We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
To say "this is the right way" and then to say "disobey me" is senseless and indicative of an ill formed philosophical concept based more on the need to have the last word than to impart a lesson.
There is no one way to build a tool chest, traditional or otherwise. There is no one way to store tools. How you store them, how you use them is dependent entirely upon your workspace, the kind of work you do, the work traditions you might or might not follow, what your employer might tell you what to do or what your teacher taught you. To attempt to define the perfect tool storage unit, much less the perfect set of tools, is more indicative of a need to control an environment than it is of a desire to expand knowledge.
The article was discussing a traditional tool chest. It's a design that is ubiquitous. An overriding theme that Chris Schwartz has pursued is the examination of the traditional. This is done in that context. I don't find it presumptuous. I loved the article and have been researching myself to build my own. I picked up some good info from the article. Obviously others' mileage has varied considerably.
I don't know that much about Ian but Frank K., who is an advocate of tool trays on benches, caught a little criticism when tool trays were called the dumbest thing I've ever seen on a bench....that would be the "dumbest" thing this week....next week, who knows ....at least Frank was not the inventor of tool trays....that honor belongs to someone a couple of hundred years ago....funny how some dumb ideas hang on.
It has occurred to me, thinking about tool trays in the past, that their main virtue may be that they prevent tools rolling off the bench and hitting the floor.
In a shop setting such as the one Chris Schwarz pictures, in which you pull the day's tools from your toolbox and set them about the bench (and, one presumes, reverse the process at night), they might make a lot of sense.
In which case, they're stupid only out of context.
I've never understood the controversy over tool trays....all it takes is a board sized to the dimension of the tray and back beveled to fit tray ramps, if there are any, and attach a couple of blocks to the bottom of the board to bring the board level with the bench top....drill a couple of finger holes in the board....one at each end....put a couple of nails in your ceiling joist to hang/store the board (use the same finger holes for the nails)....and this non-problem is solved.
I have two old tool chests and they hold tools. So do the walls. So does the tray on the back of the bench. So does the top of the bench at times. So do a couple of three old metal tool boxes. So does an old Gertsner pattern makers tool chest. Point is, this whole rigamarole about there being a basic set of tools that fits in a so called traditional tool chest is simply not true. There is a particular type of tool chest that was used more than others by particular trades but there are as many other variations used depending upon trade and geography. In 40 years of seeing this stuff I can attest to this fact. You also can't go by books unless you tell me what books you referenced. The majority of the 19th C books that discuss tool chests were written by and for manual arts education and/or avocational pursuits. Those few journals that were written by and for tradesman were written for carpenters and so discussed the needs of the mobile carpenter.
There are variations on containers for traveling carpenters, sedentary carpenters, millwrights, patternmakers, pianomakers, furnituremakers, housewrights and so on and that's just addressing the British/US variety.
If you want to make a 'traditional' tool chest, more power to you. If you want to own only those tools that will fit in it, best of luck. But why limit yourself when the point of social anarchy is to free yourself of artificial limits and follow your chosen path? I don't get the logic there.
BTW, Franz Klauz approach is to say, this is how I do it and it's up to you if you want to do it this way.
Ian Kirby says, this is the right way to do it and you should do it this way.
The thing about tool trays is whether you have them. If you do, they make perfect sense. If you don't, then they're the dumbest thing ever invented and your opinion constitutes natural law.
I have one on my bench. I like it. I use it. It gathers a boat-load of crap. It mostly works pretty well, which means that when I need to put something wide on it, I can just shove stuff into the tray. Let's see: Tage Frid, Frank Klausz. I must be in pretty good company.
I'm not blessed with a lot of room. And with a shop the size of Bill's I need to use every square inch there is.
Point is, this whole rigamarole about there being a basic set of tools that fits in a so called traditional tool chest is simply not true.
Gary, take another look at the Seaton chest inventory. This is a lavish set of tools for a cabinetmaker, housed in one chest. More than this is unnecessary and any more would be a burden to maintain.
It could well be that 18th century cabinetmakers did not work out of chests. I don't recall chests in Diderot or Roubo workshop drawings. However a chest size kit of tools is consistent with Nicholson's descriptions.
"Gary, take another look at the Seaton chest inventory. This is a lavish set of tools for a cabinetmaker, housed in one chest. More than this is unnecessary and any more would be a burden to maintain."
In this same issue we have Adam telling us that we don't own enough chisels.
My understanding (which really could use more investigation) is that The English craftsman used Chests. The Continental Europeans wall Cabinets.
Wall cabinets require walls. Chests can be anywhere in the shop, near the workbench, but require bending down.
Chests are easier to move. Easier to steal. You can close the lid of your workbench and have lunch.
The key thing in my opinion is that you should be able to reach in a grab any tool with only one hand. That means being able to open the cabinet/chest, unhook, unlatch or disentangle any tool with one hand. The reason for the one hand is that the other hand might be already holding another tool you also need.
A master craftsman - owning a business would have to own far more tools than a journeyman because the master was responsible for the specialty tools.
You can take Chris's list or leave it. I don't agree with everything in the book, you might or might not. Certainly it's a great informed starting point of a solid good kit of tools with which you can make tons of stuff.
I haven't read the article but I can't understand why anyone would do that. my toolbox is at the end of my bench. it is a trivial matter by design to get the tool I need in and out of the box. what advantage would there be in staging my saws outside the toolbox? more chance of them getting dinged, and takes up more space.
It sounds like you did not see the inventory, Bill. There are 48 chisels in the chest, one reason I called it a lavish set of tools. I think Adam would like the idea that there are chisels in sizes like 3/32 and 5/32. There are eight mortise chisels from 1/8 to 1/2. There are seven socket chisels, which Nicholson suggested for carpenters. Maybe they were loaners.
Ah, the danger of assumptions. All the Seaton chest tells us is that this is what the chests contained. It does not tell us what else Seaton might have used or needed in daily work.
Joel makes some salient points on the nature of societal differences between work preferences. There is also the importance of not taking as pure truth any one existing chest, cabinet, tool set, etc. unless you attempt to take what is known and not known of the entire work space into account. And that's the problem. We only know bits and pieces often garnered from estate lists or from tool chests that have survived but neither tell us what was used in daily work with certainty. We can interpret with skill but to say there is a basic set of tools and that's all you need is bupkis.
Adam's article, as Joel points out, is spot on. You can infer the early crafts worker depended on chisels more than today's worker does. So where is there room in these chests for the multitude of chisels?
Within a month or so I'll have a new sub section on my primary site with a bunch of vintage photographs of shops and people with their tool chests and cabinets and totes. I'll also add what I have on texts on the same. Original resources are always the best. I'm not doing this to prove anything. A bunch of this stuff was online way before this whole discussion started.
On Saturday the 5th of April, 1755 Gentleman's Magazine reported:
"A fire broke out a the workshop of Mr. Chippendale, a cabinet maker near St. Martin's Lane, which consumed the same, werein were the chests of 22 workmen."
I had exactly the same observation! (But I do enjoy a little "discussion" now and again.)
I read the book and only skimmed the article, but the book does indeed begin the way Megan mentions. Chris seems to go to pains to say this is the way he does something, and these are the reasons, but he then adds that this works for him: your results may vary (and should!). My take on the book was that he likes his tool chest for the reasons stated, and he'd encourage anyone to take an open minded look at it, or at least at the concept it represents, but then go and do what works for you. As someone already said, it's only a tool chest. I tend to think things through before I build any shop furniture, but I always build the next one differently, sometimes drastically so, because of the experience gained from the existing piece. Seemed good at the time... I suspect the tool chest will work out like the work benches have for Chris: always a different version to build and try, and eventually some sort of synthesis will happen between the work he is doing at that particular time and the method for storing and accessing his tools. My 2 cents worth.
As you say it is confusing when someone demands that you use the only one of 15 designs...
"Adam's article, as Joel points out, is spot on. You can infer the early crafts worker depended on chisels more than today's worker does. So where is there room in these chests for the multitude of chisels?"
I'm also having trouble with the idea that Adam is right about all the chisels, but also I suppose right in the piece on the chests. I have like 100 chisels and wall racks, so I get where I am coming from.
It's also a problem of confusing British traditions and American traditions. One is based on a small island nation and one on an expanding set of colonies spread over a wide geographic area with a variety of social influences.
I have a walnut and rosewood shipwrights chest from the north shore of Massachusetts. Everything looks the same as the one Chris designed except there is a three inch wide till built front to back along the right hand side of the chest at full depth to hold the heavy chisels of the shipwright. I've seen this design before and it makes sense for that trade. Also, the lid is made up of two heavy raised rosewood panels let into walnut frames. This lid is strong enough to do some serious work on if needs be. The entire chest weighs a ton even empty.
I have another tool chest, poplar, with apple sliding trays and a saw till, this one just like the one depicted in PWW. Yellow and black milk paint. The lid has a fall down flap inside to hold plans. Heavy iron handles are bolted to the sides and there are iron wheels on the oak bottom. There is a carved in stamp under the lid noting a date of 1901 for the death of a baby. When purchased at an estate sale, this chest was full to the brim with timber framing equipment and nothing else. It hadn't been touched in who knows how many years and took five trips to unpack and move it. This was a working chest yet I cannot imagine anyone moving this on a regular basis. I can see the owner unpacking it, moving it to the job site, repacking it and securing it for the duration of the job while he lived and worked on site, then going through the routine again to bring it back home. We estimated over 500 lbs full at the minimum. If that was lifted full, the bottom would fall out as it was just nailed in with cut nails. So what was it used for? My guess is job site security. The worker brought the tools to the job site separately and stored them in the tool chest while there.
What we don't know about on site work exceeds what we do know. What we know from books has to be tempered by who wrote the book and for what audience that book was written.
Yes, I was aware of the Chippendale workmen's chests. From many sources it seems that there were three categories of tools in shops that had a master and his workmen. I think these categories certainly varied over time and place.
1. Tools provided by the master for each workman: like a bench, bench planes, maybe holdfast, chisels. We often see inventories with multiple sets of bench planes.
2. Tools provided by the master that were shared: like glue pot, veneer saw, rip saw. Inventories do not have the same multiples of these as bench planes.
3. Tools provided by the craftsman. There is certainly evidence of this, but there are also references to tools that journeymen were forbidden to own in some times and places.
What is unclear to me is if many 18th century cabinetmakers or joiners worked out of large chest like that being discussed. Many drawings and paintings show bench planes on a shelf across the lower rails of the bench. Nicholson mentions this shelf and also a "locker" under the bench top, "for the convenience of putting things out of the way".
"Certainly it's a great informed starting point of a solid good kit of tools with which you can make tons of stuff. "
I couldn't make furniture with what would be in his chest, nor kitchen cabinets, house trim or farm gates, nor could most other woodworkers make what they make. I need a table saw, thickness planer, jointer, drill press and cordless drill for these tasks. My point was that without Chris informing the reader (in the magazine article) what and how he makes stuff the reader can not critically evaluate the attributes of a chest for their work.
I am willing to accept that a tool chest may be the best way to make a table with only hand tools for the small number of people disposed to do it that way. But how does a chest fit into the work of a modern shop that needs a place for a cordless drill, router bits......etc.? If Chris uses a router and makes furniture (for example) then I am willing to consider a chest. If he strives to be Period Correct then his style is so foreign to mine that a chest is likely irrelevant. I didn't see any machinery in the picture backgrounds, but I did see modern clamps and Titebond. These are the only clues I have and they are conflicting. The issue is I don't know where in the spectrum of woodworking activities Chris fits so I can't critically evaluate his proposal.
Even though you're very funny, just in case anyone takes this seriously, here's what I would ask (as if you asked, actually, but there you go, you put it out there and anyone or no one can respond).
1. Since I've never stolen anything with success, I'd like a price for these things that more accurately reflects the $0.02 material content.
Like you I would never think about stealing anything. Just think of it as "Long term borrowing". Them dairyies got plenty of `em and don`t miss a dozen or so if you don`t "borrow" them all at once
2. Fitted tops so that only dust, dirt, and water blown in on a side wind can infect the contents; although it's good they don't hold water or dirt.
Plywood from the dump works great here and if you shove 2 of the crates close enough you can make a cool bench big enough for you,your buddy,both your lunch pails and the shop dog too. I like to make my tops so that everything fitted on `em.
3. Larger, much larger, to fit some of my bigger tools. Just don't love the idea of poking my arms or other body part with jutting chisel edges, or other plastic containers for that matter, what with all that stacking.
See combined answer below
4. Modifiable structure so I could build in dividers, tills, and saw mounts.
These things can be run thru the your Sears brand tablesaw no problem and then take the leftover dump plywood to make longer sides,dividers,whelping boxes for the shop dog,etc.\, easy peasy.
Both them and the ply cut a ton easier than salvaged oak boards. I always cut the crates first so the residual plastic acts to lubricate the blade,this helps cut the dump ply. You may want to open a few windows and get some cross ventilation to help keep the smoke down to a point where you can see your line though.
5. Last, but not least, I'd like something that rots before the sun blows up and doesn't trap fish and birds on their necks, gills, legs, etc.
No problem,When I don`t need them anymore I throw the crates (the modified crates too) into a bonfire and the fire burns them and the dump ply up real quick.
Later after the fire goes out and things have cooled down I sift thru the ashes and retrieve the nails so my son can straighten them and then I shovel up the ashes and dump them on the neighbor`s property when he ain`t around. On the way back I "long term borrow" a wheelbarrow load of gravel from the neighbor`s driveway to reline my fire pit.
That wheelbarrow I "borrowed" from him last year sure comes in handy for stuff like this.
of the tools that you list that you say you need I only own a cordless drill. I found that with my toolbox just containing the tools I needed, not everything I own, I spent far far less time looking for tools, maintaining tools, and more time working. However it wasn't possible to easily work plywood and other sheet goods, and like any fully equipped shop my tool box contained the tools I regularly use, so I do have a circular saw which I keep elsewhere.
As for Chris not tell in the article what he builds he has been writing about his projects long enough so anyone even remotely following Pop Wood would have a pretty good sense of where he stands. Should have have talked about that anyway, maybe but at worst it's an editorial omission and doesn't compromise the basic positive lessons of the article.
if by Joel you mean me, where did I comment on Adam's article. I just got the magazine and haven't read the article yet. so I have no opinon either way at the moment.
We keep all our stuff in a box. We do that to keep others from borrowing our stuff without our knowledge.
That box is stout enough to be either lifted on board the boat by the crane or carried on board by you and your co-workers. We set our box down where it`s easy to get to,out of the way and out of the weather.
When going from our boxes to the job on any particular day some of us use tool bags and some of us use tool trays. either way the bag or the tray gets lifted out of the box,loaded with the tools we know we`ll need and then the bag/tray and the tools they contain get carried to the place where we will be working. At the end of the day we put the tools back into what we used to carry them to the job and carry our tools back to the box,put them in the box,close the box and lock our tools up.
This process has been going on for generations in shipyards and boatyards all around the world and across numerous trades/skills/crafts using everything from wire,steel,wood,pipe,rigging,welding etc 24/7 all year long regardless of location,season or type of project.
The only folks who have lockers and tables to work out of, or on, are the bosses and they keep their street clothes and paperwork in the lockers and when they take their stuff out of their lockers they lay it on the tables.
We build entire vessels that range from yachts to war ships this way and some of the furniture on these boats puts furniture I`ve seen in museums to shame.
Workmen and craftsmen, regardless of trade, work out of boxes. Sometimes that box is the size of a briefcase, other times it`s big enough to fit you and several of your buddies and all the tools you`ll ever need into it and the person who owns it chooses to call it a shop.
Something with your tools in it that has sides, top, bottom and a way to get into it and secure it = a box. At least in my neck of the woods it does.
There`s obviously a lot of room to move around and modify to suit in that definition and boat builders have found it very accommodating. That`s why we`ve stuck with it for centuries.
Still, though, Bill: any woodworker - any maker - works within a system of tools, procedures, workspace. Every introductory course in systems theory boggles student minds with the questions of system boundaries and where you begin in describing a system. Explaining the whole system every time would make for encyclopedically long articles.
I agree that it would have been better for Chris to have given a one-paragraph contextual setting for why - for him - the traditional chest is the best solution; and I continue a little irritated by his assumption (pointing up to my earlier post) that we all work in shops large enough to have two points of storage (long-term and course-of-the-day) for things like saws and bench planes. But he did have to be somewhat selective in describing AN element of the system within which he works.
Bob Hackett has made the point that shipwrights use boxes similar in (at least general) concept to the box Chris describes, and certainly every carpenter I've ever seen working on a house follows similar practices. In a commercial shop, where you'd want your tools secured and out of harm's way when not using them, a storage box makes sense, just as it does for the auto mechanic*. Whether that makes sense for the guy/gal working in his/her home shop depends, I think, on that guy/gal's working system (including the propensity of children or others to borrow tools**).
The direction I hope to go, if the round tuit inventory increases, is an open, wall-mounted till for saw storage - nothing novel there - and a cabinet with drawers, somewhat like a mechanic's rollaway but designed around woodworking tool sizes, for planes, chisels, scraping tools, and layout tools (hammers and such will go on the wall). This will allow me to store tools in as small a footprint as possible - in my small shop, that's a major element of the system. But, now that the kids are out in the world, I don't need to worry about tool evaporation.
One thing I do appreciate about Chris' articles on workbenches and, now, tool storage, is that he discusses the why of things. He was, in my judgment, a bit prescriptive about the choice of storage device; but, having tendered that prescription, he then talks in great detail about the functional elements of the design.
*If you want to see elaborately developed tool storage, look at the Snap-On catalogue, and consider the fact that mechanics pay more for a box to hold their tools than most of us would ever pay for a high-end table saw.
**My older son said to me once that he figured any of my tools were his tools, too. This may explain why I hid some of my favorites under the bed until both boys moved out of the house.