New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Paul Sellers

Posts

Re: Paul Sellers

#51

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I'm confused by this. I'm sure you can chop a mortise just as well as either in the video (perhaps in a contest where the wood was the same and one side wasn't free to break off like the glass side is there, he could beat you marginally), and I doubt his edges are any better than yours.

I doubt there is much difference in the edges that any competent woodworkers get, though it seems like folks are pretty sure their methods or sharpening tools are always the "right ones" or better. I haven't yet seen a method, type of stone, etc, that can't deliver an edge that is right next to hanging hair sharp in less time than it will take someone to catch their wind in a brisk session.

I get what you're trying to say figuratively, though.

Re: Paul Sellers

#52

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

In the wholeness of the craft, Sellers is a better woodworker than I am. It's just that simple. From what I've seen, I like the way he works, his approach to the craft. This doesn't mean I'm dumping the way I do things.

Re: Paul Sellers

#53

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Please, describe the theme that offends you. I don't see it, but I'm willing to be convinced.

Re: Paul Sellers

#54

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

I re-read this. You really honestly believe this guy is a huckster? I mean, how so?

Re: Paul Sellers

#55

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

Well, I don't know what you do for a living, but as it's what Sellers does for a living, I hope he's a little better at it.

According to his wiki page, he has been here since 1984 (and presume instructing since then or about then).

I tend to like to read from the guys who talk about woodworking, and not about cures for all of society's problems. I don't know the guy, I liked the approach until I read the blog.

I try to have a lot of inertia. I'm sure everything I read affects what I'm doing to some extent, but I've never done anything positive where repetition without constant wholesale changes didn't help some things.

I might revisit cutting a mortise with a bench chisel with a clock near by to see if it seems faster, but probably by the time I'd get around to doing that, I will have lost interest. I don't remember it being faster or slower, I just remember thinking I liked the feel of a mortise chisel a lot better in a mortise with defined sides. With a plane mortise, it makes no difference, it's just wholesale hogging until the end.

Re: Paul Sellers

#56

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

Paraphrased here:

* we can't enjoy life because of industrialization

* people see me and wish they could do what I do (in context, implying that someone who is not working with their hands has no fulfillment)

* industrialized society causes a lot of junk (it also allows us to have a higher standard of living where people have time and money to waste on hobbies)

* it is a shame that all of this good work at the castle is attached to dirty wealth

In reality, I see it as this - wealth drives commissions for the best work. It doesn't exist without the wealth. And pontificating about the simpler life exists only because we have things in such abundance that we can sit around and pontificate. The "simple life" in reality is ascribed to poverty for all but a very few. 200 years ago, most folks' hobby was trying to get by.

I don't get a lot of excitement of folks trashing society when their are milking it at the same time. Without an industrialized society and the disposable income that comes from it, paul sellers would have no students and his life would likely be much more difficult.

That's my irk. It's not that hard to get .. and that's why I prefer woodworking instructors who stick to woodworking.

Re: Paul Sellers

#57

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

So, there's a vague date of 1984 floating about and that's what makes him a huckster? Is it objectionable that somebody has been woodworking and teaching for 28 years? Where do you mentally set the bar? Would 40 years be enough?

What is it, specifically, that he doesn't do 'well?'

Re: Paul Sellers

#58

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

The only thing missing is a wagon with a sign on it and videos in it explaining the virtues of the "simple life" through craft.

Re: Paul Sellers

#59

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I haven't seen anywhere that I said he doesn't do well. I think you could find about 6 or 10 messages where I stated what my irk is. I don't quite follow why all of your questions asking for clarification constantly assert statements that weren't actually made. It's a style you've had for years, trying to steer conversations.

Nobody likes to waste time responding to statements they didn't make or even imply.

Re: Paul Sellers

#60

Huckster - Definition

david weaver

I don't know what a dictionary might say about huckster, I saw some odd definitions on google about people who write ad copy or other strange things.

What a huckster was where I grew up was someone who carted a wagon around, full of goods to sell. They often threw out little bits of information, staged attention attracting events or gave away freebies to bring attention to their wagon in hopes of making a sale (or directing folks back to a business).

All the way up to the early 1900s, the general stores in town would either by contract or by employment would have a huckster wagon that went around promoting their wares and their store. (in this case, it would be videos and blog posts showing freebies or in the case of blog posts bringing attention to a problem and offering a solution for sale).

By itself, it has no connotation one way or another. Only with the context of what was being sold or the results of the sale (the experience with the person or product) could you determine whether or not it was positive or negative.

Re: Paul Sellers

#61

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#62

Re: my error..

david weaver

...was in not clarifying initially that the basis was in more than just the video.

Communication of reasoning can be difficult, even moreso when extra bits are being extrapolated to your statements that are otherwise outside what you've said by a factor of 10. :b

Re: Paul Sellers

#63

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#64

Re: Well, there's an art to baiting a hook...

david weaver

It's always been obvious to me, but for some reason I like to argue, too, so I go along (I think it must be the influence of my mother - I can set her up and tell her I'm setting her up, and then we're arguing anyway, and all of the sudden i'm arguing, too, in a fake argument that I set up).

The trouble on forums is if I say straight up "you're trolling", then that's against the TOS in a lot of places, so I can't be as direct about it as I see it.

And there have been a few times where people have been obviously trolling, and when I accused them of it, they went totally off the deep end. I don't know what's worse - intentional trolling, or people who do it naturally and get offended when they're accused :)

Re: Paul Sellers

#65

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#66

Sincerity

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"As Jean Giraudoux said, 'the key to success is sincerity. Once you can fake that you've got it made.' "

And here I thought 'twas George Burns who said that.

Re: Paul Sellers

#67

Re: Maybe that was George's Bayou Name

:)

Re: Paul Sellers

#68

One day....

John in NM

I would love to see one of these threads not devolve into a sort of "my way is better" or "you don't respect my way" kind of spitting match. I think a lot of readers miss useful information through boredom with the recurring discussions of who's chisel is bigger :D

Personally, I don't care in the least if a guy out there doing illustrative videos is a huckster, salesman, period correct, or even kicks his dog off camera. If he is getting people to participate and try new things, then good for him. At that point I don't care if he's using a Blue Chip, antique pig sticker, or even a ground up piece of truck spring. It continues to amaze me how emotionally invested we all seem to get in techniques, tool choices, and even favorite TV personalities.

Re: Paul Sellers

#70

Amen John....suggestion

Bill Tindall

If one finds that a thread becomes a two person conversation, share emails and continue off line.

Re: Paul Sellers

#71

Burns was faking it   


Re: Paul Sellers

#72

Re: One day...

North of the Border

Very good viewpoint. Sellers is a skilled woodworker with his own convictions and beliefs and even though I am not in agreement with everything he has promoted, I check out his blog now and then. Sometimes, his controversial views are refreshing and force me to rethink. I wouldn't brush him off just because some of his beliefs may be wrong.

Re: Paul Sellers

#73

Sellers ain't new

Ron in Kokomo

He has been at it for a while and his classes are pretty full

Ron

Re: Paul Sellers

#74

Re: Sellers ain't new

david weaver

Presume he must've been somewhat regional. This last video push that's started recently was the first I've heard of him. I saw from wiki that he's been in the states on and off since 1984, presume also that's to go back and forth between schools.

When I think of a craftsman who really does boast a lifetime of top shelf achievement, I think of someone like George Wilson, who instructed only apprentices and who did not come up for air until he was retired. Personally, I can learn a lot more from George (and have already in regard to making tools), but you have to ask questions as folks like George aren't looking for students.

The large hobby woodworker scene is a fairly new one, at least the hand too scene. I'm sure it's existed at some level in terms of fine woodwork indefinitely, just how small. Guess there must've been a resurgence of some sort in the 70s and 80s, too? Because there seems to be a whole range of now defunct 1970s and 1980s tools (like the soft steeled fat-plated dovetail saws, etc, and the export-only japanese tools).

Re: Paul Sellers

#75

Maybe he should wear a Monk's robe

Ron in Kokomo

Perhaps if he took a vow of poverty and maybe chastity he would be OK?