New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Subtleties of shaving deflection

Posts

Subtleties of shaving deflection

#1

Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

It's now more then a year since the Kato/Kawai video was republished. I'm sure everyone has a lot of practice now, and might have found some little practical tricks. Let's share some experience.

For me, the single most difficult thing is preparing the capiron so it sits flush with the back of the blade with no light showing through. When you use the capiron very close to the edge, any small gap is an entry point for the shaving to pry it open and shove itself under the caprion. Most every capiron in my shop wasn't flat enough. I could have bought precision machined LN capirons and been done with it, but being a cheapskate I choose to repair the old ones. They usually are convex, so I start with narrow pieces of sandpaper on a glassplate to make it concave first. Using somewhat wider pieces I slowly work the concavity flatter until I am done. Check often, it's easy to go too far and recreate the convexity again.

With some capirons it is very difficult to adjust it very close to the edge. Especially when tightening the screw, the capiron seems to move again. I don't really have an answer for this. Sometimes it is a problem with the screw being off to one side, so putting pressure on one side only. Or the capiron just slips around because everything is too smooth. Roughing up the caprion at the top end might help a little bit. If nothing helps I tend not to use that plane anymore or use it as a jackplane.

With the capiron resting nicely flat on the back of the iron, it's time to think about the angle of the leading edge of the capiron. I know that the Japanese video encourages to use a very steep angle, something like 75 degrees. I've seen older German documents where they even use a 90 degree wall. So first this was were I was heading. Problem with such a steep leading edge is the increased effort of pushing the plane. And I don't know exactly what happens to the wood when you put so much pressure onto it.

So I have been experimenting with much lower angles lately. This on advice from Caspar Labarre, a Dutch cabinetmaker with a deep interest in historic woodworking methds. In my Stanley smoother I now use a 45 degree angle. Of course, you need to set the capiron closer to the edge, compared to the higher angled capiron. But it pays of in much reduced effort to push the plane.

In my wooden smoother I even use a lower angle, about 35 degrees. According to Caspar you have an extra mechanism in a wooden plane. The shaving curls forward and hits the wear of the plane, then curves back and forth between capiron and wear until it exits from the thoat of the plane. These curls have friction between these two walls and thus help to support themselves. So you can get away with less support from the capiron itself, because you have this extra support higher up. I don't know if it really works like this, but I do know now that such a low angle works. You have to set the capiron really close to the edge of course. Pushing the plane now feels as if there is no chipbreaker effect going on at all, but you still have the benefit of no tear out.

I happen to have two 49 degree planes with a double iron. I didn't do any structural analyzing of these, but subjectively I'd say they perform a little better on very curly grain.

In none of my planes I use a very tight mouth. Bailey style planes benefit from the extra support under the blade when you pull the frog back. And a really tight mouth in a wooden plane is a rare occurance, not often found in the wild. Because the chipbreaker effect is so strong, I don't feel faffing around with all kinds of combinations of tear out reduction methods is worthwhile. And when everything gets too tight around the mouth, clogging is just waiting to happen. But I'm sure others will feel different about this.

Hope this encourages some discussion.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#2

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Kees,

Thanks for a good opening for what, yes, I hope will be a useful discussion. I'm curious about what you mean by making the cap iron concave - across which dimension? If you have a digital camera and the time, a photo or two might be helpful.

Bill

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#3

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Lars Parrington

i agree with a lot of what you say.

i also tried higher angles on cap irons at first but have settled in at about 45 degrees. i don't think i'm setting mine as close to the edge as you. i'm at least 10-15 thou away.

i also had a fair amount of trouble with shavings forcing their way between the cap iron and the blade. fettling the edge of the cap iron helps, but is sometimes not enough. i've learned that setting the lever cap to clamp down tighter helps.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#4

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

Here I have a picture from the Lee Valley capiron. The edge, highlighted in the lower left corner, should be flat all the way across from left to right. If this edge is not flat (straight) but concave, the capiron will wobble on the blade and there are gaps on both sides between capiron and blade. When you peek in the area between the two and hold it up to a light, you can see very well if the fit is good or not.


img

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#5

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

Yes, I recognise that! I had to give the screw on my jointer a quart turn to make it tighter, which solved any tendencies for the shaving to dive under the capiron. Of course thsi doesn't solve a poor fit, but it helps when the natural spring in the capiron isn't as much as it should be anymore.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#6

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Kees, Lars, and all,

Kees' post motivated me to go fettle my ECE smooth plane. Has a Hock iron in it, and the original ECE chip breaker. Just sharpened it up, and the chipbreaker was sharp too, so I let it go at that. I set the iron according to a method I read elsewhere--I stuck the blade straight down with a bit of pressure into a cherry offcut that was laying around, then moved the chipbreaker down the blade til it was flush. Then set it right there, with the blade perhaps a shaving width into the cherry.

Results: Pretty good, in terms of planing curly maple against the grain. But the action seemed a bit rough, and I figured I didn't have the gap set right. Took the blade and breaker apart, and found 3 or 4 little pieces of shaving right in the middle between blade and breaker--the same thing that Kees' emphasized, and Lars seconded.

I first checked for light leak, to see what was going on. I found I needed to look from behind, with the blade/breaker held against the light--if I examined the sandwich straight on from the edge, I couldn't detect any light. But it was obvious, sighting from the rear. Of course, I didn't know whether the curvature was on the blade or breaker, so checked them individually against the stock of a reference square, once more against the light. It was the breaker--concave, which is why the shavings collected in the center.

Now let me say something right here--the ECE breaker is a very well-made item. It's not slapdash at all. Forged with an angle at the end, and the end is machined and polished. There is relief behind the edge, so that the very tip of the breaker meets the blade back in a knife edge. It looked so well done, that I never thought to check it! My point: Always check--you can get fooled, as I did. Anyway, I flattened the breaker back on a diamond reference plate--would have used fine PSA on a granite plate if I hadn't had the diamond plate. Checked it--no more light leak.

Put the plane all back together. Now the action is much better, because there is no back pressure from shavings getting clogged. And no tearout against the grain.

Couple of takeaways from this experience:

1. I like the blade/breaker setting technique described above. Blade stabbed into wood, breaker brought flush. It makes sense to me, and it releases me from searching for the right light reflectance, etc. For those who have any difficulty getting the right distance, try it.

2. Totally agree with Kees' observation about blade/breaker fit. Main point is--check it, looking from the rear of the blade/breaker into the light. If there is relief behind the breaker edge (can see it from the side), it's an easy fix to lap away the light leak, after determining which piece is curved (it'll be the breaker, 10:1, I would guess.) But if there is no relief behind the breaker, that will need to be filed in, or if you hate metal work $25-30 worth, buy a breaker from Hock, LN, or LV.

Excellent post, Kees!!

Wiley

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#7

Not sure I'm right, but...

Joe shelton

...I think it best to spend the time required to get a solid fit between cap iron and blade. I've had enough trouble with this interface on old planes that, a time or two I've used a hammer, lightly, to increase the camber of the cap iron at the leading edge, and then have better ground and fitted the double iron.

I have not had a failure from over-tightening the lever cap, but have had to replace screws in old planes because the heads were worn out and wouldn't engage the lever cap well. My reaction to this is to concentrate on the fit between the cap iron and blade.

And, lurking, there are several outstanding improved double irons that solve the problem and supercharge the plane, too.

Joe

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#8

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

And check the Hock, LN or LV too, you'll never know!

Once I bought one of the Chinese Quangsheng capirons (Woodriver brand in America I think) because I was too lazy to repair the Stanley one. I could have saved my money because this one was just as concave as the old Stanley.

Good luck with your Ulmia plane, they're nice!

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#9

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Kees,

You're right about the Ulmia/ECE planes. Mostly I use Clark & Williams/Old Street and Konrad Sauer. But the ECE is always nearby, and I don't even know why. It's handy, but I don't know why exactly.

My point about the Hock, LN, and LV is that they will reliably have relief behind the tip, right from the factory. Concavity is easy to lap out of anything, but filing relief is a job some folks won't want to do. Not saying who :) .

Wiley

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#10

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I like the bevel on the cap iron to be rounded, not flat. I think if the cap iron is so close to the edge as to make a noticeable difference in planing effort, then it is probably too close for the shaving thickness.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#11

Nah, nah, nah, nah dude, nah

Winton

I am known for my novella length posts.

Today is not one of those days.

Short, cut the _____, done

Allow me to be "That Guy"

How do I like cap irons ? Let me count the ways . . .

= 0

Pointless objects. When I need a closely set cap iron I go :

http://www.planemaker.com/products.html

and in those rare cases that ain't doin' it

http://www.veritastools.com/Products/Page.aspx?p=93

Hey look Ma no cap iron. Perfect performance. How can this be ?

Usually I will argue either side just for the sake of arguing. Not when it comes to cap iron/ chip breaker /blade bender downer /futz buckets.

Those links aren't too lively so :

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/smooth.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/OhYah.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#12

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Lars Parrington

setting the cap iron back by only a shavings width sounds way too close to me. but if it works, it works.

i switched to a LV cap iron in my primary smoother (stanley #4) a few months ago. i upgraded to a pmv-11 iron at the same time. the LV cap iron never gives me any trouble, though i think i honed it before ever putting it to use. the pmv-11 iron on the other hand, i'm not yet convinced it actually holds an edge any better than the stock stanley iron it replaced.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#13

I prefer Feather shaving.

Bruce McCrory

I just can't clear up the stubble underneath. :D

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#14

Re: Nah, nah, nah, nah dude, nah

Kees

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/smooth.jpg.html][/URL]

Nice plane, dude! Where can I buy one, and does it cost only 20 euro? :D

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#15

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

That's 30 years experience, I guess. I tend to set it quite close to the edge, if the wood looks to be troublesome, and accept the increased effort to push the plane. I don't like to fumble around too much, blade in, blade out, adjust the chipbreaker etc. But now, with the reduced angle on front of the chipbreaker, the effort of pushing the plane is much reduced, even when setting it as close as I can.

This Dutch guy Caspar Labarre comes from a woodworking family where he learned tricks like this. I include a picture from him, describing the effect of the shaving curling inside the throat of the plane between chipbreaker and the wear, and thus giving support to prevent tearout. At least that is the theory.

It is similar to the technique when using a low angled moulding plane on troublesome wood, where you can block the throat with your hand, and thus create a supporting mass of shavings (clogging in fact). I don't know if that technique was used in Britain, where they had high angle moulding planes, but it seems to have been used overhere in The Netherlands where only 45 and 50 degree moulding planes were available.


img

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#16

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

I overspoke. I don't actually know the setback I get when pushing the blade into wood (whether it's one shaving or four shavings) and bringing the chip breaker flush. Depends on how I do it, and which wood, how much pressure--I'm still experimenting. But it worked the first try. Shaving slightly accordioned; no tearout against grain.

What I like is that, for me at least, it gives a more reliable setting than doing it by eye. And mainly, it takes the fiddling out of the process. I don't get movement between blade and breaker whilst tightening the screw, because both blade and breaker are pinned against the wood.

I just mention it as an option for those having difficulty getting the setback the way they want it, in a reasonable amount of time.

That's an interesting anecdote about the LV patented iron. Please tell more as you gather experience with it.

Wiley

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#17

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

David Charlesworth

Kees,

Making the underside edge of the c/b flat so it fits the blade, can be done with a diamond stone or flat oilstone. The top of the c/b is supported on a small stick, say roughly 1/4 Inch wide. The height needs to be about 2mm or 3/32" lower than the surface of the stone.

This produces a 1 to 2 degree clearance angle so that we know the front edge touches the blade back, after the lever cap has been tightened. (The back of blade must be flat in it's width, near to the edge).

I will say again, that in my experience all c/b front edges need a little work to perfect them, no matter where they were made.

It seems to me that the diagram of a shaving in the wear of a wooden plane, is most unlikely to affect the finish. The action is far too far away from the edge. Kawai Kato show us that in their research, the action takes place very close to the edge. A matter of thousandths of an inch. Perhaps 4 to 8?

Best wishes,

David charlesworth

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#18

Re: Nah, nah, nah, nah dude, nah

Steve Voigt

[Nice plane, dude! Where can I buy one, and does it cost only 20 euro?]

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

None for sale on the bay, but I checked completed listings. You should expect to pay $700 or more, if/when one comes up for sale.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#19

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

Kees

Yes I have my doubts about that theory too. Today I grinded my Stanley #6 capiron to a 35 degree bevel and it works flawlessly too. For example, I had some wallnut crotch, with the grain going everywhere, and it was no problem to flatten and smooth it. So no real difference in performance with the woodie.

So, you can get away with remarkably low angles. I wonder where it stops? Probably will never find out, too much work. It's not very usefull info either.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#20

Just a thought, not an argument

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

For the most part, I use Clark & Williams/Old Street and Konrad Sauer infills, neither of which rely on chip breakers.

At the same time, I have high regard for those who have developed the skill to do critical planing with close-set chipbreakers. It's a good skill to have. I'm making it a point to learn it myself, on ECE, LN, and Japanese planes. Every skill you have is synergistic with every other skill, because they all embody physical principles about sharp steel and grain. Skills build upon skills, and are themselves built upon.

Does that mean I'm looking to change my planes? No way. But I want to have this skill.

Wiley

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#21

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

wilbur

If you look back at the end of the Kato-Kawai video, where the conclusions are stated, Kato and Kawai say that increasing the angle of the chipbreaker "wall" reduces tearout, and that 80º was more effective than 50º. But they go on to say that the net effect of this is that the chipbreaker can be set further back from the edge with the 80º chipbreaker.

My feeling is that at this level, the angle of the chipbreaker edge and the distance that the chipbreaker is set back from the edge are not fully independent variables when it comes to tearout. My guess is that an 80º chipbreaker set further back can be equivalent in reducing tearout compared to a 50º chipbreaker set closer to the edge.

It's not clear which setup is easier to push, and the Kato-Kawai experiment was not set up to determine that issue. If I had to bet, I would say that an increased effort in pushing the plane is mainly a function of how close the chipbreaker is to the edge.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#22

Re: Just a thought, not an argument

Steve Voigt

For the most part, I use Clark & Williams/Old Street and Konrad Sauer infills, neither of which rely on chip breakers.

At the same time, I have high regard for those who have developed the skill to do critical planing with close-set chipbreakers. It's a good skill to have. I'm making it a point to learn it myself, on ECE, LN, and Japanese planes. Every skill you have is synergistic with every other skill, because they all embody physical principles about sharp steel and grain. Skills build upon skills, and are themselves built upon.

Does that mean I'm looking to change my planes? No way. But I want to have this skill.

See, this is just such a sensible perspective. I think it's silly to argue that the Kato/Kawai video "proved" that double irons are better, but it's equally silly, especially in the face of all the evidence over the last year, to keep insisting that chipbreakers are useless. Props to Kees for trying to start a conversation about the subtleties of one particular technique, rather than more fruitless arguing about which technique is best.

Wiley--Clark/Williams + Sauer infills = one cool shop. I'm green with envy. If I still lived in SoCal, I'd be knocking on your door, demanding to see all that coolness, but since I'm stuck on the other coast, I'll just have to use my imagination.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#23

Re: Just a thought, not an argument

Kees

Ha, my shop is exactly the oposite! Only old, simple stuff. Mostly because I like old simple stuff. It's kind of a hobby to resurect them. But this also explains my interest in this topic. I don't have any high angle, tight mouth stuff. Maybe I'll get around to make some wooden planes this winter and add a 55 degree small smoother to the mix.

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#24

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection *LINK*

Kees

Like I said on woodnet (why don't we just merge all woodworking forums? :b ), Kato and Kawai did investigate the forces involved. See for the article the provided link. It is in fig. 6. The horizontal force Ph is what you feel when pushing the plane. As you can see, the force is most when the distance is only 0.1mm. But the 40 degree capiron needs quite a bit less force then the 80 degree one. At 0.2mm and a capiron with 40 degree bevel the force is almost the same as a plane without a capiron.

Subjectively, I agree with that graph. Especially the wooden plane floats almost over the shaving like a surfboard.


http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html

Re: Subtleties of shaving deflection

#25

Re: Ticked

Tom

The underlying story here is that this info was out there in western literature all along, and was obvious in Japanese plane design all along. The fact that the main popularisers where negative to anything that wasn't in the scientific literature, just held all this back. It just compounds the felony to make this a KK thing when all they were doing was quantifying stuff that every carpenter already knew in Japan ( and presumably elsewhere). When someone comes along and tries to quantify for machine tools something from hand tools, then gets the credit... Seems a little perverse. And we all know about it because we wanted it for hand tools? There was a more direct line.