Re: Given what's now known
Kees
Yes I mean 0.01mm. Getting imperial and metric mixed up.
But I feel much milder today. That article on Larry's site is an advertisement of course. So we shouldn't take it too serious.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Given what's now known
Kees
Yes I mean 0.01mm. Getting imperial and metric mixed up.
But I feel much milder today. That article on Larry's site is an advertisement of course. So we shouldn't take it too serious.
Re: Given what's now known - A question
TomD
I agree it is an advertisement, but that doesn't mean it not the world as they see it (not suggesting you mean that). What would be the downside to them of having chip breakers. You can use a CB plane without the CB; you could offer them as an option; you can upcharge for them as a specialty plane, and you avoid the liability they assume for accidents of blades falling through, etc... I see no real reason for them to offer single blades unless that is where they are. Plus they were out ahead of the curve. I guess the first decade of the century will be remembered as single blade territory, but I see them as leading that with their article, at least as I have said many times, it helped make me feel better about my practice of using SBs for the most part. That leads me to conclude that they were out there when the main message at the time was double blades.
On the settings stuff. Can anyone tell me what the chip breaker setting is when one is working over 10 thou shavings, sometimes a lot over. And can anyone tell me what the setting is for say 3/10 000" setting? I'm not sure I have the memo on this part, are we sorta saying same thinckness as shaving sought? So that would be a 3/10 000" setting which is pretty sporty.
Re: Given what's now known - A question
Kees
Yes they believe in the single iron plane and will defend that choice. So the article highlights the disadvatages of the capiron. So in that sence it's an advertorial.
My take in all this are the other millions of handplanes around. These are mostly with capiron so it makes sence to makes the use of the capiron better known to the public.
Re: thick shavings. I think a .2mm shaving combines fine with about .3 to .4 mm capiron setting. Such thick shavings are not entirely tearout free for me but it's never really deep. And i don't know about the super thin ones. Tearout isn't much of an issue with them anyway.
I'm on it
Bill Tindall
New chest of drawer drawings nearly complete......however.......granddaughter is visiting this wee for her first time away from home. I expect to busy (shall we say soon to be exhausted)
Hope you have a great visit....
roger lance
smell the roses!!
Re: Blood boiling
Denis Chenard in Ottawa
Took me a while to find the thread, somehow the WC search engine does not work well with me...
Just to make sure, the hint you are referring to from that thread, is it this one?
>Greg, I think my experience contradicts some of your notions about planes. I have used a Bailey type smoother since 1973. I have never used a back bevel. Here is some history of my experience. 1978 Last use of sandpaper on a planed surface. As you can see, I didn't learn to use it overnight. I now use the smoother so unconsciously that it would take perhaps two years of daily use to compare another type of plane. But I must say that the problems with the Bailey plane that you enumerate seem somewhat fanciful.
1975. Last time I had any problems with clogging.
1976. Last time I used a bevel up plane.
1977. Last time I had any problems with tearout and last use of a scraper on a planed surface.
If so, that's one very subtle hint! Kind of brief on the whys and hows... I for one wish you had expanded more...
DC
There's a workaround
David Barnett
"Took me a while to find the thread, somehow the WC search engine does not work well with me..."
Type your keywords plus "woodcentral" into Google. Sometimes that does the trick.
Good idea, I'll try that in the future
Yep, looks like I missed it...
John in NM
Also missed the instigation of the whole "death knell" business, but now that David's referred to it again I kind of get the whole thing in retrospect. I'll resist the urge to blame it all on Barnett
and simply offer you my sincere apology.
Re: Given what's now known - A question
TomD
Well that is the thing, on the thin end, is the breaker even necessary? Maybe some of the folks who are still out there shilling for the single blade are just at a higher level. I'm not pointing at myself and hoping someone will notice. The main thing that suited me was the cycling thing, so long as I was getting the results I wanted the remainder was just a mater of having what Steve Jobs would refer to as a "better experience".
One thing I notice is that at times a blade hammered into a 2x4 does not seem complicated enough. I think we often prefer a complicated solution. Woodworking is a form of cutting vegetables, and I find, myself included, that we sometimes aren't comfortable with that. There are monkeys in those trees and we have only half climbed down. At least I can 3D print a tool. then resin infuse a part if I get feeling too primitive.
Re: Yep, looks like I missed it...
TomD
No apology needed. I'm more a sinner than sinned against, but I'm trying.
Do you really "know" what you think you do?
Larry Williams
First, I'm not sure how long it's been since that article was rewritten but my guess is about ten years and the original version was about 15 years ago. We learn new things here all the time and maintaining the articles to reflect our current thoughts isn't something that gets much attention.
I haven't read the Kato paper and haven't even read all the posts. It's kinda busy here. I did read where it was said they were drawing conclusions about edge wear. I read a number of posts mentioning increased effort at pushing the planes with close-set cap irons.
I've been at this long enough to know it's all about trade-offs. If you gain something with a modification, you'll lose something else. That extra force required to push the plane with a close-set blunt cap iron is going somewhere. My experience is that it mostly becomes heat as the wood is compressed and released through visco-elastic compression. That heat is concentrated right at the cutting edge.
If you still believe the dulling wear is from abrasion, I'm not too concerned about your fantasy. You can't abrade something with an abrasive softer than the thing you want to abrade. If you don't believe that, try sharpening carbide or even A-2 with its carbide inclusions with novaculite stones.
Silica is the mineral wood may contain that's harder than hardened steel. With a few exceptions, temperate zone softwoods and hardwoods don't contain anything more than trace amounts of silica. When working woods with silica, like bois d'arc or Western cedar, the wear pattern and feed-back sensation one gets is different from other domestic woods.
I was sure the dulling wear to an edge was from adhesive wear. A metallurgist we had in a work shop last week thought adhesive wear is a likely major factor but suggested that it could also be the result of a type of high temperature corrosion. He seemed to think that either of these could be the major wear mechanism and it wouldn't be difficult to design a test to find out. We'll probably pursue that.
At any rate, I don't see how anyone could draw any wear conclusion from the Kato study. Did you notice how long their sample was--what, about 2 1/2"? Did you see how long it took to take a shaving on that sample? Do you plane at that speed? Steel is pretty good at conducting heat and that slow planing speed would allow for easy dissipation of heat. Heat is a major catalyst to adhesive wear and the cause of high temperature corrosion. Heat build-up at the cutting edge was pretty much neutralized in the Kato study, hardly a real world situation.
I also didn't see any comparison of steeper pitches to the 40º cutting angle in the Kato study. I read claims about surface quality differences but never experienced that myself. What's the difference in wood compression and tensioning between steeper angle planes and ones with cap irons? I do see where one can basically increase the these to the same level as a scraper plane but scraper planes aren't especially noted for the surface quality they leave behind. It doesn't necessarily follow that when a little of something is good a lot is better. I even see a pretty severe edge life drop off after a cutting angle increase after 55º. I've learned to accept subjective judgments about surface quality with a lot of skepticism. I know from past conversations most people don't look for the same thing I do. Most seem to favor burnished wood surfaces and I regard burnishing as a flaw. It's pretty hard to get uniform finish or adhesive penetration in unevenly burnished surfaces and the only relatively uniform burnishing of surfaces I've seen was done on a lathe.
It may make some people's hearts go pitter-patter to switch to high speed steel irons or some other magic-bullet steel that require more exotic sharpening techniques with increased difficulty and more fiddling but not mine. I see the sharpening ability generally achieved out there when teaching workshops or when planes are returned to us for tuning. Amateur or professional, the sharpening ability I see out there is shockingly low and will remain there as long as tool makers from the P.T. Barnum school of tool making are out there peddling gimmicks "to make it all easier." In a real-life situation Kato's cap irons that gave the greatest wood compression of wood would need to be made of some heat resistant steel like HSS, which Mark has said is what is used in his super surfacers. I think it's sad, sharpening is so easy but the gimmicks make it so hard.
Some have claimed little or no wear to the cap iron in use. That wasn't my experience back when I was using and tuning double iron planes. I asked Don and it wasn't his experience. I see worn cap irons when I look at old double iron planes. To stand up to the heat of these blunt high compression set-ups does the cap iron also need to be made of HSS or other exotic steel? The cap irons will wear just like the plane irons. Oh good, I get two irons to sharpen or maintain each time I sharpen a plane? Two precisely uniform cambered edges for each cambered set-up? It'll be easy and just as quick, right?
You are aware that the venerable Norris offered a honing guide to put bevels on the flat face of their double iron planes "to convert an ordinary plane into a higher pitched plane giving the most satisfactory results on hard or curly grained material"??? Really, Norris suggested back beveling their double iron planes for better results on hard or curly grained wood??? Son of a gun, who'd have thought?

I've read in this thread where some think it's just a matter of slapping a double iron in a wooden plane. It's not. People don't seem to understand the ramifications of the necessary wear angle change to allow shavings to pass; that the abutments suddenly become stopped cuts ending at the wear while working in a confined escapement; that the tips of the wedge forks, high point of the cap iron and abutments all must align perfectly at precisely the same point to avoid creating a trap for shavings; or that these three must all be set while basically working blind inside the escapement. All this adjustability of the cap iron setting goes away when one understands the issues. There are problems here that were never solved.
I think people are developing tunnel vision around this and not asking the questions that weren't answered in the Kato study. While the study and video are interesting, I find what I've seen pretty lacking.
Correcting a misconception.....again
Bill Tindall
The video was prepared for teaching purposes. Its purpose was to show students how the cap iron worked. It seems that the cap iron effect has been amply confirmed by many. It remains for each of us to see how useful this effect is for the kind of work we each do.
The Kato-Kawai studies on wear were done under different planing conditions which were arranged to be relevant to the planing machine and hand planing. Many variables were explored- blade angle, blade metal, coated blades, wood species, etc. and the results published over the course of numerous papers which we have yet to translate.
At least read the paper we have translated before judging the merits of their work on wear. The experimental technique is described in this paper. You may gain some insights on you wear hypotheses.
Re: Correcting a misconception.....again
Larry Williams
Actually Bill, I do need that paper if I'm going to pursue setting up some tests with the help of the metallurgist who was in our workshop last week. Can it be e-mailed?
sent
PS, it is on Elliott's web site
Re: Blood boiling
CStan
IMO, it is largely the 'premium plane movement' that relegated the cap iron effect to almost lost lore. Fine performance in a plane had to be attributed to some other set of factors, e.g. 'mass,' frog pitch, quality of machining, historicity, amount of money spent,' etc. -- anything but a reasonably well set up mass produced plane with an effective cap iron, since this could be had for twenty bucks used and maybe an afternoon's worth of elbow grease. How quaint and pedestrian.
If somebody can't afford, or doesn't want to afford, shelling out several hundred dollars per plane, or silliness to beat all silliness, shelling out several hundred dollars AND get put on a several week if not several month bloody, damned 'waiting list' then that individual simply is not serious about their craftsmanship.
Re: Blood boiling
david weaver
I still firmly believe a lot of that comes from the people writing articles going from one class of beginners to the next trying to find the easiest way to get beginners going right away.
That's part of why I blew up about beginners vs. non-beginners. When you have blog posts telling people that there is no economy in buying a $20 vintage chisel vs. a $60 new one? That's aimed squarely at beginners.
When you have larry talking about dealing with beginners who are chasing a long back bevel on a BU plane...that kind of stuff doesn't apply to any of us.
But it seems like everything that's published has to cater to making rudimentary classes go smoothly. I just don't understand how someone who has to go through class after class of rudimentary stuff is ever going to get anywhere in this hobby, but they must be making up the bulk of subscribers and blog readers, because anything that takes more than 3 minutes to master is passed off as being due to inferior tools or skills that are too hard or too esoteric to master.
Reminds me a lot of golf. The best ball strikers have always been the guys who can figure stuff out on their own.
Re: Blood boiling
CStan
Still, there are older woodworking manuals clearly aimed at beginners that don't hesitate to mention close cap irons. Granted, there is not an attempt to burden the beginner by quoting a measurement it would take a machinist's tool to make.
Re: Blood boiling
david weaver
Benefit to a manual is you don't have to figure it out in 10 minutes.
Of course, some enterprising course maker could come up with a video or expensive class to show how to use and set the double iron.
If people are willing to pay for sharpening classes (and there are those local here), who knows what else they'd pay for?
I'd like to err on the side of telling someone to figure out what they want and find out or figure out how they want to get there.
Re: Blood boiling
Kees
I wonder, isn't it time for the video channels of Lie Nielsen or Lee Valley to make an instructional video like that? They both do make double iron planes, and they both have quite a lot of instruction videos on the web.'
I'd like to see Deneb trying to set the capiron on his LN #4, only to find out the adjuster doesn't make it all the way to the bottom of the plane. 
The easy way to sell . . .
Bob Lang
. . . something to a woodworker is to first convince him that he couldn't possibly accomplish a task without the assistance of your jig, gizmo, method or expertise. Get over that hurdle (which is easy when the beginning woodworker starts off by saying "I don't know anything about . . .") and you can build a franchise. A lot of people who come to woodworking as a hobby are convinced that it's possible to buy their way around the practice it takes to develop skills, and there are a lot of people that enable them in that pursuit.
Not many people would pick up a magazine with cover lines that said "Master Dovetails in 500 Hours" or "Secrets to Sharpening: Practice Until You Get It Right". There is a steady market for the latest and greatest set of training wheels, and many of the people who write about these things don't have much experience beyond what they do for publication, and aren't ready, willing or able to give up the training wheels themselves.
When you get right down to it, there aren't that many skills to develop to be an accomplished woodworker. The number one skill in my mind is the ability to problem solve, and I don't think you really learn that by throwing money at the problems we all face early on.
Bob Lang
Re: The easy way to sell . . .
TomD
Actually the seminar that doesn't sell (OK people attend, but there isn't any uptake) is the how to master dovetails in one hour, but you have to take off your training wheels, and risk failure, but it will be easier, seminar.
Re: The man in the mirror.
TomD
"IMO, it is largely the 'premium plane movement' that relegated the cap iron effect to almost lost lore. Fine performance in a plane had to be attributed to some other set of factors, e.g. 'mass,' frog pitch, quality of machining, historicity, amount of money spent,' etc. -- anything but a reasonably well set up mass produced plane with an effective cap iron, since this could be had for twenty bucks used and maybe an afternoon's worth of elbow grease. How quaint and pedestrian. "
I wouldn't say that. As far as I can tell there were plenty of premium planes with breakers. All the LNs, etc... LV had planes out before LN, as far as I know, though I wondered whether they were an early LN contract, they had breakers. All the infills I know about that were 45 degrees or higher, obviously there are some I don't know. Also, the only planes I know of that used the thing you are all gushing about are the Japanese planes, and they were sold with breakers, whether premium or economy. We are talking about planes costing 1600 dollars in the 70s, today high prices for stuff are common, back then the most expensive LV dovetail saw was probably 15 or 25.
I think there are probably three levels. One is the breaker level, where really big chips are being broken. I think that is valid and was out there. Then there is the finishing level with the current focus breaker. Then there are planes that take cuts so fine they don't need a breaker. All people are talking about at the moment are the middle case. So some of the people making other claims were not talking about the stuff that is being talked about here, and should not be questioned as to their motives.
The other thing is that while I had no problems finding references about this stuff when Bill asked, as well as knowing it from way back. The reality is that more books had incorrect or other explanations, by far, than had correct ones. I guess I just grumped and moved on if I didn't read what I knew to be the case, and have said here over the years. But if Bill's question had been can you find misleading explanations, that would have been easier. So presumably a lot of people did not know.
The reality is this stuff was not covered up, but people just don't want to hear what they don't want to hear. And they still aren't listening on many other topics. No problem, but more answers are in the mirror than in the Jessy Ventura files.