New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Paul Sellers

Posts

Re: Paul Sellers

#26

Re: Blue Chip $5.50  PigSticker $70.00

CStan

David, whether or not he's selling chisels or selling his services as a teacher, he showed a very clean mortise cut with a $5 chisel. Maybe he shouldn't have juxtaposed with one cut with a pig-sticker. Then, the whole thing could have stood on its own and not be subject to criticism that the whole thing was rigged.

Blot out, in your mind if you will, the first part of the video showing the mortise cut with the PS. Then your left with a very clean mortise cut in only a few minutes, in oak, in real time, a very serviceable half a mortise and tenon joint cut with a Blue Chip (or insert the name of your favorite bevel edged chisel brand).

Frankly, the mortise he cut with his pigsticker was better than Follansbee's and I don't think in much more time either. So if what you say is true that Sellers consciously or subconsciously rigged the whole thing by using a dull, poorly prepped P-S chisel then there's the quality of the joint he cut vs. Follansbee's, which I frankly thought was an abomination, though it would have been perfectly serviceable in a situation with no glue and perhaps fox wedged or fox pinned somehow. The tenon sure has heck would have had to be four-shouldered to cover the mess he made with the mortise.

Re: Paul Sellers

#27

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#28

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

CStan

David, I didn't see anything in the YouTube video linking to some video for sale.

Did I miss something?

Follansbee is hawking his video through L-N.

I'm having a little bother not understanding why you can't view the thing in more of a vacuum than you're willing to. He cut a great mortise with an old chisel that is not even available on the market new. Sure, the guy has a woodworking school. So did Krenov, Frid taught, Phil Lowe has a school. All of these guys with recognizable names have/had schools or make a little extra coin at Marc Adams' school or North Bennett, or wherever as guest instructors.

What's your problem with all of this? Is everybody out to 'get' the beginner? If you go to any of these schools you can bet your bippy you will see tools being used that are in current production. If that influences you to buy then so be it. Is Chris Gochnour a bad buy because he likes using an L-N dovetail saw? Or is it Adria? Who really cares? Is he really hawking the tool or simply using the tool he likes to use?

Your argument really doesn't make sense, to ascribe a bunch of bad intention to Sellers' free video on YouTube.

You seem to the the only guy wearing the tinfoil hat.

Re: Paul Sellers

#29

Re: Blue Chip $5.50  PigSticker $70.00

david weaver

I can't comment on what follansbee does in terms of clean work, it all looks pretty coarse and i figured that's how he intends for it to look. I have never had trouble getting clean mortise sides with a fresh RI chisel, and that is by no means implying that anyone has to buy one to find out if they can get the same experience as me.

I have been all over the board in cost of tools, and have cut mortises for dais with a stanley bench chisel that I got for $10.

I personally mark the mortise out and cut it and don't worry that much about the sides. They don't look hairy on any of mine, but whatever they are, I'll worry about changing them the first time I see a failure in a piece of furniture.

Re: Paul Sellers

#30

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

CStan

A farce? Wow! What was farcical about the mortise cut on the left side of the screen?

Was it all a figment? Just staged? A camera trick? Did he have the temerity to use a sharp chisel? That ba$tard. What a jerk! Doesn't he know that beginners can't sharpen so using a sharp chisel isn't "fair."

Just because you are paranoid, David, doesn't mean we aren't ALL out to get you!

.

Re: Paul Sellers

#31

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

david weaver

I ascribed none of that to this particular video, i ascribed it to the sellers blog, I said that already.

You do a video like this (if you're sellers or someone else) assuming that traffic will bring sales or students.

He has another separate video already showing the mortise cutting. I'm not sure what the big deal is about cutting a mortise with a bench chisel, it's not new.

I did get a chuckle that someone asked why their chisel was twisting, though, perhaps that's an unstated advantage of a mortise chisel, I don't know. It makes little difference to me what someone uses.

(FTR, I have never gone to someone's "class", it doesn't appeal to my german and swiss sense, which is that you spend a lot of money to learn to do something routine that you could've learned on your own or with a little cheap reading, and you're left holding nothing in your hand at the end. They are (the classes), to me, akin to an expensive dinner. I would rather pay a craftsman or toolmaker to make something that I don't have the skill to do or make, that's just my bent).

Re: Paul Sellers

#32

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

david weaver

Charles, are you around the bend this morning or something?

I don't know how many times I have to mention that it's what he's huckstering in general, and not just the mortise video. Read his blog.

You probably would like his message, it wouldn't give you the same general irk as me. When I see someone else's message, it isn't detached from subsequent information that they provide. I have not held his other views secret in this thread, they are part of it.

I haven't disagreed for a second that you can cut a mortise with a $5 chisel, either.

But I do think the kind of message provided on the blog, and in commentary in general is a farce... that is implying superiority of your own lifestyle while depending on resources and monies provided by whatever you're trashing. The idealistic viewpoint doesn't exist without the resources from elsewhere.

You're puffering about this, I have no idea why. I guess because it's another thing where someone doesn't agree with you totally, and it elicits this maniacal batch of short posts, one after the other.

Re: Paul Sellers

#33

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

It is maddening to have a three figure investment in mortise chisels and not be able to do as good a job, in as little time, as some Scotsman (or Welshman?) wielding what many call entry level junk.

'Cept I'm not mad (I know you aren't either).

Re: Paul Sellers

#34

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

CStan

David, I linked to a video. Not the man's blog.

You obviously have some sort of weird vendetta today.

I thought the whole thing was interesting. You don't like the guy or his message. I don't really know why. I guess he does poke a few holes in a fancy balloon here or there, it would seem. This has gotten your goat and I'm sorry about that.

The video speaks for itself. Again, I saw a perfectly serviceable mortise cut with a cheap chisel. That's what I saw. You saw some sort of beguilement and attempt to misinform and over self-promotion.

If so many people didn't teach or run schools or have videos for sale you might have some, vague point worth making. Otherwise, I just don't see it.

Re: Paul Sellers

#35

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

If you've got the "three figure investment" in mortise chisels, I'm not sure why you would care what comparison someone does online. You could do the same comparison on your shop, and easily sell the mortise chisels if you don't like them.

I've cut mortise chisels both ways, but somehow this video isn't enough to get me to sell my "three figure investment". Nor is any of it enough for me to foist my opinion about what someone else should buy onto them. The secret's in the dirt, not in youtube videos.

I can't really see how any of these spats about tools are really part of the major slice of woodworking, which is made up of deciding what you're going to make, what stock you're going to choose, how it's going to look and how you're going to mark it.

Fighting over the details about tools is like arguing over the details of stepping over a pigeonhill when your real objective is to climb everest immediately after.

Re: Paul Sellers

#36

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Yep, I have a three figure investment in mortise chisels. Sure do. Just barely. Three Robt Sorby's bought from Garrett Wade a long, long time ago.

No reason to be sorry. At all. I needed mortise chisels so I bought them. My woodworking pre-dates EBay by some several years.

Re: Paul Sellers

#37

Re: Charles - what bothers you vs. me.

david weaver

You pretty much summed it up, I did think the video showed he can use a tool he uses more often better, which is exemplified by the fact that he appeared to use it faster and more carefully.

And you're right, I do have an irk about the guy more than the video. It colors my response. I was a "fan" (as near as I'll be of anyone) at first because he was using cheap tools and not linked to any retailers or makers, but the" anti-industrialized but I'll take the proceeds of the indstrialization" is something that comes across as a sales pitch to me. The same as the "cheap tools but expensive furniture" message doesn't strike me as that sensible. If the end users of the furniture made the same demands, they'd want only cheap plain furniture, because it would do the job just as well. Everyone has priorities where they want their money to go, but they want them to be subsidized at the expense of another sector.

At least it made this whole thread a little more entertaining. The last time you posted a video like this nobody or only one or two responded, and that wasn't much fun was it?

Most people are probably as tired of the "expensive tools are a sham" stuff as they are of seeing new sharpening videos. Folks like to make their own decisions as far as I know.

Re: Paul Sellers

#38

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

I don't "care." I thought it was "interesting." I care about my three year old daughter. I think Sellers' video was interesting.

And really, I thought the most interesting part was that he did a better job with a chisel he doesn't even use on a regular basis than the guy who is supposed to be an expert with his. Really, if there's any takeaway from the video it's this. And to hear you tell it, he used a dull chisel to do it.

Trust me, I'm not using my Blue Chips to cut mortises. I'm fine with my routine.

Re: Paul Sellers

#39

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Paul Sellers

#40

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

You have a four figure investment (sounds like to me) in honing stones but you're always up to your eyeballs in every sharpening thread, and posted video for that matter, that hits more than one forum.

Why would you care? You would seem to have that waterfront covered.

Re: Paul Sellers

#41

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I'm not sure I'd rely on a guy who specializes in late 1600s woodworking in white oak as a direct comparison to another guy who is using a tool in brown oak.

I have never cut a mortise behind glass, either, so I don't know what else might be in play. I hope never to cut one behind glass, and I'm sure we'll see other self promoters doing the same thing with it in the near future.

What's your experience with your mortise chisels, it seems like you could gather from this that you could ditch them for a few bucks have more money. How do the walls look vs. your bench chisels?

Re: Paul Sellers

#42

David Barnett

Ant-farm mortising. What can be next?


Re: Paul Sellers

#43

Re: Cheap can be fun

CStan

Yep, the BBs are easily the equal of the Blue Chips except maybe on the grind. A touch less refined.

Re: Paul Sellers

#44

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I do like the stones. They are my vice. i get the same thrill from learning a new one as someone gets tasting wines. No clue why, but as long as I get the thrill, I don't care why. It certainly has nothing to do with woodworking.

I did sell 3 of them off this week, though, and have another one arriving soon. Pisses my wife off every single time. In or out, she hates stones.

Every time someone has asked me about stones, I've suggested they get one set and use them until they run out, that my vice is just that, and that even at one set, their budget should determine what they get because there are really cheap ways to get good results comfortably and quickly. Sometimes people follow it, sometimes they don't i guess because they have their own curiosity.

Maybe stones are the only thing I'm qualified to give any advice on, just due to expenditure and experience, and even at that, I'm sure plenty of people will disagree with what I think. I have heard a million times that i'm not getting a good edge because I don't use a full progression of stones.

Re: Paul Sellers

#45

Re: Ant-farm mortising. What can be next?

CStan

I have some firecrackers left over from 4th. I'm going to try demolition on my next set.

Cue YouTube!

Re: Paul Sellers

#46

Re: Cheap can be fun

david weaver

I saw that thread. I, too, have a grinder that I bought for a single purpose (bought it from HF). It is still working. I have beat it, and my FIL needed one but didn't want to spend any money, so I gave it to him when someone gave me a great deal on a makita grinder.

He's still beating on it, and I know for sure he'll use it until it dies, because contemplation about spending money keeps him from spending any at all.

I do get great excitement from shaving off a cheap stone or using a $3 iron from HD that I have placed in an $11 plane. Some day, I will enter a contest with that pair - I think I could win with it, but I don't want to be labeled as "that kind of person", you know? Not that I wouldn't love the competition of it. The combination is roughly 1/45th the cost of my finest plane. I'd be lying if I said the nicer plane wasn't nicer to use, it is, but each is a different kind of excitement.

Re: Paul Sellers

#47

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

David, you wondered why I would be interested in a thread on mortising since I already have three mortise chisels. And I observed that with a far greater investment in honing gear you still have an affinity for the honing threads.

I'll tell you what -- I'll make a vow to not post in another thread about mortising if you'll do the same about honing. Frankly, I think you'd burst at the seams or cut off a leg before you'd quit opining and pontificating about all matters honing.

Again, I'm happy to let Sellers' video speak for itself. It's interesting. I'm not advocating his methods. He can do that for himself.

Re: Paul Sellers

#48

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

Jeez, charles, the last thing I have any interest in is telling you what you should post about or not post about.

In the end, we both think these arguments are fun at some level, or we wouldn't do it.

I may have not said it well, but I wasn't intending to imply that you shouldn't find bench chisel mortising interesting given that it's unlikely you really need to see anything about mortising at all. What I was more curious about was whether your experience will lead you to switch to mortising with your blue chips, or if you'd done it and come to the same conclusion, even though you're using what is likely a very clean crisp sash mortise chisel instead of a gigantic (and that was a gigantic one) pigsticker.

Re: Paul Sellers

#49

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

CStan

Well, I'm not giving advice today. Just posting a link to a fun video.

I can't chop a mortise as well as Paul Sellers. I am not as good a woodworker as I believe Paul Sellers to be. I think he is a better artist and a better craftsman all the way around. I think his edges are sharper and are accomplished faster. I don't think he is prone to faffing around, I think he wrings out every scintilla of capability out of every tool he owns. I respect that. I have to. To do otherwise would be intellectually dishonest.

You see a borderline if not full-blown huckster. I don't.

Re: Paul Sellers

#50

Re: Fun thread. Fast, too. Like being in a chatroo

david weaver

I don't see a huckster in that particular video by itself.

I see a huckster after I read the blog and then I see the video, it supports the theme. I'm not into themes.