We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Glen Huey's Blog at PW had a link to the Pook & Pook Auction web page. At the top of the page I linked to is "Catalogue for April 19.....". Click on that and you can scroll thru all the thumbnails of the auction catalog. There are other sites like Christies that you can do this and see high quality photos.
The point I was trying to make was there was an apple tree large enough to make this chest. I am sure it wasn't the easiest to saw or dry. I don't know if you have ever worked apple with hand tools but I have made some saw and chisel handles from it. I love working it! As far as a sows ear I think that is a matter of opinion. I think this silk purse (chest) is just awesome! Maybe the grain was a little hard to work. The grain was good enough to stick some nice moldings. All that great 18th century Cuban Mahogany furniture had some figured grain too. It also must have been tricky to work without time savers (Performax type thickness sanders).
Those desirable "grain swirls" are what we in the trade call knots (look at expanded view of the piece). The lumber for these drawers would grade #3 common and I have no doubt mature orchard apple trees will yield plenty of it in these sizes. It remains a mystery whey anyone would devote the work to make this piece from such low grade lumber. I have seen a knot or two incorporated in Period work but this piece takes the prize.
I do like its feet, a marriage of French Footed and bracket.
I would love to hear your thoughts on this chest. I hope you get a chance to see it. I like the proportions of this chest although the feet look a little wimpy to me. Do you think these are the original brasses?
On technical perfection, look at the key escutcheons. Some of them are a little off kilter. Would this pass the muster today?
I haven't a clue what would make that a sow's ear, and I also don't think many of the apple handles had wood a lot straight than the log that came from. They're just smaller.
I can't say I've seen any new furniture on here that's as desirable as that. I've seen stuff that's more robotic, but probably nothing new from any of us as pleasing to the eye and simple as that.
It looks like an excellent piece of furniture to me, and its design exudes a lot of warmth that is completely lacking in most of the stuff I've seen in this forum.
very appealing, adding a lot of visual interest. My wife, who gets to pick a lot of design elements in the stuff I build for her, almost always will choose knots and gnarly wood over straight-grained, easy to work wood.
That is to say go to the expanded image and go over the drawers in detail, or are you just looking at the small image that appears pleasing at this low resolution? Every large drawer has several large knot centers and most have splits on the right side, as well as holes. It is the poorest wood I have ever seen in a piece of furniture, seriously #3 common "pallet lumber" .
Some wild grain from near a knot can be attractive but have any of you built a drawer incorporating a large knot center, or 4, in it?
Have you sourced apple that large before? You're not looking at wide boards of mahogany or walnut.
It is an attractive piece. the only way you'd get caught up in the knots is if you couldn't examine the piece from a distance and appreciate its proportions.
I examined the chest this morning. The color is more golden than the photograph, a lot less orange. It does appear to be apple. The sides of the case are about 21 inches wide, made from two boards 13 inches and 8 inches. I think the widest drawer is about 13 inches as well. The sides are much plainer, much straighter grain than the drawer fronts; he definitely picked the best stuff for the fronts. The fronts seem to be consecutive boards.
Somebody mentioned the feet being awkward. The description states the feet are pieced the bottom 5 inches. It is more like 3 inches and I think it is a bit of a crappy job. Some feet in this style have this much flair, but it looks peculiar to have a foot with not much curve and then suddenly this big flair.
I think the feet add a lot of interest to the piece as well as proportion overall. That, along with the visuals of the drawers, contrast nicely to the formal lines of the chests. Figured wood, walnut or mahogany, would look nice, other than the apple.
I too was fairly surprised by the piece, that grade of wood is very unusual in period pieces. Obviously, taste trends have moved to the point where it is quite normal, even to the point of all that awful knotty alder crap that was in vogue a few years ago. Before the designers got hold of the stuff it was called "frame grade"
Reminds me of eating in a restaurant with my dad. One of the specials was Red Snapper, grilled in some froo-froo manner. Dad exclaimed "But that's lobsta bait!" Apparently rather strongly flavored fish is now acceptable to paying customers as well as lobsters
Maybe period pieces with "frame grade" timber are rare in New Mexico; here in Pennsylvania they are not. If one is looking at actual pieces of furniture and not what some latter day author thinks is worthwhile publishing, you see this stuff. Of the 55 spice boxes in the Pennsylvania Spice Box book, 14 had "#3 common" for their front panels (maybe a few more). With figure like this appearing in the most prominent position on the furniture, it certainly seems that this is what the customers wanted.
I was referring to pictures in various books and auction catalogs, but I seem to have not had the time to devote to the study that you have, so I will defer to your expertise and get back to work.
In Schiffer's book on Chester Co furniture where the goal was a comprehensive cataloging of the furniture and its makers most of the slant top desk fronts and many drawer fonts that were walnut featured lumber with knots (knots defined by NHLA standards as a defect showing the concentric rings of the center of the knot where the limb once was, not the wild grain near knots). The decorated pieces (line and berry. etc) were largely free of knots and wild grain. The pieces that were not walnut were largely free of knots.
I had always thought the knots were incorporated because lumber was expensive, and maybe not easy to come by on short notice, so that the maker used what was available at the time an order came in. The photos in Schiffer's book and Warren's observation suggests the incorporation of knots could be an intentional decorative element in this region. It would be interesting to compare this situation to New England Furniture.
An interesting dissertation..."Knots in 18th Century Furniture" Is there someone at Delaware needing a topic?
The only knots that were valued at the saw mill were the FAS knots sold for anatomicaly correct wooden hobby horses.
I grew up in Virginia, and it was a middle class status symbol to have knotty pine den/rec room paneled walls. Not furniture to be sure, but in some ways more present to eyes round the clock. I still find discrete knots in pine very attractive in furniture.