New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Posts

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#26

David Barnett

Tool familiarity

David Barnett

"I realize that one of the reasons I might be so is that I have, over the years, accumulated a considerable stash of Auld Technologie tools, and am reluctant to give them up (emotional attachment, some - you're right, Pam; and just sheer inertia). They've served me well to date."

This is where I agree more with you and less with Bill Tindall. I'd be very reluctant to give up my older chisels and plane irons, as I, too, have emotional and practical attachments. What I mean by practical is particularly important with chisels; how they feel in my hand, their heft, balance points, the different positions I shift to when using a particular chisel in a given way for various tasks. The very feel of the steel, the surfaces, fettled edges, all combine to allow me think about the work when paring, scraping, whatever, and not so much the tool. These haptics are far more important to me, especially with my diminishing sight, than edge-holding, although if edge-holding became an issue, interrupting my stream of making, I'd certainly consider upgrading.

Which is why I would probably be content with two or three NastySteel� chisels and maybe one block plane and a smoother iron in something tougher and harder than plain carbon tool steel. Options are good.

As for diamond, you know my take on that. No need for it if you're satisfied with what you have. Of course, should you ever acquire NastySteel� tools, you'll probably want them NastySharp�.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#27

Re: Need?

wilbur

Hi David,

"It doesn't make any sense to me, especially when I see a lot of really inconsistent recommendations - first and foremost the one I mentioned before. There's no "need" for anything better than O1, but iyoroi chisels and other bargain japanese chisels get blasted every time someone asks if they're OK. They are better than O1 for everything but prying."


Again, I don't think I have ever blasted Iyoroi or other bargain Japanese chisels. I've only mentioned that there have been some people who have posted bad experiences with the bargain brands, and that was one factor that led me to the brand of chisels that I do use. I really can't remember ever opining about Iyoroi.

"Woodworking and medicince are not the same thing, though I am guessing some at the medicine because I have obviously never practiced it."

They aren't, but the type of analysis that is going on here is highly analogous to what I do on a daily basis at work.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#28

Re: Need?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Apparently like many US manufacturers, Iyoroi makes at least two product lines, one cheap and one expensive. Imai does this, too; but I suspect his cheaper line is still competitive with high quality. Yataiki did this with saws, although his lines were very expensive, more than very expensive, and conspicuous consumption extravagant, from $300 to $20,000. I don't see anything wrong with warning first time users who think they've come across a great deal.

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#29

Re: Forget metal altogether

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Glass blades weren't abandoned for metal because they were less sharp, but because they generally didn't hold an edge as well.

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#30

David Barnett

Still thinking about your post, Bill

David Barnett

"It is not surprising that this Forum, perhaps better named the Traditional Tool and Techniques Forum, has a large population of persons disposed to be the right tail of this distribution of technology adaptation."

While this may be so, it really seems that most who have participated in the new steels discussion have been fairly open-minded yet sensible to the obstacles that these newer steels will have to overcome. Really, it seems the most vociferous objectors number at best only two or three uncompromising opponents. The rest range from "I'm from Missouri" to "Damn the torpedoes!"

"Excited discoveries from the Mavens, whether substantive discoveries or not, fall on the unreceptive ears of this conservative group who remain content to continue doing what they have always successfully done."

It's interesting, though, how progress and innovation can be slowed by those very few outliers at the right tail, in that third sigma and beyond. There's a cultural bias against these persons that shows up in the language, the lexicon. Take this list of words:

stick-in-the-mud

backward

regressive

retrograde

stubborn

resistant

stolid

fixed

doctrinal

dogmatic

conventional

set-in-one's-ways

habitual

conservative

hidebound

quaint

illiberal

old-school

common

Philistine

die-hard

guarded

fuddy-duddy

reticent

inflexible

orthodox

phelgmatic

diffident

retarded

reserved

Notice how many have negative connotations in our society? Whether this is fair or not is not the point. It is simply so.

Now look at these words:

advanced

progressive

avant-garde

enlightened

inventive

enterprising

forward-looking

forward-thinking

modern

contemporary

open-minded

broad-minded

efficacious

innovative

Notice a difference?

These words certainly don't signify good or bad, there are people I respect highly who are less than forward-thinking, but such connotations and biases certainly favor the more progressive-inclined and open-minded, at least in this day and age, in this country.

"Hence, to promote change I have come to realize this Forum is not a fruitful place for discussions of new metals and sharpening."

While that seems harsh, it may very well be true, or at least mostly true. However, I'm heartened at just how very many participants DO give their ear to knew ideas and give them intelligent and fair shrift, so I'm not altogether ready to throw in the towel. However, rather than becoming less tolerant of others' demonstrated need for historical perspective, I'll endeavor to be more aware of those persons and their contributions, no matter how peculiar they may seem to me personally.

Will I bend to what I believe to be incorrect or misguided attitudes or information? Of course not. Will I continue to poke fun and engage in good-natured ribbing when I think it's warranted or I simply can't restrain myself? No doubt. But as long as discussions are conducted in a fair and respectful manner, I don't see why these natural polarizations, these predisposed prejudices shouldn't peacefully coexist as long as neither side becomes overly intolerant.

You've brought up some interesting, intriguing observations, Bill, for which I'm grateful, and as you've often done, cut to the chase and to the essence, exposing the structural underpinnings of this ongoing argument.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#31

Re: Need?

David Weaver

This problem isn't as difficult as a diagnosis that can't be fully confirmed by a single test, or at least prescribing the best course of treatment.

Chisels do chip. Mine chip. I sharpen the chips out. They may not be that large, but I have looked at the edges and that's how they fail.

There appears to be a steel that chips a lot less. There is no need to run another assay (or however precise folks would say it). It may be that the disease (chipping) is something people can live with. I can live with it. But if the cure is harmless and improves the quality of life (how's that for a generalization) for someone new to the hobby, why not let them never deal with it? I doubt they'll immediately quit woodworking when they have to get a style of tool that is not available in a CPM product. But in the interim, if their tools are just as sharp and they sharpen a lot less, why would they want to sharpen *more*? For novelty?

I just really don't have any set of rules, and the last thing I'd want to do is start telling new hobbyists - here, go for this older stuff. It's not better than some of the newer stuff, and it can be harder to find as time goes on, but get it, anyway. Grampy used it, and this guy at sotheby's liked it, even though he's not a woodworker, he says you're a fool for looking at new stuff. makes no sense.

Do recall that I'm the one who argues with the schwartz on his blog when he says that there is false economy in old tools, or that it takes 2 hours to flatten a chisel. I just got a couple more old ones, and an old saw this week. I can see this from all sides. The not so often mentioned side is that folks who fancy themselves as enlightened like to come up with a conclusion and get their underwear in a wad when someone says "why not try to see if we can find something better?". I see a whole lot of that.

And just as there are japanese budget tools (i would consider iyoroi a hardware store brand, and you can notice the quality difference vs. something like miyanaga, and i'm sure versus the higher end makers), there are O1 tools that are chippy or that break, and there are most definitely old laminated tools that are soft as well as those that are chippy. My *favorite* old wooden plane, a JT brown plane - a single iron long jointer, probably has an iron that is mid or low mid 50s hardness - I don't remember the make. I really wish it was harder. I'm not going to replace it, though, but such an issue with a new japanese tool (even a hardware store tool) would be considered catastrophic.

I would, also, be surprised if any of my iyoroi chisels tested the 64 hardness that they claim to be. I tested (or a buddy and i bartered to have tested) another one that was 64 spec years ago (a mortise chisel) with a rockwell tester, and it was 61 average with three dings - 60, 61 and 62 roughly. I would've probably never known the difference, just assumed that it was easier to sharpen than expected for some reason (and it was easy to sharpen). Of course, the guy who uses it now find it holds up just fine in use.

I had a witherby chisel that was either 52 or 53, and it was undamaged.

There's just not going to be any level or age of tools where there aren't some defectives. I would be surprised if the great blacksmiths didn't manage to let a few out that didn't meet their standards once in a while, too, and sooner or later, there will probably some 3v chisels that come out not so great.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#32

Re: Need?

David Weaver

Pam, I have some chisels (iyorois) that are supposed to be the more expensive line (not the most expensive, but more expensive than the basic ones). when I see them retailed, I know I wouldn't pay for them what the retail is. They're not really that great (not remotely close to being unpleasant to use, to be clear, though - i have no intention of replacing them).

They came from fujibato, though. I don't know how he accumulates sets, but for all I know, they could be second quality. They were only about $60 per with a box with a bunch of stuff on it, which is hardly more than the mass produced line.

they are hand marked, have better handles (white oak with the pith) than basic chisels, mokume and are really easy to sharpen (still white #2, nothing exotic). I mean really really easy to sharpen, which might be what they were going for with them. who knows? I bought them on price. Each time I use them and think that maybe they are a little soft, I use an old cast steel chisel sometime in the next week and that sets me straight about what's hard and what's not.

I did read someone, maybe it was So, who said that the old man likes to get involved in the making of some of the mokume chisels, etc, and his involvement usually leads to worse quality. haha. Presumably just because he's not doing it every day all the time any longer.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#33

Re: Need?

David Weaver

Might as well point out what I was talking about. they are these.

http://www.330mate.com/zoom/1350

Fujibato has them (depending on size) ranging probably $80-$150 per.

And though I have somewhat mediocre comments about them, I have seen much worse plain iyoroi chisels at woodworking stores (the rough machine-made looking things with big coats of lacquer all over them). I think i could get them to work, though these somewhat more expensive chisels were much faster to prepare - maybe 5 minutes each at most.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#34

Re: Un met need

TomD

First chisels I bought after a 1/8" Blue Tip.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#35

Probably iyoroi is not ioroi.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#36

David Barnett said...

Larry Williams

In another thread, David Barnett said he'd never seen one instance of these exotic steels being promoted as a solution to inexperience. I didn't think it'd take long for an example to show up.

From your post, I am left wondering how comfortable you are with grinding. Can you overheat a tool while grinding? You bet. You can also badly cut yourself with a sharp chisel. Avoid both.

I can teach a person to grind in 5 minutes. It's part technique, part appropriate tooling and part proper maintenance but none of it is difficult. Have I ever overheated the corner of a chisel or plane iron during grinding? Yes, but it's also easy and quick to correct. It's just not a big deal.

Grinding M-2 or M-42 is a different matter. There's nothing fast about it. You're also spreading heavy metals like cobalt around when you grind these metals.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#37

David Barnett

David Barnett was wrong...

David Barnett

Clearly so. Wrong, wrong, wrong, Larry. And you're being nicer, more magnanimous about it than I probably would've been.

Considering I said:

"Who exactly is promoting these steels in this way -- for this reason? I haven't seen it. Not once. Never. Can you give an example?"

Even worse:

"No-one's suggesting the rank tyro, the wide-eyed hand tool newbie run right out and commission a set of M4 chisels before learning basic sharpening skills..."

You said:

"I didn't think it'd take long for an example to show up."

And you were right. Less than two weeks.

So while I thought I was right, dead sure I was, in fact, I was plainly wrong, and no rhetoric, no lengthy diatribe, no nuanced rationalization to the contrary and no glib, humorous quip will make it otherwise.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#38

Why Warren doesn't need tougher chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you have used my name as someone who needs tougher chisels. Your explanation is that my mortise chisels become dull from chipping and that the wear is very different from that on a plane.

Well, I have a surprise for you, Bill. I got out my 30X loupe and examined my mortise chisels this morning. There is no chipping at all on their edges. No chipping and no rolling, only smooth wear like one might expect on a plane iron. I guess it could be from the way I sharpen the chisels. It could be because of the type of chisel I use. It could be because of my mortising technique.

I described my technique on this forum several years ago. It is similar to that of Ian Kirby and Toshio Odate in that most of the cutting is done at 60 degrees to the direction of the fibres. At that time you dismissed this type of mortising and offered a technique which cuts at 90 degrees to the fibres, certainly harder on the edge. In addition I use a very controlled and gentle technique for removing waste. This technique would not work for mortises cut in your style.

My chisels do not appear in your photographs; your "data" does not include any of my work. A better heading would be "Why Bill Tindall needs tough chisels"

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#39

Re: Still thinking about your post, Bill

TomD

Society has a future bias that the individual does not. Society has a far longer time frame. People are individual and finite, society is collective and has relatively infinite time line. So future oriented language is more positive in a social context. This may be a consistent flaw in your approach - confusing the individual with the collective. So back to an earlier thread about what the beginner might need as a wedge against attitudes of individuals. "Beginer" is an abstraction relative to actual people, and not necessarily an overlay.

On the list of words, you might be overstepping the bounds of your vocabulary. "phelgmatic" temperament is largely positive, as are many of the other "negative" words. Some of the words like retrograde are negatives, not flip sides of forward looking terms. So where innovation might the action oriented, forward looking term, tradition is a positive word that is also more passive and rearward looking, but not listed.

A fair number of your positive terms are not really forward looking or action oriented, but a neutral class like advanced or enlightened.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#40

Re: I agree

TomD

"That said, if one is making a home made chisel there is no reason to not consider a higher performance metal, especially in the case of 3V that can be fabricated so easily with wood shop tools."

"No reason not to consider" is a pretty low threshold. There is certainly a lot of reason not to use it. For me, no local availability for the metal, I need to order it mail order which is a significant expense in my part of the world, no free delivery. The metal itself is a lot more expensive, and the heat treating is probably 25 dollars an individual tool, and a month, at best. So it certainly wouldn't recommend itself in all cases. But I would consider it.

I can make a tool in the shop and heat treat it in under 45 minutes, and the cost for something like a jointer plane blade, enough metal to make a set of chisels out of it probably about 8 bucks. But there are tools where the wear would be far more important than a few buck or speed etc... O1 costs so little that in the extreme case one could have the O1 tool while one waited for the 3V to work it's way through the system. That jointer sized piece in 3v would cost me 32 dollars, plus about 50, and it doesn't come wider then 1.5" from my current suppliers.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#41

Re: Need?

TomD

"Chisels do chip. Mine chip. I sharpen the chips out. They may not be that large, but I have looked at the edges and that's how they fail."

Mine get dull, never seem to chip, what are you folks getting up to?

"But if the cure is harmless and improves the quality of life (how's that for a generalization) for someone new to the hobby, why not let them never deal with it? I doubt they'll immediately quit woodworking when they have to get a style of tool that is not available in a CPM product. But in the interim, if their tools are just as sharp and they sharpen a lot less, why would they want to sharpen *more*? For novelty?"

Oh great the same question again. Well 1) can you give me the URLs for where I go to get these chisels you speak of? 2) oh whoops they don't make them in a form I like. etc... 3) and there is the whole sharpening thing, not everyone as yet bought in on the diamonds; 4) They mays simply have other interests like making their own tools, working easy to work woods, or using certain classes of tool. lie Japanese, etc... But the reality is that if they are better, they will probably find there way in. I mean nobody made )1 tools for sale until relatively recently. I have no idea all the differnt steels I currently use, and if this stuff leaves the vapourware stage I don't see why it wouldn't get used.

"the last thing I'd want to do is start telling new hobbyists - here, go for this older stuff. It's not better than some of the newer stuff, and it can be harder to find as time goes on, but get it, anyway."

So just so I am clear, you are talking about an imaginary future woodworker, buying imaginary "modern" chisels, in search of solutions to largely imaginary problems? Sounds like a perfect match.

I see no sign of old chisels getting used up any time soon.

"I can see this from all sides. The not so often mentioned side is that folks who fancy themselves as enlightened like to come up with a conclusion and get their underwear in a wad when someone says "why not try to see if we can find something better?". I see a whole lot of that."

I'm sorry, I am going to need an actual reference for a thread were you didn't mention this. Reminds me of that old saying. "I found a rare unsigned copy of his book". I think I saw you mention this in a bread machine forum.

"but such an issue with a new japanese tool (even a hardware store tool) would be considered catastrophic."

I would probably let it pass since I haven't seen it in 35 years, every 5 million units one slips through...

"I would, also, be surprised if any of my iyoroi chisels tested the 64 hardness that they claim to be. I tested (or a buddy and i bartered to have tested) another one that was 64 spec years ago (a mortise chisel) with a rockwell tester, and it was 61 average with three dings - 60, 61 and 62 roughly. I would've probably never known the difference, just assumed that it was easier to sharpen than expected for some reason (and it was easy to sharpen). Of course, the guy who uses it now find it holds up just fine in use."

FWW did a particularly silly chisel test some years back. One of the interesting findings was that there was a wide range of edge holding, somewhat understated in their methodology to boot. Yet virtually all the chisels were within a point or 2 Rockwell. So if one assumes the rockwell tests were legitimate, it decouples hardness and edge durability. Earlier tests showed a range of hardness more in step with the range in edge holding.

"I had a witherby chisel that was either 52 or 53, and it was undamaged."

allert the wire services!

"I would be surprised if the great blacksmiths didn't manage to let a few out that didn't meet their standards once in a while, too"

I look forward to the date,

"and sooner or later, there will probably some 3v chisels that come out not so great." Or at all.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#42

David Barnett

Yet another clarification

David Barnett

"Society has a future bias that the individual does not. Society has a far longer time frame. People are individual and finite, society is collective and has relatively infinite time line. So future oriented language is more positive in a social context. This may be a consistent flaw in your approach - confusing the individual with the collective."

What you say is insightful and correct, Tom, and I fully appreciate the distinction between the individual and the collective. As for my approach, I was paraphrasing and grossly summarizing other sources and can claim no credit for originality, although I'll accept some responsibility for casually jumbling it all together.

"On the list of words, you might be overstepping the bounds of your vocabulary."

I didn't choose these words myself, and do, in fact, consider some of them to be quite positive in nature. The list, which I kept, came from articles (which I can no longer find) used in a conference handout. These words were originally given to groups of people from differing backgrounds who rated them on a pos/min continuum.

I would say most of the first list better fits me than the second. "Plegmatic", as one of the Five Temperments, is usually associated with stolidity, though, so I can understand its inclusion in the first list.

"A fair number of your positive terms are not really forward looking or action oriented, but a neutral class like advanced or enlightened."

I'd agree, but the point was that people surveyed felt positive associations for "advanced" and "enlightened", and had difficulty associating those traits with the first list. I didn't delve into or remark on methodology, as my point to Bill was that negative associations coupled to conservative behaviors, attitudes, and personalities can bias against conservative individuals, who may actually be every bit as charitable, empathetic, and decent as more progressive individuals perceive themselves to be. Often more so, if some categories, and therefore, it's good to recognize such bias and avoid making value judgments on those persons with whom might disagree, who might prefer and trust their old Witherby chisels over some newer-fangled chisel.

And after making such a forward-thinking, "enlightened" observation, I hastily jumped all over Warren for something he'd said without considering my own high-sounding admonitions to the contrary.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#43

Two choices Thom

Bob Hackett

A-develop patience or B-relocate.

This coming from a resident of Maine. Been there ,still doing that. ;)

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#44

Re: Yet another clarification

TomD

"I fully appreciate the distinction between the individual and the collective."

I'm sure you do. I was hitherto less sure as regards this topic.

"I would say most of the first list better fits me than the second. "Plegmatic", as one of the Five Temperments, is usually associated with stolidity, though, so I can understand its inclusion in the first list."

Weisenthal's name is associated with the Nazis, but not in a negative way. Likewise the P. person is stolid in accordance with the evenness of their temperament, as opposed to being emotionally crippled, say. But again I would say the second list is mostly socially acceptable terms. Nothing wrong with orthodoxy, but maybe not the best word where the currency in question is diverse group-think.

"conservative individuals, who may actually be every bit as charitable, empathetic, and decent as more progressive individuals perceive themselves to be. Often more so, if some categories, and therefore, it's good to recognize such bias and avoid making value judgments on those persons with whom might disagree, who might prefer and trust their old Witherby chisels over some newer-fangled chisel."

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#45

David Barnett

Good recipe for crow, anyone?

David Barnett

"But in our local club where many of the woodworkers are starting or have much less experience than most of this forum that is not the case. The additional wear resistance and toughness the particle tool steels bring is a NICE side benefit."

It's hard to see how this could be thought a bad thing. I challenged Larry Williams to offer an example of anyone promoting these steels to beginners. He did. I was wrong. And while I don't personally enjoy being wrong (who does?), in this case, it's good to learn that beginners can grind without doing what I did only yesterday, drawing the temper from the corner of one of my favorite older firmers, on a belt sander, of all things. I thought (wrong again!) I was immune to such mistakes.

Isn't it amazing how these events cluster together? (Not really, of course, we just notice when they do.) Anyone have a good recipe for crow? Blackbird pie?

"...very few of the novice and intermediate and even a few high skill woodworkers are comfortable grinding edge tools with a grinder."

Yes, I actually burned the tiniest corner of my chisel*. Fixed it in little time (Larry pointed out how easy this can be only yesterday. Coincidence? Karma?) and got back to banging out joints in thick, hard SYP -- but too late -- I was completely chagrined. So maybe even I'm a candidate for some powder steel chisels in my future, as well.

In my oncoming dotage, as I call it, I miss things I hope I didn't miss before, such as after hearing about the advantages of M4 blades for beginners, having mentioned it, in fact, on WC, it didn't dawn on me that here was a refutation for the very position I'd taken in not believing anyone was promoting these steels for beginners. Oops! And while your use in limited to a local woodworking club, is not a commercially promoted venture, it nonetheless points out my personal denseness.

I prefer to think of these revelations as opportunities for personal growth -- well, after I thoroughly embarrass myself and kick something across the room, that is. :|

My shortcomings, aside, I'm still steadfast in my belief that these new powder steels are deservedly on the uptake, are going to be the next thing, even, for beginners and old hands, alike. So thanks for letting us know your experiences, Phil, and as new issues and learnings evolve, let us know those, as well.

*Didn't see it until I inspected it with a magnifier. For years I've relied on my ability to sense heat at my fingertips. I hadn't unintentionally drawn temper or burned steel in ages. Not any more! Diabetes has taken its toll on my sensitivity, so I'll simply be more careful from here on out. If it wasn't for my still fairly acute sense of smell, I wouldn't have even picked up the magnifier, though.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#46

David Barnett

"Why Bill Tindall needs tough chisels"

David Barnett

Now that's a rebuttal! Especially, that last line. The tide shifts, at least for the moment, to the naysayers.

I did notice you posted at 4:41 am. You got up at 4 am to look at your chisels? :)

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#47

Re: oilstones?

TomD

""other people aren't going to agree with you and you shouldn't care that they don't"."

That goes double in an internet forum. Probably more than double. I know when I have given seminars I get a polite and enthusiastic responses, and I even get people dogging me afterwards to be their friend or go to their club to present, etc... But you get an actual celebrity woodworker who drops in here, and there are a lot of different opinions. People sometimes put this down to a lack of courtesy, but I have come to believe it is the case that there just isn't agreement. In certain situations it seems like there is agreement but it isn't actually there. Take some famous person and put them behind a podium in front of a crowd, applause, etc... But if rather than that you immediately broke out to carrying that discussion over your Blackberries and it would be like Woodcentral on a bad day.

Of course I can't be right because nobody agrees...

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#48

Re:  Why Warren doesn't need tougher chisels

TomD

Exactly, it's a skill thing. Maybe not good or bad, but certainly what.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#49

Re:  Why Warren doesn't need tougher chisels

TomD

Speaking of which it isn't just a Japanese things, the one end to the other method uses the same geometry, and the shaft never leaves vertical. As also the case on the trad mortising machine I just sold.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#50

The lesson for me came from books

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In my early years of learning how to do wood and mechanical stuff on my own (as opposed to what I learned from Dad and Grandpa), I read every book I could on woodworking. After a while, I noticed that the "basic, can't-do-without tool list" in each book varied (note that this is back when basic tool lists were all hand tools - not true anymore). There were a few constants (hammer, chisels, jack plane), but then many variations of other tools. After puzzling over this for a while, I realized (slow learner sometimes, me) that it was a product of how that author preferred to work or the kind of work s/he liked to do, or what s/he was comfortable with, or what tools s/he'd had when starting out and learned to reach for - or something like that.

There are no doubt certain things that can be done just one way with any efficiency at all.

There are no doubt certain tools/methods that, considered carefully, have one optimal version.

There are many, many other things that can be done any number of ways, and many tools that come in lots of different forms and flavors - including cost and availability in a particular area - that can do those things. I am not here saying, "It's all good." But I do think that, often, disagreement can be as much a product of the choices someone has made from among tools/techniques that all work with varying tradeoffs.