New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Posts

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#51

Re: Ouchi would be an excellent addition..

TomD

My main bench set is ouchi, old dude version. They were the Blue steel ones, and I don`t like them as much as some others, but pretty close to 30 years with them, so I am not changing them now.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#52

Imai

wilbur

I'm very happy with the Imai chisels that I have. I haven't had the opportunity to try any other makers as of yet, but these sharpen easily, and hold an edge for a long time, which is all I want in a chisel.

There may be makers that are better, but I also don't feel any need to upgrade.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#53

Re: Is this a reason?

TomD

This is a reason. I made a comment at some point that I thought Japanese tools were a dead end. This is the kind of thing. When I started out in woodworking I was mostly metric so it did not mater. But over the last 30 years I have flipped to Imperial because of cultural weight. Having two parallel systems in the shop is not an advantage. And if I was starting all over again I would not buy any metric tools. The further my many craft avenues have expanded, the more Imperial the shop has become. Adding machine tools over the last 10 years has been 95% imperial, though bicycle builds are metric. Leatherwork is 100% imperial. Metric has been a bust since the country converted in the 70s.

Japanese tools make sense if you are going to work in the Japanese style and culture. I have yet to hear of anyone who really has done that, unless they are staying in Japan. What is more. Metric is not even the classic integrated measurement system in Japanese woodworking. They had their Metric stormtroopers also. There is a rich system of Japanese layout, and it was not built on Metric. So what the hay... Anyone know if the metric and Sun measures line up?

I think I have seen Imperial Japanese chisels, though not in a long time. I think there are some 1/2 mm sizes in my Ouchi set, and it gets to be a pretty minimal difference. You can also regrind if you need to. It would help to have a real 1/4, and a real 3/8. And since they sell 6.5, for instance, that is only 59 thou out.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3108/md/read/id/128969/sbj/more-sizes/

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#54

Re: Imai

Texchappy

Wilbur, you got those from Hida correct?

I see one of the advantages of going slowly and getting what I need (or what I think I need) is that I can try out different tools. I'm not much concerned with a matched set. One thing I'm noticing is that many of the Japanese oire nomi are around a certain price point ($70 give or take). I am getting an Ouchi (which is more) but I'm counteracting that cost by getting a smaller size (3mm). Since most of what I'm planning to make over the first few projects are very small scale I hope this will be useful. I also plan to get a larger size from Stu and go from there. If I see a great difference in spending the 30 extra bucks for the Ouchi then I might get more. If I don't (and I kinda suspect I won't) then I'll get more of what seems the best to me.

Hope that all makes sense and seems at list a little reasonable.

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#55

Re: Is this a reason?

Texchappy

TomD: I see enough of what you are saying that it has been a concern for me.

However, in going back an reading the Cherubini blog article ( http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/arts-mysteries-blogs/whats-wrong-with-the-standard-set-of-chisels ) I'm having trouble reconciling all the pieces.

Metric as bares - ok, got it.

Vintage imperial chisels - may or may not be close enough to the actual size if I'm reading it right.

New imperial chisels - don't come in the sizes that he recommends that I've found - do they anywhere?

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#56

Re: Larger one

david weaver

It will be hard to get a sense of what the chisel is really about until you get one in the 12-24 mm range, since something in the 3/8" size (sorry to switch units) is something you've already covered elsewhere.

You'll be working hard enough just to get a nice clean bevel on a 3mm chisel, and the bevel will be too small to get a feel for how the metal interacts with stones. But it is a size you should have given you plan to do small work.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#57

Mine are Tasai

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Like Pam, I have Tasai chisels and love them. The steel is superb and his craftsmanship is masterful. When the chisel work really counts, they are my go-to chisels.

T.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#58

Re: Is this a reason?

Pam Niedermayer

I buy metric only, whether western or eastern, because I prefer working in whole numbers; and a mm is as small as I ever need. It also helps that I use my tools to mark and measure.

Japan Woodworker says their Japanese tools are measured in imperial.

Pam

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#59

Re: Imai

Pam Niedermayer

There were (maybe still are somewhere) two grades of Imai, one super great sold by Misugi (no longer existent) and one only great sold by Hida. IIRC, Wiley and several others here bought the super great.

Pam

Austin, TX

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#60

Re: Is this a reason?

TomD

There are some good points in that article. The main one I was dealing with was the Cooperative Workshop idea. The other one he spends a lot of time on has not bothered me. The question of whether certain sizes suit the type of work he is doing. I don't do the work he does, though it is certainly interesting to file away that some of the sizes used in older work are non-typical.

I do think he has a point about the standard set of chisels. The first set I bought was 1/8, 3/8, and 5/8. Really only the 3/8 got used much. I agree that sets spaced by 1/4 inch are not as useful, particularly for dovetails, as ones spaced by 1/16. On the other hand, it is not necessary to cut dovetails with fitted chisels. I do lay out certain joints from the chisel, but I sometimes chop a set with a chisel that is the best average one. So I do not consider it essential to have perfectly fitted ones.

If you get a break on price you can buy a broad spectrum set. If not, you can just buy them as you need them, though one hopes at a rate of acquisition where they remain available long enough for you to complete some kind of set.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#61

Re: Is this a reason?

Texchappy

Question on sets: any advantage to having chisels of one 'set' besides appearance? I hadn't thought of any before but now wonder if there might be as far as predictability in sharpening or handling. Again, don't have a base of experience to know if that's possible.

Back to the tool slaving concept, one advantage I thought about dealt with the sizes of lumber. My thinking was this was only an issue if the lumber was perfectly tried and true to the dimension it is sold as 3/4 for instance and then only if you are doing some sort of dimension (mortise and tenon for example) where you weren't changing that dimension. Hopefully this makes sense as I'm trying to intelligently prepare my tools for a craft I'm just learning to do. I appreciate all the input so far and putting up with my long winded questions.

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#62

Re: Is this a reason?

TomD

"Question on sets: any advantage to having chisels of one 'set' besides appearance? I hadn't thought of any before but now wonder if there might be as far as predictability in sharpening or handling. Again, don't have a base of experience to know if that's possible."

Racking is more difficult, say you have tapered ferules on one and not on the other. Handling, it is like a martial art, you want to be able manipulate the tool fluidly without hardly looking. If they were different though you could get by. But you are starting to get into the minutia, here, so if you are getting into details, why would you want different chisels.

"Back to the tool slaving concept, one advantage I thought about dealt with the sizes of lumber. My thinking was this was only an issue if the lumber was perfectly tried and true to the dimension it is sold as 3/4 for instance and then only if you are doing some sort of dimension (mortise and tenon for example) where you weren't changing that dimension. Hopefully this makes sense as I'm trying to intelligently prepare my tools for a craft I'm just learning to do. I appreciate all the input so far and putting up with my long winded questions."

I'm not too sure what the question is here. If you think that a door should be 3/4" thick, and that the mortise dimension should be either 1/3 or 1/2, then you need a a chisel in those sizes. In theory. But I don't work to set dimensions, and I don't think that is the concept. I think the idea is that if you use a haunched mortise and tenon, and you want to cut the through rebate piece where the groove cut with your rebate plane has to be the same size as the tenon. Then the mortise also has to be cut to that same size. So if your chisel and plane don't add up, you have a problem. A lot of people would cut that with a table saw, and you could set and center that cut to any dimension. So you are starting to get into very specific details of work. For instance I do not prefer to make haunched mortise and tenon joints.

It is hard to predict where you will end up other than that it will not be where you started out, but the more consistent your approach to tool buying the better. And if you knew for a fact that you wanted to do only repro american furniture, buying only Japanese tools would be the hard way. But a lot of woodwork is pretty free-form, so you have latitude with the tools you buy.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#63

Imai and others

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

You have a good memory, Pam!

Like I suppose everyone else, mine was a random walk through Japanese chisels. This was years ago, and I recall how the fad would shift in waves from one maker to the next--Imai was hot for a while, then Tasai was the thing, then Funahiro (especially the genju). It's still happening, I see. All the chisels gave good service, but varied some in how they wanted to be sharpened. I started with JWW $35 a piece dovetails, added several Miyanaga oire, a 17-set of Tasai shinogi oire and a couple of Tasai slicks, a couple of Funahiro genju slicks--and a whole bunch of Imai oire (oire= ordinary bench chisel), mortise chisels, and slicks in what was then called for marketing purposes 'sword steel' and what was in fact white steel No. 1.

To me, the Tasai were and are extremely impressive, sharpened so quickly for blue steel, and so clean and precise in the weld. I found the Miyanaga's and the Funahiro genju very abrasive resistant, such that to this day I grind them to a burr on Tormek and hone from there.

What the Imai's did for me was meet my needs. And this is largely a testament to the vendor Kayoko Kuroiwa: Imai-san would make to your spec and deliver chisels in a month's time. Funahiro and Tasai were bigger names by that time, but it was a huge production to get anything other than what the vendors had on hand to sell. For example, in slicks--13" shinogi--I wanted a set of smalls, from 1/8" through 1/2" in sixteenths, i.e., from 3mm to 12mm in 1.5mm increments. This was for dovetail paring. And Imai would grind 10-degree bevels on each side of the lands, so as not to bruise the socket walls. And he would deliver those, singly, or two of them, or a set--whatever you wanted--in a month or 5 weeks' time. I could have gotten old (or worse) waiting for an order like that from Tasai, if he would do it at all. And Funahiro, forget it! Same deal on the mortise chisels--I could get 4.5mm and 7.5mm no problem, as well as the more standard widths.

Anyway, it turned out that the Imai's are what I use, and the Tasai oire's are still in the box and have never cut wood, although I truly think Tasai is a great smith.

So it all developed for me kinda happenstance, but I would suggest for Tex's consideration, that he think about how he is going to work, and whether oire makes more sense or whether paring slicks make more sense. For me, once I decided to saw dovetail waste, I only ever used one 1/4" bench chisel for chopping half blind sockets, and everything else was either a slick or a mortise chisel. One of the most-used has been a 4.5mm (3/16") slick; 1/4" second most-used; and 5/16" third. And 1/8" to get into the corners; yes, I have skews, but the 1/8" would do the same thing and was usually closer to hand.

Pam, I really admire that Tasai fishtail. And I recall that Tom Skaggs thought hard before committing to Tasai, and is now very happy. I also envy Derek his Kiyohisa slicks--I ordered some about 5 years ago, and am still waiting--it ain't gonna happen.

Wiley

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#64

Re: Imai and others

wilbur

I should clarify that I have the "only great" Imai chisels, not the sword steel ones that Wiley and others have. Maybe someday. :D

I'm fairly sure that if one is interested in the high end sword steel Imai chisels, Hida Tool can special order them.

Although Misugi Designs is no longer doing business, there is still information from their old website on the two versions of the Imai chisels on archive.org: http://web.archive.org/web/20070415155650/http://www.misugidesigns.com/chisels.html

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#65

Overthinking this

Texchappy

Ok, so I think I'm over thinking this. Guess that's easy for me to do when all I can do all day is sit in a chair and read forums over and over (which I where I am right now).

So I am thinking I will stick with Japanese chisels and get all of one kind for consistency sake. Now I just have to decide which the 'one brand' is ;)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#66

Re: Imai and others

Schtoo

Wanna know something funny?

Funny, not as in "ha-ha"...

I've asked about Imai sword steel chisels. Can't find them, not available, don't know what you're talking about. And who I asked about them, if they existed you'd better believe they'd know about it.

(If anyone can read Japanese, I can provide the emails I got regarding these mythical creatures. I also got a quote on some genuine, no BS sword steel chisels. If you've got $15000, a set of 10 can be procured.)

Stu.

(I wish I had the guts to try half the stuff other folks get away with. I wouldn't be sitting here getting grey hair worrying about paying the bills...)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#67

Chris Schwarz two chisel suggestion

Texchappy

I watched the Chris Schwarz chisel video on PW's shop class on demand. He suggests starting out with just two chisels - a 1/4" and a 3/4".

Two questions:

1. From my brief experience, Schwarz is a pretty sharp guy - is this sound advice?

2. What would the metric equivalent be?

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#68

Re: Chris Schwarz two chisel suggestion

david weaver

That would be fine.

6mm and either 18mm or 21mm.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#69

Re: Imai and others

wilbur

Hi Stu,

The Imai "sword steel" chisels do exist. Plenty of folks in the US have them.

If the issue is the term "sword steel", as in steel used for swords, that's the term that originally was used for them on the Misugi Designs web page, and that's how most folks who have them in the US have continued to refer to them.

Looking at the old Misugi Designs website, it looks like in 2007 the website changed the decryption of these chisels from "sword steel" to "special white steel", which is probably more accurate from a technical standpoint.

http://web.archive.org/web/20070415155650/http://www.misugidesigns.com/chisels.html

My understanding is that these chisels, whatever you want to call them, were made from white steel #1, and the plain Jane Imai chisels that I have are white steel #2, but I don't have confirmation on this.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#70

Ask yourself this

Bob Hackett

What do I want to make? Until you know what you want to make then we can`t be of much help.

The fact of the matter is given you limitations and back problems you may find that sitting in front of a scrollsaw (instead of a computer screen) is what fits you best. In that case all the hand tools you`ve bought will just be gathering dust till you sell them at a loss.

Until you define what direction your capabilities and personal likes/dislikes will most likely lead then all our advice is conjecture at best. How can we advise you as to tool purchases when you personally don`t yet know what you want to make or do?

It`s like saying, "I want to travel, what should I buy"?

We sling a lot of suggestions your way about the merits of Ford vs Chevy vs Doge only to find what you really want is suggestions for luggage suitable for taking on a train.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#71

Re: Ask yourself this

Texchappy

Bob, the answer is obvious - Ford.

As to what I want to make, I do have a direction - at least as I work into it. A list of projects follows:

1. A utilitarian (read ugly if need be) box to put a torque wrench in.

2. A nicer (but utilitarian (read ugly) if I screw it up) box to put esaki tissue in for airplane models.

3. A bread box for my wife (I sense a them here, next I'll be buying an old Volvo).

4. A display case for patches from my pilots in Iraq.

5. An almost book case for my wife's huge computer and to put a printer on top.

6. A desktop organizer for my wife.

7. A modular book case for my son like the one from "The Woodwright's Shop" a season or so ago.

Ultimately, I'd like to build the furniture for the bed and breakfast style PTSD retreat center we are praying about opening for my medical retirement.

I'd also like some time to try my hand a Cadovius style wall unit like my step-dad had.

And Bob, the answer is obvious, a Chevy. :)

Tony

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#72

Re: Imai and others

david weaver

the temple builder's imai chisel that I have is a plain jane one and is white #1.

What I understood to be the case with the chisels marketed as sword steel was that the blacksmith spent some time hammering or forge purifying them, or some other process that was meant to improve a material that was otherwise similar.

If he was good and it really was a difference in intention, I've no doubt that he could make a significant improvement in how tough the chisels were without making them harder to sharpen and without sacrificing their hardness.

I have never had either of the bench chisels, and as you say, it may just be a white #2 vs white #1. But a good blacksmith can definitely make very good chisels out of white #2. Presumably though, there is slightly more margin for error with white #2 than white #1.

But it's all guesses on my part (though guesses that might explain why some of the later 18th century and early-mid 19th century american chisels are so nice to use).

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#73

Now we`re getting somewhere!

Bob Hackett

Sounds like you want to start out making projects that are variations of a box. so you want to concentrate on tools that are appropriatefor the size box you want to build. In this case "thinking outside the box" is not such a good idea for now. In order to proceed you have to ask yourself what kind of joinery you want to use for the smaller projects because, in my experience, a smaller version of a tool such as a chisel can usually be pressed into service for larger work where as if you buy too wide a chisel it will obviously not work for your task.

If it were me doing this I would organize these projects in terms of either need or skill building. That is to say either the most simple project first or the one I need the most (like a saw bench) first. Once I decided what I wanted to do first I`d break down each of the tasks needed to complete the project. Things like cutting rough sawn lumber to size would require both a rip and a crosscut saw. Depending on what wood you get and how it comes to you then you may or may not need a scrub plane or jack plane and a smoother, perhaps a jointer plane as well appropriate clamps if you are going to joint boards to glue up a panel as well as a rebate or plow plane depending on how you want to fit the top and bottom panels of a box or the back of a bookcase for example.

When I was just starting out I preferred to let the projects I was making decide what tools I needed to buy, make or borrow rather than the other way around. After I had become comfortable with the tools I owned and my skills in using them I would then think about learning a new skill which led to a more difficult project and acquiring or making new tools. As I progressed I always let the projects at hand or the skills I wanted to master decide what my next purchase would be. That was my approach to building up my own tool set without making a lot of needless expenditures and wasted time. Then again, I come from a metalworking background so I made most of my own tools and still do. The only difference is I am spending my time rather than my money.

I still stand by my earlier advice that the best money you`ll ever spend in WWing will be whatever dues it costs you to be a member of the local WWing club or guild. IME no other relatively small outlay of cash will bring you such high returns.

If you lived near mid-coast Maine and were a member of the local club I`d loan you all the tools I mentioned above after showing you how to use and maintain them. If a #4 Stanley didn`t work for you you could try a #3 or a transitonal or early wood plane from my shop I could also tell you where to get the best deal on local hardwoods that are appropriate to the project you want to undertake. What you and I couldn`t do between us (like working with Asian tools) we could then bring to another club member`s shop and get a demo on how to do those operations as well. Like the old saying goes; "We learn best when we learn together".

Another good friend who`s a blacksmith from the UK is fond of saying "Nothing sorts it out like getting the hands mucky, eh." :)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#74

Re: Now we`re getting somewhere!

Texchappy

Bob, thanks for the in-depth reply. As to a guild or club, part of my difficulty is lack of mobility so I'm hesitant to pay out dues for something I can't guarantee I'll be able to use very often.

I am trying to get the tools I need for the next project. I plan a simple dove tail (i.e. one) for my first box because it is 5-6 inches tall so the only waste can be sawn. I want to make the nice one a little nicer. The lumber I have for the first box is poplar and I had it thickness planed but it was still a little rougher than I'd like. I do have a smoother that I need to play with a bit to get the hang of.

The first mortise and tenon's I'm planning on doing are for the computer/printer shelf-thingy I'm going to be making for my wife. I'm planning on altering the bookcase from Tom Fidgen's Made by Hand book to suit her needs. They won't be heavy duty tenons but through tenons at the width of the shelf stock through the sides (and the sides through the top.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#75

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)