New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Posts

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#1

Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Texchappy

or should I? I've started out with one Japanese (Masashige) 6mm chisel (and to be honest haven't set it up yet). As I expand my chisels to more sizes I've wondered if I should try an American chisel to compare.

So here's the basic question: Should I try an American (or English) chisel to compare?

The under-question: What advantages are there to American chisels compared to Japanese?

I know when I asked this on another forum, Wilbur suggested I shouldn't because of consistency in sharpening technique.

If I try an American chisel, I'm strongly leaning to Blue Spruce but would be open to other brands.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#2

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm not familiar with Japanese chisels, or Japanese tools in general. So this is a philosophical rather than knowledgeable post.

I think there's a point at which you choose a path and proceed down it. It's easy to get distracted by all the shiny pretties out there, and never do anything but play with them.

From my reading/observation, there are benefits to Western and Japanese tools, each. But each of them will cut and shape wood. You might be better off learning the limits of the tooling choice you've made so far.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#3

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Texchappy

I think you may be right Bill, thanks. I believe I've read so much I'm in information overload (e.g. I've read all the archives on this forum over the last 2-3 days). I need to now 'do' but the danged limitations I've experience have prevented that.

Continued sage advice appreciated.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#4

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Tools are just that they are tools, in the same way that a fork and spoon are tools.

One wood working tool that seems to be very personal is marking knives. I made the one I use durning my first or second year as an apprintice. it is made from a piece of tool steel and the handle is paduk and carved to fit my hand in the peculiar way I like to hold it. One of the journey men I was working with at that time used a broken off stub of a jointer knife sparpend to a knife edge and wraped with an ugly wad of electrical tape to form some semblence of a handle. the other journey man in the shop used an old obsolete exacto knife and my boss used a traditinal patternmakers knife. The funny thing was that all those knifes were equal in their marking acuracy.

In regards to chisels for you to truely know if you like jananese style chisels you will have to try western style and I would suggest a couple of vintage high carbon steel chisels because they will sharpen similarly to your japanese chisel.

Robin

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#5

Because...

Schtoo

There's always more than one way to skin a cat.

Some folks don't like the way Japanese chisels feel in the hand. Purely personal choice there, and there's no possible argument that can be made for or against it, it just is.

So it's always a good idea to at least try as many things as is possible, especially something like a chisel where the tactile feedback from the tool can be important to how effective you can be with it.

Myself, I don't care. So long as the tool isn't complete garbage, I can use it effectively enough to get the job done.

You might find that you prefer the way a Western chisel works for you, and if you find this out early on, at least you won't be spending a lot of money on tools that aren't ideal for yourself.

But don't fall into the trap of using a poor tool (of whatever colour) and deciding that "they must all be like this" and switching to 'the other one'. Do make sure you're using good quality, trusted and reliable tools to base your comparisons on.

Stu.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#6

Re: Because...

Texchappy

Thanks for the input Stu. I definitely wanted to compare Apples to りんご (using Yahoo translator). If I do this, and still don't know if I will because there are some really good points on both side, then I would want a 'fair' comparison. From my understanding, the Masashige is a pretty good chisel. I mentioned Blue Spruce and I've read LN makes some good chisels.

What would be a good comparison to what I have as far as a 'western' brand?

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#7

Re: Because...

Texchappy

I think I also should mention that ergonomics is an important factor for me since I have a degree of weakness and numbness in my hands now (especially the left). I wear large gloves and have long, slender hands if that makes a difference in thinking (though I know there are too many factors and personal preference involved).

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#8

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

TomD

"or should I? I've started out with one Japanese (Masashige) 6mm chisel (and to be honest haven't set it up yet). As I expand my chisels to more sizes I've wondered if I should try an American chisel to compare."

Japanese chisels are way the heck above anything else out there, and there really isn't any reason to try anything else, other than that if you get a chance, why not.

There are tools out there that make a beginner better, and tools that require a bit of skill to use. Sometimes there are pros and cons that make either work well. This is an in-between case. You do not want to play Tiger Wood's golf clubs, or even something in the ballpark. But Japanese chisels can be great. Right off the bat. You have to want to be that person. They work a certain way, I wouldn't buy them to use as crowbars. They will take a little longer to set up, but at least your time won't have been wasted. One can come up with reasons to dislike them or reject them. But time put in will be rewarded.

Pretty much all the chisels I have seen in current manufacture in the west strike me as junk. I have tried lots of them. I would either buy Japanese, or antique. Those are the pro grade tools. I would also consider Chinese, el cheapos.

"The under-question: What advantages are there to American chisels compared to Japanese?"

Really none. I guess you can get the new Stanleys if you like chisels the handles fall off of... Even if you wanted a chisel you could abuse and prepare largely with grinders, I would get Japanese HSS ones.

"I know when I asked this on another forum, Wilbur suggested I shouldn't because of consistency in sharpening technique."

Yeah, +1 to that. That is why you shouldn't end up with different tools, but you can still knock yourself out trying them. Chisels are relatively simple tools, you don't need expensive ones, I could get by with the ones with multi coloured plastic handles. But if the western tool makers have taken anything from the Japanese makers, it is how to run their prices up. So sure, you can buy cheaper chisels than Japanese, but none of the better ones are all that cheap.

"If I try an American chisel, I'm strongly leaning to Blue Spruce but would be open to other brands."

They are pretty much the anti-christ of what I like in a chisel. They seem very popular, so that is always indicative of something. I would just change everything. The flip side is they technically everything I would do to make a chisel for some one off purpose in the shop. If I am putting out money I want to get something I can't do as well or better myself. Look at the bell shaped ferule. Compare that to the tang, socket style on a Japanese, or the balls to the wall socket in the Barr. Why would I pay for that, any wood turner can install a band. People are loving them, so they fill a need. I think even some notable pros buy them. But I would rather raise my efforts to some other chisel than be the person for whom that is the right choice.

On ergo, it depends what you want. Japanese chisels are supremely ergo. About 20 years ago, one of the Swedish chisel companies came out with an all new ergo design, and nobody could fail to see the almost direct copy they were of Japanese chisel planform, if not execution.

For instance, you hold chisels in one hand, then you hit them with a hammer. Is it a great idea for the jarring force of the hammering to be transferred as effectively as possible to your hand. What about if the design that did that also cramped up your hand, and transferred the least force when hand powering the chisel? Sound good? That would be the western design in a nutshell. Just to mention one thing.

I do use one brand of American chisel and I really like them. They are the Barr Chris Beckworst design. Unfortunately when I bought them 10-15 years ago the steel was not very hard wearing, but a lot of time has gone under the bridge. If my first O1 tools came out better, they should be well up to speed. Real pro grade, and they do what a chisel should do. They would be better with Japanese handles though.

Basically a chisel needs an effective planform, and it needs to concentrate cutting power at the edge. What it doesn't need to do it look like a high school spindle turning project. Have expensive woods that should be in guitars, and don't respond well to being hit. why is it toolmakers are always poaching guitar woods that are known for the bell like rigging qualities.

ATMO

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#9

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Bob Hackett

Ask yourself this; "To what end".

If the answer is "to make stuff" then the next thing you need to buy is a membership in the local WWing club. The dues you hand them will get all your questions answered, give you access to tons of cool tools you can try out, as well as one on one instruction from knowledgeable and experienced people who`s work you can see and handle in person. It will be the best money you`ll ever spend on your WWing hobby.

If, on the other hand, the answer is "To occasionally dub around, spend lots of money and collect cool stuff" then continue to flip thru the catalogs and fire those checks off at will. :)

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#10

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Texchappy

Ok, follow on question. Always wanting something new, should I try another brand? If so, what brand of Japanese chisels should I try? And what size would be most useful to get new? I'm thinking 3mm or 12mm.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#11

Multiple Hollows

Texchappy

I've read on older threads on this forum that there may not be a reason other than style for multiple hollows. I also saw on The Woodwright's Shop with JRF that they may help with paring.

So what is y'alls take on multiple hollows?

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#12

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

wilbur

You only have a 6mm chisel right now, if I recall correctly. I'd vote for a 18mm one. You'll get a 12mm eventually, but for now you can simulate a 12mm chisel by taking two passes or so with your 6mm chisel.

Jumping ahead to your multiple hollows question, I think it's just style. I don't have any multiple hollow chisels, and I haven't run into a situation where I thought that I needed one.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#13

Something has changed...

david weaver

.. in western tools, I think, since you've been looking.

The AI chisels are nicely done (and fairly inexpensive), the new veritas chisels are nicely done (i haven't used them, but I can understand their virtues), and LN's chisels are nicely done and traditional.

The LNs are reasonably hard, at least the ones I have.

But as you point out, there are so many good vintage chisels in the US, that there's not always a very good reason for a non-beginner to buy high-end new chisels.

The best western chisels are close to japanese chisels in edge holding while still allowing themselves to be ground, which in the end makes them faster to sharpen and maintain, with the exception of parers that should never have enough wear to worry about it in the first place.

The one argument I can make for western chisels outside the grinding and the ability to get them cheaply over here is that stuff like cutting the bed in a coffin smoother would've been a booger with any of my japanese bench chisels. They don't have enough reach. But that kind of reach is maybe not something most people will need unless they are mortising bed frames or something.

And I was less than pleased with how my imai temple builder's chisel tolerated heavy pounding that a cheap laminated vintage 1" PS&W framer here took with less damage, and then in turn sharpened much faster, as I had to work fairly large nicking out of the imai and the backing metal did not yield to the stones as easily as it should have. (I did not pry with either chisel, so it was a matter of hitting the chisel just like you'd see inomoto do it - swift straight strikes with a 2 pound hammer).

Anyway, there are arguments for both, and if the money isn't an issue, it is nice to have both.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#14

Re: Multiple Hollows

david weaver

I haven't found them necessary for anything. I've seen people describe why they feel they're necessary for paring chisels, but if I am paring to a mark or "to a look" (i.e, paring something until it looks like I want it to), I am steering the chisel.

I had multi-hollow chisels as my first set. I no longer have them and at the time I had the same western chisel mentality that the back needed to rest on the workpiece after the cut, but in practice, I just haven't found the need when using chisels properly sized for a workpiece.

Not that someone else can't come up with a situation where they're helpful, I guess, I just haven't run into it.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#15

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

david weaver

Here's my answer - because good carbon steel vintage chisels can be ground with a dry power grinder, and you can sharpen them faster overall because of it.

They'll also be cheaper (if you buy them once you know what you want) than a good set of japanese chisels, unless you decide you like a style that has collector value.

But it shouldn't matter too much which type you buy.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#16

Re: Because...

david weaver

The only thing blue spruce that I have is a marking knife that someone gave me, and I hear dave jeske is a nice guy, so I hope this isn't taken the wrong way.

But if all blue spruce chisels are A2 steel, I would buy something else for a general use chisel that might be pushed in one cut and struck in another.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#17

I'll stick my neck out on brand...

david weaver

I agree with wilbur on the sizing, something like 18 or 21 mm.

And I would contact stu (schtoo) and get a koyama-ichi bench chisel, something plain, because the maker makes no junk and you don't have to worry about quality varying with "trim level" or anything like that.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#18

Horse preceding cart......

Bill Tindall

Fact: you can build what ever you want to build with what ever chisel you buy. So the choice now becomes personal preference and how much money you have to spend.

I don't know how this personal choice could be decided using practical metrics until a chisel is used for what ever it is you want to do in woodworking, which might be collect tools. I bought one inexpensive Japanese chisel and a set of the blue handled things because both were cheap. I quickly found that a top heavy long western chisels gave me a wicked hand cramp while dovetailing and the short light Japanese style didn't. On the other hand the short hooped Japanese chisel was an ergonomic disaster for paring when I was installing door hinges about the house.

Then there was the cost which got considered when I considered what is the cheapest means to meet my needs. I soon found that I did very little paring and lots of dovetailing. Now I had practical data to decide which chisels to buy(or make) that I would use forever more. I now own a set of these good chisels. I am used to using them and nothing would motivate me to try/buy anything else. Like most people I know that make stuff, one set of multitasking chisels is adequate. As an aside, Will Neptune made every joint one would likely ever use in a table, case and chair and he used just 3 chisels.

If cost was any consideration I would recommend to someone to buy one inexpensive Japanese chisel and one Hirsch chisel (excellent steel by my testing) from Lee Valley and then use them for what ever is being built. Then decide and fill out the collection.

BTW, I would like to hear more about different sharpening technique of Japanese vs western chisels. I don't do them any differently nor can I think of any reason that they would need to be sharpened different.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#19

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've started out with one Japanese (Masashige) 6mm chisel (and to be honest haven't set it up yet). As I expand my chisels to more sizes I've wondered if I should try an American chisel to compare.

Japanese and Western bench chisels (there are lots of styles of chisels but we shall simplify it to these) differ in a few ways.

Importantly, the steel in a Japanese chisel is laminated. This makes it harder and more brittle, which equates to a blade that can get sharper, hold an edge longer, but does not like being handled roughly (such as prying). The bevel is a little more complicated to sharpen - not a lot, but for a beginner this can be why they choose to start out with a Western chisel.

The Western chisel will not hold a edge as long, but generally they are foolproof and can take much abuse, survive being burned on a grinder (O1 blades are easier to re-temper), and have a wider range of handles - which can make or break your love affair with a chisel (they are personal choices).

Pictures taken from a recent review of the newly released Veritas Bench Chisels (they should be placed high on your list for tryng out): http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasChiselReview.html

Bench chisels (Koyamaichi, Stanley) ...


Paring chisels (Blue Spruce, Witherby, and Kiyohesi) ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#21

Re: Because...

Schtoo

Tex said;

"What would be a good comparison to what I have as far as a 'western' brand?"

Honestly?

I don't know. I can only go by reputation from the English speaking world, which is apparently good. But I won't say if they're good, bad or indifferent since I have zero experience with them, have never seen one and can't find any information about them here in Japan.

Another ghost by the looks of it to me.

Stu.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#22

Re: Sharpening..

david weaver

..I guess you're not "supposed" to grind japanese chisels. I haven't followed that exactly, but temperature is important. I have used a grinder lightly on new chisels that are bowed in the front, i guess from being allowed to roll a little when ground in manufacture.

Temper temperature is somewhere around 250 or 275, I think, instead of closer to 350-400 like it is with O1.

If not used with a heavy hand, there's no reason a japanese chisel will ever have to go past a medium stone, at least that I can think of.

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#23

Re: Multiple Hollows

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I had the same western chisel mentality that the back needed to rest on the workpiece after the cut, but in practice, I just haven't found the need when using chisels properly sized for a workpiece.

Hi David

The hollow back does not prevent it from resting on the workpiece. It is only hollow at the centre, not at the sides where it is supported.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#24

Skills First??

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

You can put the finest chisel known to man in the hands of a novice and get poor results. Knowing what types of chisels suits you best cannot be fully understood until you have the skills to know differently. Perhaps you would be well served to buy a decent set, like for instance Marples Blue Chips and develop your skills with use and sharpening. Then you will have better persoanl knowledge on which to base your evaluation of quality chisels. Your money won't be wasted....I started with Marples and they have become very useful to me for "down and dirty" work.

Tom

Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?

#25

Re: Multiple Hollows

david weaver

I guess I should've been more clear about why I thought it wasn't an issue.

I have seen people describe situations where their workpiece was narrower than the hollow on a chisel, and on the finer chisels, the hollow is very delicately and neatly made toward the sides away from the edge.

It is a situation that in practice either I haven't encountered, or I haven't noticed.

Certainly someone could say the problem is then that you don't have the right size of chisel.