Apple and Pear
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Apple is not apple and pear is not pear? I don't think you have a clue what you are talking about. I have worked these woods for more than three decades. Please tell us what species you think these are.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Apple and Pear
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Apple is not apple and pear is not pear? I don't think you have a clue what you are talking about. I have worked these woods for more than three decades. Please tell us what species you think these are.
Disstonian Institute
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill and all,
Some info is found in Disstonian Institute:
http://www.disstonianinstitute.com/
Here's a piece on how handles were made, from 1907: Says among other things that, "The woods used chiefly for making handles are beech, apple, cherry, walnut and other hard woods. Beech is the wood generally used, but apple is the favorite." See here:
http://www.disstonianinstitute.com/sawhandle.html
Further scrutiny at Disstonian indicates that handle material varied by saw model, and by year of manufacture. For example, No. 7's and D-7's had beech handles. No. 8's and D-8's had apple handles until 1947, and beech thereafter. No. 12's and D-12's had apple handles until 1947 or so, then other hardwoods thereafter (DI mentions a walnut handle from 1950).
So it looks like your original thesis--that apple is a scarce wood for commercial use--is correct. It also appears that Disston was perfectly frank in its advertising as to what the handle wood was for each saw model.
Wiley
Per 1914 Henry Disston & Sons Catalog
Ron in Sterling, CT
The prices listed in the subject catalog for saw handles are as follows:
#7 Beech 26" Saw Handle: $2.50 per dozen
#8 Apple 26" Saw Handle: $4.00 per dozen
Ron
Re: Question
david weaver
beech is mostly harvested around here for firewood, especially in southern ohio. I can get it as lumber, it's about the same price as hard maple if it's quartersawn.
I'd imagine it was chosen for tooling both for it's price and it's qualities. Think about it. Birch or white oak or cherry could have easily been used, too, but beech was chosen ultimately over all of them.
I think your judgement is clouded because you haven't done enough working of these woods by hand, and I gather your posts about most of this stuff so far are tainted by the fact that you haven't done enough working of them by hand compared to cherry, oak, maple, etc.
I have to agree with warren's comments. I have no idea what it is you're trying to achieve here, but if disston's handles weren't apple, don't you think they would've called them whatever they were? I think most of us are at a loss here because you're describing some mystery wood that isn't like any others but it's not apple. And you're attempting to infer the value of beech for hand tools from the value of beech today.
What is your point exactly?
Good luck getting the exact price of a disston apple handle vs. one that's beech, they came on different models. In the cases where a model had one and then the other, they are from completely different eras.
Whatever the answer my hypothetically be, whether its' a dime or a nickel makes no difference. Apple is apple. I think you need to start dimensioning and smoothing more wood by hand to clue yourself in to just how different all of these woods are.
Re: I should've read further..
david weaver
.. before responding to bill's prior post. Whenever that was, apple was almost twice the price.
I am still totally baffled by this apple isn't apple theme, it makes no sense to me.
Re: Is traditional "apple" really apple?
Lars Parrington
i would add that the main reason apple trees are grafted is that apples are not true to seed. plant the five seeds from a red delicious apple and you will get five trees, none of which will bear similar (or delicious) fruit. while bad news for lovers of apples, this trait could be a boon for lovers of apple wood. the seeds of an apple grown commercially on a scrawny tree could easily grow into a tall an magestic tree from yesteryear. so next time you eat an apple, don't throw the core in the trash, throw it out the window.
your data adds to the mystery
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
"The KD domestic apple that I saw at hearne wasn't even close."
Your statement furthers the mystery as to what Diston used. I don't know much about saws and I don't spend unnecessary time carving on wood with hand tools (both irrelevant information to the discussion of what Diston used) but I do know about apples and growing them. There are some widely grown varieties that have been around for a very long time and they certainly overlap Diston's use of "apple" wood, for example Red and Yellow Delicious, Winesap, N. Spy etc. Above the graft a red delicious planted in 1960 and harvested to show up at Hearne in 2010 would be biologically the identical wood as a tree planted in 1910 and harvested for Diston in 1940. So, it would appear that Diston didn't use any old apple wood salvaged from any retired orchard.
Given that you state the easier working properties of apple vs beech the substantial premium of finished apple handles suggests the wood was indeed scarce, costing likely several times the price of beech lumber. This information opens up possibilities.
So , it would seem that what Diston calls "apple" could have been some variety of Mallus suited to manufacture of the product but likely not salvaged apple orchards, or at least not any apple orchard, and/or any tree in the orchard.
Finding out what exactly was used could make an interesting quest. Maybe it was the trees grown to produce seeds for root stock, or trees planted as pollinators, neither of which would be abundant or produce edible fruit, but might produce acceptable yields of suitable lumber.
Re: your data adds to the mystery
TomD
"It might not have been easy to clear cut huge amounts of it like they could do with cherry, red oak, white oak, etc, but they were making saw handles and not train cars, so if they had to come pooled from from pastures and yards and someone could make a nickel getting them to the sawmills, I'm sure they could come up with stock."
Just by the by, when did clearcutting start? Doesn't that for the most part imply a secondary growth forest of a mono culture type. Maybe not. No question there was industrial logging going on at some point. Horses were pretty much finished off by WWII, but up through that point they were probably pretty common in logging, and they allow pretty selective harvest. It is really hard for me to picture how they did stuff.
MY best history prof at one point made a comment saying that even through the second world war, most of the cartage done by armies, other than the US was done by horse. The pictures always select modern looking scenes of a motorized military, but horses, he said, were a large part of it. Always wondered whether that was true.
Re: Apple and Pear
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Shown is a log pile of what is sawed and marketed today as "pear", the lumber popular with the Krenov school of furniture and sourced in Europe. Most who have seen one would conclude these logs didn't come from a "pear" orchard and they aren't Bartlett or Bradford. The lumber does come from the Pyrus family and it may work and look like pear orchard wood. The difference is that this Pyrus variety makes logs big enough to be of commercial relevance. I suspect something similar is going on with the Mallus Diston made "apple wood" handles from.
Re: Apple and Pear
Warren in Lancaster, PA
There is no "Pyrus family". Pyrus is a genus in the Rose family. We speak of a Pyrus species not a "Pyrus variety". I have not seen a pear orchard in Europe, but here in Pennsylvania we often have large pear trees. I have seen pear boards over 24 inches wide harvested here in Pennsylvania. Malus is likewise a genus in the Rose family. Of the 30 or so species of Malus, Malus pumila, the apple, is very much the largest; the others are crab apples, much more shrubby. The Malus group is sometimes included in the Pyrus genus.
You can't speculate on this stuff if you have no idea what is out there.
I saw a euro pear board...
david weaver
.. about 25 inches wide + at hearne. I almost bought it to make tools.
I still have no clue what bill's point is, that a few trees that he's seen at classes or a few that he's had in an orchard dictate what disston used?
Re: your data adds to the mystery
david weaver
Clearcutting was in full swing in pennsylvania by the mid 1800s. I doubt most of the big logs were moved by horses. Steam donkeys, temporary railroads and river access are a lot more likely.
They clear cut old growth.
Re: Apple and Pear
Patrick Gibbons
In my backyard of the house in which I grew up in Dallas were two Keiffer pear trees. (I believe I'm spelling it right). These grew relatively fast and were almost as tall as the two older pecan trees. At 30 years old they were about 12 to 15 inches in diameter. The fruit were large. My cat loved sunning himself under them until one day when a pear konked him on the back. A few inches difference and it would have been feline death by pear. The pears were a little bigger than soft balls. At maturity these trees would have yielded useable lumber, size wise. My mother always regretted we didn't top them off to facilitate picking. After the squirrels and birds got all they wanted there was still enough left for our and several other families' use.
to answer your question.......
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
If you wish to build a Krenov cabient from "pear" don't expect to be able to from salvaged pear orchard trees. The incidental report of a tree large enough to apparently saw lumber from does not change this fact. It is not uncommon for the name used in the commerce of lumber to not provide an accurate reflection of its source, or processing. Examples that come to mind are "pecan" typically sourced from hickory trees not pecan orchards or Cucumber that becomes poplar once it is sawed. Then there is mahogany that now days can be any number of species, none of which will accurately replicate the mahogany used long ago. Or beech, which if it is "good" lumber suitable for furniture is likely steamed European beech, steamed to make it behave better in furniture and milling and European because the American beech rarely yields a high grade of lumber. (BTW, I suspect beech was used for tool parts because it resists splitting more than woods with similar properties, as anyone that burns it will discover).
Similarly, as you have pointed out, all "apple" is not created equal. Hence, it could be of interest to know what in fact Diston used and why. In my case I have little interest in the saws but I remain curious about almost anything to do with lumber and its manufacturer. To that end I remain curious of the sourcing of the Diston wood. I now suspect that the source was "apple" in a form or variety that is now rare or extinct. Like 1720 mahogany it may not be easy, or possible, to replicate it and this information could be of interest to some. I further expect that the wood provided some practical advantage that may not have had anything to do with the "collector" or manufacturing advantages you enumerated. It may simply have been easier on the carpenter's hands, or could it have looked better in the store?. What saws it was used on could provide a clue for the curious. What ever the case, the source and/or advantage, has passed into history where it could be rediscovered by those curious.
Re: to answer your question.......
David Weaver
I have certainly seen apple trees in adams co. pa that have been uprooted to make room for pygmy sized trees that would've yielded apple for handles.
I also received apple blanks from mike hendershot that would easily make a uniform saw handle.
I've got no clue what your pear trees may have been, or what you've seen at woodworking shops (and the origin of it), but I don't get the sense that the larger trees were that rare in the days of disston. They certainly seem to have it pretty consistently in the saws that I've purchased (which generally are the higher priced saws where there is more taper in the saw blades).
You can go to hearne any time and choose european pear flitches that are made of boards the size I mentioned. The only reason I saw only one board was because I was in the front of the store where they have samples displayed. The same goes for apple, the loose lumber they had was small potatoes, but you could buy domestic apple by the flitch if you were willing. I wasn't willing at their price for either european pear or domestic apple (both were in the $20-$25 a board foot range for the flitch and even if you ordered part of a flitch, the size of the boards made the price completely prohibitive).
The disston saws of vintage that are made of beech are made of american beech. The local lumber I get from ohio is american beech. It is significantly different than european beech. If someone sold me domestic apple or pear and they had it in a large blank, I'd expect it to be what they said it is. Just because it's expensive now doesn't mean that you can't get it.
Applewood ploughs
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill,
I understand you are trying to get at the question: 'What species of Malus was large enough and plentiful enough to yield 7" wide by 1" thick saw handle blanks in commercial quantities'?
Well, surely these were seedling trees, which is what was planted in America as the country spread west from the East coast and settled western PA, Ohio, Indiana, in the first and second quarter of the 19th century. Johnny Appleseed was a real guy--started many nurseries. Apple trees were important: In parts of the midwest, settlers needed to plant orchards to uphold their title to the land they claimed. Apples were the dominant source of sugar in those times, not to mention alcohol.
I'd like to hear anecdotes as to how large seedling apple trees can get. The original Malus pumila from east Asia gets to 60', and can be the dominant tree in the forest.
As to prevalence, it wasn't just Disston using apple for tool making. Apple was also used by some makers (but not all) in plough planes. For example, the 1914 Chapin-Stephens Co., Pine Meadow, CT, advertised these,
No. 239...Handled plough, beech, boxed fence, best plate, polished, 8 irons...... $8.50
No. 239-1/2...Handled plough, applewood, boxed fence, best plate, polished, 8 irons...$9.25
Similarly, Sandusky Tool Co. advertised comparable beech and apple wood ploughs in both their 1877 and 1925 catalogs, the apple wood plough carrying a 90 cent premium in 1877 and $1.80 premium in 1925.
I do not find any apple wood products in the Greenfield catalog of 1872. A handled plough blank would need to be approx. 5" wide and a bit over 2" thick. The handle was integral and not mortised into the stock.
So the wood carried a premium, but was advertised as a standard part of the toolmakers' line over several decades.
I realize the above does not answer your question, which really goes to the size and plentifulness of seedling apple trees.
Wiley
likely on the right track
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
I think you are onto the source. It is after all the "great grandparents and aunts" of the pears in the pear orchards that yield "pear wood", not the orchards themselves any more than your CA walnut groves yield "walnut lumber.
The trees yielding seeds for root stock may also have been large. I have no idea what sort of tree the root stock would be derived from in that time but it could well have been a more "wild" and hence vigorous stock and a large tree.
If people understood sawing timber better they would better appreciate the challenge of getting useful lumber from small trees, even "big" apple trees. 12" diameter trees don't yield 12" boards. They likely would not even yield 6" boards with any clear sections.
Your additional information adds to the economic feasibility. The smaller cuttings could be used in other tools requiring smaller parts.
I am staggered at the premiums. It means the lumber was extremely expensive, costing times more than beech, which would support the high cost of finding, harvesting and sawing small trees.
As an aside there is a research effort to go back to Asia and "start over" on apple trees. The current popular varieties are getting genetically weak and vulnerable. The goal is to bring along more disease resistance as the desirable fruiting traits are refined. I hope it works. I have so many fungus and bacteria diseases in my orchard that I have about given up on it. No amount of practical spraying seems to keep up any more.
California walnut
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
"...any more than your CA walnut groves yield walnut lumber."
There's a company near me that started out as a gunstock maker, using walnut from trees removed from the orchards over in the Central Valley. Some of those trunk sections are huge. They also sell some lumber; I've never spent enough time in their lumber showroom to know what the sizes are.
I got to know of them because they sell their offcuts as firewood; back when we were heating with wood primarily, I'd go on Saturday several times each Spring and load up the truck. Spring was best because there were fewer people to compete with, and it gave the wood time to dry; wet walnut burns about as well as concrete (it is, by the way, a very, very ashy wood, although it makes plenty of heat; when we were burning walnut, I had to clean out the stove twice as often as when we scored oak to burn).
If I were turning, I'd go back again; you could get some nice pieces for small bowls for very little by intelligent scavenging in the offcut piles.
As far as I've ever heard... *LINK*
John in NM
Claro walnut does not come from huge natural forrests so much as orchards and incidental trees. I would imagine that we would not have so much available if it were not for decades of housing booms in California.
I've bought stock blanks from the guy in the link. He started out as a tree trimmer and started milling lumber out of trees he removed. I have yet to hear of a CA walnut vendor who's story is not along similar lines.
http://www.clarowalnutgunstocks.com/pages/history.html
Re: California walnut
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
The trees get large and the burl from the graft larger still. The trees I have seen suggest it is the burl section that is harvested for figured lumber. I saw a mountain of these trunk sections piled at an orchard awaiting sale. I never saw any with much trunk as we would see on a wild ungrafted tree.
Disston use of rare or extinct apple
Patrick Gibbons
Up until their sale to H. K. Porter in about 1954, Disston made saws with applewood handles. I have a 1960's made D12, a premium model, with a beech handle. My 1930's D12 has an apple handle. Atkins made applewood handles at least through the 1940's. I don't think there was any applewood from an obscure source. Apples aren't native to North America but were important to the European settlers who came here. There were hundreds of different varieties planted. Commercial farming and the spread of supermarket chains have dictated just a few varieties available for purchase dooming the other varieties to neglect. Orchards are managed to keep tree trunks short and fruit more amenable to picking. I would doubt that applewood came from commercial orchards but from trees that grew in a mixed hardwood forest just as cherrywood doesn't come from a cherry orchard. Cherry is an understory tree that became dominant in forests that had been clear cut of other trees.
you are misinformed about cherry.
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
The cherry that grows wild is but distantly related to what is found in orchards.

"Wild cherry" as it is called in these parts, is picky about where it will grow, but in a desirable location it can be the dominant species. The birds spread its seeds widely so it can pioneer remotely from its source, if the conditions are favorable. Other places it will be scattered among other hardwoods and where the soil and moisture is unfavorable it will be but a stunted under story. At the northern extreme of its range in the Adirondacks it can be found in nearly pure stands on ridge tops that have good dirt. At the southern end of its range it will be found on benches at higher elevation where again there is good dirt and moisture. For example, on the way to Ramsey Cascade in the Smokies there is a breath taking stand of cherry with the largest trees 54" at breast height and clear for 75 or more feet. The one in the picture is 48" breast height. This stand has likely been here since the last ice age retreated. Its elevation is high enough that the cherry out competed the poplar that would have otherwise liked this spot.
Most of the commercial cherry comes from but a few counties in western PA and SW NY. While the stands are not great in acreage, some exceptional cherry comes from the Roan Mt area here in TN.
Re: Is traditional "apple" really apple? *LINK*
Patrick Gibbons
Here is some info on apple orchards prior to WWII. Orchard trees were substantially larger than now. Look at this and the next page.
http://exhibits.mannlib.cornell.edu/apples/The_Apple_NY.htm
From 1907 Disston Pub on handle making *LINK*
http://www.disstonianinstitute.com/sawhandle.html
no handles from those trees
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Those look like the apple trees I remember picking from in the early 50's in NYS. I was fearless on a ladder and pressed into high ladder service such as picking the top branches or cleaning gutters from tall homes and barns.
But, note that the branches go to the ground. There will be no clear trunk of length suitable for sawing clear lumber. Similar feral trees may well have yielded suitable log lengths, but even the trees in the picture would not have trunks of diameter sufficient to yield 6" lumber. If you haven't run or hung around a mill it may not be apparent how large a log is required to have a chance of yielding clear 6" lumber. The diameter at the butt is irrelevant. The diameter is needed at the small end. The requirement is to saw away as waste enough of the curve to reveal a 6" face free of bark. Enough distance must then remain to be free of wood near the tree's center which is unstable in drying (2" is good rule of thumb)and be far enough from the center that scars from limbs that fell off early in growth have grown over and the grain straightened. If you see wild grain in handles (from near knots) then smaller and lower grade logs could have been used.