New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Posts

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#51

Re:  Why Warren doesn't need tougher chisels

Dean J in MN

Warren's experience echos a similar finding in my tools. I, from time to time, can be found at local woodworking shows manning a booth for SAPFM. I usually bring something along to work on/demo. One of the most popular is cutting DTs, and we always offer to take anyone step-by-step through their first set. What I find is my poor chisels, the very same chisels I can use for the entire show and not sharpen (and still have a fine edge for the pine we use), are trashed buy the time the first half of the joint is cut. Why? Beginners do very nasty things to chisels. The most common is twisting and scraping. If that hunk of wood doesn't come out they don't go back and cut the fibers holding it in, they twist, scrape and pry with the edge. In these cases I know the CPM-* chisels hold their edges longer, but once the learning curve is gone I'm not sure the real gain.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#52

It's spelled Wiesenthal.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#53

David Barnett

Found it! �ber steel hand tools at 66 HRC?

David Barnett

"A tough chisel metal will yield a chisel that can be hardened to a higher value as well as one that can be sharpened to a more acute angle, both substantial benefits in practical applications."

Bill's right, of course. This reminded me to try and pin down where I'd seen M4 can be oil quenched then tempered to an incredible 66 HRC. It's triple tempered at 1000�F an oil quench following an austenitizing (hardening) soak at 2200�F (at the very tip top of my furnace's range) for 5 minutes, a very hot hardening temperature, compared to M4 soaked at 1900�F for 45 minutes, then double tempered at the same 1000�F to yield 59 HRC.

Another chart showing M4 oil quenched from 2200�F and triple tempered at 1025�F, yields a hardness of 65.5 HRC at a test temperature of 72�F. So temper the hotter, harder austenitized M4 at 1000�F, and you'll have an M4 tool at 66 HRC. Aim for 64 or 64.5, and that's still one pretty hard, tough hand tool. Lower the target HRC and you'll gain even more toughness, too. More realistic, perhaps, would be 62 HRC at 600�F. Still extremely impressive and exciting. Well, to me anyway.

"A Rockwell "C" hardness score of 65 is approximately a Mohs score of 8, which means the item is as hard as a topaz", I read. Now that's hard. And steel being ever so tougher than topaz when fractured along its cleavage planes, it should stay sharp a good deal longer, too.

So, 66 HRC. Am I going to shoot for it? No. Are hand tool manufacturers going to aim for the upper limits of hardness when they upgrade their tool lines to powder steels? Doubtfully. But there's still a lot of valuable head-space above O1 for these �ber steels to really show their 'mettle'.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#54

David Barnett

Good grief! I forgot the *LINK*

David Barnett

From Diehl Steel - tool steel specialists:

"CPM M4 high speed steel is an extremely versatile high speed steel which provides a unique combination of high wear resistance with high impact toughness and transverse bend strength. A large volume of vanadium carbides provides the high wear resistance. The high impact toughness and high transverse bend strength are results of the fine grain size, small carbides, and superior cleanliness of the powder metallurgy (CPM) microstructure."


The data sheet. The 'numbers'.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#55

OK... A bit confused here (more than usual...)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Haven't had much time to roam around of late, thanks to all who helped on my cast iron question of a couple weeks ago, I'll get back to it hopefully shortly...

First, let me say that I'm all in favor of experimenting with new steel alloys, given the availability of diamond to sharpen those buggers. In fact, I got a blade "made" for me a few years ago by a friend of my father (he actually ordered the steel blank and cut it to my specs), I asked for M2 at the time but the stuff is so hard (it will eat a zirconia belt in half a minute or so, and gray wheels are powerless to grind the blade) that I suspect it's actually T2. I'll have to clear that out one of these days...

Anyway... The point I wanted to make here is that we are discussing about finding the steel alloys that are as tough AND as hard as possible to use in woodworking. Maybe I missed something in this thread (and the others that lead to this one, I must admit that I didn't read all the posts), but I don't recall seeing any mention of Japanese steel. Blue and white steel are commonly hardened to Rc64-65, the high quality tools don't chip, and last seemingly forever between sharpenings (which are done on waterstones). The question is, what do I gain from using the new alloys?

And where does tamahagane fit in all this?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#56

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#57

Re: Confused you say? This may not help.

TomD

"So I ask, if you could make or buy a chisel that could really take abuse, could be easily ground on cheap imported grinders and honed on diamond stones and laps, with edges that last longer in the less-skilled hands of a beginner and longer still in the hands of experienced tool users, why wouldn't you? And what if experienced hand tool designers were to take up the torch and manufacture affordable powder steel tools, would you not try them? And if not, why? Because you own perfectly good chisels already? Well, that makes complete sense. But would it be such a bad thing to be able to own them if you so wanted? I think not."

I guess my answer to that would be that 3V has been around for a while, and has not displaced other knife steels, and is for that mater, not the only steel offered for sale by Crucible. There is no one perfect steel, and I see no non-rhetorical evidence that all the characteristics you claim are there. I don't say they aren't I just don't have any evidence. In fact, when I quite innocently asked whether M4 would be better, there really wasn't a convincing answer, though the data sheet sounded better than 3v in accordance with your litany of harder tougher, etc... So in short you don't even know your own subject.

"Arguments to the contrary seem specious and territorial."

I think you are back on the bottle here. All these arguments sound specious and territorial, the latter in particular. I think everyone gets pig headed when the arguments get too far out on the limb. You know the old stuff works, other people will adapt new steels should they ever be proven and become generally available. I would also add that there is a richness of new stuff being offered today. A much better world than the one I started in where none of the main tools we any good whatsoever. I wrote to LL fro LV in the 90s I think and pointed out that of the 3 main tool categories, chisels, planes, and saw, LV did not sell a single pro grade example in any of those categories. That is no longer the case, to say the least. But the flipside is that there is a new next best thing in every category every month. As a practical mater there is no keeping up with this stuff. It's costly, takes a lot of time to introduce to a shop. You have to pick your upgrades.

On the Japanese chisels thing, I would say they are great and the limitations described in david's tome do not actually exist. Japanese work harder woods than we do, and also softer, and they work ones with abrasive components to them. Japanese steels are not functionally brittle for the most part. Also Japanese chisels have by far the best design. They are very solid which is actually worth more to me than some increment of edge holding (though I don't have to choose), they have very little loss through vibe, which is a problem with chisels cut from flat stock, often.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#58

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#59

What is your demon name? Curious minds...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#60

They call him...

Bob Hackett

Tater Salad.

Of course he`s a bit more refined than that guy from Texas who claims the same alias. :D

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#61

Hey Thom...

Bob Hackett

You do know those Japanese smiths are all well over retirement age and dropping like flies don`t you? From what I understand there aren`t a whole lot of folks lining up to replace them either.

Pretty soon those fancy Japanese chisels will be just as finite and hard to get as Whitherbys and Swans only with a price tag that`s several orders of magnitude larger than the old US laminated chisels are now.

I will grant you that making your own chisels is not for everyone. If you`re going to do it then you may as well have some fun and open yourself up to the possibilities instead of being one of the sheeple who wanders along with the herd.

Yes it`ll take some research that you will have to do on your own to keep up and get the best available but hey,that`s half the fun for folks like me.

Any way you cut it,I for one would much rather see someone grinding a new "Uber-steel" blank that can take a bit of ham handedness both at the grinder and at work than see them grind away at an old relic from the past that is no longer being made in order to "custom make" the chisel of their choice.

I mentioned stewardship and preservation in a previous post. I thought that alone would make the folks who swear by "old iron" happy yet that too went by without a comment.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#62

Stephen Shepherd

I'm Happy

Stephen Shepherd

'I mentioned stewardship and preservation in a previous post. I thought that alone would make the folks who swear by "old iron" happy yet that too went by without a comment.'

Comment.

Stephen

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#63

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#64

Re: They call him...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

How did you know this before his reply? OOOOOOOeeeeeeeeeeeee.......

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#65

Re: Batata Salada Maximo

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, at least now I know the name to avoid calling out in my nightmares. :)

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#66

Re: Hey Thom...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Now that Japanese tools have got a wedge into the American market, it may be somewhat easier for hand made tool makers to make very good livings; and the Japanese gov't seems quite happy providing stewardship and preservation. We still have a lot to learn, just last night I saw a video in which the Japanese woodworker used a type of plane (wooden, of course, some sort of skewed rebate) I hadn't seen before. He used it to form the mitre part of mitred dovetails, a task I do using chisels. His way is faster and cleaner.

As to making old tool types happy, no one can make someone else happy, not really. How's that for a comment? :)

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#67

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#68

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#69

Re: Yabut...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, that would be a kicker, I thought; but then I remembered that 10,000 miles is not all that far for rads to traverse. (:

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#70

Re: Ah... can't tell the players without a scoreca

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hmmmm, not believing in a deity, as either starter or ongoing, kind of requires a disbelief in evil as well. At least in my little world, it's all metaphor.

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#72

Easy answer...

Bob Hackett

I`m a witch. :D

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#73

OK, my bad.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#74

 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#75

Re: Foiled again!

tomd

" Sometimes, it even seems like you scan my post, find one or two things that slows your eye, and then go off on wherever the shiny object of your attention leads you. That aside, I believed then as I believe now that M4 bests 3V quite handily."

That is worth knowing, so we can stop talking about 3v, even if not for the reason I might have preferred.

Normally I read the whole post, and then when I claw my way back up to the top of it's El Cap like prow, I try to pick on a few parts of it. If I am not mistaken, you were ranting a few cycles back about the volume of my posts. Am I to assume you know what fullsom responses to your every phrase?

"Yes, you are a clever debunker, you are. You've seen through my ploy to undermine the sanity and security of others. I can no longer ply my wiley wickedness on Wood Central. No, if I was an honorable man, I'd slink away in shame. But as I'm obviously a cad, a villain, a morally derelict dunderhead, I'll simply find some other group to undermine, to contaminate and adulterate. Yes, I have no real knowledge, no credible base of understanding. No, I'm simply faking it at every step, writing blithely but without content, without substance, without meat. Everything I've ever said here is a lie. A complete fabrication."

I know you don't really mean that, but at least it occurred to you as your best rhetorical argument. I see light at the end of the tunnel...

"I know. I know. You revere Japanese everything. I, too, admire Japanese craft. But never mind that I've had chisels crack and chip."

Forgive me should we meet and I not shake your hand. It will pain me to seem rude, but things that pass through your hands seem rarely to escape un-shattered.

I am not really excited about the Japanese part, it would be better if the origin was... New Brunswick. That these tools have a Japanese origin is not really helpful for all but a small percentage of adopters. It's just the case that they make great edged tools. And it isn't as if woodworkers were alone, people have come to that conclusion in several completely unrelated crafts.