New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Posts

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#1

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Bill Tindall

Background to help put my evaluation in perspective.

My major use of a chisel is for making dovetail drawers, usually half blinds. I am only going to own and maintain one set of chisels so they most do well as multitaskers. Acceptable ergonomics is a must. The chisel must be comfortable in the hand both paring and chopping to a scribe line. These three essential requirements lead me to reject the hoop handled Japanese chisels as well as the top heavy Western chisels. All these factors led me to make chisels using, at the time, the best steel available for chisel making that could be readily obtained and commercially heat treated, Crucible Products CPM 3V.

I am at the end of evaluating the Lee Valley chisel for drawer making- poplar sides and walnut fronts, a typical combination of drawer materials. Half the chisel operations on each drawer were done with my home made 3V chisel and half with the LV chisel. Edge retention and ergonomic factors were judged. Worn edge pictures will be forthcoming in Part 4 when I can arrange with the lab to do the pictures. It could be weeks, or not.

Edge Retention- The edge of the Lee Valley chisel held up somewhat better than the 3V. The edge degraded in both cases by deformation, not chipping, micro or otherwise. If the 3V had been more optimally heat treated to Rc60-62 instead of the Rc58-60 it was at I would predict the results would have been more similar. In previous evaluations of CPM 3V against Sorby, Two Cherries and a chisel made of M2 this 3V chisel had better, to substantially better edge retention. The bottom line is that the steel in the Lee Valley chisel is exceptional for the tasks involved in drawer building, at least as good as or possibly better than CPM 3V.

While edge retention is nice to have I find edge retention in a chisel less important than in a plane blade, for the kind of work I do. Particularly when edge failure is by deformation the edge can often be restored to acceptable function by straightening it (on a micro level, we are not talking about major edge deformation here) by rubbing on a hard smooth stone, such as a hard Arkansas stone. In this current case I would have done a quick rub of the back of each chisel after one complete drawer (actually two half drawers), though the 3V chisel was in greater need of this refinement. Both still pared acceptably after one complete drawer but I do a quick rub on the fine rock when I can see any deformation with a 10X lens or feel deformation by carefully passing finger across the chisel back.


Ergonomics- In Part 1 I reported on the comfy handle and bolster area on the Lee Valley chisel. My home made chisel blade is 0.140" thick and steeply side beveled. It fits in tight places making owning, or picking up, another chisel unnecessary for removing dovetail waste, for example in half blinds. I found that the Lee Valley chisel functioned equally well for all chiseling tasks involved in dovetailing, including removal of the pesky corner waste in half blinds.

Over time I became more accommodating of the thicker blade on the Lee Valley chisel. I no longer think I will grind it thinner. I thought it would get in the way removing pesky half blind corner waste. It didn’t. It is a bit more comfy to hold down near the bevel than my thinner chisel.

Bottom Line- This chisel has exceptional ergonomics and steel in the context of how I use a chisel.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#2

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Sounds very good Bill. I've been lusting after a set of Blue Spruce chisels as a general purpose set for some time.

However, it seems like these really might work well.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#3

try before committing to a set

Bill Tindall

Much like the pizza crust is 90% of a pizza's goodness, so it is with chisels. So long as the steel is up to some minimum standard, personally I think A2 doesn't make this standard, the choice should be on how well the shape of the blade and handle fits the kind of work you do and how you do it. To that end buy one chisel of the types you are considering before committing to a set.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#4

Re: try before committing to a set

Rob Lee

Excellent advice!

Also good to pick and choose among sizes and styles...instead of full sets. A set is generally only good value if you use all sizes....

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#5

Re: try before committing to a set

roger lance

Rob....will you allow a purchase of one chisel and then if your customer wants to buy the remaining chisels in the set, the set price ??

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#6

Re: try before committing to a set

Rob Lee

Yes.... I'd allow that...

Probably get me in trouble with Customer Service.... :D

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#7

Re: Now that's a computer inventory nightmare...

david weaver

tracking folks doing that a lot would be a party.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#8

Years ago...

david weaver

... i bought one of the koyamaichi dovetail chisels.

If you bought the set, you got a roll. I didn't want the set at the time, I just wanted to get a look at a chisel.

Had it for a week and called back and asked if I could get the rest of the chisels and asked if I could buy the roll.

"roll goes with the set, we'll figure something out. No separate inventory number".

I knew right then I caused problems because I also knew that there was no way CS was not going to see to it that I got a roll, despite the fact that they had no separate inventory number.

I'm sure that caused tracking problems, I still have the chisels and the roll. I felt a bit guilty about that! Love the chisels, though.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#9

Re: Now that's a computer inventory nightmare...

roger lance

maybe not....everyone has a customer number and I know from prior experience with LV, they know what they have sold to you and they have a list of who bought a particular item.....I could see a time limit on this though. At any rate, what a company !!!

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#10

Re: try before committing to a set

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Actually Rob, you and I had something like this happen a number of years ago with respect to the Flush Plane. I posted some question about it here on Woodcentral and you responded with something like, "Try it and if you don't like it, I'll refund your $29 and shipping too."

(The price ought to give you an idea of how long ago that was).

I still have that plane...and I have yet to sharpen it or even clean the coating off the blade even though I've used it countless times.

I recommend it to anyone who asks.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#11

Re: try before committing to a set

John Jesseph

Hi Rob-

I bought one chisel to see how I like it. So far, so good. I have some small chests to make from curly maple, so it will get a good workout over the next few weeks.

You mentioned sizes and styles in your post. Are there more sizes and styles of chisel coming out? My friend and mentor Randy O'Donnell has a favorite go-to chisel that is 3/16 wide, for example. Just curious what is coming down the pike. I would be happy to test anything and report back.

Also, when will the Stanley style irons be out? I am waiting to buy a few replacements, based on how much I like the chisel.

Thanks,

John Jesseph

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#12

Re: try before committing to a set

John Jesseph

IIRC you can log in under your customer service number and see everything you have ever ordered there for at least the last ten years...

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#13

more thread hijack, for Rob

John Jesseph

I am curious about the saw file holder progress- any prototypes being trialed? Thanks!

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#14

Re: try before committing to a set

Rob Lee

Hi John,

Stanley blades are coming, next batch of steel is for those. Butt chisels start soon, but also depend on sales of the bench chisels ( same tooling ).

Mix in Christmas demand, and it gets hard to predict dates...we may have to go to a third shift in the machine shop....

Also, working on tooling for 3/16 and 1/8 sizes....

We also have to complete the PM-V11 blades for Veritas planes.

At least we're keeping busy.....

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#15

Re: more thread hijack, for Rob

Rob Lee

Hi,

Past prototypes, and into production...not sure of the dates yet, but should hit the shelves before Christmas....

Will check on Monday.

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#16

other sizes

John Jesseph

Thanks for the reply- I will be looking out for the smaller sizes, and maybe even get one of the 3/16 chisels for Randy!

5/16 would be a nice size too :)

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#17

Where else.....

Bill Tindall

....can you have a personal chat with the CEO of a major company about the company products? Amazing!

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#18

Re: Where else.....

TomD

I'm thinking just about every other wood board I have been on... Still is amazing, but not the most amazing thing about their service level.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#19

Re: Where else.....

Farkled

Rob Lee is not only a great CEO, he is also a consummate gentleman. I try not to look at the list of stuff that I've bought from him, it's embarrassing. It is quite exhilarating to meet and talk with a class act.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#20

Butt chisels!

Martin S.

Rob,

Got any pictures of the prototypes?

You've got me very interested...

Thanks for all your hard work on our behalf.

Martin

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#21

Question

Bill Tindall

what would one use a butt chisel for that the chisel they are already selling would not be suitable for?

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#22

No to speak for Rob Lee, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I grew up using Stanley 60's and I still prefer that shorter length.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#23

Re: Question

Martin S.

Probably the same thing.

I think the Blue Spruce Butt chisels are nice and seem well balanced.

I am sure Rob's are just as cute and just as nice to hold.

Isn't it ok to have more than one set of chisels? ;-)

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#24

Butt vs socket

Bill Tindall

There is a huge difference between the Stanely socket chisels and butt, myself preferring a shorter chisel too. But the Lee Valley chisels are so light and well balanced I don't think anyone preferring a Stanley butt is going to find the current LV too long and unwieldy.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#25

Re: Question

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

Good point.

One factor is that we can go significantly wider with a butt chisel (cost effectively) than we can in the bench format. We'll have both 1 -1/2 and 2", in addition to the same sizes as bench chisels.

We'll probably only run narrow chisels (1/8") in a butt format as well, as the shorter blade length makes it simpler to manufacture.

Cheers -

Rob