New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

Posts

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#76

Re: The real stuff

TomD

"or more desirably, less than 90."

I realize a lot of the illuminati do this, but it is not more desirable. There is a a lot of glue holding power in the end grain, and there is also a lot of structural strength. The issue is twofold. One is that endgrain is very strong, so a little goes a long way, however, a sharp edge to sidegrain is too little. A solution there (as i your method if I got it) is a square cut buttress which is the registration point, then undercut the rest. Though one still misses out on glueing area. The other issue is that the dovetail failure mode may not involve initial rotation in the corner. Where this is the case the fact there is not end grain to buttress the joint is not a problem. So while drawers may not fail due to rotation in the joint... Even they may be dropped with heavy contents, or during a move, and the proportional limit could be tested. Also, there are structures where the dovetail joint is at the base of a canti structure, and those certainly should have all the strength elements present.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#77

Re: didn't understand the explanation

Ray

I am fairly new at all this, but I was originally planning to get O1 because they can be used at a lower angle than A2. That way I could use them for chopping non-exotics and also paring. LN recommends that A2 be used at 30 degrees or higher.

This what LN states on it site regarding O1 - A2

Our A-2 Steel chisels will hold an edge extremely well, especially when sharpened at an angle of 30 degrees or higher. Some folks however prefer O-1 Tool Steel, because O-1 holds up better at lower angles, 25 degrees or less, making them more useful for slicing or paring

I decided to go with A2 with the better edge retention and look for a dedicated set of paring chisels that can used at a much lower angle-probably Sorby or Taylor.

I rationalized that if I went with O1 I might be limiting my self to the type of wood I could work and the LN O1 chisels were not the traditional length, thickness & flexibility for paring.

At my age I have decided that I don't want to re-buy something due to a calculated compromise.

Hope that helps.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#78

Re: try before committing to a set

CStanford

I have Marples Blue Chips with some older Marples chisels marked 'cast steel' (boxwood handles and ash handles) thrown in for good measure and for enough of a sense of the British tradition I suppose. There is probably no way to estimate the amount of successful woodworking done with these chisels given the thousands upon thousands that were sold.

The moral is not that there isn't something 'better' out there (on paper, there probably is), simply that there is a tradition that you can fall back on if you so choose.

Take the stuck with a shank pigsqueals of those forced to use gnarly tropicals with a grain of salt. These same chisels were used all over the Pacific Basin in all sorts of wood. And with much success. If you have any doubt, Google museums in Australia and New Zealand that have decorative arts collections to see for yourself. An modern aircraft carrier would probably not hold all the Marples gear shipped to and sold in Australia and New Zealand.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#79

Re: try before committing to a set

CStanford

"An" in the last sentence should be "A."

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#80

Re: blizzards

William Duffield

This one came equipped with a blizzard, too, in western VA and WV.

I've experienced my share of blizzards, too. They're no more fun than hurricanes or nor'easters, or combinations thereof, especially if you don't have a fireplace, or haven't laid in a good supply of firewood.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#81

Re: blizzards

Bruce, a MN Galoot

blizzards don't seep into your basement and flood your stuff. You can also generally move snow someplace where it stays piled up until sometime in May when it has the good grace to melt. Sometimes. And although I do remember one blizzard that had winds in excess of 100 mph (March 1966) that doesn't usually happen. One advantage of blizzards is that the places that usually get them also tend to have the equipment to deal with them.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#82

Re: blizzards

William Duffield

At least, what does "seep" in isn't salt water, and it won't float your house away. A guy I worked with in Ohio in the late '70s left an upwind car window cracked about a half inch in a blizzard. The storm totally packed the passenger compartment with wet snow. The ice finally thawed out enough he could get into the car in May.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#83

Re: didn't understand the explanation

david weaver

In the end, it won't make a difference as long as you sharpen them and use them.

But i wouldn't choose A2 for any chisels were I in your shoes, at least going forward. The things that make it more difficult to sharpen don't make it any better in chisels like they do in planes.

It is a nice middle of the road plane iron material, better than O1 if it is hardened and tempered properly, but it in chisels, it is the other way around.

If nobody told you the two were different, though, and you worked your whole life with one or the other, it would make no difference to you.

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#84

Re: didn't understand the explanation

Ray

You have gained my attention.

Can you go into more detail as to why the relationship between O1 and A2 is different for chisels than planes? One of the reasons that I purchase most of my tools from LN because some are very expensive and without a retail store close for testing, I can always return them if it makes sense.

I would appreciate hearing from others on A2 vs O1 also.

Thanks

Re: Lee Valley PMV11 chisel evaluation Part 3

#85

Re: didn't understand the explanation

david weaver

Chisels fail by hammering them into things. Plane irons fail ultimately (hopefully) by rubbing them against things.

O1 is better at impact when the angle is 25 degrees, a comfortable chisel angle. A2 really likes something more along the lines of 32 degrees to perform well in impact tests, maybe more and is harder to sharpen because of the things that make it a better plane steel (those things being carbides).

Carbides in A2 that make it more resistant to wear by rubbing don't do anything for it in terms of impacting, I guess they probably make it less resistant to impact damage.

But they are wear resistant when the issue is rubbing against something (and when you plane, the wood is rubbing both sides of the bevel), so they are beneficial for that. A2 definitely lasts a lot longer planing if you use a common pitch plane and a final bevel angle of 30 degrees. Or if you use 30 degrees as a final bevel and any final bevel for O1.

As long as you can sharpen, though, it doesn't make much difference. Now that you've bought, it's water under the bridge. If you someone hasn't bought yet, O1 for chisels. A2 for higher wear planing situations (debatable that a good medium hard O1 is better for smoothing, but that's only definite if the A2 is not hardened and tempered properly and leaves little lines all over everything).