New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

Posts

I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#1

I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

Bill Tindall

For some reason I appear to be the last in the nation to get my issue of Popular Woodworking. Maybe my rural carrier enjoys reading it first. Anyway.......

It strikes me as presumptuous to claim that your this or that kind of chest, bench, vice etc. is best without describing in detail what kind of work you do and your preferences for doing the work. What is unfortunate is that persons beginning a woodworking career don't have the experience to evaluate claims of best and they waste time and money pursuing the confident recommendations of experts when the stuff being made and the techniques to make it can be widely divergent between the two woodworkers.

To take the case of a vise , I have enough experience to know without any doubt that anything other than a quick release metal vice is not best for my work, and by example, a lot of other's work too. I used to work some in another persons shop and I was driven to consider slitting my wrists with a plane iron in exasperation from slowly cranking his wood screw vice in and out. I could not care whether it held 5% more secure when it took 9 time longer to get there. One day in a fit of frustration I asked him why he didn't buy a decent vise. It turned out he owned a quick release vice but lent it to someone else because he read how this archaic vice was so much better (at something I suppose). Soon after, he retrieved the quick release and it has been on the bench ever since, presumably because he found it better than the alternative.

I don't have any quibble about what influential woodworkers choose to promote, but they would be more effective and in the end more credible if they state what they actually built, and how, with this or that bench, chest, vice, saw, or what-have-you so we could better judge how the recommendation fit what we build, and how we choose to build.

To make another example, a visiting master craftsman made a comment about what he clearly thought was my extravagant clamp collection. (These sorts of people tend to think that novices have too many tools, and they can be right.) In his shop he builds one piece of complex furniture at time. At times I have had 6 stair treads, or other panels, in clamps, and 6 more later in the day. It would be absurd for me to offer a recommendation of how many clamps he needed, and vice versa, in spite of his expertise.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#2

What do we really need?

Bob Hackett

I think the key to chasing anything we intend to be passionate about in this life is being able to discern the difference between a master and a huckster.

Once someone has been awarded the title of "master of XXX craft" (and don`t get me going on who decides this or how) they many times come under pressure to take that shingle down off their door and take their show out on the road. Once that show has gained a wider audience then those same "masters" are again pressed to begin endorsing either a certain line or type of tool or techniques that lead their audience toward a method of work that requires either more skills or more tools in order to perpetuate the interest in them personally and stimulate sales for their managers, promoters or sponsors.

I have a friend who is internationally known and produces works that can sell for over $10,000 and still be held in your hands. He produces this work in a shop the size of a one car garage. The really ironic part of this is that most people would consider the heart of his shop to be a top of the line lathe that he has over $10,000 dollars invested in. What makes this ironic is, that huge investment and "heart of the shop" rarely gets used anymore and he could just as easily get by with something that cost 1/10th the investment or less.

The tools he uses most and his work pivots on on all cost less than $500 and like his work can be held in your hands,most of them in one hand.

The heart of any shop and the things that impose limits on a craftsman are not what you hold in your hands but what you hold in your head.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#3

My New Shop

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

After recently moving I have nearly completed building my new workshop. I am still in the process of setting it up. Already having the tools, the challenge I find is contemplating how I work and applying that to the arrangement of the shop and location of certain tools. So far, so good. But I have a feeling that after I get a couple of projects under my belt a few things will require relocation.

Over the years I have seen magazine articles about "perfect workshops" or the like. They are usually quite tidy and beautiful places. They are also places that would be dysfunctional for me.

All the bloviations about "tool philosophy" or workshop ideals don't amount to a pile of sawdust to me. If someone wants a trophy workshop then I say more power to them. But I have a living to make, clients to satisfy and hopefully in that mix be able to enjoy the journey with an occassional Zen experience.

So the design of my shop and the choice of my tools are unique to me and best help me achieve my goals and what I produce. What anybody else thinks is irrelevant.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#4

Moses Yoder

Nothing

Moses Yoder

All we need to survive is food, water, and shelter. We could live very easily in a cave near a small river close to the equator. We could break off a sapling, sharpen it with a rock, and spear fish. We would drink the water out of the river. I really don't undertand why people wear clothes in the first place, other than protection against cold. So we really don't need anything. The only reason we accumulate things is to show them off to other people, thinking that wealth equals intelligence.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#5

difficult issue

roninkokomo

Most woodworking mags sell because they sell the fact that the writers know more than the readers. Makes a certain kid of elemental sense... even if we know that reality is sometimes quite different.

Bill, is of course correct, but the magazines might be perceived differently if the authors messages was "do what works for you"

Ron

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#6

Perhaps we should be including with....

roger lance

our postings things like IMHO or IME to indicate that the opinion we are giving is not an absolute but only a view point or method we have currently and your experience/view point may differ and be valid. A person who has a lot of experience and skill gained those things thru a lot of effort and it is only natural that they may want some recognition of their accomplishment/status. But making statements that this tool, bench, shop organization, method, furniture style or what-have-you is THE way to do things is untrue and potentially misleading. On other forums, I have noticed an interest in bench building and almost without exception all these people are making Roubo benches....which is fine with me but it is being done because of the current popularity given to this design by a book....and there is little to no discussion of other types of benches or their features. The current "expert" says such and such and people respond. One of the nice things about woodworking is that there are many ways to accomplish a task....pick one....master that way....talk about it....show other people....but don't discount other approaches. Bill, you might not be the last guy in America to get your copy of Popular Woodworking....I sent them a check a number of weeks ago which they cashed but no magazine !!??

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#7

what is a master?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

When people refer to someone as a master of something I think many of them lack an understanding of the true meaning of the word and the process that one becomes a master at something.

In a traditional apprentice ship of 4 or 5 years a person would finish out as a journeyman. This is usually understood to mean a person who is fully trained and competent in their craft, which is actually not what it means to be a journeyman. As an apprentice you would work at one shop with a master and when you were turned out as a journeyman you were literally turned out, or let go from that shop and from then on you made a living traveling from one shop to the next as work warranted. This allowed one to learn from more than one master as well as to do many different types of work since shops often specialized. The basics of a craft are learned as an apprentice but you really learned more as a journeyman about the craft then as an apprentice. Some trades had projects or tests that one completed to become a master and some were more based on time spent as a journeyman.

I was trained by a bit of an old school craftsman. When I completed my four year apprenticeship as a patternmaker I received a pink slip and then spent the next couple of years traveling from shop to shop in the area until I eventually opened my own shop, and since have drifted from patternmaking to furniture.

Somewhere along the way people started referring to me as a master woodworker. I might be inclined to believe them if I thought they understood the true meaning of the word. My old boss used to tell me that everyone makes mistakes, the difference between an apprentice and a master is that a master catches their mistakes and quickly and efficiently fixes them. Well I am still making mistakes and I am pretty good at catching them but I am still working on the quickly and efficiently part.

Robin

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#8

disclaimer and clarification called for ......

Bill Tindall

To be clear, my point was that persons advocating this or that, especially authorities advocating this or that, should qualify their recommendations by what they make and their philosophy of making(ie., how they use the recommendation).

I have no objection to authorities, authors, experts, master craftsmen, and the like, or their recommendations, if they are properly qualified by application. Bit if I am told that working out of a trunk is best I would like to know what work is done from the trunk to best judge if it is best for me.

I think troughs in a bench are the dumbest idea I ever seen on a bench(qualified by my kind of work), but they must have effective application for some. I had thought that drilling holes in a bench was similarly misguided until my style of woodworking changed and I discovered the handiness of bench dogs.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#9

agree with all plus holdfasts!!


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#10

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

TomD

I think it is a little unfair to attack Chris on this front.

First, who has written, or published more on woodworking in the last 5 years. I doubt I have read 1% of it, but I still think I have the gist of where he is going with his stuff. I doubt people will think he is recommending techniques for laminate counter top production.

Second, I just came back from Lee Valley where I happened to pick up a recent book of his. One Chapter was something like "15 designs for a tool chest". So just whose arm is he twisting with this stuff?

Third, in my first retail job, I remember the manager pointing out that people want to buy stuff. As a bunch of impoverished university students in sales, one of the problems they had was that we were all backing away from selling people stuff. At LV today I also saw the Fein line of tools that contains some tools that are 10 x more expensive than need be. But cha know, for some people that is pocket change. They want someone to come along and provide them with a consumption template. That's what it is about, people want to know what to buy, they are looking for an outlet for their consumerism. Get out of their way. Sure a lot of people will deny it, and for some people it is all about how little they spent, but overall people want to be taken to the overly expensive tools rack, over and over again. They want someone to invent a reason for them to buy more stuff. Probably 75% of the expansion of interest in hand tools comes from the realization that people can be sold more stuff, why stop at a table saw.

Fourth, I am unimpressed by how little stuff pros use to make a living with. Out there there is someone making a living playing the triangle. If your hobby were watching movies you would probably get through more movies in a year than the guy who makes movies - he watches the same movie over and over again, sometimes for years. I want to master the most techniques, and design and make everything.

My youngest daughter asked everyone at the table what their hobbies were. I had more than one, most of them discreet crafts, for every letter of the alphabet, with a few exceptions. I have tools for all that stuff. It's going to be a great estate sale.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#11

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

Mark Salomon

I don't see that Bill "attacked" anyone. What he is reacting to is the presumtousness of one person trying to tell all of us that woodworking nirvana will be found digging around in a floor chest for our tools. Lest you forget, the "rash" that collected on your old tools was most likely due to spending time housed in a chest. I can't imagine that my back could possibly like the stooping that is associated with a floor chest. Also, since I'm now ranting a bit, you can drink the Roubo kool-aid if you want but I'll keep my quick release front vise thank you very much.

People in the magazine business need to either sell us something new or package something old to make us think that it is something new. I don't resent this, it's what sells their magazines. I just keep reminding myself what they're doing and keep it in perspective. So, while it is a bit presumptious to tell everyone that they should put their tools in a floor chest, or build a roubo bench, or use drawboring for fine furniture construction, it's no different than the selling that occurs with all magazines. In case any of you think that I'm somehow slamming Mr. S you are wrong. I believe that no one over the last 5 or 10 years has done more for beginning and intermediate woodworkers than he has. It's been a boon to all of us to share his journey and we've all learned alot along the way. Enough to know that a floor chest is not the thing for me.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#12

Limited perspective, I think

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I just read the article today (got the magazine a day or so before you, I guess, Bill T.). About 2/3 of the way through, Chris Schwarz mentions that, at the beginning of the day, you would pull out the saws and hang them on the wall (presumably near the sawbench) and pull out that day's bench planes and put them on/near the workbench.

Thus, he's proposing a shop model in which there are TWO places to store these commonly used tools. I lack that kind of space in my shoplet; I'm cramming woodworking and the tooling needed to support maintenance of house (I count about six distinct trades) and car into 121 square feet, so my storage needs to be highly space-efficient. To use the terminology of another forum, I lack both the floorium and the wallium to use the toolchest model he advocates. In addition, his toolchest design is storing a lot of air. If/when I get around to improving my woodworking tool storage, the resulting storage will qualify me to apply for an apprenticeship as a sardine packer.

I guess I'm concurring with Bill, from a slightly different point of view: an article like that should start with some context about "this is my shop and why this works for me."

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#13

Turnabout being fair play

wilbur

Hi Bill,

That's a pretty high standard for anyone to meet. What if I applied that standard to your posts here on Woodcentral? I may be off on the exact wording, but I recall that you've stated that your main priorities with your woodworking is to complete as many furniture projects as possible, using professional furniture makers as your standard, and that you don't understand why one would want to get bogged down in process details.

I don't have those priorities, and I happen to like figuring out the details at this point in my woodworking life. Does that mean I should dismiss everything that you post out of hand? That would really dumb of me. I think there is something to be learned from everyone, even if their interests and priorities are quite different from mine.

You should also know that Christopher Schwarz has made quite a few furniture pieces, some for sale, and some that were commissioned. Just because he doesn't write about it for Popular Woodworking Magazine or on his blogs doesn't mean that they don't exist. And I'm sure that if I were writing for a magazine that had Glen Huey and Robert Lang as editors, for me to add project articles would be trying to write on an aspect of woodworking that was already well covered at that publication.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#14

Re:Meh.....

Edward in Vancouver

Finished building the chest. Don'thave timenow to build the trays/till until after christmas.

Three years ago I build myself a "gerstner" style toolchest and had pegboard on the wall. Now I've got shallow shelving for larger tools which just collects lots of sawdust.

It's only a chest, if it doesn't work out, my daughter has "dibs" on it.

It's worth a try, I don't regret building the chest, and am looking forward to working out of a box. Since I usually am "ecologically minded" (read cheap),all lumber is salvaged, so are the hinges. I only forked out for the lock and paint, oh, and the book.....

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#15

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

TomD

Well attack is perhaps not a good word. I like an "argument", and don't expect to see splinters when a family member "attacks" the piano. But I do get that for some with Kumbaya radar there are a lot of words that probably shouldn't be used. Bill regularly brings up these kind of topics the only reason for which seem to be their discussion, since the premise is rarely convincing. I assume we are supposed to jump in with both feet. I thought I was showing restraint not copying Dan Ackroyd's opening salvo to Jane Curtin

I'd dismissed the Roubo bench probably before Chris discovered it, but he does have a knack for connecting with newbies that is quite beyond me.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#16

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

Pam Niedermayer

I'd dismissed the Roubo bench probably before Chris discovered it, but he does have a knack for connecting with newbies that is quite beyond me.

Pretty simple, really, he tells them what can/should be done and how to do it, all lucidly.

Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#17

Didn't feel the presumption

Pam Niedermayer

I didn't feel any presumption in that article (which I just now finished because any topic that lasts two days is of interest, even though I seldom read rags). Chris simply says that chests built in the traditional style are excellent storage devices, and are also very efficient and economical since they limit your tool set to that which you need. Then he proceeds to tell you about the traditional design, why, and how to build it.

Of course, it wouldn't work for me if I needed portability, would never be able to lift it; so I go for the much smaller Japanese toolboxes on the rare occasions I have to move. :)


Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#18

The key word being...

Bob Hackett

Lucid. :D

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#19

Re: Didn't feel the presumption

Bob Hackett

I prefer the "Redneck Tansu", (plastic milk crates).

They`re stackable,the holes let the chips and dust fall right thru while letting you see what`s inside,they never rust,rot or need refinishing and if you go look behind the big grocery stores late at night while they`re stocking the shelves and too busy to chase you,they`re free.

What more could you ask from a tool storage system?

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#20

Color co-ordinated....I presume.


Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#21

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

megan fitzpatrick

For what it's worth, the first words of the foreword of the book from which the article is basically excerpted ("The Anarchist's Tool Chest") are: "Disobey me."

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#22

Ohhh, that one hit home.

Bill Tindall

"go look behind the big grocery stores late at night while they`re stocking the shelves and too busy to chase you,they`re free."


I find them very handy. Note the jumbo"painters pyramids" in use. Available from Lee Valley catalog 88K58.XXXL.

The labels on them bring back memories like pictures from trips.....no further details forthcoming.

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#23

What more could I ask?

Pam Niedermayer

Even though you're very funny, just in case anyone takes this seriously, here's what I would ask (as if you asked, actually, but there you go, you put it out there and anyone or no one can respond). :)

1. Since I've never stolen anything with success, I'd like a price for these things that more accurately reflects the $0.02 material content.

2. Fitted tops so that only dust, dirt, and water blown in on a side wind can infect the contents; although it's good they don't hold water or dirt.

3. Larger, much larger, to fit some of my bigger tools. Just don't love the idea of poking my arms or other body part with jutting chisel edges, or other plastic containers for that matter, what with all that stacking.

4. Modifiable structure so I could build in dividers, tills, and saw mounts.

5. Last, but not least, I'd like something that rots before the sun blows up and doesn't trap fish and birds on their necks, gills, legs, etc.

Pam

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#24

That would be item #  *LINK*


88K58.70

Re: I just got the "Chest Article"-presumptuous

#25

What else would an anarchist say?