New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Posts

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#51

Re: The storm

William Duffield

I'm at 14 feet, according to USGS markers at either end of Ye Greate Streete, and this house has stood here for 285 years. There was some minor flooding at bridges on most of the roads leading out of Greenwich, and low lying areas in the immediate vicinity on the Cohansey had tidal flooding. The Jersey Shore was a totally different situation, but that is not an environment that I would ever want to call home, storm surges or not.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#52

Re: How does the guide block help?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I went out and bought a sump pump in the middle of the storm. The store is 3/4 mile away, but I drove 6 miles to get there. The store was running on a generator and there were only 2 employees (usually more than a dozen) and me until another pump customer came.

Until about 15 years ago, I never saw anyone hold a chisel anywhere but the handle. I was demonstrating the pole lathe and a fellow came up and described problems with mortising. I had a mortise chisel along, so I demonstrated. Then when he tried it holding the chisel like a pencil I was really shocked. Holding the chisel that way affords little angular control, is tiring for the hand, and is very rough on the edge. I don't think I have ever seen a historic illustration of anyone working that way. Maybe not any Japanese either.

I don't think I have ever used a guide block for anything, but I would not argue that it is not a historic technique; some guys do some don't.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#53

I prefer blizzards, thank you.  I'll stay in MN.


Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#54

Re: try before committing to a set

Ray

I had made up my mind to buy a set of LN chisels until I found out that the new LV steel was available. I contacted LV with the question - Will you be offering 1/8" chisels in the future? I was told that they had no plans to do so - so I bought LN.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#55

Re: try before committing to a set

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ray

Ouch. I can hear your frustration. Still, LN chisels are excellent, and you may be happy with them .. or sell them and get the LV in PM-V11 - fortunately the resale value of LN is very high.

My understanding of the size situation (early on) was that the aim was to make the basic set available. LN did the same, then added more sizes over time.

For dovetails I use the 1/8" almost exclusively for tails. A 5/16" would be nice as well. What I did was to grind a 1/4" pre-production O1 chisel (used to evaluate handles and balance) into a 1/8" size ...



It is not straight forward to make a chisel of this length. The narrowness makes it susceptible to flexing and bending. If you increase the depth (as is done with many brands), you can end up with something that is closer to a mortice or firmer chisel than bevel edged for dovetails. Making a shorter chisel is a solution.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#56

Re: try before committing to a set

TomD

And then about 80% of the ones that see actual use come back like a pretzel...

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#57

Missing from action- Hirsch/Two Cherries

Bill Tindall

Hirsch/Two Cherries (the steel part is identical) never come up in these chisel discussions. Edge toughness was outstanding when I did an evaluation of common chisels 10 years ago and they cost 1/3 of what "premium" chisels cost. Has anyone ever compared this brand to any of the A2 chisel brands?

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#59

I've been wondering about that, too.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I got a set of the Hirsch chisels from LV on your recommendation, Bill, and I've been very pleased with them. It would be interesting to know, just for curiosity's sake, how they stack up against the new PMV11 from LV, but that would be just for comparison because I wouldn't replace them in any event.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#60

Re: Missing from action- Hirsch/Two Cherries

david weaver

I had a set of them. I think they've increased in cost since I got mine, though, and are somewhere around $30 per chisel.

Their grind is poor enough that I wouldn't consider them now, especially given I can usually piece together a vintage set of chisels over a year of stopping at a tool stand that's on the way to my parents' for about $7-$10 per chisel.

It isn't the steel that I would consider great in most premium chisels (I haven't tried the new LV steel), but rather the grind. You can always sharpen a chisel pretty easily, but grinding accurately for the average person, especially without ruining a chisel, is less practical.

I thought the 2cherries chisels I had were nice steel, like a smooth chrome vanadium steel that was fairly hard, but I have seen accounts of folks mentioning edge retention issues with theirs. Maybe it varies some.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#61

Re: Missing from action- Hirsch/Two Cherries

James Watriss

I always figured that grinding was a gateway skill.

I have a set of Pfeil, which seemed to be of similar quality to 2 cherries...

New, they were a little soft. I think this was just due to being over-buffed. Once they were ground back a bit, they became very solid performers.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#62

Re: Missing from action- Hirsch/Two Cherries

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, are yours the polished or unpolished variety?

The polished versions came in for much criticism as the sides were dubbed and the backs required a great deal of work to flatten. Ironically, the good steel was the problem here.

I cannot recall how thick are the lands - how do they compare with chisels like the LV, LN, Blue Spruce and Ashley Iles (which admittedly are more expensive). That would be relevant for those with dovetailing in mind.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#63

Question

Bill Tindall

I would like to know the details of the width reduction grinding process you used. You clearly did a nice job of it. Given a reliable approach to the task others will use it. It is clearly the route to custom chisel sizes.

Indeed I too use a 5/16 with some regularity. In fact I find application of all my smaller sizes- 1/4 to 5/8 x 1/16" increment but rarely use the wider ones.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#64

Agree...

John in NM

Grinding is a very basic skill, as much so as honing really. If a manufacturer's grind doesn't suit, there should be no hesitation to fix it. I suspect that reports of poor edge retention have more to do with putting too shallow a bevel on the chisel than with the steel itself.

What you say about the Pfeil getting "harder" with use is interesting. I would bet you've got it right with the question of polish, that was pretty sharp :D :D :D

Funny thing is that Two Cherries/Hirsch used to be benchmark chisels to which many new ones were compared. That seems to have changed considerably as more and more manufacturers introduced fancy steels and fancy handles. It seems to me that chisels are to woodworking what sneakers are to retail fashion. Like shoes, I've rarely had a truly awful, un-serviceable chisel, but I've also rarely had a fashionable one :D

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#65

Re: Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I can give you two - not one - methods of reducing the width of a chisel! :)

The first method uses a jig, and the second is freehand.

The link to the jig method is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html

Basically, this used the guide arm from a Tormek along with the Veritas Small Blade Holder. This allows one to run the blade along the wheel face (I've seen some use the side of the grinder wheel, but that is a poor method. Only the wheel face offer the control for an even grind). Take a few light test cuts to get the grind angle you want ...


Here is a 1/8" chisel I made for a friend ...



I seem to recall the entire chisel took about 1 hour to make.

I find it as easy to just freehand the blade past the wheel face. One of the key elements is to add a slight camber to the wheel.

Here is the tool rest on my grinder ..


I added a layer of MDF so that the blade had the maximum support. Adjust the angle of the rest to get the shoulder angle you desire. The waste was marked in blue, and then the blade was freehanded along its length. Make sure that you take long, even strokes. Take very light strokes to keep the heat down (mine barely got warm to the touch before I dunked it in water). Only grind to about 1/4" from the bevel end (otherwise the thin steel there may burn), and finish that at the end.

Here's a close up of the LV 1/8" chisel ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#66

Re: try before committing to a set

Rob Lee

Hi Ray,

You bought good chisels... I have a set of Tom's too....

Whomever gave you the answer on the 1/8" size should have said no "immediate" plans to do so. It takes quite awhile to make tooling, and develop the production process for new sizes - and narrower chisels are particularly difficult. We are planning them though, and working on new sizes.

For a 1/8" chisel, we will likely make this size within the Butt chisel line, and not the Bench chisels. Eventually, we will address specific uses and functions with individual designs not tied to a particular set.

Right now, our challenge is to keep up with what we're making now, and have finished designs and tooling for....

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#67

answers

Bill Tindall

Bill, are yours the polished or unpolished variety?.......... Agggg! they are the hideous polished version of long ago, plus the hideous lacquer to boot. What were they thinking! Took forever to get the backs flat. Were I to do it over I would have simply ground away an 1/8" of tip and started over.

The polished versions came in for much criticism as the sides were dubbed and the backs required a great deal of work to flatten. Ironically, the good steel was the problem here........... Yes, indeed!!

I cannot recall how thick are the lands .......they need to be refined for best dovetail use.

Which brings us to a conclusion about chisels. Unless they are really awful metal, for example Sorby, the physical attributes of a new chisel are way more important than the steel. Which is why the sage advise is to buy one before buying a set.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#68

Re: did you get O-1 or A2?

Ray

I originally planned on getting O1 with the intent of making them do double duty of paring with long handle. I finally decided to get A2 and get a set of paring chisels in the future.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#69

Re: try before committing to a set

Ray

Rob,

I knew that I would be happy with them. I doubt that anyone can go wrong by purchasing from either of the two North American companies that make very high quality tools.

I even made a small shrine for mine.


img

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#70

Re:to clear it up..

david weaver

I'm talking about accurately grinding tasteful looking bevels all the way up the length of a bevel edge chisel, and not the primary bevel, that is easy grinding and is the same almost without regard to the cross section of a chisel.

But accurately grinding bevels down to a thin even and crisp land on a hardened chisel is not an easy thing to do, especially on the narrow chisels.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#71

didn't understand the explanation

Bill Tindall

Are you saying the A2 is a different shape than the O-1 chisel? Not clear whether the metal choice was do to shape or intended use, or something else.

They do seem to have a nice home.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#72

Re: Question

TomD

I scribe a line over layout dye, or more likely just use a carbide pen scriber, then grind it back freehand. You lock in your angle with your arms tight to one's side, and move from the floor. I've done this a few times with plane blades also, and when making chisels. With the plane blades I probably did it on the dry wheel, since that is mostly what I had at the time. Belt sanders are easy because the platen while joint the edge for you. With a belt sander it only takes a few minutes. I ground the plane blades to get particular blade types for those ECE planes. I'm thinking.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#73

Re: long handle for paring?

TomD

"Hmmm .. longer handles also mean more leverage.... and a different design!

Not that anyone ever pries with chisels..... ;) "

They shouldn't be. But there are literal leverage situations, like slices pivoting off the support hand.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#74

Re: What are they used for?

TomD

"What little paring there is in my case can be met with what ever chisel is close at hand. "

This is like saying that one does not have a lot of use for a car since the bike is always near to hand. Until one has paring chisels one does not know how useful they can be. They have a lot of precision and power that a single handed chisel can't match. But as you say everything is a further maintenance and storage problem. I put off buying a decent set till I had nearly everything else, and I have to say the power and perfection of the ones I have is pretty amazing. However, there is little that could not be done with a hammered chisel. I think the substitute, for better or worse is not a single hand pushed chisel but the tap tapping of a single handed chisel, usually.

I think the cautious in particular like to pare as they think they will do less damage that way. As far as safety is concerned, any time one has the chisel in both hands, or a chisel and hammer, it is pretty difficult to get cut. Where the work is concerned, paring is production. In fact, taking big chips is often more accurate that faffing away with little ones. There is a middle path where the chip size controls the cut.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#75

Re: Krenov

TomD

Krenov, I suspect (directly or indirectly). He shows this method in his book. What he says is that at the school he was trained at dovetail pieces had a habit of ending up hidden under the bench. Krenov is not an extremist when it comes to methods, one of his points is to work well within yourself, and produce perfect results. He is an extremist when it comes to results, at least to some extent.

When I taught dovetails I taught a method designed to get people up to speed, make practice simple, and results fast. I also taught and "art" approach designed to produce gallery work where the results have to be perfect, no crappy misses justified by what an 18th C maker's son left on a piece of furniture when he was learning the craft and has been immortalized since. A lot of the gallery guys don't last that long, and they work with very expensive wood. A block is confidence building and produces good results.

Contrary to your experience I found the chopping the hardest part. If I had instructors it would have been easy, so long as I followed the program. I had to look careful at what the likes of FZ were doing because I found it all to easy to bruise the layout line. As you say, the method not to do that is pretty simple.