previous post I most definitely returned to the flat back and would only back bevel at gun point. I sharpen often and it is a pain in the rear to maintain ; for my perfectionist ways anyway.

For the Scrub I have two blades (thought I would buy more but the scrub stays sharp enough to work for a long time so I don't need a stack of blades). I have one back beveled and one flat.

Thanks for any further info.

Thanks for keeping this chat room interesting with your interest in my interests.

Winton

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#79

Belgium Walnut Table

Winton Applegate

Kees,

Thank you for the photo of your work !

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#80

Re: Hey Joe

Joe shelton

You use the plane itself as a honing jig? Why would you do that? Are you honing with a 30 terrabyte flux capacitor?

I'll follow you anywhere. I have an idle sense of curiosity.

Joe

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#81

Re: And another thing

david weaver

I only read the first part of your post, and looked at the picture. I wouldn't have any trouble planing that board with a stanley bench plane.

A lie nielsen's bedrock semi-copy is similar. This is a case where the problem isn't the arrow.

Warren used to tell me that. It irritated me because I wasn't getting it at first, mostly because the first time I ever set a cap iron close, the plane was harder to push (it was a little closer than it needed to be) and I concluded that using a back bevel made more sense.

It doesn't, however, I found that out when I had to eliminate it to plane soft maple, 60+ degrees of bevel angle dulls it. It's also impossible to take a practical quick work shaving with it (something like 6 thousandths thick) for very long.

There's no reason you have to use the cap iron, but inability to plane a board doesn't mean it's the plane that's limiting you.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#82

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Kees

Today I repaired the movable mouthpiece from my Ulmia smoother. Man that thing rocks! Lignum vitae sole, very easy to adjust with a hamer, capiron(!), 49 degree bed. Much much much nicer then any heavy metal plane.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#83

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

david weaver

How does the iron attach to the plane? I bought an emmerich or whatever primus smoother last year, and as much as I wanted to like it, I couldn't deal with the way the iron was retained in the plane -not convenient.

Plus, it didn't solve any problems I have with a stanley bailey smoother, nor with the mujingfang version of the continental smoother (which is a little less well finished, but has a supersteel iron in it and the entire plane is made of very hard wood - and I think it's common pitch).

So I sold it - just as I had bought it - cheap. It's tempting to view the ECE planes as an improvement on stanley planes, especially given that their marketing basically says that's what they are. But I can still do more work faster with a stanley bench plane, and there wasn't really any difference in the finishes between the two planes.

I probably would have a different viewpoint on it if I'd have been fortunate enough to get one with a wedge and hammer adjustment, but the mujis already are that and with a much better iron.

However, I did get a hold of an older ulima double iron rabbet plane with a laminated iron (instead of a modern chrome vanadium iron) and its quite nice. One of the older ulmias with such an iron would be nice for people who don't like the short nose of a stanley smoother (paraffin takes care of any friction issues, and is super cheap here - probably on the order of 50 cents per year).

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#84

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Kees

Mine is an older one with a levercap and a central screw. Adjusting with a hammer. I was exagerating a bit, but I really like the feel. The lv sole is superslick. No compare with a waxed steel plane. The wax wears offquickly too.

I was also playing a bit with the Stanley. One blade with the capiron, the other with a 10 degree backbevel. The latter drags more and doesn't cut as smootly.

So, completely subjective how ite feels: the woodies with capiron come first. The Stanley with capiron second. Then the Stanley with backbevel. And last my homemade 55 degree wooden plane. I think the last one is just too light for such a high angle.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#85

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

david weaver

Light planes and figured woods, especially if there is a heavy cut or knots - are an elbow jarring, and sometimes finger jarring experience. Very undersirable when you're sweating it out a little bit and fatigued.

For use, I would put a stanley bailey at the top, as i always have paraffin wax around (and because they all seem to work the same if they are decent quality), then double iron woodies (including the mujis) and my infill planes probably tied - for very different reasons.

Stanley iron planes are a bit of an acquired taste when you compare them against something that is very slick, but they are deadly accurate and on the heavier ones with wax and the mental note to push the plane forward instead of down (which just creates extra work for the user to push through the friction), you can remove a lot of wood quickly with them. I see a LOT of people leaning on their planes when they're tired, which just creates the illusion that the plane is in need of sharpening or very hard to push.

Same with lower angle infills, push forward instead of bearing down on them (which you can get away with on wooden planes, the friction is so low it hardly matters if you lean on them or don't if there is any wax involved at all).

This reminds me that I need to dump some planes.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#86

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Kees

Here is a picture of my Ulmia. I guess it is a 1930's model.

To get familiar with setting a wooden plane with a hammer, I used them exclusively for half a year. For me it is still faster to set a Stanley, but now I am not afraid to do it anymore. It just takes a couple of extra seconds.


img

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#87

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

david weaver

That's a nicer design than the primus design with a long rod that extends through the body of the plane.

Does it have a sprung chipbreaker that moves a little when you set it? The mujingfangs do, and I'd presume they just copied them from ulmia.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#88

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I worked at a historic site in 1978 we had some nice Ulmia planes: a double iron beech coffin smoother, a double iron beech "English Pattern" jack plane (17"), and a double iron trying plane. All were buttress and wedge, appropriate for a historic site and all worked very well. The trying plane may have had a Carpinus sole. Woodcraft carried them back when they were a hand tool company.

I was away for a few days. It is surprising how people with apparently little experience with double iron use nevertheless felt compelled to comment on the subtleties. I would say that if you are not getting a better surface at 45 degrees (double iron) than at 55 degrees, something is wrong. Smaller differences in angle like between 45 and 47 or between 45 and 42 are harder to notice.

I think that if a double iron plane is noticeably difficult to push, it is an indication that the shaving thickness is too great for the the cap iron setting. Cutting in the sweet range is very smooth. It reminds me of Frank Pain's words on turning, "cutting the wood the way the wood wants to be cut".

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#89

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Kees

Yes, it shifts around when you tighten the screw, which is irritating. Maybe I'll put a Stanley capriron in.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#90

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Tom

I've had good luck with the ECE, I do find the rod thing inconvenient, but I don't have to change the blade much because it is blue steel. I Sometimes forget that pre LN i pretty much tossed every blade that came with a western plane as part of the "unboxing". So I may have an odd perception as to their relative value given that the blade is key, and I have never really used the ones that came with them after the first few trips through that swamp. Back then, plane blades took a significant amount of work to get a usable edge so it wasn't even worth a look-see to see if something have slipped through the "quality control".

My ECE planes basically fill a slot for wooden planes where I can do stuff like ship them, or take them to a seminar, and not really care what happens. But they don't have the power to stay in the rotation. The height, the chip clearance, etc... I don't only use Japanese planes, home made planes, and a few oddballs like a Noris block plane, but they are the only ones that stay in the rotation. So if you want an ECE type wedged plane, that would seem like something worth spending 45 minutes on.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#91

Re: Couple questions 'bout K&K

Kees

Well, I am one of these who don't see a difference. Point is, I get a pretty good surface with a high angle plane allready. With the 45 degree plane and the capiron set tight enough to avoid tearout, I don't see any improvement in the surface. Yesterday I tried a bit of spruce, very soft and very easy to tear around some pin knots. Both planes made the surface glossy with sparkling detail. Both blades were sharp.

Probably a personal problem.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#92

Very Easy To Adjust With a Hammer

Winton Applegate

Ha, ha, ha,

Taken out of context or read by a newbie that sounds funny.

I know what you mean but if I told my customers "Yah I was able to fix your expensive precision machine. It was very easy to adjust with a hammer". I might get some pained looks (though some times that is precisely the way I made the adjustment).

Mostly I am posting to say I am with you. I went with the "New" and "Improved" version. I forget now exactly how they describe it but that is close.

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_2392_zps5d7affa1.jpg.html][/URL]

Though for some of the hard stuff I mentioned, for me, it is still . . . nah dude, nah give me the bevel up iron job.