Re: Need?
TomD
"Chisels do chip. Mine chip. I sharpen the chips out. They may not be that large, but I have looked at the edges and that's how they fail."
Mine get dull, never seem to chip, what are you folks getting up to?
"But if the cure is harmless and improves the quality of life (how's that for a generalization) for someone new to the hobby, why not let them never deal with it? I doubt they'll immediately quit woodworking when they have to get a style of tool that is not available in a CPM product. But in the interim, if their tools are just as sharp and they sharpen a lot less, why would they want to sharpen *more*? For novelty?"
Oh great the same question again. Well 1) can you give me the URLs for where I go to get these chisels you speak of? 2) oh whoops they don't make them in a form I like. etc... 3) and there is the whole sharpening thing, not everyone as yet bought in on the diamonds; 4) They mays simply have other interests like making their own tools, working easy to work woods, or using certain classes of tool. lie Japanese, etc... But the reality is that if they are better, they will probably find there way in. I mean nobody made )1 tools for sale until relatively recently. I have no idea all the differnt steels I currently use, and if this stuff leaves the vapourware stage I don't see why it wouldn't get used.
"the last thing I'd want to do is start telling new hobbyists - here, go for this older stuff. It's not better than some of the newer stuff, and it can be harder to find as time goes on, but get it, anyway."
So just so I am clear, you are talking about an imaginary future woodworker, buying imaginary "modern" chisels, in search of solutions to largely imaginary problems? Sounds like a perfect match.
I see no sign of old chisels getting used up any time soon.
"I can see this from all sides. The not so often mentioned side is that folks who fancy themselves as enlightened like to come up with a conclusion and get their underwear in a wad when someone says "why not try to see if we can find something better?". I see a whole lot of that."
I'm sorry, I am going to need an actual reference for a thread were you didn't mention this. Reminds me of that old saying. "I found a rare unsigned copy of his book". I think I saw you mention this in a bread machine forum.
"but such an issue with a new japanese tool (even a hardware store tool) would be considered catastrophic."
I would probably let it pass since I haven't seen it in 35 years, every 5 million units one slips through...
"I would, also, be surprised if any of my iyoroi chisels tested the 64 hardness that they claim to be. I tested (or a buddy and i bartered to have tested) another one that was 64 spec years ago (a mortise chisel) with a rockwell tester, and it was 61 average with three dings - 60, 61 and 62 roughly. I would've probably never known the difference, just assumed that it was easier to sharpen than expected for some reason (and it was easy to sharpen). Of course, the guy who uses it now find it holds up just fine in use."
FWW did a particularly silly chisel test some years back. One of the interesting findings was that there was a wide range of edge holding, somewhat understated in their methodology to boot. Yet virtually all the chisels were within a point or 2 Rockwell. So if one assumes the rockwell tests were legitimate, it decouples hardness and edge durability. Earlier tests showed a range of hardness more in step with the range in edge holding.
"I had a witherby chisel that was either 52 or 53, and it was undamaged."
allert the wire services!
"I would be surprised if the great blacksmiths didn't manage to let a few out that didn't meet their standards once in a while, too"
I look forward to the date,
"and sooner or later, there will probably some 3v chisels that come out not so great." Or at all.