Paul Sellers
CStan
... Sellers has gotten into the 'chop a mortise through a glass window' act 'ala Peter Follansbee:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_NXq7_TILA
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Paul Sellers
CStan
... Sellers has gotten into the 'chop a mortise through a glass window' act 'ala Peter Follansbee:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_NXq7_TILA
Blue Chip 1 PigSticker 0
Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
I think it's more like $10 vs. $30
Unless you choose the cheapest you can find a used bluechip against the most expensive new chisel.
It seems paul wants the blue chip to win, too, because he hammers it faster and works faster with it (he should be a salesperson, they like comparisons where you draw a conclusion first and then try to make it appear that you're working to it, too). Not only his hammer pace, but the pace he works between cuts to get the chisel back into cuts.
One might guess by the distance that the B/C works through the wood (with each hammer strike) that it's also sharper.
It'll be beginners gold, though, I can just see the beginners on SMC decrying the "fraud" that's been wrought on woodworkers for several centuries with mortise chisels, all backed by a youtube video.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
Paul states that he's more comfortable using a beveled-edge chisel than a mortise chisel. I believe that's the reason he's faster with it.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
Right, and the best way generally to work is what you're familiar with. It makes comparisons a little biased.
The conclusion is fine, I don't have a problem with it, you can chop a mortise with anything (at least I hope people can).
If cheap is the metric.....
Bill Tindall
then make a chisel. Once I left the strange piece of wood I was practicing on my home made chisel (less than $10) did nicely in these deep mortises. I am not going to buy a $100 historically "perfect" mortise chisel to chop out some mortises once a year. I made my chisels from bar stock and had it heat treated along with some other tools. However, one could buy already heat treated long rectangular lathe bits in M2 and simply grind out a chisel of pig sticker format.
I tried the bevel chisel for mortising. It certainly works and if I had not made a chisel, in the spirit of multitasking, I would be mortising with a bevel chisel after seeing that I can be done. In fact that is a valuable contribution of the video. For the woodworker not inclined to have a chisel perfect for every task it was good to see that the average (well below average in the case of the Blue Handles) chisel could do mortising.
That said, with the amount of experience I have I felt better prying with the robust piece of bar stock than a wimpy bevel chisel deep within a 5/16" mortise.
Differing objectives
Bill Tindall
For some woodworking is all about owning, or finding, or restoring the perfect tool for a woodworking operation. For others it is the belief that if they own the perfect tool for the task they can do the task perfectly. Happily, a multitude of suppliers have developed over the past 20 years or so to satisfy these clients.
For others it is about time. A minute saved is a dollar earned. For still others it is getting the job done with what ever is at hand. Etc.
It is great that we have magazines, clubs, forums, etc. now days to discusses these differing approaches. It enables better informed choices.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
Really?
I saw a mortise being effectively cut with a $5 chisel.
What's your take on the smoothness of the walls? How did Sellers stack the deck in favor of the Blue Chip? I guess one man's "manipulation" is another's good technique.
Re: Differing objectives
CStan
What's your take on the difference in the mortise walls?
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
The Iles 3/8" chisel at TFWW is $90, though it appears several sizes are currently out of stock. I guess these things can be had, vintage, on EBay for $30. If you say so.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
You must just ignore parts of my posts on purpose when you respond. Sure, he cut a mortise with both. He cut a mortise faster (and worked at a faster pace) with the chisel that he uses to do the same thing a lot.
There's not much surprise there. Those are relatively large mortises. One would look at those and conclude that there was no reason for a mortise chisel to ever have been invented, so you'd wonder why all of these sash mortise and oval bolstered chisels exist in the first place?
It must've been faster for workmen whose job was to cut mortises fast in order to feed themselves (vs. the new brand of "professiona woodworker" who is selling videos and some false idealistic idea of anti-industrialism - while you sell to the people who only have discretionary income because of industrialism), otherwise the OB mortise chisels and the sash mortise chisels wouldn't have existed. Andy they do exist in great numbers.
I must've totally missed in my own posts where I said that you can't cut a mortise with a $5 chisel.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
They can be had for $10 on ebay if you're willing to make your own handle. The going rate for handled versions appears to be $20-$40, with many not selling at $40 (i.e., the price at $40 was too high even for ebay, which is what I would describe as a no effort max cost place to get things). Most are not nearly as bulky as the one that sellers chose, either. Compare that chisel with the picture on Joels page or some on ebay, the chisels aren't as bulky, nor are the business ends as blunt.
I don't know what a new blue chip would be individually, $15? Even paul won't use the new ones, I'd bet. They don't even have the same side profile as the old ones. But it doesn't matter what it is, it could be a $2 tool box chisel or a brand new chisel for $2 from HF if someone wanted to use that.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
I thought it was interesting that he appeared to cut a better mortise with his big chisel than Follansbee did in his video.
What do you think?
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
Well David that's interesting because you first post in the thread was poking holes in the whole thing. What impression were you trying to leave?
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
What about the mortise walls?
Any explanation for that phenomenon?
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
You're the EBay expert - do the same analysis on Blue Chips as you've done on pigstickers and let us all know.
They ain't much, I'm pretty sure.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
Individually, they are all over the board. Sold from $5 to $22 for one chisel, there's one past sale of 3 for $8 (that's a good buy!, came to about $18 with shipping), but I didn't check to see what shipping was. Average price for individuals is probably about $10.
Set of 4 for $35 delivered, though there is nothing like that listed now, there's a reason those sales were successful.
I bought a set of 5 for $45 delivered a few months ago. I doubt it was up long. I consider that a good deal.
As far as how clean the mortise is with the two chisels, I have no idea what the OB chisels is like in Sellers' video (how sharp the bottom is), but mine are fresh and they leave clean sides. I'd imagine how clean the mortise is is more a function of how sharp the edge is on the bottom of those two chisels, and that his OB chisel does not have clean lines like his marples chisel does.
I did notice, too, that sellers does not excavate the waste completely or break it with the mortise chisel, but he's very careful to excavate it completely with his blue chip chisel, and cleanly across the bottom.
It appears from the comments that he has a lot of tinfoil hat fans who think he's the key to someone else not controlling their mind. You're championing him, but he's selling very pedestrian advice to beginners, instead of tools. I don't see the difference. One could buy wearing's book for $20 or less and get what a lot of current pushers are trying to sell for several hundred.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
Just what I said. You can cut a mortise with anything. You can certainly make one tool look worse than the other if you intentionally use one with more effort, though.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
I checked EBay, looks like vintage Blue Chips (pre-Irwin) sell at a premium.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
They do, and they should. The new ones don't have nearly as good of a profile, and while the CV steel in the old bluechips is nothing special, there's nothing wrong with it. Who knows what the new ones are like, they are probably OK, too, but their profile sucks and the finish level is coarse.
The whole deal with them ceasing production instead of raising prices to where they need to be was a real disservice to bread and butter woodworking.
But it has been the same story with everyone. It probably costs them $3 to make a full set of chisels in china, so they sold out.
Being that you can get one for $8 plus a little shipping, that's not too bad, though. And you can get sets like I did if you're willing to wait.
There is, however, a dealer near my parents that has vintage chisels of better brands for that price ($5-$8 each) if one has the inclination to pick through them and do some refurbishing.
But, anyway, sure they sell at a little bit of a premium but to have a set of 5 for $50 is by no means bad. they probably sold for that much at least 15 years ago new.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
I really don't know Paul Sellers well enough to impute some sort of malintention to his whole exercise. You're obviously seeing a lot more than I saw. He doesn't SEEM like that kind of guy. There doesn't seem to be a whole lot of guile in the thing. It would be kind of hard for him to be hawking Blue Chips since he's not even using a version that's currently available new.
I saw two mortises cut at about the same speed. It doesn't surprise me that the Blue Chip sinks faster since the mallet is driving a lot less meat into the hole. I think Sellers even addressed this in the video anticipating comments like yours.
I'll go back and check sometime.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
Nope, I bought a set of five about fifteen years ago for around thirty bucks and this from a local tool dealer/lumber yard known for being on the high side.
They were $5 dollar per chisels back in the day Garrett Wade carried them.
Charles - what bothers you vs. me.
david weaver
Charles, apparently we are bothered by significantly different things.
There is a whole range of tools available. Depending on my mood, there are days that I go totally cheap, and other days I spend a lot of money. I don't have money issues, though, and if I didn't have it (and then some), I would go the cheap route all the time.
But it's not foreign to me that you can do good work with inexpensive tools, and I don't think it's foreign to most. Beginners will often buy the best tools they can find thinking that it will move them up the ladder, and they'll sometimes misinterpret better tools for better results, just as some folks will look for a sub MOA rifle to hunt deer in the woods.
What bothers me is the number of hucksters trying to sell videos displaying nothing new, and at the same time shooting barbs at each other or industrialized society (selling a fake ideal, like sellers who loves to shoot barbs at industrialized society and wealth, while holding his hand out for money that's a result of industrialized society). People are not apparently aware of just how poor craftsmen were and how little they had in the idealized retroactive look that most of these hucksters push.
Sellers may have a slightly different message, but it's clear that the ideals that he pushes would leave him with no students in reality, so it's a farce. To me at least. What I hope to not see any more of is the next new teacher who comes along teaching the entire set of beginners woodworking stuff with a different twist in how the message is delivered. But I'm sure there is another one on the horizon somewhere. This time, the message is instead that you shouldn't spend a lot of money on tools, but somehow you should spend a lot of money on instruction that should instead be replaced with inexpensive references and time in the shop - in my opinion.
Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
david weaver
I gathered that from reading his blog for a while. I got so tired of it, I had to stop reading it. Like I mentioned below, it's just one of those irks of mine.