New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Posts

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#1

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Bill Tindall

In spite of my many discussions and pictures of what happens microscopically to the edge of a chisel used for mortising and dovetail waste removal, or any other operation where the chisel is struck however reasonably, some continue to believe that toughness is required only of crow bars, or at least abused chisels. It should be apparent that chisels used in these operations get dull vastly faster than what might be predicted by the relatively small number of feet the edge passes through compared to what a hand plane experiences before dulling unacceptably. The reason is that these chisels dull by a different mechanism than planes. The two dulled edges bear no similarities.

A tough chisel metal will yield a chisel that can be hardened to a higher value as well as one that can be sharpened to a more acute angle, both substantial benefits in practical applications. This benefit is not something that only enables the chisel to be used for prying off paint can lids but rather the practical benefit is at the very tip of the cutting edge where the edge of the dovetailing chisel dulls by micro chipping if it is not tough enough, or by deformation if it is not hard enough, as I have amply revealed in photographs of edges used for dovetailing, my main practical interest in chisels.

I don't know how carving chisels dull as I have not studied this process. But my data supports the premise that for dovetailing and mortise chopping the edge of very tough chisels that can therefore be made very hard, are superior. I might add that carbon steel is a very good compromise of hardness and toughness while M2, or A2, is not. It is no surprise to me that people are very satisfied with the highest quality carbon steel chisels, although they are not justified to conclude nothing can be significantly better.

While on a recent very wet, but beautiful, CA vacation I had occasion to listen on CD to a remarkably insightful book entitled "The Tipping Point" which explores that phenomena of why and how some things "tip", that is go exponentially from an isolated practice to one widely practiced. It was revealed that persons of widely different constitution are involved in developing a tipped practice. At first it is the "Mavens" that discover the practice and advertise it. These risk taking personalities are driven to change stuff if for no other reason than change's sake. If the new practice has the potential to be widely beneficial the next category of people, trusted in the "community", promote the new practice. (we are about here with diamonds and modern metal) The practice "tips" when the cautious "Early Majority" is sold on the benefit and adapts it. Eventually the Late Majority, risk adverse, adapt the practice. We are at this state with carbide cutting tools and yellow glue. There remains a small population that continues to resist the practice. Overall the velocity of change follows a bell shaped curve.

It is not surprising that this Forum, perhaps better named the Traditional Tool and Techniques Forum, has a large population of persons disposed to be the right tail of this distribution of technology adaptation. Excited discoveries from the Mavens, whether substantive discoveries or not, fall on the unreceptive ears of this conservative group who remain content to continue doing what they have always successfully done. This is not to disparage this group but rather to recognize the reality of the situation.

Recall that to "tip" the Mavens need to reach an audience of promoters who in turn reach the Early Majority personalities. Hence, to promote change I have come to realize this Forum is not a fruitful place for discussions of new metals and sharpening.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#2

David Barnett

We're nearing the threshold, Bill

David Barnett

I've read Outliers, Blink, and The Tipping Point, and the latter is the most intriguing, although I tend to ascribe the underlying cause to morphic resononance (Sheldrake). In other words, The Tipping Point describes how we experience resonance of morphic fields and subsets (e.g. morphogenetic fields), how they manifest consciously once the phenomenal threshold is breached. Well, that's how I think it works. Either way, these steels are not only here to stay, they're becoming concretized within the hand tool morphic fields. Resistance is Futile.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#3

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

TomD

"In spite of my many discussions and pictures of what happens microscopically to the edge of a chisel used for mortising and dovetail waste removal, or any other operation where the chisel is struck however reasonably, some continue to believe that toughness is required only of crow bars, or at least abused chisels. It should be apparent that chisels used in these operations get dull vastly faster than what might be predicted by the relatively small number of feet the edge passes through compared to what a hand plane experiences before dulling unacceptably. The reason is that these chisels dull by a different mechanism than planes. The two dulled edges bear no similarities."

Really, that's a long paragraph for not mentioning how. It also seem to overlook that dovetails are cut in a lot of different methods. For instance using chisels of extremely fine shape that penetrate in one blow; using bevel up of bevel down techniques; splitting out vs. cutting out; sawing out; techniques for through vs. other methods. There are also a lot of different methods of doing mortises. How do we know they are have the same edge wear conditions if you are suggesting they wary in other cases.

"A tough chisel metal will yield a chisel that can be hardened to a higher value as well as one that can be sharpened to a more acute angle, both substantial benefits in practical applications. This benefit is not something that only enables the chisel to be used for prying off paint can lids but rather the practical benefit is at the very tip of the cutting edge where the edge of the dovetailing chisel dulls by micro chipping if it is not tough enough, or by deformation if it is not hard enough, as I have amply revealed in photographs of edges used for dovetailing, my main practical interest in chisels."

Hmm, this would seem to be your pictures of your practices? That is hardly going to unearth the mother load of variables. I think you are right about benefits, but the proportion does seem to be variable. For instance Japanese chisels allegedly combine toughness of iron and hardness of their particular steel, they also use a variety different design features that may deal with the cut differently. I have always been skeptical about the reason for what these chisels do, but it's possible.

"While on a recent very wet, but beautiful, CA vacation I had occasion to listen on CD to a remarkably insightful book entitled "The Tipping Point" which explores that phenomena of why and how some things "tip", that is go exponentially from an isolated practice to one widely practiced. It was revealed that persons of widely different constitution are involved in developing a tipped practice. At first it is the "Mavens" that discover the practice and advertise it. These risk taking personalities are driven to change stuff if for no other reason than change's sake. If the new practice has the potential to be widely beneficial the next category of people, trusted in the "community", promote the new practice. (we are about here with diamonds and modern metal) The practice "tips" when the cautious "Early Majority" is sold on the benefit and adapts it. Eventually the Late Majority, risk adverse, adapt the practice. We are at this state with carbide cutting tools and yellow glue. There remains a small population that continues to resist the practice. Overall the velocity of change follows a bell shaped curve."

Man you should get a rap deal, I haven't heard such rampant self love since NAS released I Carry the Cross. :)

"It is not surprising that this Forum, perhaps better named the Traditional Tool and Techniques Forum, has a large population of persons disposed to be the right tail of this distribution of technology adaptation. Excited discoveries from the Mavens, whether substantive discoveries or not, fall on the unreceptive ears of this conservative group who remain content to continue doing what they have always successfully done. This is not to disparage this group but rather to recognize the reality of the situation."

What the reality that you are stuck up like a porcupine? What is it that makes you think the people in this forum are somehow defined by the forum's title? Even more mystifying is what makes you think that constant attempts at characterizing the mindset of others is a big rhetorical winner. The latest info on metals followed up with yet another self-enhancing definition of your audience is rarely a winner. The way you sell to people is to listen, tell them back just what they told you, then go from there, not tell them who you think they are, and better still, why it is at odds with historical inevitability.

There can be a multitude of reasons why people don't adopt new tools. Jay Barrs won the Seoul gold medal in archery, with a bow several generations out of date, and a factory second with a bent riser. He realized it was about 10% about the bow.

"Recall that to "tip" the Mavens need to reach an audience of promoters who in turn reach the Early Majority personalities. Hence, to promote change I have come to realize this Forum is not a fruitful place for discussions of new metals and sharpening."

I don't know how influential this audience is. I know I don't talk to anyone else about this part of woodworking, so even if you had the capacity to influence, I don't think it would avail you, in my case. Though in fact, I am now using loose diamonds, after hearing about it on this board, and I am considering trying out 3V. Basically hearing about it, in this case was not followed by availability. But once it became available I am willing to try it. But I also don't believe there are any points in it. I just like trying out stuff. But it won't lead to my getting any life long substantial productivity out of it.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#4

Re: We're nearing the threshold, Bill

TomD

Diamonds seem practical, and cheap. 3V or M4 might be wonderful, but it will take a significant commitment to get them out there, and they aren't a commodity, there are lots of reasons outside of steel type that determine why chisels or planes succeed. In fact where planes are concerned it is amazing how long, since the craft revival of the 70s, the were sold without any kind of decent blade in them at all. That has changed recently but it still does beg the question about whether the demand is there. chisels seem to be difficult to market. I think of all the planes LN has trotted out and yet the chisels seemed to take longer. Not sure if that is true. It seems to be an expensive process to bring a real chisel to market, not just some chisel that looks like a somewhat shinier version of a home made model.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#5

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Gawd, I'm so tired of Gladwell's various juvenile philosophies and David Brooks' yapping about them; although tipping point was probably the best and most useful. Note: I never read this book, it all seemed intuitively obvious. If you want a really interesting read in this type book, check out The Wisdom of Crowds by James Surowiecki, probably a hard copy is better.

First, people take on different personalities in different areas. For example, I was always an early adopter, even inventor in a couple of cases, when it came to software development methodology and tools, but was quite happy mucking about on a very old motorcycle with a primitive tool set (it's all you can carry on a long road trip).

Second, when it comes to woodworking tools, people tend to buy sets of things and have a relatively large number of dollars invested in their existing tool kits, relative to the fact that woodworking is not their profession. So it's got to be something special to make them give up the comfort of the same old, like their shops burning down or a fault line busting them up. And even then, the replacement most likely won't be something that takes a long time to make, assuming the shops were insured and big payment checks are in hand so they can afford what they always wanted anyway.

Third, many people seem to become somewhat attached to the things they own. I know it's almost impossible to even think about selling my R90S or letting go of my LN LA Jack, even though I almost never ride these days or use the LN much at all. This is probably a bit stupid.

So, why am I interested in 3V? Because you've talked about it a lot, I have someone to ask about the process, I hate metal working but need to make some chisels and plane irons, I'm a little curious, and there's not much furniture I need (well, none that I need); so I may as well turn my attention to tool making. But I don't perceive any urgency. It's perfectly fine if it takes some months to accumulate stuff and sufficient knowledge.

Now, why are you interested in what steel I use? That's a serious question. What does it matter if any other woodworker uses 3V chisels?

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#6

David Barnett

You really put it in perspective

David Barnett

"It is not surprising that this Forum, perhaps better named the Traditional Tool and Techniques Forum, has a large population of persons disposed to be the right tail of this distribution of technology adaptation."

Alas, perhaps you're right, Bill. If it had been so named, I doubt I'd have made the crossing from the Pond, as I'd long-ago outgrown my interest in 'traditional' for its own sake. I became (and remain) far more intrigued by hand tools as der dinge an sich , that is to say, tools guided, controlled and finessed by hand control rather than jigged or under machine control -- more interested in the hand-brain connection than in who made what tool and did what with it. In that respect -- and as I personally wouldn't consider living with a piece of period furniture in my own home -- perhaps I really don't fit in, and seem, to those who crave tradition, disrespectful of the canon. It's no wonder that advocating the 'new' arouses defensiveness and even ire.

I must say, I was surprised how little interest or response my posts generated on how the hand actually functions, senses, moves, haptically and otherwise, which I apparently mistook as the essence, the very core of what WC Hand Tools is about. I'd chalked it up to bad timing. I hand taken 'Hand Tools' too literally.

Obviously, I recognize that old tools are largely the story of hand tools, but hadn't really considered that it's more about history and a need to experience the past that truly drives this forum. The aesthetics and economies of hand tools are what have always appealed to me. That direct flow, that tango of mind and hand, that more intimate and safer interaction with my materials is what speaks to me -- not provenance or historical authenticity. I must conclude that I largely lack that emotional need to experience antiquity or the mundane artifacts of antiquity, although my love for ancient literature and poetry is nonetheless diminished. How very enlightening!

Didn't mean to personalize your thread, Bill -- I know it's not all about me :), but it's food for thought and will inform and temper my future participation.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#7

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

David Weaver

I get it, Bill.

They're better, and there's no reason to not have better. I don't think anyone 200 years ago had the attitude that they wouldn't want something better if it was available at the right price.

I'm not going to look down on someone who uses something better.

I'm not going to go to a seminar or a powwow and conclude that I am enlightened and nobody needs to use anything better than what the seminar presenter used, even if we're talking about chisels and the presenter was using carving tools.

I'm not going to go back to some mythical age where people were satisfied to say that there were plenty of things that you can't see and understand about a particular chisel that will never be known, but "it's just better".

But on this forum, you'll always get a few who will tell you that if you can't sharpen it on an oilstone and get it for $3 at a flea market, you're not a real woodworker. :\

I'm not above buying stuff at flea markets, that's for sure, but the attitude that using better means you're worse....that's dumb, and I:

* don't understand why the people who think that way feel like I should to, or even care to tell me that I should

* despise groupist "I think we can all agree because ___ said so" kind of stuff.

* don't care what someone else thinks when I decide what I like.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#8

I agree

Bill Tindall

Carbon steel makes a very good chisel if heat treated to its optimum hardness for chiseling. Additionally, it can be forged so that something that looks like a traditional socket chisel can be made. And the metal is cheap. The incremental benefit of going from steel saw blades to carbide saw blades is not replicated in chisel steel. I suppose it may be possible that something "better" replaces A2 as the "commodity" "higher performance" steel.

Diamonds will eventually tip, I predict. As an example, May May a leading US carver, is now using and advocating diamond sharpening in her business and classes.

That said, if one is making a home made chisel there is no reason to not consider a higher performance metal, especially in the case of 3V that can be fabricated so easily with wood shop tools.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#9

Making the use of available technology

Bob Hackett

For me using hand tools is a way for me to get exactly what I want. Instead of being limited to the profiles of mass produced cutters or the available jigging ( like fences or max depth of cut) that comes with a machine I am free to do what I intend as long as I am willing to make the tools to perform that process. The fact that hand tools allow me far more control over that process is also a factor. It`s about stretching the limits rather than setting them.

Every day there are people developing better versions of what`s available in a wide spectrum of products. The idea of "getting by" with a single type of material will appeal to some folks and there`s nothing wrong with that. What is "best " today may not be best next week,electronics are a excellent example of what I`m talking about.

I try to stay up on developments in materials because it allows me a much wider set of choices. I can choose based on using the absolute best vs the most cost effective or even ease of manufacture using only "in house" technology and tooling.

For me knowledge means more options.To say "good enough" sets limits as it implies my search will go no further. I much prefer to have as many options as possible rather than limit myself and my work.

I find it ironic how wanting to have the most options has both kept me looking at new technology and also brought me back to hand tools.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#10

Mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About a year ago I made 40 mortises in one day without even thinking about sharpening the chisel. I could not remember when it was previously sharpened. A few days later someone on a forum suggested that in the 18th century workers must have ground away their mortising chisels, using only a secondary bevel, because the stones available at that time were so poor. So I sharpened that same mortise chisel, full bevel, on natural sandstone and chert bench stones. It took 118 seconds. Probably less than 2 seconds of sharpening per mortise and not even my regular stones. How much time per mortise would a different steel save? Should I get a grinder and a respirator and a face shield and walk to the other end of the shop so I can use some nasty steel that was designed for making dies?

Mortising is about finesse, not bashing and abusing. It is ridiculous for a beginner who barely knows how use a mortise chisel to try and design a new tool. It takes some gall to suggest that someone with much experience is foolish for not adopting a beginner's methods.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#11

Remember to play nice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Bill T. has offered a challenging perspective on the responses to recent discussions on new technologies. While most of this thread has been admirably focused on the ideas in his post, some of the responses have been more than a bit personal. Remember that we can disagree with each other's ideas all day long while remaining respectful of each other, eh?

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#12

Re: If you had to use bronze...

David Weaver

Just think how much of a nuisance that task would've been if you had to use bronze.

I have to admit that of the d2 mortise chisels I have, I don't know how many mortises they've cut, but after their initial honing, they've never seen anything other than a finish stone. They haven't had to. I don't know what the effective angle at the edge is, I don't sharpen them in a guide - that's too much thinking.

I'd rather have them than carbon steel chisels - i like a lot that I can swipe them on a finish stone after every mortise or two - like 5 times or so - and never do anything else with them.

I could very easily get along with carbon steel mortise chisels. But I don't have to, so I won't.

I don't know how most people cut mortises, but i've never had to wail away to cut one. I tried that for experimentation when I first started, but it seemed like more work, less pleasing and a sloppy result.

I get a chuckle out of our discussions about what tools provide utility to us and what tools are a waste of money. Each time I buy wood to make something, it's costing more than it would be for me to go and get a piece of furniture at a flea market. There's really not a lot of utility in this for most people, so describing what's not necessary really should extend to hand tool woodworking not being a necessity.

While we're doing it, I'll always entertain entertaining myself with new materials if they are reasonable cost and it satisfies curisity.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#13

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The director of our local volunteer center used to say that potential volunteers need to see the possibility of volunteering at an organization three times before they do.

I agree with Pam that we may play different roles in different parts of our lives. When it comes to hand tools, I'm probably way over on the resistant tail of the bell curve, at the moment, when it comes to chisels and planes. But, in thinking about it, I realize that one of the reasons I might be so is that I have, over the years, accumulated a considerable stash of Auld Technologie tools, and am reluctant to give them up (emotional attachment, some - you're right, Pam; and just sheer inertia). They've served me well to date.

On the other hand, if, when I get out of the remodeling business here on our house and into the shop, I start exploring some of those exotic woods that Derek Cohen, Andrew F., and others from the lower side of the world think of as normal furniture woods, I may find myself looking at newer steels in order to work those woods.

On the other other hand, the discussions of diamond sharpening, including Bill Tindall's several comprehensive reports on his experiments, have convinced me that I need to explore that technology. I'm not unhappy with my Auld Oylstones, but something that will get me a sharp edge and back to work faster is worth examining. This is probably still Late Majority behavior, but not quite so late as with the tools.

That the discussions encounter some resistance to the new ideas, and that they don't trigger everyone running out and buying/making tools from the alphabet steels does not, in my opinion, mean they're falling on deaf ears, nor useless discussions. Change takes time and repetition.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#14

Specialty steel chisels only available to

Chuck Nickerson

those willing to make them. That's not where some of us want to spend our time right now.

Then there's the whole argument about which substrate to use with diamond sharpening.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#15

As far as our reactions...

David Weaver

... and I'm as guilty as anyone else. I often leave here wondering why I bothered discussing a topic, because....

.. well, aside from the initial flurry, I really don't care what conclusion someone else comes to.

I get the sense that some of us do? It appears I do temporarily.

I like to read what warren says. I've never seen anything that warren makes, but his response is usually so different than mine that I like to see what he says.

It doesn't bother me that much that I don't always agree with warren when it comes to opinion, because when the rubber hits the road, I still use a lot of carbon steel chisels, I still use plain old bench planes a fair amount and (don't tell anyone), on rare occasions, I use the second iron on a plane where it is in good enough condition and properly tuned to be used.

But we all throw our opinions out there....and i'm not sure we really are as fouled up about things as it looks like we are in the posts. I surely am not.

Someone said something a while ago on another forum, i can't remember what quack life-theory guy it belonged to, but it was one of the deepak chopras or something - the kind of book-selling goofiness that I don't agree with. But I really agreed with the statement - "other people aren't going to agree with you and you shouldn't care that they don't".

I get a little less inclined to write pointed posts every day even when I completely disagree with someone, because I realize after I get in a protracted discussion, I never really cared nearly as much as the effort to flop my opinion out there, and afterwards, I always felt like "that was a waste of time".

It comes across so rotten in a forum when you say to someone "well, i don't really care what you think", but i hope a lot of us feel that way, even if there's no nice way to put it. If someone doesn't care what I think, and they tell me, I'm never offended by it.

You can even respond to my post by telling me that!

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#16

Re: oilstones?

David Weaver

Wasn't this the forum where some were discussing recharging their oil stones by putting diamond powder on them?

I know the idea of putting diamonds onto oil stones will just get some people to absolutely flip. :b

I'm not that enthralled with my oil stones, but i'm not going to do that with them.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#17

David Barnett

Even works on NastySteel� *LINK*

David Barnett

"Wasn't this the forum where some were discussing recharging their oil stones by putting diamond powder on them?"

What fool would suggest that, David? Besides Norton Abrasives, that is.

"I know the idea of putting diamonds onto oil stones will just get some people to absolutely flip. :b"

Ya think?

But it also allows you to hone NastySteel� on that same stone.

Back then I actually thought this thread was long:


Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#18

Re: Even works on NastySteel�

David Weaver

Thanks for the refresher - so you were the troublemaker! :D

I think a pile of 1 micron diamonds would do wonders for my black arkansas, but I am afraid that I will want to sell it sometime. It is a BIG one.

If I had only it to use, i'm pretty sure I would get to the point that I did that, though.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#19

Need?

wilbur

I made these points recently, but from Bill's current post I think it bears repeating.

For me, the issue is not whether powdered metal technology is better than, say, O-1 steel or old laminated 18th-19th century tools in terms of edge retention. That's data, and powdered metal wins. For me, the issue is whether this translates into a useful or needed thing to have in terms of woodworking.

Now, if you work primarily in rosewoods or jarrah, you might have different needs. But it seems to me that using CPM steels for working with North American species because the edge retention will lead to increased productivity is trying to solve a problem that doesn't really exist. Too many people have no issues with the older steels in terms of their satisfaction with edge retention for me to believe that there is a widespread problem with chisel edge retention in the domestic woods that a lot of woodworkers use that requires a switch to a chisel with the newer steel formulations.

In my day job, I run into this issue all the time. There is invariably some lab test run on a patient that I am seeing that would cause one at a first pass analysis to launch into a therapeutic intervention to "fix" the lab value. If medicine were that easy, a relatively talented college upperclassman could do this job. But there's a huge difference between identifying that a lab value is out of whack and figuring out whether that lab value really means anything significant for the patient.

The ongoing discussions of the use of modern steels for woodworking seems to be a very analogous situation. Again, I'm not denying that CPM steels have better edge retention than, say, O-1. That is a measurable piece of data, and as I said above, CPM steel wins. Whether that translates into a significant improvement in the amount of effort or time spent making a woodworking project still isn't clear to me, especially since the amount of time spent chopping with chisels on a project seems to be relatively small compared to all the other tasks needed for a project. So to say that chisels made of CPM steel is something I need for working with domestic hardwoods is, I think, an overstatement.

This has nothing to do with a tipping point, or an attitude against change. This has everything to do with proving that using chisels made with modern alloys solves a problem that is real in a significant way.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#20

Un met need

Phil Smith

"In my day job, I run into this issue all the time. There is invariably some lab test run on a patient that I am seeing that would cause one at a first pass analysis to launch into a therapeutic intervention to "fix" the lab value. If medicine were that easy, a relatively talented college upperclassman could do this job. But there's a huge difference between identifying that a lab value is out of whack and figuring out whether that lab value really means anything significant for the patient.

The ongoing discussions of the use of modern steels for woodworking seems to be a very analogous situation. Again, I'm not denying that CPM steels have better edge retention than, say, O-1. That is a measurable piece of data, and as I said above, CPM steel wins. Whether that translates into a significant improvement in the amount of effort or time spent making a woodworking project still isn't clear to me, especially since the amount of time spent chopping with chisels on a project seems to be relatively small compared to all the other tasks needed for a project. So to say that chisels made of CPM steel is something I need for working with domestic hardwoods is, I think, an overstatement."


For well experienced woodworkers like the woodworkers who populate this forum you well may be right.

But in our local club where many of the woodworkers are starting or have much less experience than most of this forum that is not the case. The additional wear resistance and toughness the particle tool steels bring is a NICE side benefit. From my experience over the last several years is that very few of the novice and intermediate and even a few high skill woodworkers are comfortable grinding edge tools with a grinder. Most all have a fear of over heating the tool and taking the temper out of the tool. And for many this concern is well justified. The advantage of the particle tool steels is that essentially anyone can grind an edge without fear of damaging the tool. This is a huge advantage for the tool steels and where the real opportunity exist for these materials.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#21

Concretized?

Joe Shelton

So now I have to look for a chisel laminated of rebar and a cutting edge of a Portland and aggregate compound?

And how the heck do I sharpen THAT?

Still, drive on. I'll follow, even if it's just idle curiosity.

Joe

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#22

David Barnett

Gettin' crusty

David Barnett

Well, considering we're talking, in part, about powder steels, ...

And considering that one method of manufacturing these steels is sintering...

And further considering that sintering is a ceramic process...

And considering that ceramics can be said to become concretized...

How am I doing so far? Okay, so I'm no James Burke. :b

Sharpening? Three-day-old french bread charged with diamond in a paste of your choice of human exudates, although earwax workls, too. Learned about the uses and joys of cerumen from Benvenuto Cellini.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#23

Re: Un met need

wilbur

So why not recommend Japanese chisels for the beginners, then? They have good edge retention, and because of the laminated steel construction and the hollow on the back, they are very easy to sharpen without using a grinder. ;)

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#24

Forget metal altogether

Bob Hackett

What you need is a jade bladed adze like the ones they use in New Zealand.

There used to be a video on you-tube of a guy hewing a beam and really going to town on it. The spectators were as amazed as I was to see it was a stone edge.

Now THAT is hand tool history right there,I don`t care who you are.

Didn`t say what he used to hone it though. :)

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#25

Re: Need?

David Weaver

there isn't even a need for O1. We could all use 1080 steel and cast stones at the people who use something tougher.

There's no *need* for us to buy japanese chisels, especially not chisels that have hand work in them.

There isn't really even a need for any of us to do woodworking. There's no need for us to have expensive furniture, or houses that do more than keep us warm and dry and give us a pot to pee in.

Somehow, tools that are plain carbon steel or O1 have arbitrarily been chosen as the point where the people who are "right" use tools, and everything else is excessive.

It doesn't make any sense to me, especially when I see a lot of really inconsistent recommendations - first and foremost the one I mentioned before. There's no "need" for anything better than O1, but iyoroi chisels and other bargain japanese chisels get blasted every time someone asks if they're OK. They are better than O1 for everything but prying.

Woodworking and medicince are not the same thing, though I am guessing some at the medicine because I have obviously never practiced it.

The day I see the 3v chisels and other stuff expressed as a minimum needed to do good work, I'll call BS. Writing them off because a few people have gotten used to using carbon steel is just as arbitrary as anything else, though.