Re: Why should I try Non-Japanese Chisels?
TomD
"or should I? I've started out with one Japanese (Masashige) 6mm chisel (and to be honest haven't set it up yet). As I expand my chisels to more sizes I've wondered if I should try an American chisel to compare."
Japanese chisels are way the heck above anything else out there, and there really isn't any reason to try anything else, other than that if you get a chance, why not.
There are tools out there that make a beginner better, and tools that require a bit of skill to use. Sometimes there are pros and cons that make either work well. This is an in-between case. You do not want to play Tiger Wood's golf clubs, or even something in the ballpark. But Japanese chisels can be great. Right off the bat. You have to want to be that person. They work a certain way, I wouldn't buy them to use as crowbars. They will take a little longer to set up, but at least your time won't have been wasted. One can come up with reasons to dislike them or reject them. But time put in will be rewarded.
Pretty much all the chisels I have seen in current manufacture in the west strike me as junk. I have tried lots of them. I would either buy Japanese, or antique. Those are the pro grade tools. I would also consider Chinese, el cheapos.
"The under-question: What advantages are there to American chisels compared to Japanese?"
Really none. I guess you can get the new Stanleys if you like chisels the handles fall off of... Even if you wanted a chisel you could abuse and prepare largely with grinders, I would get Japanese HSS ones.
"I know when I asked this on another forum, Wilbur suggested I shouldn't because of consistency in sharpening technique."
Yeah, +1 to that. That is why you shouldn't end up with different tools, but you can still knock yourself out trying them. Chisels are relatively simple tools, you don't need expensive ones, I could get by with the ones with multi coloured plastic handles. But if the western tool makers have taken anything from the Japanese makers, it is how to run their prices up. So sure, you can buy cheaper chisels than Japanese, but none of the better ones are all that cheap.
"If I try an American chisel, I'm strongly leaning to Blue Spruce but would be open to other brands."
They are pretty much the anti-christ of what I like in a chisel. They seem very popular, so that is always indicative of something. I would just change everything. The flip side is they technically everything I would do to make a chisel for some one off purpose in the shop. If I am putting out money I want to get something I can't do as well or better myself. Look at the bell shaped ferule. Compare that to the tang, socket style on a Japanese, or the balls to the wall socket in the Barr. Why would I pay for that, any wood turner can install a band. People are loving them, so they fill a need. I think even some notable pros buy them. But I would rather raise my efforts to some other chisel than be the person for whom that is the right choice.
On ergo, it depends what you want. Japanese chisels are supremely ergo. About 20 years ago, one of the Swedish chisel companies came out with an all new ergo design, and nobody could fail to see the almost direct copy they were of Japanese chisel planform, if not execution.
For instance, you hold chisels in one hand, then you hit them with a hammer. Is it a great idea for the jarring force of the hammering to be transferred as effectively as possible to your hand. What about if the design that did that also cramped up your hand, and transferred the least force when hand powering the chisel? Sound good? That would be the western design in a nutshell. Just to mention one thing.
I do use one brand of American chisel and I really like them. They are the Barr Chris Beckworst design. Unfortunately when I bought them 10-15 years ago the steel was not very hard wearing, but a lot of time has gone under the bridge. If my first O1 tools came out better, they should be well up to speed. Real pro grade, and they do what a chisel should do. They would be better with Japanese handles though.
Basically a chisel needs an effective planform, and it needs to concentrate cutting power at the edge. What it doesn't need to do it look like a high school spindle turning project. Have expensive woods that should be in guitars, and don't respond well to being hit. why is it toolmakers are always poaching guitar woods that are known for the bell like rigging qualities.
ATMO