New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Posts

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#26

Re: Butt chisels!

Rob Lee

Hi Martin!

Will see what I can track down.... I've lost my desktop PC, and am not yet patched into the R&D system, so it may take another day or so...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#27

2-inch butt chisel

Steve Elliott

Rob, it's great news to me that you'll be offering a wide butt chisel. Now I don't have to keep trolling ebay to find an old one to rehab. And the flat back will save me a lot of time, too.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#28

Butt Chisel Rendering *LINK*

Rob Lee

Here you are:


Butt Chisel Rendering

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#29

Flat backs

Bill Tindall

In case anyone missed it, the back of the PMV11 chisel was so flat that just rubbing on 1 micron diamond polished all of the end of the chisel. As much as I hate back flattening this feature alone makes the chisel a good deal.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#30

Re: more thread hijack, for Rob

Rob Lee

Hi John -

This is now on track for end-November, early December....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#31

Thanks, they look great!


Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#32

Re: more thread hijack, for Rob

John Jesseph

Thanks, I will keep an eye out for it and pick one up!

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#33

How often do you find the CEO of a company...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...saying, "Don't spend money with us if you don't need to" - ?

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#34

long handle for paring?

Chris Friesen

Hi Rob...the butt chisels look sweet. Have you considered offering a longer handle on the wide blades? The end result would be sort of like a japanese paring chisel.

I know, we can always re-handle and who knows how much demand there would be...

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#35

Hard to judge from the rendering

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

But the butt chisels seem to have a lower side bevel angle than the bench chisels, is it the case?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#36

Re: Question

TomD

Not being the arbiter of such things, when I hear Butt, I think hinges, tool belts and blister packs. My Occidental Leather rig has two older LV butts in it, for general workday stuff.

Mini chisels are just smaller versions of bigger ones. They are good for small project, small hands, very delicate work where you weld your hand to the piece, and don't expect to drive the hand into the project as a result. But there is nothing, really that you can do with minis, that one can't do with bench chisels. And there really isn't much one can do with bench chisels that one can't do with chisels in the 12 inch range. When I started out in the 70s, quite a few writers were pushing the longer chisels as the all around variety. I soon moved on to the bench length.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#37

Re: Butt Chisel Rendering

Jim Toews

Rob, you do realize this could cost me some money, don't you? I've been looking for good butt chisels in wider sizes. Better not show this to LOML.... Oh, any ideas (ball-park) as to when these will be available?

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#38

Re: long handle for paring?

Rob Lee

Hi Chris -

Hmmm .. longer handles also mean more leverage.... and a different design!

Not that anyone ever pries with chisels..... ;)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#39

Re: Butt Chisel Rendering

Rob Lee

Hi Jim -

I think early in the new year. We're still trying to get caught up with the bench chisels, and more plane blades....

This time of year is always a bit hectic....!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#40

Re: Hard to judge from the rendering

Rob Lee

Hi Denis -

No definitive answer on that yet... could be the same, or it could change....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#41

Re: long handle for paring?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Chris and all,

Agree with your idea of paring slicks. As Rob said just above, it's a different design. Also, if the goal is to emulate Japanese slicks, there's a little more to it than adding longer handles.

Here is a pair of Japanese paring slicks, Funahiro, 14" long or so, 12mm and 30mm:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8135513179/in/set-72157631881424249/

Here are the two chisels in side view, back to back:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8135507907/in/set-72157631881424249/

The shanks are curved to provide clearance for the handle over the work. A little closer look at the shanks:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8135536550/in/set-72157631881424249/

Wiley

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#42

What are they used for?

Bill Tindall

I encounter little need for paring during construction of the things I make, so I am not able to imagine what one needs such a chisel for. What little paring there is in my case can be met with what ever chisel is close at hand.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#43

have to agree here....

Bill Tindall

I am just not interested in having to maintain a stable of special purpose chisels or searching for one when its special purpose comes up. Anything I need to do with a chisel is readily met with a beveled edge bench chisel such as the recent offerings from Lee Valley.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#44

Re: What are they used for?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

A little crackerbarrel philosophy: "Need" is an ambiguous word. We each 'need' what we've decided to use, and everything else looks like it's extraneous :) .

Some time ago, I decided I preferred to saw out the waste on dovetails, and on multiple-tenon joints. Normally I gang the two drawer sides, but in this picture I was making heavy drawers for a workbench. Fretsawing the waste:


And then paring the remainder, using a guide block:


It's helpful to have "in-between" sizes for this task. One reason I like Imai-san's chisels, is that he will make a 4.5mm (3/16") and a 7.5mm (5/16). For me, the 4.5mm is a gotta have.

The Imai chisels are shorter than the Funahiro's, at about 12". The guide hand goes right under your jaw--just lean down slightly to make the paring cut.

Of course, one could make this same cut with any chisel, including a ground-down screwdriver, but I happen to like the paring slicks. And mainly I'm used to them.

Wiley

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#45

How does the guide block help?

Bill Tindall

I can see that the long chisel a a logical companion to the tall guide block. But why use a guide block? I am a great fan of crutches but I don't see how/what the guide block helps.

Of all the skills involved in dovetailing, removing this waste requires the least skill. Splitting a fine line with a saw takes skill and practice. Sticking a chisel in a scribe line doesn't. Granted, while locating the chisel edge in the scribe line with a long chisel clutched by the handle would be difficult, it is trivial with a short chisel held at the bevel with heel of hand on face of board. The chisel is slid across the surface until it falls in the valley of the scribe line. Falling off a log comes to mind. So the guide block is no help here.

It matters not if the chiseled surface is undercut. In fact the professionals I have seen do this operation purposely undercut a few degrees. So in this aspect the tall guide block is just in the way for the chisel should not be at 90 degrees to the surface.

I just finished doing 5 drawers worth of these cuts. To do this operation I use a short chisel as do most every professional I have observed. The chisel is grasped between thumb and forefinger near the bevel with heel of hand on surface of board. This arrangement enables quick,reliable location of chisel in valley of the scribe line. The first blow to the chisel is light with the chisel slightly angled away so as to not undercut and violate the scribe line. This first blow establishes a slight shoulder. Then the chisel angle is reversed to provide a few degrees of clearance where the end of the drawer side mates with the drawer front or back. The chisel can be more smartly whacked now for the shoulder will keep the chisel from pushing back against the scribe line and overtaking it. If the chisel angle varies a bit while driving it to the bottom of the cut it mattes not so long as the result no more than 90 degrees, or more desirably, less than 90.

The next step is to orient the board vertical to clean up corners. It is very easy to do a slight paring cut across this surface to ensure there is a bit of relief for the drawer side ends. I find it very easy to know that the chisel is tilted up slightly for the paring cut, if it is needed.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#46

Re: How does the guide block help?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Do you have snow yet? I'm worried about some of our east coast brethren--Sir William was right in the eye of the storm yesterday evening. Not sure where Warren is, but he's got to be looking at big weather.

The guide block. Whereas you chop the tail board waste; I saw it with a fret saw, with the drawer sides still in the vise following the dozuki cuts. Your chopping procedure with cutting ledges and reversing chisel and so forth, as you describe, seems eminently sensible. But I'd rather saw, as the first step. When I'm done sawing, I have maybe a 32nd of waste left to be pared. I use the guide block for two reasons: (1) to make a vertical reference cut, without undercutting, and (2) to make sure the chisel does not twist or back up at the scribe line, particularly on the end pieces for the half-pins (that photo shows the end pieces still unsawn, but now I saw them slightly fat with dozuki, and include them in the paring).

Couple of notes on the above...For me, it is easy to make a slight mistake on those end pieces, which the guide block averts. Undercutting I find unnecessary (though I do on tenons). To forego cutting a little 'ledge' for backing, I don't locate the chisel in the bottom of the scribe line--I put it literally a hair away from it. The guide block helps with this locating, and the cut will end up exactly at the scribe line.

In the photo, I was holding a camera, so hand positions don't show. One thumb is holding the chisel flush against the guide block, the other hand in a fist under my jaw--the chisel is not waving around loose. Incidentally the guide block is on bolts with wing nuts, in effect it's a horizontal vise.

Finally, just as in sawing, I prefer keeping a little distance from the action rather than having my nose right down in it. Want to see the whole picture at once. So the longer chisels suit this preference.

Them's my reasons!

Wiley

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#47

wrong assumption

Bill Tindall

I remove as much waste as I can with a band saw. So I begin the same place as you do.

It's not at all clear why you don't locate the chisel edge in the scribe line like everyone(?) else. But if you do not then the guide black is indeed essential. As for not undercutting, if for some reason not undercutting is essential then again I can see the guide block will be helpful.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#48

Re: wrong assumption

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

OK, bandsaw first, and you're right, I missed that point. However, from the description, it sounds like you're still in chopping mode when you get to the chisel:

"The first blow to the chisel is light with the chisel slightly angled away so as to not undercut and violate the scribe line. This first blow establishes a slight shoulder. Then the chisel angle is reversed to provide a few degrees of clearance where the end of the drawer side mates with the drawer front or back. The chisel can be more smartly whacked now for the shoulder will keep the chisel from pushing back against the scribe line and overtaking it. "

What I'm reading: The first strike establishes a 'slight shoulder' or ledge--this shoulder keeps the chisel from backing up and crushing into the scribe line on the next lick. If it backs up, it's beginning to move the scribe line.

Shoulder. The guide block is my 'shoulder', or ledge. I still cheat just a hair off the bottom of the scribe line, to end up at the right place.

Undercutting. I'm not making a point of avoiding undercutting, as though that were an objective in itself. I just want to make one paring slice and it's done. The chisel fills the width of the socket, the chisel sides are tapered 10 degrees, one slice and done, then move to the next socket. With the guide block it's "one and done", just as with the original saw cuts. And I stop sweating the end pieces.

I don't want to fine tune or carve these tail board sockets. One saw cut, move on; one chisel slice, move on. Now with the pins board, like you, I'm doing some chopping, even if I drill out the center of the waste with a Forstner bit. In that case, I like a shortish striking chisel just as you do, usually a 1/4" one. Your procedure does have the benefit of using a single chisel set--I'm using both striking chisels and push chisels. So I give on that point!

Wiley

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#49

Re: How does the guide block help?

William Duffield

All is well at the Loxahatchee Toolworks. Power was out Monday night and in and out all day yesterday. We lost a large branch from a silver maple tree which just missed the roof of the shop, and it has been blocking me from hauling sticks and leaves off the yard and gardens and out to the firewood stack and compost pile, and keeping me from putting away my generator, gas cans and extension cords. Sandy dumped almost 7" of rain on us, but the soil was dry before the storm, and my sump pump hasn't started up yet. I'll need to spend the rest of the day today doing major limb, stick and leaf clean-up, and hope to have the front yard clear enough for ghosts and goblins by this afternoon. Maybe I'll get back into the shop tomorrow. I still have a carload of tools and benches to unload from a presentation I gave at a SAPFM meeting in Virginia over the weekend.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#50

The storm

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That is very, very good to hear, William! That 8pm high tide plus storm surge on Monday looked very threatening--the storm center was moving right up the Delaware Bay and estuary. Didn't even look like there was any high ground to be on, in those parts. Glad all's well.

Wiley