Re: Blue Chip $5.50 PigSticker $70.00
CStan
David, whether or not he's selling chisels or selling his services as a teacher, he showed a very clean mortise cut with a $5 chisel. Maybe he shouldn't have juxtaposed with one cut with a pig-sticker. Then, the whole thing could have stood on its own and not be subject to criticism that the whole thing was rigged.
Blot out, in your mind if you will, the first part of the video showing the mortise cut with the PS. Then your left with a very clean mortise cut in only a few minutes, in oak, in real time, a very serviceable half a mortise and tenon joint cut with a Blue Chip (or insert the name of your favorite bevel edged chisel brand).
Frankly, the mortise he cut with his pigsticker was better than Follansbee's and I don't think in much more time either. So if what you say is true that Sellers consciously or subconsciously rigged the whole thing by using a dull, poorly prepped P-S chisel then there's the quality of the joint he cut vs. Follansbee's, which I frankly thought was an abomination, though it would have been perfectly serviceable in a situation with no glue and perhaps fox wedged or fox pinned somehow. The tenon sure has heck would have had to be four-shouldered to cover the mess he made with the mortise.



