I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous
Bill Tindall
For some reason I appear to be the last in the nation to get my issue of Popular Woodworking. Maybe my rural carrier enjoys reading it first. Anyway.......
It strikes me as presumptuous to claim that your this or that kind of chest, bench, vice etc. is best without describing in detail what kind of work you do and your preferences for doing the work. What is unfortunate is that persons beginning a woodworking career don't have the experience to evaluate claims of best and they waste time and money pursuing the confident recommendations of experts when the stuff being made and the techniques to make it can be widely divergent between the two woodworkers.
To take the case of a vise , I have enough experience to know without any doubt that anything other than a quick release metal vice is not best for my work, and by example, a lot of other's work too. I used to work some in another persons shop and I was driven to consider slitting my wrists with a plane iron in exasperation from slowly cranking his wood screw vice in and out. I could not care whether it held 5% more secure when it took 9 time longer to get there. One day in a fit of frustration I asked him why he didn't buy a decent vise. It turned out he owned a quick release vice but lent it to someone else because he read how this archaic vice was so much better (at something I suppose). Soon after, he retrieved the quick release and it has been on the bench ever since, presumably because he found it better than the alternative.
I don't have any quibble about what influential woodworkers choose to promote, but they would be more effective and in the end more credible if they state what they actually built, and how, with this or that bench, chest, vice, saw, or what-have-you so we could better judge how the recommendation fit what we build, and how we choose to build.
To make another example, a visiting master craftsman made a comment about what he clearly thought was my extravagant clamp collection. (These sorts of people tend to think that novices have too many tools, and they can be right.) In his shop he builds one piece of complex furniture at time. At times I have had 6 stair treads, or other panels, in clamps, and 6 more later in the day. It would be absurd for me to offer a recommendation of how many clamps he needed, and vice versa, in spite of his expertise.







