New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Death Knell of Woodcentral?

Posts

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#26

And a different challenge..

david weaver

... for every person who says it works marginally, I would suggest using a plain #4 sized smoother with the cap iron set up properly. If you're doing a lot of projects where you need a smoother, force yourself to use the smoother for one month. See how much changes after the 50th time you're sizing something up vs. the 5th.

It took me two weeks with it to be comfortable enough to speak up to warren before any of this video stuff came out. Some project work putting together glue-ups and some playing with woods in my scrap bin that have given me trouble before.

I figure since then just in the last two months, I've learned a lot about how to set the plane so that there will be no tearout, but also so that I don't have the cap iron just right on the very edge of the plane (the temptation at first was to set the cap iron so that it was working the chip pretty hard on every cut, and that's not necessary).

So that'd be my challenge, use the cap iron and a stock thickness iron for all of your smoothing for a month, if you're not doing a lot, use it for two or three.

You'll learn a lot about when you need to sharpen (since the cap iron makes it so that you can let the iron wear a little bit more and still avoid tearout), and things you might've thought about the common metal bench plane, like its suitability toward heavier harder woods that are used in the US like maple and beech. My thought at first was that a much heavier plane is a lot nicer to use on those woods, but over time I figured out that if I'm applying extra pressure to push in those woods, all i have to do is be conscious that my extra pressure is only in the direction of the cut and I'm not adding extra unnecessary pressure into the board and bench top, making the plane harder to push.

I can understand why now warren was reluctant to go into details about any of it. It's like hogan said about the golf swing, the secret's in the dirt.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#27

Re: The acid test

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom and all,

You've demonstrated by reference that there have been a number of authorities who stated that yes, chip breakers do break the shaving to reduce or eliminate tearout. But your 'Acid Test' post is not fair to what Bill actually said. In 'A Challenge', Bill said in part,

"...The video shows(1)how setting the cap iron too far back (in this case infinity) results in grain tear. Then it shows that setting it too close (2), and a quantitative value is provided, results in scrunched shavings. Then(3) a range for effective cap iron effect is shown, with distance values provided. In the 15 minutes it takes to view these experiments one is taught that the cap iron alone can prevent tear-out and, we are taught what it looks like when the cap iron is too close as well as an approximate range where success is to be found."

Bill is explicit about quantitative data, which the Kato-Kawai papers provide. And the convincing video of the result.

We--meaning those like myself who were deficient or plain wrong--have now learned that use of the chip breaker is very sensitive to distance setting, not to speak of the little blunt facet at the edge. (Our most celebrated teachers have consistently taught us to strive for a smoothness of intersection.)

The only place I know of where one could really find out how close the chip breaker must be, along with an approximate range--is at Steve Elliott's website, as pointed out by Larry Williams among others.

I have the highest regard for Warren and Warren's abilities and perspicacity, and was glad he posted his earlier remarks on the subject. Similarly with Odate--there is info there. Yet, I am unable to glean from what Warren posted, or from what Odate wrote--and I'll let these two stand in for all the other references you gave--how to proceed if I want to use the chip breaker.

How to do it? How close is close enough? How close is too close? What does it look like? I'm sympathetic to Warren and Odate being reluctant to write down a cookbook, because from the experienced professional's point of view, it's detail and nuance that you just have to learn by doing the hard work, and there is no 'cookbook'.

The only two places I have been aware of, where it was indicated how close the chip breaker had to be were (1) at Steve Elliott's website--Steve is truly an unsung hero of plane craft; and (2) a remark a few years ago by Jim Blauvelt, a working professional using Japanese tools, that the chip breaker had to be set so close that "if it were set any closer, it would be doing the cutting."

Has there been quantitative data around, other than Elliott? Or 'how to' tutorials?

For me, the breakthroughs have been (1) the detailed Kato-Kawai quantitative data and video, complete with limits for 'too close' and 'too far', and (2) David's and Kee's personal history descriptions of how-to, backed by Kee's video.

Finally, my hat is off to Warren, Tom, Mark and all those who knew exactly how to do it all along. I didn't.

Am I a convert? To the knowledge, yes. And I think this is a big breakthrough for Bailey- and Bedrock-type plane users, and Primus also. To doing it?--No, why change?

Wiley

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#28

Re: Very limited data

CStan

Very well said and so very true. These planes give you a kit of options in the cap iron, the mouth aperture, and of course cutter projection. Within these three parameters, some combination will work.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#29

It's been interesting watching ...

Sgian Dubh

... the recent discussions on 'chip breaker's, and viewing the Kato video.

I don't get perfect results from my planes. There's sometimes tearout, and I know that poorly set up planes are very frustrating and don't work at all well. What I have found on the subject of hand planes is as general as writers that have been cited in the discussions to which I refer, eg, Hayward, Peters, Joyce, et al. I do the usual things when setting up my planes, eg, make sure there's no gap between the blade and the cap iron, make sure the end of the cap iron isn't nicked or very blunt, clean up the upper surface of the cap iron so it's smooth and the shavings can flow uninterrupted; and finally set it 'close' to the cutting edge of the iron, but vary the closeness according to the job you are doing, eg, 'very close' for fine cuts and polish prep, and a 'bit further away' for heavy cuts and roughing. How close is very close? I don't really know as I never measure it, but probably within 0.5 mm. But how close can you expect the cap iron to go when the cutting edge of the iron is slightly curved anyway, and the corners are bevelled off a bit? Get the darned cap iron too close and the outside corners mash over the cutting edge at the bevelled corners of the blade, so it's pointless getting the cap iron too close.

There is also perhaps some need to adjust the mouth opening according to the heaviness of the shaving being taken, and perhaps the type of wood being worked, although I find that the benefits to planing through fiddling with the mouth opening are limited and are probably overrated, so the Bailey frog is just about as good as a Bed Rock to me.

There's also a need to make sure the wood ahead of the cut is held down so it doesn't lift as the iron cuts the fibres, which points to getting the plane sole flat, or reasonably flat, and certainly the bit at the front of the mouth should be in the same plane as the rim of the plane. Some hollows within these key areas don't seem to matter much, and even a plane with a convex sole can be coaxed into working reasonably well.

To get a plane to cut effectively there's the usual information about using a sharp blade, but I'm a notoriously sloppy sharpener, and I don't often bother sharpening finer than 800 grit which does for 90+ percent plus of all work. I hear of people discussing sharpening to 10,000 grit and beyond, and using jigs and guides to hold their irons-- that's all far too much bother for me. I haven't got the hours in the day to sharpen and sharpen and sharpen for little return in productivity.

And of course, to top it all off, from a production point of view, there's always scrapers and abrasive papers to get a surface polish ready. I hear of people claiming to polish straight off the plane without recourse to scrapers or sandpaper. The problem with that claim as I see it, is that in nigh on forty years involved in the woodworking industry, I've never actually witnessed it, except where the intended finish is a rusticated one with scalloping and tearout as part of the 'character' of the piece, usually a reproduction olde worlde oak kist or refectory table with some distressing using bits of concrete, whacking with chains, and plenty of van dyke brown, some linseed oil and a bit of wax put on it all.

I doubt forums are dead though. There's always stuff to talk about. Slainte.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#30

Re: Measurement vs feel

TomD

+1, though there is a difference between what you do when the numbers are knowable and not. Part of the reason we have the feel is because we can't measure. But as time goes by many things are increasingly measurable. Take watches for instance (or wherever time lives these days). Forget whether one prefers hands aesthetically or not, one can quite easily work with hands and no numbers. But when digital watches came along, and we got time displayed to at least the second, that was fine also. And it was superior on occasions where seconds work. I don't want my microwave to time stuff with hour and minute hands, though a sweep second hand would be usable.

In golf it is great fun to just look at the target, feel the club and environment and make a swing. But if you have a caddy who gives you precise yardage, or a laser range finder, it changes how you play. The average golfer will have much higher scores.

If there were hand planes with precise knobs, and digital displays, that would be great. I would like to add digital displays to my milling machine and I certainly am not pulling the dials and replacing them with hammers. What I like about a Japanese plane is that given that actual useful hand planes beyond a block of wood don't actually exist, I prefer the intuitive fast to cycle one, to one that just seems badly designed, no mater how 19th century state of the art the technology might seem.

So if I could adjust all the parts of my plane to the thou, and have displays, I could probably pretty quickly get some useful results from it.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#31

Re: The acid test

TomD

Mostly +1.

The quant stuff does not interest me, and it is really just an insurance add on to the questions. If you can prove the main point we still have you on the data kind of thing. The preposterous claim that is getting the heat is the stuff on tear-out/breaker being a revelation. Bill can add as many additional claims that are not in question as he likes, we are not required to take any of that too seriously. think Bill said it well when he said that the data illustrates an approximate range.

1) I think there are two reasons why the quant stuff is also largely irrelevant. One has already been mentioned which is that it is not really transferable or useful. + People are jumping in and saying, that what makes all this so great is that as long as they set the breaker in a friendly range, they are getting great results. So either one is in a place where exact numbers are relevant, and therefore these numbers are not plane or wood specific enough to mater. Or, one is among those who find a general range great, in which case the numbers are irrelevant for a different reason.

2) The other reason is that for me the best system is an adjustable one where the breaker is adjustable on the fly. This is the Japanese system, but according to that Woodcentral document I just posted it is also a western method. So why use number info and settings when you can tune it to perfection.

So they don't interest me, though I am happy if they are helping others. I never said there was no new info in the study, it is the claim about breaker/tear-out that is so crazy.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#32

Re: Newbie Paydirt

TomD

"(2) a remark a few years ago by Jim Blauvelt, a working professional using Japanese tools, that the chip breaker had to be set so close that "if it were set any closer, it would be doing the cutting.""

As they say, the sub blade.

That is basically in the Odate book where he says that if you go too far you will end up with the shavings under the breaker. He also says the breaker should be "as close as possible to the cutting edge". He also mentions different bevel angles on the sub blade, which I was also aware of, but the video did catch my interest on that stuff.

"For me, the breakthroughs have been (1) the detailed Kato-Kawai quantitative data and video, complete with limits for 'too close' and 'too far', and (2) David's and Kee's personal history descriptions of how-to, backed by Kee's video."

There probably is newbie paydirt here. I am objecting to the idea that there is anything new. Also, this whole thread I started is precisely on the question of whether WC is broken when only a package such as you describe has an impact. I am with you on the idea that some extraordinary impact occurred, that is why Woodcentral should just turn out the lights.

It's great that people have learned all kinds of new stuff, I just don't want some bogus history lesson to occur.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#33

Looking forward to the challenge

Kees

Ok, I'll humbly crawl back under my rock. Forgive my hotheaded remarks from the last weeks, please. :D

At the other hand, it's not awfully difficult to get pretty decent results with the capiron rather quickly. But there is a plateau looming ahead, and it takes time and perseverance to climb higher then that plateau. There is a piece of curly maple in my shop right now. I can plane it without tear out with a Bailey plane in one direction now. The other direction is still giving me fits. Is that my plateau? Or am I doing the right thing, looking for the bet direction? That's a question for me at the moment.

Trying to climb higher on the ladder of handtool skils is what makes handtools so exciting for me. More and more I'm leaving the jigged world of the beginner and now I'm trying all kinds of freehand techniques. A long way to go still, but I'm looking forward to it. I am restoring a full set of wooden handplanes right now and my challenge is going to hide the Bailey planes and concentrate fully on the woodies.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#34

Re: You make my case

TomD

"The Kato-Kawai video is about teaching something, not discovering it. I will say for the third time, for some still don't seem to have read or understood, the Kato-Kawia video was prepared for teaching. Again, for the third time, there is nothing in the Kato-Kawai papers that suggests that the cap iron effect was not well known before their work, which is focused on edge life and self sharpening. No where do they claim, nor has anyone else claimed except their detractors, that they discovered that a cap iron mitigated tear-out."

I'm not actually aware of anyone claiming they claimed that, detractors or otherwise, though it may have happened. What I saw was people running around saying that the lesson of the video is that. Which I think continues in this thread today. I thought you had said that also, but in that I may well be wrong. You do place the claim with the data, which I took to be tactical and colossally boring, but was evidently purposeful and apparently confusing. I take it that the position you are actually holding to is that the limits with the data, are of some value. I find that odd to a point because anyone who was aware of the limits from practical experience was also in the presence of the data, and presumably had a repeatable means of getting there. But the error is mine.

"Hence, the only relevant criticism of the video is whether it is effective at teaching what a cap iron does, how it does it and about where to set it. I might add that the Kees video must be judged by the same criteria, is it effective at teaching. To this end, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, ie the student. If you want to be positive spread the word about these videos. Or if you feel they are lacking make you own, or teach a class(as Mark does) or write a book or article."

Right, and I am holly in agreement that the video was a great teaching tool, and that Woodcentral should be closed down, because even the most obvious matters of the craft are inexplicable here, even when they are covered in the articles. And to add to the charge sheet, even when good new info rises to the top it gets horribly mangled on the boards. You make my case.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#35

Re: Looking forward to the challenge

TomD

Well aren't you the right thinking young lad, I hope my daughters meet men like you!

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#36

I, for one, am very eager to see....

roger lance

some physical fruits from all these discussions and insights in the form of photos of actual work pieces that you have planed and pieces of furniture that you have made. :D :D . Please somebody, make something. :D .

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#37

Re: Looking forward to the challenge

Kees

Thanks for the compliments.

I must confess I am terribly lazy at the moment, after finishing the kitchen. I'm mostly looking forward to the summer hollidays at the moment. ;)

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#38

Re: I, for one, am very eager to see....

TomD

What, and have one of these moments?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBBFzerJ1Ss


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#39

Is such hyperbole really useful?

John in NM

I don't think so.

I now have another reason to not view this video, I might form an opinion and get sucked deeper into this god awful time wasting silly argument :D

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#40

Re: Tautology?

TomD

Hyperbole - Exaggerated statements or claims not meant to be taken literally.

Carry on, just remember the sand toys are mine...

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#41

Just logic

John in NM

When you repeatedly refer to the redundancy of this forum and that it might as well close up shop, yet continue to post on it, one can only assume that you are either being hyperbolic, insincere, or irrational. The choice is yours, keep the sand.

There will be no further comment from me, I only came back to this train wreck of a thread to delete my previous post - however, since you have already replied I will leave it be.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#42

Re: I, for one, am very eager to see....

roger lance

Well, it does appear to have been well planed....no tool marks to be seen....well done!!

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#43

I'm with Wiley here

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

In all the years I've followed WC, plus the time at Badger Pond before that (total of what, 15+ years?), I don't recall anyone mentioning things like, don't waste your money on a premium plane and/or a high angle frog, just learn to prepare and set up the cap iron properly on your Bailey and you will get optimum results, or, don't use the ruler trick because then you can't set up bevel-up blades optimally, and so on. I'm not saying it didn't happen, but if it did, those for whom Bill's (and others') work is old hat sure did not communicate clearly what they knew... :\

Just sayin'...

I hope this whole "discussion" (the actual expression I have in mind is not used in polite society) will not discourage Bill in his pursuit of knowledge. I know I learned quite a bit from this, and I'm willing to bet that a majority of people on this board did too.

Cheers,

DC

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#44

Re: I'm with Wiley here

TomD

Keep in mind there isn't just one kind of knowledge, the history of the craft is also important. Why in gaining one insight, does it have to be at the cost of another?

"I don't recall anyone mentioning things like, don't waste your money on a premium plane and/or a high angle frog, just learn to prepare and set up the cap iron properly on your Bailey and you will get optimum results,"

There is always someone around who says don't waste your money. I have probably told the story of my crappy Japanese franken plane that takes a 3 tens shaving 10 time here. The first few times I told the story the response was split between interest and "disbelief". I have posted many times the basic conditions that are required to get good results with any plane. Most of my favorite planes cost less than a chipbreaker. Once the beech is ready, I expect my planemaking to be mostly molding planes for a considerable while.

"or, don't use the ruler trick because then you can't set up bevel-up blades optimally, and so on. I'm not saying it didn't happen, but if it did, those for whom Bill's (and others') work is old hat sure did not communicate clearly what they knew... :>"

When there is a hot vibe running you can say whatever the heck you want about whatever, your chance of moving the needle is zero. How much luck are people here having on the current subject even if they are right. There are a lot more things around this subject, that you guys will get to one day. Do you think this is finally The Answer. Do you feel receptive today? Would you have been if people had said the ruler trick was a waste of time? I have never used it.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#45

Re: The subject is a joke, as stated in OP

TomD

If people want to take it in another direction, that's very sporting of them.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#46

Re: I, for one, am very eager to see....

TomD

This evening's plane making task was cutting in this dovetail plane with my osage rebate plane. Fun job though no breakers on this one.


Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#47

Blood boiling

Warren in Lancaster, PA

"I don't recall anyone mentioning things like, don't waste your money on a premium plane and/or a high angle frog, just learn to prepare and set up the cap iron properly on your Bailey and you will get optimum results,"

I hinted at this in a thread on this forum back in 2006. Your post in that thread: "Why does this thread get my blood boiling." It is hard to counsel people to avoid the high priced planes without upsetting those who have already shelled out good money to purchase those planes.

One time in another forum I tried out a premium plane and suggested that it was no better than the flea market find I was using. You should have seen the owners of the premium plane come out of the woodwork and the names they called me. One fellow who had taken up woodworking in retirement, perhaps alerted by a friend, had joined the forum just for the purpose of berating me.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#48

Re: That's really funny

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

I will confess I have not watched the videos related to this discussion.

I am still busy with a dictionary and a thesaurus after each of David's posts.

Everyday there is a few new words to learn each time he writes : )

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#49

Re: Blood boiling

david weaver

I don't remember exactly what was said, but I think it was along the lines of playing ping pong with a cast iron pan.

I was one of the folks with a negative reaction, but I don't own anything more expensive than LN/LV that I haven't built myself or put together.

Re: Death Knell of Woodcentral?

#50

David Barnett

Given what's now known *LINK*

David Barnett

"Stop talking about the 1 thou setting of the chipbreaker, which is too close in most circumstances anyway. And OPEN the mouth of the plane so you don't have so much trouble with clogging."

I'm missing where Larry spoke about setting the chip breaker at one thou (.001"). I do see in his above post that he mentions four thou (.004") Of course, .004" would be about .1mm, which is pretty tight for a chip breaker, according to Kato-Kawai, if this is what you meant. As this is so tight, are you saying Larry's offering a straw man argument that's guaranteed to fail? Like O.J. spreading his fingers so the glove wouldn't fit? I'm willing to accept that he simply offered an unusually tight example but with no intent to obfuscate.

Larry does mention .001" in the section of his article on how to control tearout:

"2. Take light shavings of about .001" to .002". A fine shaving won't have the beam strength to lift wood ahead of the iron."

Perhaps this is where the "1 thou" came from.

The article does go on to use a much larger setting, however; 1/32" or 0.03125" for Larry's lower range, or as he puts "...a chip breaker set at an uncommonly close 1/32". Compared with a .00787", or .2mm set-back demonstrated by Kato and Kawai, that is 397% greater, which is quite a lot with what we now know.

As the last paragraph of Larry's article states:

"We're simply not all that impressed with the supposed "improvement" of double irons."

With a setting of 1/32" no wonder they're not impressed! To be fair, though, I have seen 1/32" mentioned as a viable chip breaker setting by others both on the internet and in books*, so again, Larry may have been using the same flawed setting to which many were unfortunately exposed. The paragraph ends:

"We feel that it's one of those oft-repeated things that is blindly accepted and repeated without regard for its accuracy."

Which would suggest, now that Larry has seen the refutation of 1/32" as being relevant in his analysis, he'll likely wish to amend his article (as you requested) to reflect what is now becoming common knowledge. Even so, he may very well hold his opinion that double irons have unredeeming drawbacks, as he argues in his next to the last paragraph in the linked article.

*In the very first Fine Woodworking issue from 1975, the article, Hand Planes - The care and making of a misunderstood tool by Timothy E. Ellsworth, states:

"The chip breaker should be set back 1/64 to 1/16 inch from the cutting edge of the iron. The closer setting would be used for the very fine shavings on finish work and for hard-to-plane woods. Setting the chip breaker back 1/32 to 1/16 inch would be for rough work and large shavings."

So it would seem 1/32" was not always considered "...a chip breaker set at an uncommonly close 1/32".


Single Irons vs. Double Irons