New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Death Knell of Woodcentral?

Posts

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#76

Re: The man in the mirror.

CStan

Pay attention to what I wrote. I said nothing about the planes not having chip breakers/cap irons.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#77

Re: The man in the mirror.

TomD

I read what you wrote, but to me that would be like blaming car manufacturers for their seat belt policy because they put them in, but didn't do them up for you. You seem to me to be suggesting that the makers of unnamed fancy planes had some kind of role in the prevailing ignorance. If they put breakers in their planes, that isn't much of a cover-up. More likely there are a fairly long list of folks making fancy tools who are newbies. I particularly noticed it with the saw blogs. Got interested in saws today, started a company the following day.

But folks who knew what they were about were making planes with breakers, for people who knew how to use them all along. Who do you figure is really responsible for that not having happened here?

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#78

Re: The man in the mirror.

CStan

I didn't articulate my point very well. Let me think about it and try again later.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#79

bridger

Re: Given what's now known - A question

bridger

>On the settings stuff. Can anyone tell me what the chip breaker setting is when one is working over 10 thou shavings, sometimes a lot over. And can anyone tell me what the setting is for say 3/10 000" setting? I'm not sure I have the memo on this part, are we sorta saying same thinckness as shaving sought? So that would be a 3/10 000" setting which is pretty sporty.

My scrub plane is an old coffin smoother. massive thick blade with a deep crown to the edge, wide mouth. the chipbreaker is pulled back a lot- it might as well not have one. purpose made scrubs don't. it leaves tear out, lots of it- but it's a scrub.

on the 3/10 shaving- I generally set up a plane for a particular kind of work and leave it at that. if I wanted to take a 3/10 shaving first I'd try with my best smoother and fettle from there. I've never needed a shaving that fine. there would be some satisfaction from getting a full width, full length 3/10 shaving, but for me there is no practical need.

I do think that a 3/10 setting on a chipbreaker is unlikely to work well. you'd need a pretty good microscope just to get there, anyhow.

Bridger

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#80

Re: Given what's now known - A question

Steve Elliott

Since I do my milling on power equipment I'm probably not the best one to tackle the question of really thick shavings, but here are a few thoughts anyway.

On a scrub plane I wouldn't bother with a chipbreaker. To remove stock quickly I'd be planing across the grain and expecting a somewhat rough surface which would be refined with different planes.

A shaving thickness of 10 thousandths is still very coarse and I'd probably only try it in softwood when planing an edge, not expecting a full width shaving. I haven't tried using a chipbreaker with shavings this thick because my working style doesn't call for them.

For final surface refinement (meaning the removal of whatever defects and tool marks remain from bringing the workpiece to the desired dimension) I would use shaving thicknesses of maybe 3 thousandths down to somewhat less than one thousandth. This is where the chipbreaker is especially useful. A setback of 8 to 12 thousandths is the ballpark figure I'd start with and then just watch the results.

Very fine shavings, like the 3/10,000 you mention, just haven't been useful to me. They remove wood so slowly I lose patience and getting a wide shaving is difficult unless I'm just planing an edge that's narrower than the blade. Shavings this fine are less likely to cause tearout in the first place, as the Kato studies show. I wouldn't bother with trying to set a chipbreaker close enough to be used with this thin a shaving.

I don't have the expertise to recommend a chipbreaker setback for every species or every type of planing, but I've found it easy to get the results I'm after with a little experimentation.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#81

Re: Given what's now known - A question

david weaver

Quick answer -

For the coarse shavings, you should set the cap iron so it's far enough off that you only just feel the effects in a thick shaving. Closer than that, and the plane will bull you, too far away and you'll just have more tearout.

Since this whole thing came up, the biggest improvement in anything that I do has been with a panel plane that will max out (because of the mouth) at about that shaving thickness or just a little less. What I like about it was that it always had minimized tearout going in a diagonal on a panel. I could remove the jack tearout if there was any, and flatten a panel going either direction on the grain and not have much tearout to remove. But setting the cap iron just in the range now is pretty much eliminated the tearout completely, so smoothing is extremely fast after the plane. A plane that is just mitigating tearout (without bulling you from the cap iron being too close) will be much nicer to use than one generating even minor tearout, it will be much smoother.

The ability flatten a board in an X pattern from one side of the bench, regardless of grain direction, is a real luxury. If the board is wide enough for that, there's no need to bother checking for wind. Just a set of through strokes after it's flat and then a few quick smoother swipes.

As far as the 3/10,000 setting, you don't need a cap iron for a shaving that thin. If a .004" cap iron setting isn't flexing a chip, then the chip is not thick enough to need a cap iron to begin with, and you won't have tearout unless you're planing something nobody would put in furniture. From the standpoint of hand dimensioning, a shaving thickness that thin isn't really practical unless you're just fiddling for fun.