New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Paul Sellers

Posts

Re: Paul Sellers

#76

Re: Maybe he should wear a Monk's robe

david weaver

More like not complaining about industrialized society and then riding airplanes back and forth across the ocean and extracting money from it.

I keep comparing George Wilson, partly because I think it's likely that George is a better craftsman all around, but also because I have seen him mention several times that he grew up poor and determined and he has no delusions about what it was like to live 200 years ago where the bulk of society lived in poverty.

Industrialization makes our lives pretty easy. We don't have to work nearly as much as people did 200 years ago and we can sit around complaining about the ills that it's created while figuring out how to pitch something to extract disposable income generated by it.

Re: Paul Sellers

#77

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#78

Re: And move to East Aurora and answer only to "Fr

david weaver

No chastity required!

That'd increase frustration with society even more, regardless of whether or not it was industrialized. :b

Re: Paul Sellers

#79

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

Michael Brady

Sellers does tend to be openly critical of his peers, in the context of his blog. He is very dismissive of some of the popular gurus of hand tool woodworking. On one occasion where he had taken a woodworking friend of mine to task, by name, in his blog, I personally notified this respected professional furniture maker about Mr. Sellers' comments. He was not at all bothered by it, to his credit, and had not even heard of Paul Sellers. As a final touche', he allowed that he seldom reads blogs and never forums. Clearly I was more bothered by the situation than either of the parties directly involved; and I proceeded to retire to my room and sulk in my insignificance.

Re: Paul Sellers

#80

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

I'd love to read that blog entry... can you link to it?

Re: Paul Sellers

#81

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

There are probably gobs of world class craftsmen who have much higher work output and never get on the internet, I don't know how many, but I'm sure they're too busy completing projects and perhaps instructing a few true gifted apprentices to be out looking for students. George Wilson never showed up on the internet until he retired. I don't see anything in the sellers portfolio that looks remotely like some of the things that George has posted, and you can openly ask a question and get a conservationist quality answer.

I haven't met anyone who has more fascination with tools (or understanding of them), either, which is curious because some of the experts here are certain that if we are fascinated with the tools, we can't actually work with them.

Re: Paul Sellers

#82

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Being fascinated with tools is one thing. Being fascinated to the point of never really doing much of anything with them is quite another. At that point, one is basically a collector. Nothing wrong with it, but might as well call a spade a spade.

George obviously isn't one of those guys. Don't know about the rest of us. I'm not fascinated with them and my output is still lousy.

Re: Paul Sellers

#83

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

If there's something wrong with advertising your school to potential students you obviously haven't been on Philip Lowe's email mailing list (Furniture Institute of Massachusetts). The email comes fairly frequently. I happen to like Lowe, I think he's an excellent craftsman and I don't see anything wrong with him 'advertising' his school. It's top-notch.

What do you think?

Re: Paul Sellers

#84

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I have seen the name, but I know little about who he is or what he does.

I mentioned previously that I will get follansbee's blog stuff ported to my reader, but that's it. And I have never made anything that he makes nor do I intend to, I just find his blog entertaining because it's miles different from what I normally do.

I don't get any other email lists, etc. They are too narrow and they don't help me with my biggest problem, which is figuring out how I want something specific to look. If I can't figure that out, and I don't have something to copy, then I can't get very far without getting crippled in indecision about whether or not something looks OK.

Re: Paul Sellers

#85

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

People who have woodworking schools promote them.

Here is Lowe's in case you're interested:

http://www.furnituremakingclasses.com/fim/

Re: Paul Sellers

#86

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Lowe did conservation work on a chest that sold for $2.4MM at auction. He's pretty important in the furniture world. They don't put work like that into the hands of any old hack.

Re: Paul Sellers

#87

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

It seems fine to me, like it is a more serious school than a weekender's place for beginners. I'm having trouble seeing some of the work on his page, but I'm seeing enough of it to see that the full-time program is intended to have people doing exceptional work.

Re: Paul Sellers

#88

David??

ron in Kokomo

EVERYBODY WHO TEACHES TEACHES WHAT THEY ARE FAMILIAR WITH. There...... maybe a little loud, but I have said it. Your posts would have lead us to believe that Mr. Sellers is the only opinionated woodworking guru. Ever read Ian Kirby, or Frank Klausz, or Tage Frid??

There are apparently a lot of folks who like what Mr. Sellers teaches. You don't. OK Fine, but don't bash him unless you are willing to compare bona fides so that we may judge how likely you are to know what you are talking about.

The folks at Popular Woodworking must think Mr. Sellers is OK. They know a little bit about the craft

Re: Paul Sellers

#89

Re: David??

david weaver

Why are you responding to a post I made 10 days ago? I thought we were pretty much done with the subject, other than Charles sharing another woodworker. You're free to ignore my posts. Like everyone else, I'm unlikely to consider what someone else wants me to say or not say when I post.

Re: Paul Sellers

#90

Missed the time limit sorry


Re: Paul Sellers

#91

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

...still hoping you'll link to the Sellers blog post you mentioned...

Re: Paul Sellers

#92

Re: David??

CStan

Sellers is mild compared to Ian Kirby. And I like the hell out of Ian Kirby.

Re: Paul Sellers

#93

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Yes, it's a serious school run by a seriously talented craftsman.

Lowe has written continuously for FW since the black and white days, the very early years of the magazine.

Do you read much?

Re: Paul Sellers

#94

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

If you search FW on Phil Lowe's name you get ten pages of results and I don't think this covers the entire actual cumulative index of the magazine.

Re: Paul Sellers

#95

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I got FW for one or two years, but it was in about 2006. It wasn't very good (at least to me it wasn't, lots of stuff like how many feet a router bit can go and the 14 inch bandsaw shootout - the kind of stuff I'm not into).

I hear that the old issues were spectacular, but I haven't come across them anywhere.

Re: Paul Sellers

#96

Me too


Re: Paul Sellers

#97

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

They have them all on CD. It would be money very well spent I can assure you.

Re: Paul Sellers

#98

Re: 2.4 million

TomD

Actually they often do, or did. If the people doing the placing are in some kind of formal deal, like conservation, they are going to need someone qualified. But it is amazing how much is just proximity, and who the guys sending the stuff out know.

Re: Paul Sellers

#99

Re: David??

TomD

I don't find Klausz opinionated, he forcefully says how he does stuff. But I find him correct on that, and he has even changed all his tools just to put students at ease, eschewing the German stuff for more familiar american gear.

Re: Paul Sellers

#100

Re: David??

CStan

He and Kirby used to go at it in competing articles in FW.