New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Posts

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#27

Something carbon (or close to it) steel...

david weaver

.. like a vintage chisel that's on the hard side (might not be quite so easy to find).

* A stanley 750 in good shape.

* A LN O1 chisel

* One of the LV O1 chisels

* One of the Barr chisels (a bench chisel, and not a timber framer)

* One of the ashley iles chisels that has a nice profile, though I noticed that my stanley 750s were a bit better at edge holding than the last set of AI chisels I had

Any number of vintage chisels are good, PS&W/Pexto, Buck that say "cast steel" (they may be a tiny bit softer, mine have been, but they make up for it in the fineness of steel and ease of sharpening, and the bevel edge chisels have delicate edges), stanley 750s and 750"shaped" later unmarked chisels that just say stanley USA, but are of the socket type.

There is no shortage of good vintage chisels, if you are willing to buy them one at a time and avoid matched sets that appeal to collectors.

There are good old English brands, too, sometimes they are softer than you expect, though (an octagonal bolster usually does a good job of indicating a good older chisel):

* ward

* ibbotson

* marples

* greaves

* old sorby (not shiny chisels, old ones)

* butcher

My personal metric for a quality chisel is one that provides good edge holding for a given ease of sharpening. I used to be obsessed with chisels that held their edge for a really long time, but that maybe will go away once you get into using a chisel more. You'll be easier on the edge just out of experience, and you'll get faster with sharpening.

My favorite japanese chisels of the ones I've used aren't the ones that are the hardest, they're the ones that hold their edge well and sharpen like a dream because the steel is simple and the backer is an older softer iron.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#28

Re: Multiple Hollows

david weaver

ah... my sense of humor is off lately. :\ No clue why...maybe my brain is drying up! :)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#29

Re: ... has changed...  Yeah we are in K-Car land

TomD

"

.. in western tools, I think, since you've been looking.

The AI chisels are nicely done (and fairly inexpensive), the new veritas chisels are nicely done (i haven't used them, but I can understand their virtues), and LN's chisels are nicely done and traditional."

I went to the LN event that came through locally, and I was really disappointed in both the design and finish quality of the LN chisels. I have quite a few LN planes, and for the most part there was a gratifying bling value when buying them. I went to the LN event, and the finish quality was so ordinary. I think they made a mistake in how they positioned the tools, they didn't have the planes showing their best side on the racks they had. But I was willing to be sucked in by the shooting plane, and just had a real ho-hum reaction. It was as if they had been bought out by Delta, or something.

"The best western chisels are close to japanese chisels in edge holding while still allowing themselves to be ground, which in the end makes them faster to sharpen and maintain, with the exception of parers that should never have enough wear to worry about it in the first place."

All Japanese chisels can be ground, how do people think they make them? I have dry ground them at times. It does not affect temper if you follow normal practices. I don't do it as regular practice, because that isn't what owning them is about. HSS Japanese chisels can be ground more aggressively than plain carbon western chisels, and those have been around for the last 30 years +, not something that is still coming out.

"The one argument I can make for western chisels outside the grinding and the ability to get them cheaply over here is that stuff like cutting the bed in a coffin smoother would've been a booger with any of my japanese bench chisels. They don't have enough reach. But that kind of reach is maybe not something most people will need unless they are mortising bed frames or something."

Back when I bought, there was a long chisel bias, so I bought temple carpenters chisels, though I prefer the bench chisels, and now have both. The thing about Japanese chisels is that the handle angle allows one to cut much deeper than the blade length, plus it aligns the forces for more cutting power, and provides knuckle clearance. So I don't have any long ramp fear. Ask me later after project beech is fully executed. One place where the western chisels do make me happy, is for very narrow blades. The laminated chisels start to make me nervous in small sizes, and long blade lengths.

I am reminded of this article I read in some business mag, back when K-Cars were the big news. It said the while they were a notable achievement in bringing Deming's principles on quality back to their home shore, it was still too late. While Detroit was just getting to the point where their cars were marginally reliable, Japan had whole teams of engineers tunning the sound of the Miyata exhaust. I feel that way about chisels. There are so many ways that Japanese chisels are better, and price barrier is dropping away when western makers are charging 75 each for an O1 chisel. Hand made laminated steel if there were any american makers with a hundred year plus tradition of offering that, would probably be 300 an inch. 85 will pretty much get you a custom tool from Barr. I'm just unclear on the value proposition of current offerings. Chisels seem like such a tough nut to crack for the tool companies. If you look at what 85 dollars buys in a knife, it is even less conceivable. This is where the stanley Sweatheart make sense. I am mostly just amused by the handle thing. If they are good chisels, then they may have something.

However I think the ending will be different. Hand tool makers want to buy american hand tools. Woodworkers have seemingly no qualms about buying Makita, but there is a huge resistance, and even prejudice against Japanese hand tools. With FWW once publishing racist comments about traditional japanese blacksmithing just being a scam.

However, in this case the OP wanted to know why he should move away from Japanese tools. No reason. Now if he had asked whether western tools modern or old would work. Sure, they will get the job done. And they have tradition, which is a big part of the scene.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#30

Re: Sharpening..

TomD

+1

The main reason you have to dry grind your chisels is when a furnace installer comes, and uses them to cut through bolts. :) It's been thirty years and I still am not over it. I used a 600 grit stone at the time.

My practice with fragile steel is to dip the tool in water, and dry grind until the water evaporates. You can actually get an effective grind going that way, and you will never draw the temper. I grind with bare hands, use sharp belts if I am using a belt, use the right grit to grind, blunt then bevel, etc... But the water trick will eliminate any surprises. You are sub 200 when doing that. If heat seems to be accumulating none the less, just rest the tool. However, with Japanese tools they are designed to be sharpened on japanese stones, so they sharpen really well with hand methods. The tool cycle for sharpening is great.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#31

Re: Skills First??

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I still have my set of plastic handled buck chisels that i picked up at a local hardware store. I still reach for them when I'm doing something abusive like chipping out around a nail so I can get a grip to extract it. They tought me a lot about what a handle shouldn't be shaped like too.

Robin

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#32

skills?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I still have my set of plastic handled buck chisels that i picked up at a local hardware store. I still reach for them when I'm doing something abusive like chipping out around a nail so I can get a grip to extract it. They tought me a lot about what a handle shouldn't be shaped like too.

Robin

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#33

Ergonomics (longish)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"I think I also should mention that ergonomics is an important factor for me since I have a degree of weakness and numbness in my hands now (especially the left). I wear large gloves and have long, slender hands if that makes a difference in thinking (though I know there are too many factors and personal preference involved)."

_______

Because of these overriding ergonomic considerations, plus your back, it would help you to have an overall strategy guiding your tool choices. I offer the following as only an example of a thought process:

Grinding, Sharpening. Pick a sharpening strategy that requires relatively little focussed muscular pressure, e.g., a lot of psi exerted through your fingers onto the back of a chisel or plane blade to keep the bevel registered on the stone. Machine grinding and sharpening can help you here. If you're not able to separate your work area into 'dirty' and 'clean' sections, pick a machine or system that doesn't sling grit. If a tool-holder (other than your hands) seems attractive, pick a sharpening machine that does the holding for you, and at a selected bevel angle. If wet-sharpening doesn't fit the work area, use a dry sharpening system. Flattening the honing stones can be a hassle as well--consider a system that doesn't require it.

Example 1: Veritas® Mk.II Power Sharpening System - Lee Valley Tools

Example 2: Bill Tindall's hollow-grinding + diamond honing setup. (Note: Bill doesn't use this setup for Japanese irons and chisels, and I suggest you don't either.)

Flattening. As in blade backs, chisel backs. Select tools that come to you flat, so that your issue is maintenance, rather than the initial chore of flattening.

Example 1: Lee Valley or LN planes and irons, which arrive with flat backs and soles. Not vintage Stanley, which is almost certainly going to require elbow grease to get the sole's periphery and front of mouth in the same plane.

Example 2: Chisels which are either easy to flatten (Japanese), or come with flat backs--LN, LV, Blue Spruce to take three, but not vintage chisels or Three Cherries (to pick two) which are notorious for needing work on the back.

Planing. Pulling will be easier than pushing. Also, think about width of what you have to grab. For example, I would suggest for Japanese planes to think 60mm or less initially--it's a very useful width, not too hard to grip, and blade is easier to maintain than 70mm or higher. Bear in mind that any metal plane with a knob can be pulled as well as pushed, but think about the maneuverability of the tool--a No. 5 or 5-1/4 will be ergonomically easier by far than a No. 5-1/2 or 6, and again, it's easier to maintain the narrower cutting iron. For a pushing plane, Clark & Williams make (or did make at one time) a 12" narrow plane with a stalk handle that is a most useful and easy to use tool. And light to the hand. Think narrow--the tool becomes exponentially harder to pull through the wood as the blade widens.

Sawing. Again, pulling seems the way to go here. And Japanese saws are best used with a light grip like you're eating a peach, as opposed to a hard pinch grip or death grip. It would also be easy, if need be, to drill the handle and insert a crosswise dowel if you need that type of auxiliary hold on the saw.

Chiseling. Consider your methods of work. For mortising, chopping is certainly standard, but there are workarounds (see below). For dovetails, chopping is optional for through dovetails; you can saw the waste with a fret saw (I do this anyway), and leave yourself with a paring job. Paring dovetails to the scribe line can be done with little muscular input if you will get yourself a coupla three paring slicks--12-14" total length, push chisels, and especially in the narrow widths, start with 1/4". You can pare dovetail waste by positioning the handle against your collarbone and jaw, and just lean on it--this gives the best control anyway. You can arrange to do most chiseling with slicks (push chisels). For dovetails, there is the problem of half blind sockets: use a drill press with Forstner bits to drill the center of the waste, then you can pare the surrounding waste. Or have one 1/4" chopping type chisel to deal with the remainder. For mortises in M&T joints, you can chop, but there are alternatives, such as the aforementioned drilling with Forstner bits, to leave yourself a paring job--the Forstner cuts can be overlapped on each other to leave a pretty small paring job.

Tex, as I say, these aren't so much hard and fast recommendations, as an example of ways to make things ergonomically sustainable. Many more examples could be offered in the same vein, but the above should be enough to convey the idea. Second thought--paring slicks are a hard and fast recommendations, at least a 1/4" slick.

Wiley

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#34

Lot's of reasons Money is first

roninkokomo

Some of the most exquisite furniture in the world has been made with western chisels. You can find them dirt cheap. If you are like most of us the chisel will be better than you are for some time. In other words a Western chisel will not prohibit your making museum grade furniture.

You can buy them on ebay for less than lunch if you have a little patience. Plenty of time to buy premium chisels when you are a premium chiseler.

A personal note I am very partial to chisels made by Charles Buck they take and hold a fantastic cutting edge.

Oh a side note... until you learn how to hone well, it doesn't matter much what chisel you use.

Ron

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#35

Re: ... has changed...  Yeah we are in K-Car land

david weaver

While a lot of the premium chisels are expensive and I also don't know why...

.. it may be that there isn't a lot of mid-level stuff in the US because of both the lack of need for it, as well as the fact that there are gobs of antique tools in the US that are perfectly capable - they were machine made long before anyone in japan thought that was acceptable, so we have them here in quantity.

I can't think of anything japanese that I would want to have at the $20 price level over and above a stanley 750 or a similar PS&W beveled chisel.

I think if you approach the whole thing from the standpoint of japanese tools just being superior, then most people are not going to be able to relate to you because, well, most individuals aren't going to come upon such a thought no matter what.

I don't have tons of expensive japanese gear, but I do have enough of it to know that it's not the magic that enthusiasts claim it is compared to western tools.

As far as the grinding goes, how many of those tools are ground heavily on a high speed dry wheel after heat treat and temper? (like I said, I have ground mine and don't have any fear of it). I'd guess none. I've seen the wet wheel that tsunesaburo uses to grind the bevel onto their plane irons (similar to the wheels a knife maker would use) - not similar to a dry grinder wheel.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#36

Re: Sharpening..

david weaver

I don't do the same test, and I use a dry wheel grinder which maybe generates more heat than a coarse belt grinder.

But I do consider it overdoing it with a grinder if I can't immedately stop the grinder and walk away with the bevel of a chisel held against my palm or between my fingers.

Thus my comment about grinding - if I was getting close to the temper temperature of 275 or so, I would not be able to pinch the bevel of the chisel between my fingers and tolerate it.

But if I have any japanese chisel that needs regular grinding (I don't have any HSS, they are almost entirely white steel except for some mortise chisels), then I would consider them to be very poorly made chisels.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#37

Re: Lot's of reasons Money is first

Texchappy

Thanks for all the responses. I do understand that most of the use of the tool comes down to the operator and don't expect any tool to make me Krenov or Duncan Phyfe without putting in the learning. I guess I'm coming from the perspective I take with most 'tools' in my life, buy the best functioning tool once and pass it onto the kids or grandkids. Also, I'm being influenced right now into the 'artisan manufacturer' vibe by Schwarz.

My larger question was to form influencing function and I've gotten a lot of input to consider on that vein. I'm not rushing (or at least trying not to rush) into buying tools so I can weigh each purchase thoughtfully.

I will keep my eye open on ebay though I'm hesitant to risk to much on a vintage tool with my lack of knowledge. In sorting through the information, I'm leaning towards sticking with mid-range (i.e. good user quality) Japanese chisels until I get the right opportunity to try western or figure out what I have isn't working for me. Hey, if they do work then I'm none the wiser to what might or might not be 'better'.

Thanks again for all the responses and information.

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#38

Re: Sharpening..

TomD

I do the same thing on dry wheel grinders, I have several of those. Since getting belts I use them infrequently for this kind of thing, but they are great for their original duty which is sharpening HSS machine cutters, really. The only thing the water does for you is allow you to grind longer, since I can't hold onto a chisel edge at pretty low temps, while some part of the chisel is quite possibly hotter than 200 with the water test. But your method is just as good.

I don't grind Japanese chisels, except now and again, but it is a myth that they can't be ground. Or that they are terribly fragile where grinding is concerned. The real truth is probably just that even if someone needed to grind one, they would be too scared, given what they cost. The other real truth is as you point out, the system is well enough designed one does not need to grind them. Another aspect to the issue is that there are really cheap Japanese tools out there, that work better than anything made over here, and are cheap enough to eat with a grinder. As with the water powered car engine, they won't let us have them. :) Importers do not make enough money, or something.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#39

Re: Something carbon edge retention is like money

TomD

"My personal metric for a quality chisel is one that provides good edge holding for a given ease of sharpening. I used to be obsessed with chisels that held their edge for a really long time, but that maybe will go away once you get into using a chisel more. You'll be easier on the edge just out of experience, and you'll get faster with sharpening.

My favorite japanese chisels of the ones I've used aren't the ones that are the hardest, they're the ones that hold their edge well and sharpen like a dream because the steel is simple and the backer is an older softer iron."

+1

I was even thinking of starting a thread on the idea that edge retention is exaggerated. The thing about edge retention is that like money it is something we can pretty much all agree is valuable. Or velocity with bows. The fastest bow may not be the best, but anyone can make a slow one. And anyone can make an O1 chisel with the same hardness as the stock metal. Getting more performance out of the same steel, is impressive.

Since chisels are the easiest to sharpen, and the fastest to cycle of all three main tools, the downside to lower edge retention is the least.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#40

Re: Hey, we agree on something!

david weaver

My favorite chisels are iyorois (I'm sure we don't agree on that part of it).

I was afraid at first that I must be a lowbrow user because I was told constantly that nobody can like iyoroi chises.

I got mine on discount ($600 for 10 of them, quite a few of which I don't use), they are these (I am far too cheap to ever buy them at regular price):

http://www.japan-tool.com/nomi/Iyoroi_Mokume/Iyoroi_Mokume.html

I'm not sure I've used the regular iyoroi chisels they used to sell over here for $30, but the bad ones of those are probably the origin of "all japanese chisels chip easily". These are fortunately not the same thing. I don't confuse myself into thinking that I've gotten tasai chisels or something else top dollar, but they are still really a dream to use. They leave pleasing black streaks on my finishing stones (natural stones) without fighting the whole process.

It's just too bad that it seems that there are not many chisels in the lower price range that sharpen dreamy like these do, and still hold an edge well enough that you really feel good about the balance of edge holding and sharpening.

I've got a couple now (individual chisels from different brands) that are harder, and the backer is also fairly hard (I could only wish they were HSS so I could freely grind them hard, they're not). They are a booger to sharpen if they get damaged for any reason, especially if you want to carry on some of the process with natural stones.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#41

Makers: Funahiro v Koyamaichi v Ouchi v...

Texchappy

Trying to sort out the pro's and con's of different Japanes chisel makers.

Stu has Koyamaichi and some others.

Iida has Funahiro, Tasai, Ouchi, and some others. I emailed and he recommended Ouchi. (I kinda like what I read about Funahiro).

So has a bunch of different makers.

Then there is Hida with Masashige and Fujihiro (Imai).

Aside from levels, is there much of a difference between them. If so, can someone run down the differences?

Continued Thanks,

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#42

Re: Makers: Funahiro v Koyamaichi v Ouchi v...

Pam Niedermayer

My favorite chisel is a Tasai ultra thin paring chisel; but the only problem I've ever had with Fujihiro, Funahiro, Koyamachi, or Tasai is a Funahiro mortising chisel broke first time I used it, fractured.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#43

Cheap Japanese tools?

Schtoo

TomD wrote;

"Another aspect to the issue is that there are really cheap Japanese tools out there, that work better than anything made over here, and are cheap enough to eat with a grinder. As with the water powered car engine, they won't let us have them. :) Importers do not make enough money, or something. "

Details please?

Seriously, I want to know what they are, where they come from and how cheap they should be. I'm intensely curious because, well, I ship tools out from Japan on a fairly regular basis and though I was aware of most of the cheaper, better quality tools out there and was in fact shipping some of them out.

Or don't I count?

(Possibly, I've decided that shipping out headaches isn't worth the trouble? And sticking to my guns about not shipping out a product I don't trust is probably why I've missed out on finding all of these magical, cheap, excellent tools and sending them out into the world. But what do I know?)

Stu.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#44

Re: Makers: Funahiro v Koyamaichi v Ouchi v...

Schtoo

I don't think I should comment on who's chisels are better here, due to a serious conflict of interest.

But I can tell you that we (my wife and I) are taking Mr. and Mrs. Koyama(ichi) out to lunch next Wednesday, and then we going to visit Mr. Ouchi for a chin wag and then to take some pictures and pick up a few tools.

That's all. Just a bit of a shameless name drop. :D

I just hope Koyama-san doesn't opt for sushi. I don't like the stuff, although the last place I went to in Miki for sushi was good enough that I actually ate it. Thankfully, I didn't have to pay the bill that time, I think it was rather steep. :O

Stu.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#45

Re: Makers: Funahiro v Koyamaichi v Ouchi v...

Texchappy

Stu,

Understand completely why you wouldn't want to compare. However, perhaps it would be fair and fitting to share why you chose to carry Koyamaichi (though I would appreciate your position if you didn't).

I imagine that all these makers would be good but was hoping to find some way to differentiate them.

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#46

Is this a reason?

Texchappy

I asked about this on one of the other forums - the metric factor. I come back to it because I just happened to be knocking around and found a blog entry from Adam Cherubini (Arts and Mysteries). Quoting his blog: "Metric chisels can be a good source of off-sizes (full and bare is the 18th-century lingo for slightly more than and slightly less than), but I certainly could never live with them as a “standard” set of chisel."

And more: "Again, if you are following me, it has to do with what you actually need in real-world use. Not surprisingly, we encounter a fairly narrow range of joint sizes based on our stock size."

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#47

Re: Ouchi would be an excellent addition..


Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#48

Re: Is this a reason?

Guillaume Dery

With all due respect, Adam Cherubini i making a mountain out of a molehill there. Yes, metric sizing is close to but not dead-on to the imperial counterparts. However, you just need to adjust accordingly and apply tool slaving principles to work for you (e.g. size your mortice and corresponding tenon to match the width of one of your chisels).

That being said, if you are going metric on your chisels, you probably want metric drill bits to match (based on what you posted about your condition, I don't imagine you'll be chopping mortices out entirely by hand).

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#49

Tool Slaving

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

Just some perspective on what Adam is about ...

The background issue in Adam's argument is the notion of "tool slaving". This refers to having tools that cut the same dimensions and permit one to go from one to another in the same joint. For example, if you plough a groove with a 1/4" blade, then you have a mortice chisel that will fit that groove, or vice versa. (It may be argued, on the other hand, that if you chop the mortice first, then you do not need to match the chisel to the width of the groove ...).

It is a concept that some like to follow, and it begs the question "which tools/blades go together?". I think that you will find that there are a selected few only, not enough to dictate a "set" of chisels.

Further, in practice, few chisels, metric or imperial, are perfectly accurate in the widths they declare. I have no doubt that some are - such as Blue Spruce, LN and LV. Most of the vintage chisels I have either a little above or below the quoted size. Or that the plough blades are also not at the sizes they claim. The point is that, if you want to slave tools, you need to either choose them all carefully, or modify them accordingly. Note, too, that there are modern plough blades that are available in metric.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#50

Re: Ouchi would be an excellent addition..

david weaver

not to imply that koyamaichi isn't a good option. I had a back and forth with someone in tokyo last year, and they were discussing the difference between the well-respected plain chisels in japan and the export market bling that gets sold to us.

I asked about a few makers, and the tokyo hardware store where he shops (and where the dealers are very critical about tools) has this to say about ouchi and koyama-ichi

Ouchi - good

Koyamaichi - good "like ouchi"

Obviously the chisels aren't the same, but there were a lot of other ones where the dealer didn't have a good opinion.

I see ouchi chisels that someone got 30 years ago were probably made by the father of the guy currently in place.

I see also from tomohito iida's site that the price of the ouchi chisels offered has gone up a TON (and not just exchange).

If that's not something stu can rectify with stu's normal markup (which appears to be less), then koyamaichi are still affordable and well regarded, even in tokyo where the hardware store folks seem to be the most critical.

Stu can tell me if this is wrong, but a lot of tokyo tools I've gotten seem to be a bit harder and it seems like the dealers (and probably customers) like things done to a hard old-spec way, and a little more on the plain side. No compromise is made for the chisel's ability to perform at *at all*. (as in, it seems like the folks in the tokyo region feel like another good tool that isn't made to their style and specs is not acceptable - theirs are "the best").

Long story short, if the tokyo dealers like koyamaichi and ouchi, they must be good, and nobody is blowing smoke up your butt selling it on or to the american shores like a lot of sellers used to do with stuff that was sold as top notch here, and seen as something a lot of carpenters wouldn't be caught using in japan.