New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

chisel handles

Posts

chisel handles

#1

chisel handles

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm not a fan of the stock handles on my Hirsch chisels. They've got to go. There is a chunk of apple in my garage, ready to go. Will that apple work, take a light/moderate pounding, or will it likely split?

Thanks.

Re: chisel handles

#2

Re: chisel handles

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't know about apple but the dogwood handles I made 10+ years ago are holding up perfectly.

Try the apple. Turn a cylinder and pound on its end and see what happens.

Re: chisel handles

#3

Re: chisel handles

David Weaver

I've had several different pieces of apple. Some of it feels like waxy maple (much nicer wood than maple, aside from its behavior when it dries) and some stuff that feels like glorified cherry...dry as a popcorn fart and dusty.

I think a lot of the issue stems from the fact that apple trees are grafted and what you have will depend on what the base tree is.

It likely will be fine, though. Convert one and see how it goes if you're worried it might not hold up well, and make sure to crown the end of the handle so it takes blows in the middle.

What are you going to hit it with? Beech mallet?

Re: chisel handles

#4

Sorry bill..

David Weaver

that reply was supposed to be to bruce...I just didn't manage to get it in the right place.

Re: chisel handles

#5

Re: chisel handles

TomD

Hoops also make a big difference. I would not be super optimistic about apple, it is a softish hardwood, between cheery and maple, but then, how hard are you going to hit it? Tap, tap, tap... Or hammer above the head stuff. Most people do not hit their chisels anywhere up to par.

Japanese chisels are often made out of heart centred wood. So if you want a 1" handle, you get maybe some 1.125-1.250 wood, and turn it down. In that section the heart is pretty small, and or solid. The reason I mention it is that one can cut wood off of living trees, pretty much anywhere you can outrun the consequences. OK I jest, but you may even have something in your back yard. I have turned these wet, and slapped them right onto files etc... They do not split in the drying. This could open up the use of different woods for your project.

Re: chisel handles

#6

Re: chisel handles

Bruce, a MN Galoot

most of the whacking comes from either one of those Wood is Good urethane mallets or a 16-oz dead-blow hammer. I just have a problem with the loud crack of a wooden mallet.

Re: chisel handles

#7

Re: the hoops...

David Weaver

..I almost said the same thing, but was figuring that if one doesn't like the (hooped) handles on a hirsch chisel, probably because of how they feel, then they are probably out of the equation.

I like hooped, too. I pare with paring chisels, so those hoops don't bother me much.

Re: chisel handles

#8

Re: the hoops...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't mind hoops. My Berg chisels all have hoops, well, except the permaloid 2" one. It's the shape of the handle that I don't like on the Hirsches and have thought of putting hoops on the new handles just for the sake of bashing (well maybe not bashing, but just to prevent what splitting could happen). I have one Matsumura, and I don't find the hoops problematic at all.

Re: chisel handles

#9

Re: the hoops...

David Weaver

If you don't mind the hoops, apple will be fine. If you do, it still will with what you said you'd use to strike it. I agree with you about striking noise...I just don't like loud striking noise that much and do most of my work with one of those WIG mallets.

Re: chisel handles

#10

Re: chisel handles *LINK*

Lars Parrington

i put a cherry handle on a corner chisel, it didn't last too long. the wood failed across (perpendicular to) the grain, just below where the handle necked down to go into the chisel's socket. there was no hoop on the end of the chisel, but never any evidence of splitting there. no excessive hammering force, wooden mallet. i chose black locust for the replacement handle.

here's a picture of the original handle. i never really liked the shape of it anyway:


img

my blog -- corner chisel article

Re: chisel handles

#11

scott grandstaff

Re: chisel handles

scott grandstaff

Wood is so wildly variable that merely naming the species doesn't mean much.

I have had fir you could jam your fingernail clean though,

and fir that even when cut into a round only 12" long.............??

Outright laughed at an 8 pound splitting maul, with all the leverage and strength I could bring to bear. Many times straight.

Still laughing. Not even the little beginning of a crack!

And I have split some wood in my life.

Apple can be so hard and tough you could pound it with a sledge,

or so soft and frail you can break it merely pushing!

Just the name doesn't mean too much.

Rings can be nice. This is the female end of a garden hose connector. Nice brass, comes in many patterns, self threads itself on if you turn the tenon to the right size. This is a big 1/2" shipwrights chisel with a "beer mug" socket, btw.


Mallets are cool.



yours Scott

Re: chisel handles

#12

Re: chisel handles

William Duffield, in Winter Haven

Where do you source your brass hardware with the ring for the mallet handles? Is the post threaded?

I don't see the photo with the "beer mug" socket?

Re: chisel handles

#13

Re: chisel handles

Patrick Gibbons

I have a reprint of White chisels made in Buffalo from the early 20th c. They provided most of their chisels with apple handles. I believe this is a good indicator that apple is a proper wood for handles, it is a commercial application and their chisels were, and are, highly regarded. The few examples of their chisels I've seen on eBay have original handles, IIRC. Their millwright's chisels, which were long-bladed mortise chisels, used hickory for handles. Their butt and bench chisels were differentiated by handle design and whether the edges were beveled or not.

Re: chisel handles

#14

That last one a maul that ...

Patrick Gibbons

John Henry would be proud to use. Some nice stuff, as usual.

Re: chisel handles

#15

Is traditional "apple" really apple?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I am trying to imagine the labor involved in manufacturing lumber from domestic apple trees and I come up with an impractical source of lumber. It would be costly to harvest, saw and the yield of useable lumber would be low as a result of very low grade, small logs that yied lumber difficult to dry. A saw handle requires no extraordinary lumber properties that would only be provided by the domesticated Mallus species.

What we know as "pear" isn't; it just looks like pear, or it may be related but it is a "real" tree that can be practically harvested and sawed to yield clear lumber. I am inclined to think what we hear of as "apple" is the same situation. Does anyone have any reliable information on the wood called apple and used for saw handles?

Re: chisel handles

#16

Re: Separate old and new...

David Weaver

... we don't grow the types of trees in the US any longer that have apples growing on a tree with a thick trunk. Where I grew up, there are about 23000 acres of orchards, and they use pygmy trees. They're smaller, on a per acre basis they grow as many or more apples and they are easier to pick.

What comes as domestic apple....i'm not sure what it is. In the days when disston was making saws with apple handles, people were less urban and had orchards in the meadow or behind the house, and the trees weren't pygmy, so I'm sure they had the ability to get trees that grew in groves and had longer, clearer and much wider trunks.

Every apple tree is grafted, though, so I don't know what the base trunk stock is.

No shortage of large fruitwood boards coming from continental europe if you're willing to pay for them, though.

I have had several iterations of apple, and only one (an abandoned tree) looked anything like the apple disston used. Dead quartersawn and almost 6" wide without the pith and without the bark. I don't know if the wood was the sap or the heart of the tree, but it was light colored. I've never worked any other wood for saw handles that was as nice. You can rasp right back into the face of it and it doesn't chip out, it works like it's impregnated with wax.

The KD domestic apple that I saw at hearne wasn't even close.

Re: chisel handles

#17

I have owned an orchard for nearly 40 years

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have enough experience with saw mills that I know what kind of log it takes to yield boards with clear sections 6" wide, the size I am guessing are needed for a saw handle. Furthermore, I know the economics of sawing small and/or low grade logs to yield clear lumber cuttings, especially so with the un-automated mills of an earlier age(I occasionally worked at one in the early 70's). And in my youth I have picked apples in NYS from trees that were not grafted to dwarfing root stock. The sum of this experience leads me to thinking that sawing domestic apple trees would have resulted in very high priced handle blanks even if the logs were essentially free. I fail to see the advantage of apple as a wood that would command a huge premium over an alternative species, say beech, cherry ,etc. (BTW I made a dandy handle from cherry)

The incentive in an apple orchard is to begin branching near the ground, even in 1920. There is no incentive to prune a 10' clear trunk section which yields no fruiting branches. The graft will be near the ground, but it will still eliminate the first 12-24" of trunk from being useful lumber. The lumber below the first branches will be curly from the stress of the branches, which eliminates another foot or so of log. What length of clear log remains?

The center 3-4" of trunk diameter yields useless "fruitwood" lumber. It will invariably shatter when dried. The boards from the outer portion of the log, which yield the clearest lumber, are of no value for handles until they are wide enough for blanks. The saw kerf of that day was 1/4". Draw out this situation and see how big the log must be to get even two useful boards from a log. It will be a big apple tree, or a small beech. Will there be a market for the rest of the lumber unsuited for saw handles, with enough value to pay the saw bill?

When one salvages clear cuttings from small or low grade logs the clear cuttings will include lots of wild grain from the cuttings taken near knots. I have not examined old saw handles. Is the grain consistent from cuttings made from low grade or small logs, ie. it looks like the cuttings were taken from near knots? If the handles are largely straight grain then the lumber was from larger trees yielding relatively long clear logs, not the kind of log I imagine harvested from an apple orchard.

Conclusion- I remain skeptical that "apple wood" was harvested from retired apple orchards. If someone wished to send a chip to the Forest Products Lab in Madison Wisconsin (its free) I could be proved wrong.

Re: chisel handles

#18

Re: I have owned an orchard for nearly 40 years

David Weaver

Bill, i have no clue how we'd have apple from the golden age of handsaws, which is what you'd really need to have.

Disston didn't use it in every saw, but in the saws where they used apple, take a look at the handles compared to beech handles of the same era. The beech handles generally have gotten dinged up and dry rotted, and about the worst you'll find with disston's apple is that someone broke it but the integrity of the wood from 125 years ago is still very very good.

Every single apple handle I have from that era (on disston 12s or on richardson bros saws, or any others) is better than every single american beech handle I have from that era (on disston 12s.)

I would pay double for apple of that type vs. what I would pay for cherry, which to me is not a suitable tool wood. I've made planes (moulding and a smoother) from cherry, and it is not nearly as tough or as dense as the apple that I had that was from an abandoned tree.

Disston's lumber could very well have come from commercial orchards, I'd imagine that anything they would've used in volume would've been relatively inexpensive.

IF we had gobs of lumber like that these days, there wouldn't be such a premium on apple. And I think it's safe to say a lot of what is sold as kiln dried apple is not comparable to what's in disston saw handles, and certainly not comparable to the wet blanks that I got from a woodnet user who used to sell lumber there. I'll take a picture of one of my handles if I can remember to. I send the remainder of that wood to George Wilson, you can let him settle it if you'd like to. He's made tools out of just about everything.

That said, if you can get quartersawn american beech cheaply, that's fine. But at best, cherry is uninspiring in tools, and is the one thing (aside from the fact that chipbreakers sometimes aren't milled properly to use the double iron) that I don't like about lie nielsen planes...flatsawn cherry wood. It just looks like a cheap substitute, and I won't be using it for any more tools.

Re: chisel handles

#19

Re: I do have a broken..

David Weaver

....disston handle, but it's a #7 disston handle, and it's in my trash can.

I have three other english handles made of beech that are destined for the trash.

But no apple handles, those are all on good saws. If I had a dud, I'd send it off to be examined. It takes very little time working wood by hand to notice that the "good" apple that looks like the vintage stuff disston used is far different than anything else you've worked by hand. It's like double density fine-quality cherry with a waxy feel, or like beech with a waxy feel and much less prominent pores.

Re: chisel handles

#20

I question your assumptions on the economics.

Chuck Nickerson

As a trigger for rethinking I offer the following parallel example.

In her book "40 Acres and No Mule" Janice Holt Giles relays her family's and extended community's experience with Appalachian subsistence farming in the 1940's.

When money got exceptionally tight one year, her husband went out, cut down some hickory trees, sized the pieces, and sold them to an firm that made axes.

Surely by the 1940's activity on this micro-scale wouldn't make sense, but there it was.

For someone as close to the land as yourself, I think the book would be an enjoyable read.

Re: chisel handles

#21

scott grandstaff

Re: Is traditional "apple" really apple?

scott grandstaff

I think so.

Apples were unbelievably important in early America. There was hardly any beer, and no wine of consequence at all, compared to cider.

Cider was IT! Everywhere you went. It was said that every single landowner of any kind grew apples. I am sure this isn't really true, but true enough.

It was counted in barrels and every homeowner kept dozens to hundreds of barrels around.

The trees were trees too. Not dwarf or super dwarf like now.

They grafted apple trees, to crabapples to get those.

Crabapple is practically a bush. A rather pulpy bush at that.

Henry Disston was taking advantage of the wave of new dwarf apple trees, when millions of traditional trees were being replaced.

Finely polished apple is like no other wood. Nothing else comes close.

Go find yourself an old apple handle saw and really do a number on the tote. Close your eyes. Squeeze.

Apple feels like velvet against your skin! Freaky soft. Better than velvet!

Not rosewood, cherry or heaven forbid beech, is any comparison at all no matter how you polish it.

Oh the "beer mug" socket on chisels were the oversized shipwrights tools. Underhill made lots, but others did too.

They are massive in every way compared to other chisels, excepting pigsticker mortise chisels of course.

yours Scott

Re: chisel handles

#22

Re: finely polished apple..

David Weaver

>>Finely polished apple is like no other wood. Nothing else comes close<<

Exactly. It's as if it feels like the wood has been waxed and has no pores at all. It's sublime. It's dense without being super hard to work, strong, and super pleasing to the eye. The color it takes on with blonde shellac (when it is clear) is heavenly.

Re: chisel handles

#23

Re: I have owned an orchard for nearly 40 years

TomD

As far as commercial scale, I would imagine you are right. Smaller scale, like supplying big enough chucks for woodturning impractically large bowls, it for sure comes from apple trees. We got a chance to saw an orchard, and passed on it. But they definitely had the scale to supply a bunch of woodworking clubs.

I do marvel at where they get the quality of wood on the scale we have. Any time I have sawn up trees, I got lots of good stuff, but never really stuff that would be commercial. The beech I sawed for planes and a bench top was a rotten tree. Most often trees have a lot of twist and knots.

It should be noted that while there are operations that operate at a large scale of input and output, there is a lot of wood that is boutiqued, and is being done so profitably. Brazilian which is certainly an outlier species, is harvested from stumps. Same is true of a lot of soundboard materials. One has the special situation where large timber buildings are being repurposed.

I heard of this great deal in I think BC where they built a rail line into a wilderness area. Logged off all the noble trees, and then dumped them in a mountain lake, at which point the whole operation went bankrupt, and the wood sank out of sight to be recovered decades later. There is a lot of reclamation being done, and a lot of it could be a gold mine, except there are environmental issues, and the result is very slow exploitation.

But Diston, no idea...

Re: chisel handles

#24

Re: Disston..

David Weaver

was operating in a very large city that was served by canals and railroads that may have been loaded from rivers and logging.

At their peak, people had already been living in the surrounding 200 mile radius for over 100 years.

There was an organized system of logging where you could mark your log and put it in a river and there was a good chance that it would get to a mill that could use it. When that was the market, I doubt they really had that much trouble getting apple. It might not have been easy to clear cut huge amounts of it like they could do with cherry, red oak, white oak, etc, but they were making saw handles and not train cars, so if they had to come pooled from from pastures and yards and someone could make a nickel getting them to the sawmills, I'm sure they could come up with stock.

I don't for a second believe that people back then had no idea that sawmakers wanted apple wood and that it would've been that much of a challenge for Disston to get a steady supply of it.

As scott said, there is no comparison between that wood and cherry, etc, or most of what's grown for fruit remotely recently.

I know bill said that they picked apples from wild trees that weren't grafted, but every tree where I'm from (where the orchards are commercial and must be palatable, not just tolerable) is grafted and the trees are grafted locally from local stock, because bringing in a foreign tree that wasn't resistant to local pests would make no sense.

I'll bet the orchards were pretty consistent on what made the trunk of the tree, I'm sure they knew what yielded.

Re: chisel handles

#25

Question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What was the price premium of a Diston "apple" handle over one of beech? This information might provide a clue about how difficult it was to find suitable logs to saw handle stock from. I presume old Diston literature would have this information.

There never has been any significant demand for beech. So this wood would have been at the bottom of the price category, costing little more than what it would cost to harvest the logs and convert to lumber. Currently there is a tiny market for beech occasionally for rail ties, but it is not a preferred wood for this application. Mostly the trees are just left in the woods to crowd out desirable species. I have killed hundreds of them on timber land we own, left from previous logging of desirable species.