New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Posts

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#76

Tool map for upcoming projects

Texchappy

Hmm, "And may I say it's refreshing to find that you're not just another highly-motivated tool acquirer. I was beginning to wonder." Now, I wouldn't say that ;)

So I thought about what I'd need to do these projects I have planned:

1. A utilitarian box (torque wrench): really all I need is layout tools and my ryoba (got)

2. A box to put esaki tissue: ryoba, chisel to clear out dovetail waste. if I choose to groove in the bottom then I would need either a chisel, a router plane, or a plough plane. Thoughts on that?

3. A bread box: shouldn't need any new tools but haven't come up with a design yet

4. A display case for patches: would need a tool to groove or rabbet in the glass and back.

5. Book case whatchamacallit for computer and printer: might need a bigger saw to rip and cross cut larger stock, plough plane for the larger grooves to set the steps in, maybe a mortise chisel since this will be my first mortises.

6. A desktop organizer: shouldn't need any new tools

7. A modular book case for my son: IIRC what Roy Underhill used: router plane, plough plane, rabbet plane. Need to go watch that video again.

So the grand total of what I think I would need for these projects is: (and I just realized these all be 'maybes') larger saw for larger stock, router plane, plough plane, mortise chisel, and maybe some extra sizes of chisel (but doubtful) Oh, and I think somewhere along the line a gauge would be useful.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#77

Re: Imai and others

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, I have only a couple of Imai, only great, also from Hida. They work great, only. :)

Thanks, Wiley, for confirming my memory still works. Any time you want to unload some of those Tasai's, just yell.

Pam

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#78

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#79

Re: Okay, okay... you've made your point.

Texchappy

Nothing special about the torque wrench. Just an old beam style that I don't have a case for. It's kind of unwieldy to put anywhere and somewhat long. Figured it was a good test to ease into making something. it can be ugly, simple to make, and just has to function.

My wife loves an old table she uses as a desk but the problem with that is that it has no drawers or organization built in. The organizer is to raise up both her monitors an give her some cubbies and drawers.

David, I would answer: smart aleck first, woodworker to be second, and tool hoarder third ;) The possibility of being a tool hoarder is there but in asking this question I was attempting to start hoarding the right tools :)

Not mentioned in my list is the tool and accessories I'll need to make. I was thinking of doing saw benches early on but can't decide on the low Japanese or the knee height English. To be honest, I hadn't thought of making my own marking gauge. I'll have to look into that.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#80

Re: Imai and others

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I own one of the "only great" chisels, and two of the sword steel ones.

The "only great" one, it is a 2" or so bench chisel, at the time I wanted to have chisels in all sizes, regardless of type, I felt that having a variety of chisel types would help steer me towards a brand/type (western or Japanese), but that one has stayed mostly unused, as there are few tasks in my work that asks for a 2" bench chisel. I should have chosen a slick or something of that kind...

The sword steel ones I used a fair bit. Easy to hone, yet the edge seems to last forever! Beautiful, beautiful work, terrific balance. I'd buy more if I could afford them...

Here's what Kayoko said about the difference between the two lines:

" The sword steel is also white steel but much better quality of the white steel. They are more strong, stay sharper longer, easy to sharpening. However, for the craftsman, this steel is more harder to control temperature, more labor to make the chisel. These reasons yes, the sword steel chisels are much expensive. but for the professional wood worker, I will recommend them."

I did not purchase a lot of tools through Misugi, but you can chalk me as a fully satisfied customer :)

DC

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#81

Re: Now we`re getting somewhere!

TomD

Don't join our local guild. Nice bunch of guys, but you will not learn anything along the lines discussed here. Bill reports going to all these great seminars from, for him, local people and renowned experts. Now our local woodturning guild is top notch.

I think that Hogan's comment that the answer to golf is in the dirt, has some resonance.

Also, there are people who really like certain activities online, but they don't survive "the first contact with the enemy". I looks like so much fun when X-expert is doing it. Also as a guy with all the right breaks in all the wrong places, adapting to new physical stresses can be a chore. It is amazing what one can do, but stuff comes along that one can't.

For your size of work, I would use 1/4, 3/8. 1/2, which is 6, 9, 12 mm. For one thing, you can use a 1/2 chisel, or a 3/8 to do pretty much anything a 3/4 will do, but the reverse is not true.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#82

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

TomD

That is something about Blue Spruce, he has an eye for line. That chisel in your picture Derek, caught my eye.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#83

Marking gauge

Pam Niedermayer

To be honest, I hadn't thought of making my own marking gauge.

Can be as simple as a nail in a stick.

Pam in Austin

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#84

Re: ... has changed...  Yeah we are in K-Car land

TomD

"I can't think of anything japanese that I would want to have at the $20 price level over and above a stanley 750 or a similar PS&W beveled chisel."

you are probably right, though we don't get 1/100 of what they have on offer.

"I think if you approach the whole thing from the standpoint of japanese tools just being superior, then most people are not going to be able to relate to you because, well, most individuals aren't going to come upon such a thought no matter what."

Yeah, there is a lot of prejudice on the subject. Japanese manufacturing vs US used to be a hot topic. Thankfully I don't have a dog in that fight: Lee Valley is best because it is made in Canada.

As far as this thread is concerned, I said the chisels are far and away better than anything made in the West, and that is just a fact. Who really doubts it? Can anyone name a tool review that found otherwise, on performance, or quality? Even hostile magazines normally put their highest rating on some often quite low quality Japanese chisel, and then they put their Editor's pick on the Three Cherries, or something that they know the punters want to buy.

And tool reviews are a pretty low standard. Japanese blacksmithing is widely respected. Larry makes a stirring case for various western, historical makers. The difference is that in Japan they never disappeared.

"I don't have tons of expensive japanese gear, but I do have enough of it to know that it's not the magic that enthusiasts claim it is compared to western tools."

+1 I've never said it was magic. But some virtually have. That has hurt a market that stands easily on it's two feet. Would it be enough, though, if it was just better on every point, and at what point would just buying it be enough. Nike is a pretty non-magical business, but they market as though buying their shoes ties you into something that is as big. Celebrity. And when you see a really great Japanese carpenter working, it will move you, if you are into that kind of thing. So people have sold the proximity thing. You could have the same plane... At some point you actually have to do some work. And it may help to have some minimal commitment. What's the saying "Beware of the man who studies kendo one day, then watches a youtube video on boxing the next..." Something like that. I've had the same set of Japanese chisels for 30 years.

"As far as the grinding goes, how many of those tools are ground heavily on a high speed dry wheel after heat treat and temper? (like I said, I have ground mine and don't have any fear of it). I'd guess none."

They sure could grind the HSS ones like that. You can dry grind the carbon steel ones, just have to slow it down, as with western carbon chisels. You could grind them on a wet grinder. So how does that add up to there is an advantage to western tools because they can be ground?

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#85

Re: Marking gauge

TomD

And if you make a japanese one, and they are the best, it IS as simple as a nail in a stick, just buy a blade from JW or someone. The one I have used with perfect satisfaction over the years, actually has this dead cheesy mild steel blade in it or something, that bad. Just works great. Cuts a beautiful line, stays put when locked, adjust by minute increments, and has the best support from the fence. I even have a Bridge City! Nothing holds a candle to my every day gauge.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#86

Re: ... has changed...  Yeah we are in K-Car land

Pam Niedermayer

I think Japanese tools are magically great. So there. :)

Pam

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#87

Re: Marking gauge

Texchappy

Are there plans or a guide somewhere. I know I could probably reverse engineer it from pictures but some guidance would help me avoid mistakes.

Thanks for all the ideas.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#89

Titemark or shop made marking gauge?


Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#90

Shop Made.


Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#91

Why for? or Y4?


Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#92

you get exactly what you want

Bruce, a MN Galoot

besides, it's good practice.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#93

To mark stuff.

Bob Hackett

Here`s the process the way I see it.

You go to a catalog and see a high dollar gauge that jumps out at you, you order it and when you finally hold it in your hand you have to figure out how to use it properly, it`s limitations, etc. If it falls short of your expectations is it something the gauge is doing or fails to do or is it you? Now you have to find someone who knows what`s going on and ask a bunch of questions to sort things out. Not a lot of fun in my book. too much opportunity for frustration to set in.

On the other hand if you make one you`ll first do some research in order to better understand how these things are supposed to work and why there are so many different types floating around. You begin to think more about what you really want to do with this gauge and how you want to make it function. You think about appropriate types of wood for a proper gauge and grain orientation within the lumber. You have to decide between things like; do I want a knife or a pin and why, where, and for what application each might excel. Then, once you have sorted thru all this accumulated knowledge and done all your planning you then pick up some of the tools you already have and put them to work either building new skills or honing your old skills. Much more time spent initially (then again maybe not as you have to wait for the ordered gauge to be delivered and then figure out how to use it) but the return is far greater all around.

If the bought gauge fails to live up to expectations you can always blame the manufacturer, send it back and buy another different one. when the shop made one doesn`t perform you have only yourself to blame and have to continue your education until you end up with exactly what you want.

In the end I find I`m always happier with simple tools that I make or refurbish myself. The results fits me exactly instead of being made to fit over 50,000 people who are sort of , nearly, close to, an approximation of me, but not really.

When you`ve got oversized, semi-functioning hands like mine hanging off the ends of your semi-functioning arms one size most assuredly does NOT fit all.

BTW- Both David B and I have serious physical limitations as well. We try not to let them slow us down too much. The quality of David`s work speaks for itself. I make up in quantity what I may lack in quality (I`m a rank amateur compared to David and others here) but have yet to hear any complaints about the things I make in metal, stone and wood for the shops and folks around here and NH and I do commission work as well.

My best advice to you is to push away from the keyboard, put down those catalogs, go out to the shop and make shavings for a bit, maybe a gauge or three. Then come back and tell us how it went so we can all pat you on the back and give you enough confidence to tackle the next rung in the WWing (rather than the tool buying) ladder.

There`s a saying in the blacksmith community; "The tools don`t make the blacksmith, the blacksmith makes the tools". I think that saying can be stretched to apply to a pretty broad section of WWing as well.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#94

Re: Ouchi / Ohuchi prices are up a lot!!

david weaver

I see that the same person who carries yamamoto blades pretty reasonable is also carrying ohuchi chisels.

Holy cow...they're almost twice what koyamaichi charges.

I could just be out of touch. I think a set of ohuchi chisels (for someone wanting a full set) was about $700-800 perhaps 5 years ago.

I think something similar now would be $1400 - for chisels with white #2. Some of that explained by exchange rate and inflation, but perhaps with a sprinkle of name recognition premium added in now.

I guess I'll go back to beating the drum straight out for koyamaichi, which I know are excellent and as yet don't seem to have a name premium.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#95

Re: ... has changed...  Yeah we are in K-Car land

david weaver

As far as the grinding, I would probably dry grind even my carbon steel chisels if I felt like it. In the end, none of mine are that expensive, and they are still tools.

And I do have a tormek and a dry grinder (and a belt grinder). I used to put all convex bevel new tools on a tormek just to get everything straight on the edge, but I haven't had to do that in a while.

That said, a dry grinder, high speed, makes keeping a western tool ground a snap.

I guess where the rubber hits the road for me is that if a chisel doesn't chip harshly or roll right away, I consider it a good chisel to use, unless it is monstrously hard to sharpen for its edge holding.

Quick sharpening after that is important (to me at least), especially if a chisel needs to stand up to the odd bit of heavy use.

I'd imagine most other people feel the same way as I do about magazine tests.

I don't have LN's O1 chisels or Barr's chisels, but I seriously doubt I would prefer my japanese chisels over either one. I might like them the same. I sure do like the 750 style of socket bevel edge chisel, as well as the older tanged version of chisels in the US, and I love the older chisels that are stamped "buck brothers cast steel" even though they could be harder.

I guess it's all taste. I used to be into marveling at the edge that lasted the longest, but that wore off over the years as I ran into quality tools (western or japanese) that had other virtues. At one point, I would've been a good target for HSS chisels, but at this point, I'm not. I could probably sell all of my chisels tomorrow and go through the $5 rack at my favorite old tool digs and be no worse off.

(I did just order two koyamaichi chisels last week, though, so what I could do and what I do do are two different things - they are replacing other japanese chisels that I got before, one matsumura and one koyama - which I learned the hard way isn't the same thing as koyamaichi. In this case, it's a matter of wanting to support the blacksmith more than it is to get chisels out of need)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#97

Re: Ouchi  - sometimes it's nice to be wrong

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, Stu sent me one of the Fujikawa bench chisels to play with. This has "a specially selected Hitachi patent steel (YXR-7)", and Stu refers to them as "PM HSS".

3/4" ...


The bevel came with a flat grind 22 degrees. In retrospect I think that the manufacturer is expecting the user to add a secondary microbevel. It is really not advisable, and definitely not sensible, to try and hone the flat bevel as if it were an everyday Japanese chisel. I tried with Sigmas, and then with diamond paste ... OMG! :O

Finally I said "bugger this", and hollow ground it on the Tormek. It then took no time at all to run through a 13000 Sigma. Did someone say "sharp"? This steel takes a frightening edge.


Now we will see if it lasts as long as Stu says.

Incidentally, I needed to set the hoop. Here is a tip for those who have difficulty. I use a brass hose connector - just place on top of the hoop and hammer down ...


Then fold the wooden end over the hoop ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#98

Re: I've seen those..

david weaver

Or should I say I've seen chisels made of that steel out there before, but for lack of a better way to put it, I haven't been able to tell exactly what they are until now because the sellers can't communicate well enough in english.

I was talking to stu about ouchi not long ago, and he mentioned those are super tough, and not made to compromise to be easier sharpening. Be interesting to see how they compare to LV's powder metal, which is according to them fairly easy to sharpen in relative terms.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#99

Derek's chisel...

Schtoo

Isn't an Ouchi and it isn't by true definition Powder Metal HSS.

I explained this to Derek last night, but I'll do it here as well.

The chisel is made by Fujikawa. Not a well known name, but they make a lot of chisels and a lot of them end up outside Japan with someone else's brand on them.

The steel in it is Matrix HSS, which is essentially a forge refined HSS. Instead of the components of the steel being atomized into a powder and compressed into a block and melted together as PM steels are made, they take a block of metal with all the alloying elements in it and refine it so the particles become small and the grain in the steel is improved.

According to several independent laboratory test, the Matrix HSS doesn't quite exhibit the resistance to wear than true PM-HSS does, but it's significantly 'tougher' (chip, crack and deformation resistant) than an equivalent 'true' PM HSS. In the case of the steel in these chisels, the closest 'normal' HSS is M4, also known as CoHSS which is pretty durable stuff in it's own right.

The YXR-7 alloy in those chisels is specifically engineered for toughness, and it's also one of the more wear resistant alloys out there. It's not junk stuff, but we can't be sure what is actually in the steel because it's still covered under a patent, which is more likely a 'trade secret' kind of deal.

In my own limited testing, it's insanely tough. Even compared to good HSS, it's off the scale.

According to what us unwashed have heard, LV's V-11 is looking like a nice 'bump' on top of A2 in edge retention and quite a bit tougher than A2.

I don't think it's really fair to compare V-11 with YXR-7. We don't know what's in them exactly, they not made in the same way and I fear it'll be like comparing apples to oranges. The V-11 appears to be intended to be a 'nice to live with' compromise, the YXR-7 was made with a single goal in mind and to heck with everything else.

But what do I know?

(I do know it's nice to have a chisel you just can't hurt, to be able to attack a bit of dead tree with something akin to semtex with a handle is a nice thing to have.)

Stu.

P.S. I know they're not PM HSS, but Fujikawa's name for them translates as PM HSS and to try and explain what matrix steel really is is no simple task. Explaining powder metal has already been done for the most part, so instead of trying to re-educate folks, it's a sensible course to simply default to the maker's explanation.