New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

chisel handles

Posts

Re: chisel handles

#51

Re: Where did the second post go?

David Weaver

that had a nice picture of the logs waiting at disston. It clearly showed that not all of them were 3 foot wide solid center clear trees.

One of the problems with the largest of the abandoned trees around here (apple trees with trunks 2+ feet wide on private property is they are usually in some state of disease and the trunks are rotted in the middle.

Re: chisel handles

#52

Another Disston source on applewood *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

I can't get it to reproduce but I googled for disston applewood for saw handles and clicked on an entry for The Disston Crucible, A Magazine for the Millman. It shows a picture of apple logs delivered to the factory and says they come from all over the East.


http://www.google.com/search?q=disston+applewood+for+saw+handles&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-Address&ie=&oe=#q=disston+applewood+for+saw+handles&hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-Address&ei=BWtUUcONIciErAGH7oC4BQ&start=20&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.

Re: chisel handles

#53

Re: Disston use of rare or extinct apple

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Patrick,

"Up until their sale to H. K. Porter in about 1954, Disston made saws with applewood handles."

--------

Just a slight correction in the interest of historical accuracy. According to the Disstonian Institute, Disston discontinued apple wood handles some years prior to the sale to H. K. Porter in 1955. A quote from the Disstonian Institute's entry on D-8 saws:

"This is the typical D-8 handle after 1928, with the color varying with the wood species and coloring under the lacquer. Handles can be anywhere from blonde to brown to red, depending on when it was made. The handles were apple until about 1947, when they were changed to beech, as these handles demonstrate. The D-8 was sold until shortly after the acquisition of Disston by HK Porter in 1955."

And again, from the Disstonian Institute's discussion of the No. 12 and D-12 saws:

"D-12's still had applewood handles through the 1930's and 40's. When the D-12 was introduced in 1928, the handle changed to a smoother shape at the top with the cutaway for the web of the hand in two handed-use and had grown an extra nut. There are five saw nuts instead of the earlier four. Notice that the shape of the handle becomes blockier and less ornate with every passing decade.

This is an example of a D-12 about 1950 with a walnut handle, and its appearance is a far cry from that of the saws made 70 years earlier."

Wiley

Re: chisel handles

#54

Re: Another Disston source on applewood

David Weaver

having trouble with that one. Hopefully this one works.

http://books.google.com/books?id=M_1DAAAAIAAJ&pg=PA74&lpg=PA74&dq=disston+apple+wood+logs&source=bl&ots=V5ygefm6Ki&sig=j5xBdzdU4_zYiYtL0gu7NF0AbvQ&hl=en&sa=X&ei=rmtUUdShEPW64APXzoCwBg&ved=0CDwQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=disston%20apple%20wood%20logs&f=false

(scroll up one page above the text in the link to see the picture of the logs).

Re: chisel handles

#55

good information

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Looking at the pile in the center if we assume a typical stick spacing the lumber is but 5-6' in length. A typical mill carriage will not support such a short log. Obviously sawed from very short logs on a special mill, consistent with the orchard source theory.

BTW, these are the sloppiest piles I have even seen on a yard. One strives to have sticks one above the other to avoid sagging, and the pile ends square and never leave ends unsupported. The center pile violates all these rules.

The three year air drying is baloney. This lumber will be as dry as it will ever get outdoors in 6-12 months.

Re: chisel handles

#56

Cost of Applewood to Disston in 1912  *LINK*


http://books.google.com/books?id=FtQoAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA95&ots=dKnc2B4DRd&dq=use%20of%20applewood%20to%20make%20saw%20handles&pg=PA96#v=onepage&q=use%20of%20applewood%20to%20make%20saw%20handles&f=false

Re: chisel handles

#57

Re: Cost of Applewood to Disston in 1912

Patrick Gibbons

Notice it was $17.31 for 1000 bf of beech and $40.00 for apple.

Re: chisel handles

#58

It is worse than it looks

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Given the astounding low quality of the logs the lumber would have been substantially less yield than the beech, making the finished product the almost 2X cost that someone found. Presuming that the conversion cost of lumber to handle is maybe 10X the materials cost, the lumber cost for apple to yield a handle costing nearly twice as much was staggering.

Re: chisel handles

#59

A large thanks for finding this publication

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have " wasted" an hour reading it already. Fascinating information---at least to a lumber nut. I have ordered the book to waste yet more time.

Under apple I found the following . So what does that mean?

The other uses may have made cuttings too small for handles marketable and hence more practical to saw the crummy logs shown. Earlier in the discussion it was stated that its attraction for saws was entirely aesthetic, it took a high polish.

Perhaps the most interesting tidbit was that PA used 10X more mahogany in furniture this year than cherry or walnut. No wonder Honduras ran out!

Re: chisel handles

#60

OMG!!

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If you don't spend your spare time hanging around saw mills you may not appreciate how bad these logs are. They are 10X poorer than the worse walnut I ever saw in the height of the great walnut log shortage of a few years back. Most, maybe all, could not be sawed on a typical mill. The carriage would not hold them. The labor to saw would be times more then typical logs of that day where you rolled a log up onto the carriage and didn't need to roll another till 3 to 400 bdft of lumber was made. There isn't 50 bdft of lumber in those logs. I can now believe they came from orchards, fence rows, pastures and anywhere else junk trees prosper. The question remains as to what happened to all the clear but wild grained wood from near the knots, crotches etc. Could it be carved to handles?

This has been a fascinating discovery for a wood nut. Next time the question comes up there will be many experts to answer it.

Re: chisel handles

#62

Re: OMG!!

David Weaver

No, apple is so poorly behaved that you'd be able to use only straight sections of it if you wanted to do something on a production basis and have it be decent. If it warped with humidity changes, it would just project the warpage on the saw plate.

I would bet at the time they didn't have much trouble unloading the offcuts (which probably would've been the bulk of the material) for people to burn as firewood if they weren't good enough for anything else. A lot of philadelphia was probably coal fired and town gas in 1907, but wood like that is nice to burn when you can get it.

They are worse logs than I expected, too. They look a lot like the old trees that I saw pushed over in adams co. when I was young, back in the late 70s early 80s. I have no idea what most of those orchards did with their wood, but do recall seeing some of them selling it as firewood if you cut it yourself. There were a few specialty lumber places that dealt fruitwood, but the ones I've been able to find numbers for don't actually have it any longer.

I wouldn't be surprised to find out that the price for the apple parts was due solely to the trouble handling the logs and sawing them. No sawyer near me would take on any of those to do anything other than slab cut them, and they'd charge you more than they'd normally charge on long clear trees.

Might've been a losing proposition all the way around, as the mill men might've had more labor in them, but I doubt they loved it.

Re: chisel handles

#63

Re: you are misinformed about cherry. *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

How is this misinformed? Quoting from a U. S. Govt. publication, "Reaction to Competition- Black cherry is classed as intolerant of shade. Although black cherry seedlings are common under uncut stands and survive for 3 to 5 years, they do not live for extended periods or move up into larger size classes without moderate to heavy opening of the overstory canopy.

In sapling and larger sizes, black cherry trees are considered very intolerant of competition. Cherry trees are found primarily in the dominant and codominant crown classes. Those individuals that drop to lower crown levels decline in growth and soon die. Thus, diameter distribution of black cherry in even-aged stands follows the bell-shaped curve typical of intolerant species (51)."


http://www.na.fs.fed.us/pubs/silvics_manual/volume_2/prunus/serotina.htm

Re: chisel handles

#64

You are correct, Wiley


Re: chisel handles

#65

Re: Cost of Applewood to Disston in 1912

Patrick Gibbons

Also notice walnut was $81.90 and cherry was $50.00 for 1000 bf of lumber. Both more expensive than applewood.

Re: chisel handles

#66

need to read the fine print to understand prices

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Well, I expect most were not smitten by all the information on lumber manufacturer back then and didn't read most of the book. What struck me is how plastic and metal have replaced wood for fabrication of stuff.

Somewhere back about page 20 the details for assembling the data are described. The prices include veneer and the veneer is counted in an unconventional way. Suppose it was cut 1/16" thick. Then the cost of 16 pieces 1 x 1 foot would be included in the bdft price averages. This convention skews the price of woods that are used as veneer, especially the foreign woods as stated in the book, but also domestic veneered woods to a lesser amount.

There is a further complication to estimating the relative costs of the wood in the handle. The prices are not adjusted for lumber grade. Even in 1970 with a largely unautomated mill we did not harvest low grade logs. There was too much labor in sawing them. At that time I would expect that the yield in saw handles of a 1000 bdft of beech would have been times more than the yield from the logs shown in the picture.

I expect Diston paid almost nothing for the logs. Transportation cost would have been high as the bulk density of logs is much less than lumber. Conversion costs to lumber would be some higher as it is a nightmare sawing crummy logs. Yield from the lumber would be poor but the pipe and type usage may have provided a market for the clear cuttings too small for a handle. If we knew the conversion cost of lumber to handle we could estimate the relative cost of the blanks used for the handle from the difference in selling price of the finished handle, assuming the mark up was similar. A 5X difference in blank cost is not out of the question.

Re: chisel handles

#67

expert

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It seems that it was just Tuesday morning that you did not know anything at all about apple wood. Thought Disston must have been using something else and calling it apple. Now on Friday you are an expert on Disston's apple trade??

Re: chisel handles

#68

scott grandstaff

apple handle

scott grandstaff

Just one last thing

Even though there is no way it could ever be commercial, old pioneer planted, now bear broke down, and dead,

rotten apple tree stumps can still provide a small thrill.

Here is a saw tote I carved from just such a stump, in a #10 glove size.

A few year sago I went on a crusade against the "One size fits few" saw tote standard.

My friend Charlie Driggs has bear paw hands. 11's !

My old friend Bill Franklin had even larger mitts. 12's!!

The fact that nobody had ever made tool handles in different sizes suddenly struck me as outright creepy.

I began to scale saw and other totes to fit actual human hands.

Regular glove sizes.



yours Scott

Re: chisel handles

#69

An excellent idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

It is curious that Diston would offer handles in different wood but not different sizes. I solved my problem by finding an old saw with a comfy (much smaller) handle and replicating it for my most used Sandvick saw. The people in Sandvick land must have enormous hands. Not being "period" or politically correct I made it from cherry and it has served me well.

Re: chisel handles

#70

BadAxe does


Re: chisel handles

#71

Re: apple handle

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Scott

Now you got me wondering about the old dead apple orchard that I own!!!!

What a beautiful saw!

Work safe,

George

Re: chisel handles

#72

A lot of Saw Handles in this one *LINK*

Paul Dzioba


A 1780 applewood Chipendale Chest. Follow the link for a better picture that you can zoom in and scroll around. Must have come from a large tree!

Paul Dzioba


Applewood Chest

Re: chisel handles

#73

Re: A lot of Saw Handles in this one

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I had seen that too, Paul. I had planned to go over to Pook and Pook today for the preview, so if I see that chest I will look it over.

My largest apple tree is about 35 years old and 58 inches in circumference, about 18 1/2 inches diameter.

Re: chisel handles

#74

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

How did you find the picture? The picture is good enough that one could do a reproduction from it. Which leads to the thought that there are other pictures of stuff one might want to do a reproduction of if only one knew how to find them.

As far as handles, look closely. There isn't much straight grained area to be found. Which leads to a question of why this thing was built from apple in the first place. The failure of making a silk purse from a sow's ear comes to mind.

Re: chisel handles

#75

I love...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

the drawers on which the grain swirls are centered.