New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

Posts

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#76

Re: Hey Thom...

tomd

"You do know those Japanese smiths are all well over retirement age and dropping like flies don`t you? From what I understand there aren`t a whole lot of folks lining up to replace them either.

Pretty soon those fancy Japanese chisels will be just as finite and hard to get as Whitherbys and Swans only with a price tag that`s several orders of magnitude larger than the old US laminated chisels are now."

That is an interesting point, though it also occurs to me that it would be easy to keep on trucking with only their more industrial tools. Say CPM did not exist and no fork in the road was under consideration there are plenty of Japanese tools that are of better quality that what has come out of the west to this point that are in no danger of dying with one person. In any case, your point is more of the forward looking stuff as if I need to consider some changes when I have more sets of chisels than most pros have chisels, and could easily carry on my actual working craft with nothing more than one or two standard plates of 3/16" O1 steel.

There seems to be also and impression that I get from your post, that I am close minded about 3v, or diamonds, the latter I use, and in some form have used for 30+ years. 3V I just found a source for, and I think this thread started (or some recent one did), when I asked for clarification of whether it was even the best CPM, since I am planing on making some CPM chisels. My argument over the last few months has been with the overstatement and insulting tone of the promotion of this stuff, not with the stuff itself.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#77

Re: Hey Thom...

tomd

Cool, where was the video? I crashed my computer yesterday, so I am not having what the techies call as "rich an experience" as I normally do. My skin always crawls when I here that "rich experience" stuff. But maybe it applies in this case. The new stuff being promoted by the CPM folks provides the rich experience of Windows 3.1, while the equally new stuff we prefer is more like the rich experience from Apple, at least as I have heard it described.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#78

Re: Yabut...

tomd

Well I did go out and buy a few bags of nori...

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#79

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#80

Re: Hey Thom... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Sure, it's in Neanderthal Haven, Japanese Boring gimlets, 2nd page, about the 3rd or 4th video; but I watched the whole set, kind of mesmerizing apparently. But I've always enjoyed watching other people work.

Fortunately when my 3 year old MacBook crashed repeatedly, I had it backed up, cloned, and it only crashed from the heat of video playback; so I was able to limp along as long as it was below 60�, at least at night. Alas, my insurance on it expires on April 22, so I had to send it in for logic board replacement; and it was getting hotter, such that I could never play video without a crash. I've been using Macs since 1984, but also DOS and Windows and UNIX for software development, no problems, I'd just use Jack's Windows laptop for a few hours a day. NOT! The cursor jumps around as if it has free will, and it just gets worse. I was lucky, Apple took a grand total of one day to fix my Mac.

Pam


Page 2, Japanese Boring Gimlets

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#81

Re: Fair analysis

tomd

"I will, however, suspend judgment for when a major hand tool maker manufactures and brings M4 or some other �ber-steel chisels to market. Then, with samples in hand and anecdotes galore we shall make our decisions."

I would like to try such chisels, and I would be very open to it. I don't think there are many points in it, or even know what the game is that is being played. But there is always interest in trying anything that will have a well differentiated advantage. What is happening at the edge will only be a part of it.

" I, for one, fearlessly cast my lot with the new."

And that would mean what exactly? Chisels representative of "the new" sounds as brain dead a concept as those people like because they are old. There will be a lot about them that isn't new, like chiselness, form, etc... I am not sure how many points there will be in any of it.

"Oh yes, I fully realize early efforts may fall short, may initially disappoint, may take some time to overcome the right-side resistance of that bell curve that Tindall has spoken upon, but I believe these steels will, in time, become entrenched. I could be wrong, but I think I'm right."

I wouldn't bet against it happening, particularly at some level of generality. Even if you take O1, it has not really been around that long. There was a time when possibly Hock aside, one didn't really hear about it. Then it became apparent it was being more widely used, people would confess they made their blades out of O1. Then people started to actually put it in the ads. That last stage feels like about 10 years, where one would open a catalog and see it in there, and maybe A2 also. Could be longer. But not exactly a luddite's dream. I have been surprised that A2 didn't take off. I felt a swing to it and then back. It often appears that something is dominant because all the newbie chatter switches to it for a while. How much of an installed used base it becomes I have no idea. Then a big name woodworker changes over out of respect for his student so they will feel comfortable with their choices while at his seminar. One will really know it has happened when some folk working in a sweat shop somewhere are using it. Finally some points.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#82

Re: Fair analysis

joel moskowitz

We have been selling japanese chisels made from HSS for years. We sell a a fair number. With diamond you can get them sharp. In Japan they are recommended for carpenters who need a touch edge over an uber sharp edge.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#83

Re: Hey Thom...

tomd

Pam, would you be so kind as to post the Youtube link. This system I am using to patch me over won't recognize the particular link in that thread. It does recognized others - above my pay grade.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#84

Re: Hey Thom... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Sure, here's the link for the first one. There are five more in the series.

Pam


Japanese woodworker videos

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#85

Talk about piston fit!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I will never tire of seeing those clips. The thing that amazes me, though, is what he can do with a cutting gauge.

btw, is that oak or ash?

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#86

Re: Talk about piston fit!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, it was pretty funny when he seemed to be trying to close the drawers. And what he does with that cutting gauge is magical. I've only watched the videos once, so back for another view in a couple of days, and I think I've figured out how that skew, or perhaps reverse skew, had to have been made.

Pam

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#87

Re: Fair analysis

TD

Cool. The ones I got from Mahogany Masterpieces around 1980 are about the same as the Oucii chisels I bought at the same time, as far as sharpness. Seems to be pretty much to the limit of the stone, Kings at the time and for the most part since. One of my fine little arm hairs explodes off my arm when the chisel is really sharp. They are probably easier to sharpen than blue steel chisels. MM had to write very carefully about their properties to differentiate them somehow from sets that cost 350 1980 dollars. They were that good. They sold some HSS planes at the same time, and they had some of that resistance to sharpening one might expect.

I keep bringing up the fact that the Hitachi carbide router bit that came with my TR12, was arm shaving sharp out of the box. So all this talk about carbide size, etc... and how sharp certain stuff could be sharpened doesn't seem to apply there.

Talking somewhere up thread about disappearing masters. Funny how the price of J. tools has been pretty stable. When I was buying stuff for 350 a set of 10, or was it 500, those prices hardly shifted when the yen went from 300 something, to the 100s, now lower. Should be 1500 a set plus 30 years of inflation. Very very cheap right now.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#88

Re: Fair analysis

wilbur

Wow. I should have taken up woodworking a long time ago.

Over the recent past, Japanese woodworking tools seem to have taken a hit in affordability due to changes in the dollar-yen exchange rate. My favorite brand of Japanese chisels have gone up about 25-30% in price since I first bought them about 4 years ago.

Re: Why Warren (and others) need tough chisels

#89

Re: Fair analysis

TD

That makes sense, that is about the loss against the Yen over that time period. Not much of a premium for the increasing scarcity of practitioners. I don't know why there wasn't much of a change when the initial slide occured.