Re: Hey Thom...
tomd
"You do know those Japanese smiths are all well over retirement age and dropping like flies don`t you? From what I understand there aren`t a whole lot of folks lining up to replace them either.
Pretty soon those fancy Japanese chisels will be just as finite and hard to get as Whitherbys and Swans only with a price tag that`s several orders of magnitude larger than the old US laminated chisels are now."
That is an interesting point, though it also occurs to me that it would be easy to keep on trucking with only their more industrial tools. Say CPM did not exist and no fork in the road was under consideration there are plenty of Japanese tools that are of better quality that what has come out of the west to this point that are in no danger of dying with one person. In any case, your point is more of the forward looking stuff as if I need to consider some changes when I have more sets of chisels than most pros have chisels, and could easily carry on my actual working craft with nothing more than one or two standard plates of 3/16" O1 steel.
There seems to be also and impression that I get from your post, that I am close minded about 3v, or diamonds, the latter I use, and in some form have used for 30+ years. 3V I just found a source for, and I think this thread started (or some recent one did), when I asked for clarification of whether it was even the best CPM, since I am planing on making some CPM chisels. My argument over the last few months has been with the overstatement and insulting tone of the promotion of this stuff, not with the stuff itself.



