New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Fear

Posts

Fear

#1

Fear

Pam Niedermayer

I've seen a lot of accusations of fear here and on sawmill creek the last few months, the latest by Weaver: "However, a western smoother with common pitch, proper sharpening gear and a clean sole can make just about an indistinguishable finish compared to a japanese plane if you're afraid of japanese planes..."

By Larry Williams: "People are afraid of grinders."

By Derek: "People who don't use BU blades are afraid of putting a camber on bevel up blades."

Now when I suggested that such a use was arrogant, offensive, and insulting on sawmill creek, I got kicked off, even though several others pitched in to point out that they saw nothing to be afraid of.

I'd like to know how you all feel about this. Is it a nothing issue? Does it matter to you if someone assumes you're afraid to do something a certain way, vs just not wanting to do so?

In my opinion, it's real hard to have a discussion about technique if the assumption by one party is that the other party is merely afraid; but I can be convinced otherwise if that's how everyone feels.

Pam

Re: Fear

#2

Re: Fear

Chuck Nickerson

If one takes the population and plot each person's willingness to try/change, you'll get a bell curve.

People towards the high end of the curve are not going to understand what 'holds up' people at the low end of the curve. "Why don't they want to learn?"

People at the low end of the curve also don't understand the people at the other end of the curve. "Why don't they just get to work?"

Each end of the bell curve simply can't undertand the motivations of the other end of the bell curve.

Guessing/making up a motivation, and it not being particularly flattering, is human nature. (Politics anyone?)

Re: Fear

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Adding Fear

Stephen Shepherd

Pam,

I have to agree with you, I don't even go to SMC anymore. But I think I can add one more to the fear category.

Most woodworkers fear finishing. Not completing the project but putting a finish on their woodwork. This is real fear.

Stephen

Re: Fear

#4

Re: Fear

wilbur

The way that I see it is that it's not so much the fear issue per se as it is the assigning of a universal explanation for everyone's motivation for making the choice that they do.

Being involved in medical education, I see that there are many reasons why a medical student or resident may not make the best diagnosis for a patient. Sometimes it's a knowledge deficit. Sometimes it's misinterpretation of the data at hand. And sometimes it is fear of what that diagnosis implies, or fear of the quantity or type of work involved once the diagnosis is made. I imagine that there are analogous issues in why people choose the woodworking techniques that they do.

There are many other areas where the assumption of a universal motivation seems to be just plain silly. How many times have you heard this on the news: "On Wall Street, the Dow Jones Industrial Index fell 8 points today as traders reacted to rising oil prices due to increasing tensions in Syria."? As if every trader was only interested in following political news from the Middle East, and conducted their business accordingly.

Re: Fear

#5

Re: Fear

Paul M.

Tablesaws cause me fear. Powered Jointers cause me fear. Shapers cause me fear. These are reasonable and expected causes of fear as this is a healthy source of fear that keeps my fingers attached to my hands. These are the fears that have directed me towards using hand-tools.

But using the word fear to talk about a different bevel angle or a plane you pull instead of push does seem a bit over the top.

Re: Fear

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Adding Fear

Moses Yoder

I am not afraid of finishing. I know I can do it well, brushing, spraying, and rubbing on with a rag. I recently made 2 white oak frames for my wife, and I took them to another shop to finish. Several reasons for it. 1) A deadline. I wondered if I would get them done in time. 2) Setting up and cleaning up a spray gun. These had a combination dye and pigment stain on them, so I wanted conversion varnish over the top. This takes a good bit of time to thin to the right consistency to spray, set up the spray gun, then clean it up. 3) It would have cost me at least $40 for the quart of stain and gallon of varnish (minimum purchase quantities) which I would probably not have used the left over material. The finish would have gone bad before I used it, and the stain is an unusual color. 4) It only cost me $20 to get 2 frames stained and finished.

Re: Fear

#7

Re: Fear

TomD

"I'd like to know how you all feel about this. Is it a nothing issue? Does it matter to you if someone assumes you're afraid to do something a certain way, vs just not wanting to do so? "

I think sometimes it is just words, a thoughtless way of conveying that someone is resistant, for whatever reason. I do think fear plays a part in woodworking, from actual physical fear of stuff that can hurt you, to fear of messing stuff up, to fear of getting in too deep, to perfectionism, to fear of being perceived as insuficiently practical (too arty), fear of being rejected by pals who are going in a direction like say table saws, etc... So it is probably there. But yeah, it is bad maners to suggest the motives of others, and it is also likely to be incorrectly judged, so people ought to be afraid of getting stuff really wrong. I've seen you work, and even at that a long time ago, so I think I have some sense that you have real skill, and therefore probably weren't too scared to get to that point, but others may make other snap judgements.

Is the a link to the dust up that led to your untimely departure form SMC.

Re: Fear

#8

Re: Fear

TomD

That whole thing with the stock market is a classic, let's match up the headlines. I remember seeing similar headlines in Canada when the real reason for the drop was some technical issue like repatriation of profits to foreign owners, part of a monthly cycle.

Re: Fear

#9

Moses Yoder

Re: Fear

Moses Yoder

I think you are assuming a lot when you assume that someone actually thinks a person is afraid of something just because that is what they say. The actual reason for their statement is probably a negative motivation strategy to get people to do what they want them to. In "Back to the Future" when that hillbilly with the big truck calls Michael J. Fox a chicken, he knows he's not chicken. Before Michael knows the outcome of this reaction, he stomps on the gas to race the hillbilly and ends up killing someone. He was motivated to ruin his entire life simply because someone called him "chicken" and he didn't want to be seen as a chicken.

If fear were a detrimental emotion, it seems like after millions of years of evolution it would have been weeded out. I'm going to continue to do things as I see fit, and if someone wants to call me chicken, I am not about to cut my hand off for them.

Re: Fear

#10

Re: Fear

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Pam, I suspect you favor dialectical discussion and unfortunately few people even know what that is, let alone are capable of practicing it. Instead we are left with good old debate and just as it did when we were in the 6th grade it often ends with perjoratives rather than a winner.

Robin

Re: Fear

#11

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Guessing/making up a motivation, and it not being particularly flattering, is human nature. (Politics anyone?)

I guess you're right; but it took me about 10 minutes as a kid to realize that attributing motivation usually resulted in a wrong attribution, therefore was a waste of time.

Pam

Re: Fear

#12

Re: Adding Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Most woodworkers fear finishing. Not completing the project but putting a finish on their woodwork. This is real fear.

I love it, Stephen. I think you're wrong, of course, after all, it's just wood.

Pam, who just started reading your Hide Glue book, very, very cool

Re: Fear

#13

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, economics and finance are chock full of faulty assumptions. In addition to sell off/buy reasons, there are the perfect knowledge participants in a perfect market. My BA was in Econ, but I never wanted to work in Econ because of all the obviously faulty assumptions. However, that was the wrong response. I should have gone in and made cases for corrections and become a famous economist. :)

Pam

Re: Fear

#14

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Good points. I think the problem with debating is that there are winners and losers, nothing in between.

Pam

Re: Fear

#15

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Paul, I, too, admit to the presence of fear when faced with rapidly spinning power tools, but not enough to stop me from using these tools.

Pam

Re: Fear

#16

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

And then there's the stranger in a white car we encountered as we drove across southern Louisiana a few weeks ago. Seems he wanted to play chicken without even asking us first. Fortunately there was enough of a shoulder so we could get out of the way. Now that was fear.

Pam

Re: Fear

#17

Re: Fear

Pam Niedermayer

Hmmmm, OK, so it's OK to think of fear but bad manners to assume it out loud. I can buy that.

But I'll also note that I wouldn't have had those skills, thank you very much, without trying stuff first; so if one is afraid, it's real important to work through it. And it probably doesn't help to have some authority saying you should be afraid.

Pam

Re: Fear

#18

Maybe yes, maybe no, probably yes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

as far as I'm concerned, when my project is glued together, scraped, sanded and ready for finish, it's done. I don't like finishing, but that really is what catches most people's attention.

I talked to one woodworker in Eugene, OR, last fall who said exactly the opposite. For him all the working with wood was a prelude to the main show, which was the finish. His finishes were exquisite.

Re: Fear

#19

Re: Maybe yes, maybe no, probably yes

Pam Niedermayer

as far as I'm concerned, when my project is glued together, scraped, sanded and ready for finish, it's done.

I really love the feel of raw wood that I get from Japanese planes; but certainly the finishing is what draws the eyes.

Pam

Re: Fear

#20

misuse of "fear"; overreaction to misuse

Bill Tindall

Lets get some woodworking posted because I fear this Forum is withering and more woodworking might stimulate more participation. Is anyone making anything?....what, how, any problems?

Re: Fear

#21

Re: misuse of "fear"; overreaction to misuse

TomD

This isn't a wodworking forum, it's a hand tool forum which is mostly the wood avoidance hobby. I gotta get out there and glue up a backing, then get my big lathe craned ouf of doors, then make a little block so I can piggy back my daughters bike on mine.

Re: Fear

#22

Moses Yoder

Re: misuse of "fear"; overreaction to misuse

Moses Yoder

So far as i know, fear is an integral part of hand tool woodworking, and has never before been discussed on this forum. In fact, this discussion is the most activity I have seen on the board in several years. Next up for discussion is "Joy".

Re: Fear

#23

I am making a 4 drawer A&C nightstand...

roger lance

but fear I still do not know how to post pictures of it !!

Re: Fear

#24

Re: Fear

Charles

I read this stuff and shake my head and wonder if any of you folks ever settle into a routine of any kind with regard to your shop practices or if it's endless experimentation with Western tools vs. Asian tools, oilstones, waterstones, scary sharp and back around the horn again.

It mostly makes me tired just reading about it. Futzing around can be mildly amusing at times, but what I'm seeing are YEARS of it. Seems like it would get old.

Re: Fear

#25

Moses Yoder

Re: I am making a 4 drawer A&C nightstand...

Moses Yoder

If you know how to email pictures, I can post them for you. Just send them to mose@riegsecker.com