And a different challenge..
david weaver
... for every person who says it works marginally, I would suggest using a plain #4 sized smoother with the cap iron set up properly. If you're doing a lot of projects where you need a smoother, force yourself to use the smoother for one month. See how much changes after the 50th time you're sizing something up vs. the 5th.
It took me two weeks with it to be comfortable enough to speak up to warren before any of this video stuff came out. Some project work putting together glue-ups and some playing with woods in my scrap bin that have given me trouble before.
I figure since then just in the last two months, I've learned a lot about how to set the plane so that there will be no tearout, but also so that I don't have the cap iron just right on the very edge of the plane (the temptation at first was to set the cap iron so that it was working the chip pretty hard on every cut, and that's not necessary).
So that'd be my challenge, use the cap iron and a stock thickness iron for all of your smoothing for a month, if you're not doing a lot, use it for two or three.
You'll learn a lot about when you need to sharpen (since the cap iron makes it so that you can let the iron wear a little bit more and still avoid tearout), and things you might've thought about the common metal bench plane, like its suitability toward heavier harder woods that are used in the US like maple and beech. My thought at first was that a much heavier plane is a lot nicer to use on those woods, but over time I figured out that if I'm applying extra pressure to push in those woods, all i have to do is be conscious that my extra pressure is only in the direction of the cut and I'm not adding extra unnecessary pressure into the board and bench top, making the plane harder to push.
I can understand why now warren was reluctant to go into details about any of it. It's like hogan said about the golf swing, the secret's in the dirt.








