New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

Posts

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#51

Re: getting back to the point I tried to make

TomD

Yeah, I get your original post. But the problem is A) You have him dead to rights, he is the guy using old tools in an old way who also has modern clamps, and glue. Bingo, where is the mystery. B) There is no more recognizable figure in post blog US woodworking, so the mystery is what exactly.

It's like jumping into the latest episode of Breaking Bad, and asking what is with these people, don't they understand you can't just start a story in the middle, when there are years of previous episodes.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#52

No such thing as too many chisels !!


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#53

Some great discussion here.!!!


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#54

Re: getting back to the point I tried to make

Alan Schwabacher

While I am quite familiar with Chris Schwarz and have never heard of "breaking bad", I agree. His work is like the serialized products of Dickens and Dumas: enormous, originally published in snippets, and sometimes collected into books.

Schwarz's approach reminds me a bit of Farley Mowat in "Never Cry Wolf". On studying wolves, he did not often see them eat deer and caribou, as thought, but mostly mice. He wondered if it was possible that they subsisted on mice, so he tried it, and found with some surprise that he could.

Schwarz's reading led him to suspect that some very capable woodworkers of the past had worked out of chests, using a limited set of tools, so he tried it. He found, somewhat to his surprise, that he could.

However, I found it interesting to note that one of his earlier tool storage methods, the accessible rack in front of the window, is visible in one of the photos of the chest article.

Neither Schwarz nor Mowat is telling you what to do, but each is giving you something interesting to think about. You will get only part of the story if you read only one article or chapter.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#55

Re: Breaking Bad

TomD

You would enjoy Breaking Bad. It is the story of a humble maker, whose family falls on hard times. In order to bail them out financially, he goes back to the roots of his craft, and becomes successful as a maker of quality. The series follows his ups and downs, and the many people he meets along the way.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#56

Re: Breaking Bad

Pam Niedermayer

Wow, what a humble version. Is it illegal to mention crack online?

I love this show; but it's about a chemistry teacher who has been diagnosed with cancer and needs money to fund his family after his death. So he starts cooking crack. My library has the whole series (seasons 1-3, 4 to be available soon). It's great, and you possibly learn a lot about cooking and chemistry. I say possibly because I don't know squat about cooking crack, so they could send you down wrong paths.

Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#57

Re: Breaking Bad

TomD

That is one of my main questions, how realistic the chemistry premise is. I wonder how difficult it is for a professional to make that stuff, and whether there would really be a substantial intellectual property component for him to leverage. As far as I know he is making Chrystal meth, not crack.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#58

Re: Breaking Bad

TomD

"Wow, what a humble version. Is it illegal to mention crack online?"

I don't know, have to give the security state web crawlers something to do. I was mostly hoping to extent the audience for the show, by making it soon more appealing to people who might not like the whole drug deal gone wrong thing.

But anyway, if that is too harsh, what about the Walking Dead? It's about a family, on a trip across the South, that is forced to face the harsh reality of their aging ancestors, and consider different options for their after-care...

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#59

Re: Breaking Bad

Pam Niedermayer

Chrystal meth? Shows you how up to date I am on the drug industry.

I don't care so much for Walking Dead, kind of thing which makes nightmares. :)

Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#60

Heartily agree. 


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#61

Re: Didn't feel the presumption

kygaloot

Although Chris' toolbox has a certain flexibility in its design, I always wonder what happens when you need to add tools that won't fit? Build another toolbox, I guess.

The point is that if that is probable, I like the idea of building a series of smaller toolboxes, like yours Pam, which would seem have the advantage of being portable when required.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#62

Re: Didn't feel the presumption

Pam Niedermayer

Yes, those little ones take no time to build and no real effort to move; although they're more suited for eastern style tools, and I am thinking of adding luggage wheels to a bigger one I use now and then.

Even though I don't think Chris is being presumptuous, I do think toolchests are kind of a waste of time to build, for me. But then I also don't build wall cabinets for tool holding, too much work rearranging and updating for a new tool. Floor cabinets are nice since they can hold tools and serve as work stations, as are sets of small drawers for chisels, as are magnetic strips for saws, etc.

It sure is fun to think about this stuff.

Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#63

Re: Heartily agree.

Michael Brady

I agree that this has been a good discussion that helped open my mind a bit on the topic of tool chests. Method of work seems to be the operative theme, and if you consider the case of author Chris Schwarz, he definitely has to get his tools to numerous teaching locations throughout the year in a safe and orderly fashion. Thus, a tool chest makes perfect sense for him. Personally, I rarely take good tools out of my shop, and would definitely not want to work out of a box. Co-mingling of sharp tools in trays seems odd to me.

From his standpoint, he needs to have a "hook" to hang his hat on to keep his audience engaged. When exploring a topic as arcane as hand tool woodworking, one has to largely look to the past for inspiring topics. It was benches for awhile, now chests; and still something else in the future. Take from it what you will.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#64

Re: Tool Trays

Guillaume Dery

Ok, so here is a question for all of you tool tray users out there and the one thing which has prevented me from adding a tool tray to any of the benches I have built (I can always use more room to spread my mess to!)

How do you deal with flattening the bench?? It would seem to me that keeping what is essentially 2 separate slabs not only flat but perfectly coplanar would give me fits. Flat I can do no problem. It is the second part of the equation which has always given me pause

Inquiring minds... yadda, yadda, yadda...

Guillaume

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#65

Re: Tool Trays

roger lance

I have to assume that you are speaking of benches that are divided by a tool tray....otherwise, I don't understand your premise of having two separate slabs that must be kept flat and perfectly coplanar. I am not a fan of such designs because of the issues that you mention. But a bench with a tool tray in the rear of the top is flattened in the same manner as a bench without a tray....planed flat...checked with a straight edge....winding sticks....etc....etc....???

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#66

If you are considering having a tool tray....

roger lance

there is a very personal question you should ask yourself (and I intend no offense here...but I find this to be true)....ask yourself if you are a bit of a disorganized slob or are you a little anal about organization/cleaning. If you are a little casual about letting things pile up, don't have a tool tray. If you have some inner compulsion to put things back in their place, consider a tray.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#67

You can always insert wood to bridge the gap.


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#68

Re: Tool Trays

Bob Lang

So far on mine it hasn't been a big deal, but I machined each half of the two half tops by running over a 6" joiner and through a lunch box planer before gluing them together. After a careful glue up, a few minutes with a jack plane to level the glue joint on the bottom and another trip through the planer left both sides flat and the same size. Throw me out of the hand tool forum if you like, but that's what I did.

Since then, I've taken my jack and smoother to the tops about once a year, usually before the bench makes a public appearance so no one will know what a complete slob I am, and what poor care I take of my bench. Maybe I've been lucky, but there hasn't been any significant movement to deal with. I check with a level bridging the gap every now and then, but it's been fine. If I did find a difference worth dealing with, I don't see how the gap between the tops is a problem. The other half is only a few inches away to use as a reference.

If I felt the need to plane on both sides at once, I would unbolt one side (4 lag screws to remove), slide it over across the gap and clamp it to the other side. Then I'd have one top to plane and fuss over to my heart's content. The base is solid and sits level, so as long as the top halves stay straight there aren't any problems with coplanarity.

Bob Lang

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#69

Re: If you are considering having a tool tray....

Guillaume Dery

Hi, answer to both of your replies below.

Yes I meant the tool tray in the middle which divides the bench into 2 slabs. Tool tray in the rear makes sense from a flattening perspective. I haven't used a tool tray in benches so far. Were I to do something, I would probably tend towards a slot block attached to the rear in which I could drop chisels, marking gauge, dovetail saw, etc.

As far as to my neatness... consider me bipolar. I vary between the 2. I have my periodic neatnik fits in which everything in the shop gets organized... place for everything and everything in it's place. I usually go nuts and rearrange for optimal work flow. This lasts a few weeks then I start building something and my inner slob comes out. Tools left where last used, sometimes hiding under piles of shavings...

A quick shove to make room on your bench and oops, there goes a chisel on the concrete floor...

Time to reorganize and tidy, return to step 1.

Don't ask me how many duplicate tools I have accumulated over the years because I couldn't find the tool I was looking for...

So, like I said, slightly bipolar in that department

Cheers,

Guillaume

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#70

Re: Tool Trays

Guillaume Dery

That makes sense. An argument in favor of knockdown benches.

I am not about to throw you out of the hand tool brigade either for machining the tops. 4 squaring rough lumber by hand is not my idea of a good time.

I am a hybrid woodworker but quickly transitioning towards the hand-tool only side. Apart from my traditionalist tendencies and the personal challenge, this is mostly driven by the fact that my shop assistant is 19 months old and weighs 30 pounds. I like the idea of being able to have her in the shop without worrying and to be able to work when she is sleeping.


cheers,

Guillaume (and Marguerite)

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#71

Besides being slightly bipolar (perhaps)....

roger lance

you are a lucky man....she is adorable....God bless.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#72

Re: Tool Trays

roger lance

Bob....glad you joined in as I should have also stated that I did not have any real experience working long term with a split top bench and as far as throwing you out for using power tools, no survey has been done here that I know about but a very high number of people here are "blended" woodworkers....you are among friends.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#73

Now THAT's a gloat if I ever saw one

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A very cute galoot in training.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#74

Re: Now THAT's a gloat if I ever saw one

Guillaume Dery

It was a gloat.

Right now I am shell-shocked however.

I just found out 5 minutes ago that I have 2 more galoots in training on the way!!!

Egads! Time to start making cribs and shop for a mini-van

Cheers,

Guillaume

(who is looking decidedly paler right about now)

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#75

Congratulations times two

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What you'll find is each child brings you a new kind of joy (well, and new challenges, too - it's like they test which buttons the older kids didn't find to push). You'll have fun.