New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Death Knell of Woodcentral?

Posts

Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#1

Death Knell of Woodcentral?

TomD

I got two main things from the Kato discussion. One of these was the refreshed idea that it isn't real until it is in video. People have said what was in Kato before. Not the detail, but that doesn't seem to have been the main take-away. But there was no reaction. I can remember some other occasions when quite hot topics would rage over the years, and then all of a sudden a video comes out and all it is conventional wisdom.

CS is one guy who can actually write stuff, with pictures and get his ideas across. But for the most part on boards, there is whatever level of understanding that prevails. One has essentially zero chance of informing that consensus alone. Pretty much the only cases where one makes some headway are when someone else chimes in in support. But that sorta means you can't expand the bubble of knowledge in absolute terms, but maybe combine some bubbles.

So mostly for the yucks, as with David's thread, what is the point of boards if pretty much nothing happens to expand the level of understanding until it is first published or in video?

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#2

That's really funny

John in NM

I don't have the patience to watch videos :D

Sounds strange to many, but the reason is that the people who make videos, especially amatuer videos tend to hem and haw, have lots of ummms in there, and generally drive me nuts by not getting to the point! I feel like yelling "SUM UP" at the screen :D :D :D

So I haven't watched the recent planing video(s) - I'm not pointing any fingers, just including all in my general prejudice :D

I prefer reading a good written explanation - because I can easily skip over the parts I already know, and go back and re-read stuff I missed with greater concentration. I just don't seem to get that from vid's, cultural dinosaur that I appear to be.

However, I think the trend you notice is real, but has more to do with our poor writing skills than anything magical about videos. It's simply easier to clearly communicate your ideas about woodworking using pictures and images than words. If one can write clearly and concisely, and are willing to do the work of self-editing, there is no reason a person cannot clearly communicate here as well. There are several regular, knowledgeable posters here who write like that.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#3

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#5

How do we find videos without the forums?


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#6

What I got from the discussion.......

Bill Tindall

....not that anyone should care except as a compliment and encouragement for Hennebury,Weaver and Kees.

Kato and Kawai taught me how a cap iron works and provided a quantitative measure of the range over where it worked. Hennebury stimulated thinking about the details of the forces involved in planing and tear-out mitigation. He also instantly established credibility with his portfolio of stuff he has designed and made. Weaver taught me that the Kato and Kawai work was applicable to the kind of hand planes I own. Because I have never seen anything he has made I remained skeptical about applicability to stuff I do. Kees convinced me with the unassuming video that the cap iron effect could be easily applied to practical planing tasks used in building stuff, not just diddling with a hand plane.

Not to sound disrespectful, but if Kees could do it I could do it, and what he was doing is typical of a task involved in making stuff- an ordinary woodworker, and an ordinary plane, a simple adjustment, a typical wood and a typical grain reversal. Seeing is believing, especially on a Forum.

These people were successful at teaching what they know. If I am able to apply what I learned on my next project you all, and this Forum, have had a positive impact on my woodworking. And that is why I am here, to learn.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#7

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

wilbur

There are many ways to communicate information. Some are more effective at reaching some people than others, and for those in the second group, there are other methods of communication that are available that is more effective for those people that may not be very effective for the first group.

For me personally, I've not had much luck with cap irons, and I've heard and read the description of setting the cap iron as close as possible to reduce tearout, and I tried doing just that. It didn't work for me. As a result, my fallback when planing had been either to resharpen my blade, take a thinner shaving, or get a different plane with a higher bed angle. All of these methods work, by the way.

For whatever reason, watching this video crystallized things for me in a way that didn't happen before in terms of my understanding of cap irons. And since then, I've had better luck with my cap irons than I did before watching the video. So I think that this video helped in a way that no other description of the use of the cap iron did for me.

For those who already knew how to effectively use a cap iron, this video is at most an interesting look at what happens on a microscopic level, and most certainly doesn't have much value in increasing the knowledge of the woodworkers who belong to that group. But that does not mean that making this video is without value, nor does it mean that it is without value to other people.

As to the idea that the knowledge was always out there, so why wouldn't everyone know this already? Regardless of how much I flail as a woodworker, I teach as part of my day job, so I think I can address this. One of my responsibilities is to teach pediatrics to med students and residents. One could argue that all the information one needs to learn about pediatrics at a medical student or a resident level is already out there, just like the information about how to use a cap iron.

Most medical students and residents will pick up on the majority of what they need to know about pediatrics without too much trouble. But every one of them will hit their stumbling block. A good teacher has their usual set of canned explanations for these sorts of topics. A great teacher can rephrase or set the idea in a different context so that the learner is able to understand the concept that they are having troubles with, and a great teacher will be able to adjust to each individual learner's strengths and weaknesses, and work around them.

I'm not saying that the student doesn't have some responsibility toward their education. But to just leave it at "The information was already out there, so why do we need this video?" to my mind illustrates the difference between an experienced practitioner and a great teacher.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#8

Both/and

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Disclaimer: like you, John, and for many of the same reasons, I generally have little patience with videos. That said, there are things that can be made clear with videos that would be hard/nearly impossible to describe in words.

Analogy: I'm/we're in the midst of a remodel right now that requires buying several windows. I'm trying a new supplier, and I drove down there (35 minutes away) before ordering, because there are things that can be communicated instantly by a sketch on a piece of scratch paper that simply cannot be communicated reliably over the phone. But there are also things that must be written out to be sure everyone's on the same page. A sketch won't cut it for issues like whether or not a window should be low-e, argon-filled, tempered glass, etc.; that requires a specifications document in words.

And, to digress a bit (I can never resist digressing), woodworking fora are dynamite for many topics and discussions, but an old-fashioned book (or analogous online document) can't be trumped for a coherent presentation of a particular topic. I don't find myself doing it here as often, but on a couple of other fora I visit, I regularly find myself suggesting that people go find the nearest public library and read everything they can find there on the topic about which they're asking. A high percentage of the people who've asked the question to which I respond this way seem never to have thought of this, but that may be a different issue, and my reaction to their failure to have thought of it yet another sign of my curmudgeonliness.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#9

A challenge

Bill Tindall

For those that consider the Kato-Kawai video common knowledge let us review.

The video shows(1)how setting the cap iron too far back (in this case infinity) results in grain tear. Then it shows that setting it too close (2), and a quantitative value is provided, results in scrunched shavings. Then(3) a range for effective cap iron effect is shown, with distance values provided. In the 15 minutes it takes to view these experiments one is taught that the cap iron alone can prevent tear-out and, we are taught what it looks like when the cap iron is too close as well as an approximate range where success is to be found.

Challenge 1. Can you find anywhere in the WC Archives where equivalent data are provided? To refresh, the data are distance and result for the three cases, 6 pieces of data and a quantitative range where the cap iron effect is expected. References such as set the cap iron "close" don't count for this is useless information without a definition for close.

Challenge 2. Can you find these data on any Forum?

Challenge 3 Can you find these data in any magazine?

Challenge 4, Can you find these data published anywhere else?

The answers to these challenges will reveal whether those of us that were clueless are lazy students or whether there is a teacher shortage.

The number of hits on Wilbur's post of the video probably answers the questions.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#10

Number of hits

wilbur

Over 2,200 views at this point. :D

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#11

calling Steve Elliot

Larry Williams

Steve,

How long has the information about the Kato study been on your web site.

Anyone who might have attended workshops or presentations Don and/or I did at a Marc Adams', Kelly Mehler's, WIA or in Rochester in the last several years where we also did our slide show. Do you remember this slide with the caption, "4/1000 ???"?


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#12

Re: A challenge

Mark Hennebury

The problem is never about the availability of information.

There is teaching and there is learning, both are parts of our nature as humans. We once were childen and looked to adults to teach and as adults we teach our children, So those things are hardwired into our brains. Little children learn about the world around them because its all new. The have no reference points, they soak it up as they recieve it, they have no way to evaluate it. So they get it what ever way they interpret it, not neccesarily the way it is.

When those children are adults they have many already preconcieved notions, and no longer are able to see things "as if for the first time" like a child, with no preconceived idea or expectation.

Example: A guy that took one of my woodworking classes asked me to evaluate an expensive furniture set that he had just purchased at a high end furniture store. What he wanted was to understand what if any the difference would be if he had had it hand made, as he was sure the peices that he paid so much money for were top quality.

After a quick glance at the catologue photos, i started with "well the door panels are not bookmatched cathederal arches, but made of 2" wide random boards and the whole unit is sprayed "Cherry red" to hide the difference in grain etc.. I didnt need to go into the construction.

He was devestated, he had this furniture in his home and had not noticed even that the door panels in the cabinets were made of 2" wide strips. Let alone the stain and the shading and the black speckles etc.

The human ability to not see what is in front of them is boundless.

The human ability to paste their on mental image over reality is incredible.

A teachers job is to show you this, so that you may look and see what is there.

And occcasionally point it out when you dont.

Teaching is a lot of fun and gives you a great sense of feeling special , like you count. But it has a responsibility with it: to open minds so that the learning continues and the collective knowledge grows.

Woodworking is different in that it is not a of critical importance like medicine,

so it is left up to us idividuals with no guidence no, standards and no rules.

Whoever promotes themselves as a teacher, is a teacher whether or not they have a clue, and with the internet and Youtube the one with the most videos and corporate sponsers is the winner.

They can teach anything, right or wrong. Who will call them to task?

Asking questions and answering is not enough without active involvement, You may remember what you are told but that doesnt mean that you understand it. without work, experimentation and open minded anaylisis you wont learn a thing.

Forums are a great place for debate and learning and also a place for lazy people to get quick answers. Students do have a responsibility to not just accept but to verify and understand what they are told. And teachers have a responsibility to debate, learn, verify and spread real knowedge over the forums.

How Woodworking continues is up to us because we are the ones that have the torch. All of those that worked and struggled to raise the craft are gone and it is our duty to not just try to remember what they did but to expand and improve it, to push it further in the same spirit as they did.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#13

Re: calling Steve Elliot

david weaver

Maybe it should say 8/1000, since that also works fine.

somewhere just south of 1/100th.

Not that hard to do.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#14

I think...

Larry Williams

I think you missed the point. This information has been around for a while. We've had that information in our slide show since we first put it together about five years ago. It's updated each time we use it but that slide has been there since the beginning.

Steve's web site explained his experiments as well. Steve's information looked at Western style planes while the Kato information examines Japanese planes with a 40 degree bed angle. There's a difference in fiber deflection, spring back, clearance angle, temperature at the cutting edge and edge life.

One of the people in the workshop we finished today is a metallurgist who spent his career working in steel mills. He'll also be in the workshop we're doing this weekend. It's been interesting having a long on-going discussion of just what the steel is going through at the cutting edge. Once we got through the nomenclature issues, I found myself agreeing with what he had to say. One key point is that dulling wear in plane irons usually doesn't involve abrasion and heat is a catalyst to that wear.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#15

Re: calling Steve Elliot

Steve Elliott

I put Kato's written description of the video on my site in spring of 2005. At one point it was linked to by Christopher Schwarz as part of a discussion of whether cap irons were of any use. As I recall, no one was convinced that they had much effect.

The impact of the video itself has been much greater. There's something more persuasive about watching things happen with your own eyes than just reading about it.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#16

craigd

Re: challenge 4

craigd

I think your challenge is a difficult one as you are trying to reconcile science fact vs folklore. The information is out there in the "do it this way, it works, trust us, we have been doing this for centuries" not the "it works for these reasons and here is proof". Would you rather read Nature or Popular Woodworking (possible reason why PW only had a tiny bit of info (blog pointer to Steve's/Mark's pages))?

But, not to be deterred:

Hack, The Handplane Book (1997), pg 71:

"Ideally, the cap iron should be as far from the cutting edge as the thickness of the shavings you expect to make".

The how to tune a plane information is pretty good (you can tune a plane but not a fish). The emphasis is on how to do it right (cookbook) vs "here is the science, now apply it".

Lee, The Complete Guide to Sharpening (1995), pg 12:

"Keep the cap close to the edge" in a blurb about why that works. Not all that useful but he does discuss in good detail the how and why of shaving type (I,II,II).

The video is very nice because we can see the science in actions, which is important if you are a visual learner. To me, it just great science for non scientists: understandable, repeatable and applicable.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#17

Re: I think...

Kees

There have been too many countervoices on the Internet over the last years. For example when you do a search on the popular woodworking site for chipbreaker, you won't find a single positive article about it. Only negative stuff. Then there is the article on your (Larry) page, which is completely dismissive about the practical use of the chipbreaker. And that article has been linked to a lot. The slide you show from your slideshow, Larry, also emphasises the impracticality of using the chipbreaker outside the labaratory.

All that negative vibe wasn't helping the average home woodworker to interpret these single sentence messages from the handbooks in the right manner. Lucky them who learned handplaning in a more humble environment.

Now we know that using the chipbreaker is a VERY PRACTICAL way of improving the capabilities of all the cheap and abundant double iron planes in the world, we need to turn that negative vibe into a possitive one. I mean, when even I can use the chipbreaker to great effect with dirt cheap planes, tuned up in my garden shed, then everybody can do it.

So Larry, please revise that article on your website. Stop talking about the 1 thou setting of the chipbreaker, which is too close in most circumstances anyway. And OPEN the mouth of the plane so you don't have so much trouble with clogging.

Thanks.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#18

Re: A challenge

TomD

I produced in the separate thread. But here are a few more points.

Mesirow and Herman, in their book show a line drawing that is identical to the video side view. The key point is that the shaving is being forced down, it isn't a breaker type picture. It is in their section How to Prevent Splintering.

I think a lot of stuff can be read to say what is in the video, but not everyone is clear. Krenov said that the shaving should be south of 16 thou, basically. 1/64. Yet Krenov is one of few western workers who actually claimed to be finishing without sanding. How did he do that with cuts of 16 thou? I mean you can get a nice cut like that, but come on. I think the point is he probably just said 1/64 because that was as fine has his scale went. I have all kinds of measuring stuff. If you then re-read his stuff and look at his pictures with the idea that he was just throwing out a number, I think it makes more sense. He said he was setting the breaker, his numbers were just pretty coarse. In part he was working coarse for today, just look at his shavings, but I also think he knew about setting, and just throwing it out because he used overly coarse measurements is probably to miss the point.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#19

Re: The acid test

TomD

So here is the test. Bill issued his challenge, it has been met by several. So does the suggestion that nobody knew breakers were for tear-out now die, or does it persist until Bill reads about it in a scholarly journal, or posts a video? If the false idea does not die, then Woodcentral is broken. :)

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#20

Re: Oh, beat the drum slowly and play the fife low

TomD

"Why do you post here? You know a colossal buttload of stuff and you don't really ask all that many questions, either."

I don't doubt when they do turn the lights out, should the experiment fail, the 3 or 4 people you mention, will still be posting. I have published stuff in mags, and I don't really feel the experience is any better. You have to target what you are saying, and you get edited, which is good overall, but not entirely self-indulgent. I like writing, don't need the money, and don't like the hassle. I was an investment magazine editor as one of my many hats, actually two publications. By the time I was ready to write for woodworking mags, I no longer cared about being published. I think the hassle would be worth it if one had something to flog, but not really as a private person. By answering questions I get to communicate with people the way they want to be communicated with (though maybe it doesn't feel like that to them :) ), rather than having to make something up that has a chance of being published. The gratification, which admittedly is pretty much zero online, is so delayed with print it also pretty much amounts to zero.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#21

Re: A challenge

TomD

http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/plane_tune.shtml

Here he mentions the idea of leaving a breaker loose so you can keep fiddling with it until the optimum shaving is produced. I suppose he means surface, and the shaving as an indication of what is happening with the surface.

16 Move the breaker a little closer to the tip of the iron - the shaving should get better.

Interesting approach

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#22

Discovery vs teaching

Bill Tindall

Mark has correctly addressed the issue as teaching, and well said it was.

The Kato-Kawai video is about teaching something, not discovering it. I will say for the third time, for some still don't seem to have read or understood, the Kato-Kawia video was prepared for teaching. Again, for the third time, there is nothing in the Kato-Kawai papers that suggests that the cap iron effect was not well known before their work, which is focused on edge life and self sharpening. No where do they claim, nor has anyone else claimed except their detractors, that they discovered that a cap iron mitigated tear-out.

Hence, the only relevant criticism of the video is whether it is effective at teaching what a cap iron does, how it does it and about where to set it. I might add that the Kees video must be judged by the same criteria, is it effective at teaching. To this end, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, ie the student. If you want to be positive spread the word about these videos. Or if you feel they are lacking make you own, or teach a class(as Mark does) or write a book or article.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#23

Re: I think...

David Weaver

Larry, I don't disagree with any of that, and for five years I used almost entirely single iron planes, and the last 3 or 4 of them i don't machine dimension.

But I didn't know the kato and kawai stuff was out there, I thought the time or two I saw it mentioned, someone was reciting something they'd read that wasn't available. If it was discussed on here as being available, then I missed it in a few posts, I definitely don't read all of them.

The universal or near universal loud internet voice that it's fiddly to use the second iron combined with a time or two when I ran the second iron over the edge and ruined it had me believing it, too - if you read something a few times, and you have a little bit of experience that confirms it, you're inclined to believe it.

The only reason I changed my mind is because in a discussion with george wilson, I said something about it being hard and fiddly, and george (who by rule at work used mostly single iron planes) said "no, it's not really hard to set it properly".

Those of us who are rank amateurs sometimes need a little bit of calibrating. I decided I'd use one for a month trying to set it tight, and it really only took about a dozen resets of the cap iron, maybe less, to be able to set it that close quickly.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#24

Very limited data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, what the Kato video has provided is a very limited set of data for cap iron use. It does not discuss a wide range of wood species, a wide range of shaving thickness, a wide range of practical applications. It does not discuss the use of a jack plane on pine or mahogany, the use of a trying plane on quarter sawn cherry, the use of a smoothing plane on butternut or Osage orange. It does not even try to come up with optimum settings for fine surfaces. You yourself, Bill, still have limited experience and it would show in practical application. I have found that the best way to approach the problem is to get a wide range of experience, to concentrate on the symptoms associated with poor adjustment and to use intuition to place the cap iron. I have not spent my life measuring shavings or settings, rather learning to plane wood. If you think a chart will suffice, you do not understand the complexity of the situation.

Find a violin player and ask where to put the first finger on the A string to play a B (I calculate 1.391 inches for equal temperament). Try to find a good player who knows this or who thinks in these terms. Tell a guy you want to copy his finger settings so you can play the violin like him and see what he says. They teach you instead to put the finger about here and listen to the result, make adjustments. A violinist knows this stuff well without ever learning any numbers.

I have written on this subject for quite some time on this forum. Those who have discredited me include some of the most valuable contributors to this forum. But of those few who are actually excited about using the technique, David Weaver and Kees (and Bob Strawn on another forum) have long been interested in my writings. If there is tearout, move the cap iron. It has been explained this way for 200 years because this is the way craftsmen think. If the violin note is sharp, move the finger, don't get bogged down in measurement. Peter Nicholson, trained as a cabinetmaker in the 1780s, became a brilliant architect, inventor and mathematician, but then when it came to placing the cap iron he later wrote:

The distance between the cutting edge of the iron, and the edge of the cover, depends altogether on the nature of the stuff. If the stuff is free [straight grain], the edge of the cover may be set at a considerable distance

That is all he wrote. No millimeters, thousandths, charts or formulae. This is the way craftsmen think.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#25

Challenge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here are some things I have written on this forum in the past.

April 4,2006

I think my experience contradicts some of your notions about planes. I have used a Bailey type smoother since 1973. I have never used a back bevel. Here is some history of my experience.

1975. Last time I had any problems with clogging.

1976. Last time I used a bevel up plane.

1977. Last time I had any problems with tearout and last use of a scraper on a planed surface.

1978 Last use of sandpaper on a planed surface.

As you can see, I didn't learn to use it overnight. I now use the smoother so unconsciously that it would take perhaps two years of daily use to compare another type of plane. But I must say that the problems with the Bailey plane that you enumerate seem somewhat fanciful.

December 8, 2007

Adam, the double iron is a sophisticated instrument. For things to work well everything has to be just so. There is no shame in having trouble with it. If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it. I can say that the benefits of learning are well worth the effort and I would not want to be without it.

I am not the best person for troubleshooting, especially without having the plane in my hand. I have only ever maintained five bench planes: a fore plane, a trying plane, a jointer and two smoothers. All were put into service between 1973 and 1983, so its been a long time since I was dealing with cranky planes. Often I read about some tuning operation on this forum that I had long forgotten about.

And this on WoodNet March 5, 2008



I have used the double iron for controlling tearout for more than thirty years. It is a sophisticated system requiring practice and judgment. It does not surprise me that many do not have this skill. There is no shame in not knowing how to do it. However the lack of this skill is not something to brag about, as many have done.

The pole vault record is somewhere around 20 feet, but if you took a bunch of middle aged people and handed each a pole you wouldn't expect much the first day. I can imagine some saying the pole just got in the way, or they could jump higher without it.

It does surprise me how many were unable to read the information presented by Kato and Elliot. Those who suggested that the setting needed to be within .004" might reread the material.